Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

England And Wales Cricket Board Ltd & Anor v Tixdaq Ltd & Anor

England and Wales High Court (Chancery Division)
Mar 18, 2016
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

The Plaintiff entities own copyrights in television broadcasts and films incorporated within such broadcasts of most cricket matches played by the England men's and women's cricket teams in England and Wales. The Defendants operate a website ("the Website") and mobile applications, notably the fanatix app ("the App"), which allowed employees, contractors, and users to upload clips of cricket match broadcasts lasting up to 8 seconds. These clips could be viewed by users on the App, Website, and related social media accounts. The Plaintiffs allege that this constituted copyright infringement. The Defendants deny infringement, primarily relying on a fair dealing defence for reporting current events and secondarily on immunities for mere conduit and hosting. The Defendants also counterclaim for a declaration of non-infringement regarding versions 8.5 and later of the App.

The Plaintiffs are the governing body of cricket in England and Wales ("the ECB") and a major UK pay-television operator ("Sky"). The Defendants are two English private limited companies operating the fanatix services and related platforms.

The Plaintiffs called several witnesses including commercial directors and content protection experts, while the Defendants called their CEO, former COO, and a Vice President of Engineering. Evidence included analyses of the App's functionality, use patterns, and internal documents.

The App allows users to capture and share short clips of sports broadcasts, accompanied by commentary, with restrictions evolving through versions to limit clip length, require attribution, and impose viewing limits via an algorithm. The Website and social media accounts also hosted such clips.

The dispute arose after the Plaintiffs discovered highlight clips on the Defendants' platforms in mid-2015, leading to correspondence and ultimately legal proceedings, including interim undertakings given by the Defendants pending trial.

The legislative context includes international treaties (Berne Convention, Rome Convention, TRIPS, WIPO Copyright Treaty), European directives (Information Society Directive, E-Commerce Directive), and domestic legislation (Copyright, Designs and Patents Act 1988 and Electronic Commerce Regulations), all relevant to copyright protection, exceptions, and intermediary liability.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the Defendants' reproduction and communication to the public of short clips from the Plaintiffs' broadcasts and films constituted copyright infringement.
  2. Whether the defence of fair dealing for the purpose of reporting current events applies to the Defendants' use of the clips via the App, Website, and Social Media Accounts.
  3. Whether the Defendants' services qualify for immunity under Articles 12 and 14 of the E-Commerce Directive as mere conduit or hosting providers.
  4. The assessment of whether clips uploaded constitute a substantial part of the Plaintiffs' copyright works.
  5. The sufficiency of acknowledgements accompanying the clips under the fair dealing defence.
  6. The impact of the Defendants' use on the normal exploitation and legitimate interests of the Plaintiffs' copyrights, including commercial impact and potential conflicts with licensing arrangements.

Arguments of the Parties

Plaintiffs' Arguments

  • The Defendants infringed copyrights by reproducing and communicating substantial parts of the Plaintiffs' broadcasts and films without authorization.
  • The use was not for the purpose of reporting current events but for commercial exploitation and sharing of highlights.
  • The scale and nature of the use conflicted with the Plaintiffs' normal exploitation, including live broadcasts, licensed clip services, and future licensing plans.
  • Many clips lacked sufficient acknowledgement of the Plaintiffs' rights holders.
  • The Defendants' immunities under the E-Commerce Directive do not apply due to their active role and control over content.

Defendants' Arguments

  • The reproduction and communication of clips falls within the fair dealing defence for reporting current events.
  • Users add commentary and attribute sources, supporting the claim of reporting and sufficient acknowledgement.
  • The App is designed for a younger audience accessing news via mobile devices, representing a modern form of citizen journalism.
  • The Defendants' services qualify for immunity under the E-Commerce Directive as mere conduit or hosting providers, especially regarding user-generated content.
  • Any infringing clips can be removed upon notice, limiting liability.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
British Broadcasting Corp v British Satellite Broadcasting Ltd [1991] Ch 141 Established the Sports News Access Code of Practice (SNAC) and principles on use of broadcast footage in news reporting. Used to contextualize permissible use of sports footage in news programmes and to distinguish from the Defendants' App use.
Pro Sieben Media AG v Carlton UK Television Ltd [1999] 1 WLR 605 Interpretation of "for the purpose of reporting current events" and requirements for fair dealing. Applied to assess the purpose of the Defendants' use and the objectivity of the fair dealing defence.
Ashdown v Telegraph Group Ltd [2002] Ch 149 Liberal interpretation of "reporting current events" and factors in assessing fair dealing. Supported a broad interpretation of reporting, including modern media forms.
Football Association Premier League Ltd v QC Leisure [2008] EWHC 1411 (Ch) Assessment of substantial part in short clips and fair dealing considerations. Confirmed that short action replays can constitute substantial parts and informed the court's substantiality analysis.
ITV Broadcasting Ltd v TV Catchup Ltd [2011] EWHC 1874 (Pat) Considered substantiality of short video fragments and their copyright implications. Distinguished from the present case, with the court favoring the Premier League approach.
L'Oréal SA v eBay International AG [2011] ECR I-6011 Interpretation of hosting immunity under Article 14 of the E-Commerce Directive. Guided the court's provisional view on the availability of hosting defence for user-posted clips.
Marleasing SA v La Comercial Internacional de Alimentación SA [1990] ECR I-4135 Duty to interpret domestic law in conformity with European directives. Applied to interpret the Copyright Act in light of EU copyright directives.
Sociedad General de Autores y Editores de España v Rafael Hoteles SA [2006] ECR I-11519 Principles of interpreting EU legislation considering wording, context, and objectives. Supported purposive interpretation of copyright exceptions.
Public Relations Consultants Association Ltd v Newspaper Licensing Agency Ltd [2014] AC 1438 Application of the three-step test and balancing rights under EU law. Referenced in discussing the three-step test and fair dealing balance.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court began by outlining the factual context, describing the Defendants' App and related services and the nature of the Plaintiffs' copyrights in broadcasts and films. It emphasized that the copyrights in question are signal rights protecting investment rather than intellectual creation, and thus the test for substantial part considers both quantitative and qualitative aspects related to the broadcaster's investment.

The court found that each 8-second clip, typically featuring highlights such as wickets or centuries, constituted a substantial part of the Plaintiffs' copyright works because it exploited the Plaintiffs' investment.

Regarding the fair dealing defence for reporting current events, the court undertook a detailed analysis. It acknowledged that "reporting current events" should be interpreted broadly, including modern forms of citizen journalism and user-generated content. However, the court distinguished between genuine reporting and use primarily for sharing and consumption of highlights.

The court examined the Defendants' presentations and evidence about the App's purpose and concluded that the primary purpose was sharing clips and facilitating debate, not reporting current events. Accordingly, the use was not "for the purpose of reporting current events" for versions 8.2 and 8.3 of the App.

Even assuming the use was for reporting, the court found the use was not fair dealing. It held that the use conflicted with the Plaintiffs' normal exploitation, including live broadcasts, licensed clip services, and future licensing plans. The scale of use was potentially large given the App's design for millions of users, and the extent of use was not justified by the informatory purpose.

The court considered subsequent App versions with restrictions on commentary length, upload limits, clip removal, and viewing limits via an algorithm. It found these changes did not alter the fundamental purpose of the use or justify the extent of use, and thus fair dealing remained unavailable.

On the issue of sufficient acknowledgement, the court accepted that broadcaster logos or user attributions could suffice, but noted that many clips lacked proper acknowledgement. The Defendants' argument that a moderately attentive viewer would appreciate the source was accepted in principle but could not be conclusively determined without further evidence.

Regarding the Defendants' reliance on mere conduit and hosting immunities under the E-Commerce Directive, the court provisionally held that mere conduit immunity did not apply due to storage of information, and that hosting immunity might apply to user-posted clips not editorially reviewed but not to clips in editorially controlled feeds. The question was left open due to limited argument.

The court also found that the Defendants' infringements were not flagrant, noting their efforts to address issues and the absence of deliberate wrongdoing.

Holding and Implications

The court held that:

  • The reproduction and communication to the public of clips via versions of the App up to version 8.3 infringed the Plaintiffs' copyrights.
  • The use was not for the purpose of reporting current events and, even if it were, did not qualify as fair dealing.
  • Some clips infringed due to lack of sufficient acknowledgement.
  • Subsequent versions of the App did not alter the availability of the fair dealing defence.
  • Use of clips via the Website and Social Media Accounts also infringed the Plaintiffs' copyrights.
  • The infringements were not flagrant.

The direct effect is that the Defendants are liable for copyright infringement for the relevant versions of the App and related platforms. No broader precedent was established beyond the facts of this case. The court did not conclusively determine the scope of the Defendants' immunities under the E-Commerce Directive, leaving some issues open for future consideration.