- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Property Alliance Group Ltd v The Royal Bank of Scotland Plc
Factual and Procedural Background
The issue before the court was whether certain documents referred to as the "ESG High Level Documents" were subject to legal advice privilege claimed by the Defendant, Company A. These documents were disclosed as part of a supplemental list in February 2015. Following a judgment in June 2015 by Judge B, an order was made directing that these documents be produced for inspection by another judge to determine the validity of the privilege claim and whether redacted copies should be provided.
The underlying litigation involves the Plaintiff alleging that Company A induced it to enter into several interest rate swap agreements referencing a particular benchmark rate and that Company A implicitly misrepresented that it was not manipulating this benchmark. Company A admitted wrongdoing related to other benchmark rates in different currencies but denied misconduct regarding the relevant benchmark rate in this case.
Due to the vast volume of potentially relevant documents, the court focused on "high level" internal reports and summaries related to the allegations of misconduct. Attention centered on the Executive Steering Group ("ESG") of Company A. Prior findings by Judge B expressed doubts about the claim to legal advice privilege over these documents, prompting the order for inspection.
The inspecting judge was appointed and received 81 ESG High Level Documents for review. The judge ordered Company A to provide witness evidence explaining the background and basis for the privilege claim and allowed the Plaintiff to respond. The judge personally reviewed the documents before hearing legal arguments.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the ESG High Level Documents are protected by legal advice privilege claimed by Company A.
- The proper scope and application of legal advice privilege to communications prepared by external legal advisers for an internal committee overseeing regulatory investigations.
- Whether any parts of the ESG High Level Documents that do not contain legal advice should be disclosed or redacted.
Arguments of the Parties
Defendant's Arguments
- The ESG High Level Documents were prepared by external legal advisers, Clifford Chance, for the ESG committee, which was established to oversee regulatory investigations and liaise with legal counsel.
- The documents consist of confidential memoranda updating the ESG on regulatory investigations and summaries of meetings with legal advice and analysis.
- The communications were made in a relevant legal context and form part of a continuum of communications aimed at giving legal advice.
- Clifford Chance's role in preparing agendas, leading meetings, and drafting minutes was integral to providing legal advice, not merely administrative.
- All documents were marked "privileged and confidential" and communicated in confidence.
Plaintiff's Arguments
- Even if some parts of the ESG High Level Documents attract legal advice privilege, it is unlikely that the entire documents do.
- The ESG had a broader role than receiving legal advice, so not all information or minutes of decisions could be privileged.
- References to public events or dealings with regulators would not be privileged.
- Analogies were drawn to board meeting minutes, which are generally not privileged.
- Suggested that only direct references to legal advice could be redacted, with the remainder disclosed.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Three Rivers District Council v Bank of England (No.6) [2004] UKHL 48 | Definition and scope of legal advice privilege; communications made in confidence between solicitor and client for legal advice. | Confirmed the fundamental requirements for legal advice privilege and the need for a relevant legal context. |
| Price Waterhouse v BCCI Holdings (Luxembourg) SA [1992] BCLC 583 | Legal advice privilege applies to confidential communications for legal advice even without litigation. | Supported the principle that privilege attaches broadly to legal advice communications. |
| Balabel v Air India [1988] 1 Ch 317 | Legal advice includes advice on what should prudently be done in a legal context; privilege applies to communications forming part of a continuum for legal advice. | Used to assess whether communications formed part of the necessary exchange of information for legal advice. |
| Nederlanse Reassurantie Groep Holding NV v Bacon & Woodrow Holding [1995] 1 All ER 976 | Communications related to a transaction for legal advice are privileged even if not strictly legal content. | Affirmed that communications directly related to solicitor’s professional duty are privileged. |
| Minter v Priest [1929] 1 KB 655 | All communications between solicitor and client relating to a transaction for legal advice are privileged. | Supported the principle that privilege extends beyond pure legal advice to related communications. |
| Financial Services Compensation Scheme v Abbey National Treasury Services plc [2007] EWHC 2868 (Ch) | Scope and limits of privilege in internal documents and redactions relating to legal advice. | Distinguished from the present case; concerned redactions in internal documents rather than communications from lawyers. |
| Atos Consulting v Avis plc (No. 2) [2007] EWHC 323 (TCC) | Privilege in board minutes and supporting papers; redactions on grounds of privilege or irrelevance. | Distinguished; did not involve claims to privilege over lawyer-client communications. |
| Bank of Nova Scotia v Hellenic Mutual War Risks Association (Bermuda) (The Good Luck) [1992] 2 Lloyd's Rep 540 | Privilege extends to records of legal advice within a client’s organisation. | Supported the claim to privilege over internal records reflecting legal advice. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The court applied established legal principles governing legal advice privilege to the ESG High Level Documents. It accepted that the external legal advisers were engaged in a relevant legal context given the serious regulatory investigations facing Company A. The documents formed part of a continuum of communications aimed at providing legal advice. The tabular memoranda served to inform and update the ESG on regulatory developments as a basis for advice and decision-making, while the summary minutes reflected legal discussions and advice given during meetings.
The court rejected the Plaintiff’s argument that only direct references to legal advice could be privileged and that the remainder should be disclosed. It held that communications passing information in confidence for the purpose of giving legal advice are privileged, even if they do not explicitly contain legal advice. The court distinguished cases cited by the Plaintiff, which concerned internal documents or redactions, emphasizing that the present documents were communications from lawyers to their client.
The court also addressed the role of the lawyers as secretariat for the meetings, concluding that this was part of their legal advisory function and not merely administrative. Therefore, the documents prepared and circulated by the lawyers in this context were properly subject to legal advice privilege.
Finally, the court considered the policy underpinning legal advice privilege, emphasizing the public interest in enabling clients and lawyers to communicate candidly and securely, particularly in complex regulatory investigations. The ESG High Level Documents fell squarely within this policy justification.
Holding and Implications
The court UPHELD the claim to legal advice privilege in respect of all the ESG High Level Documents inspected.
The direct consequence is that these documents are protected from disclosure to the Plaintiff. No part of the documents was ordered to be disclosed or redacted beyond the privilege claim. The decision does not establish new precedent but applies and confirms existing principles regarding the scope of legal advice privilege in the context of communications between external legal advisers and an internal committee overseeing regulatory investigations.
Alert