Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

DB v PB

England and Wales High Court (Family Division)
Dec 22, 2016
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

This opinion concerns the final hearing of three separate applications related to ancillary relief, provision pursuant to Schedule 1 of the Children Act 1989, and an order for sale of the former matrimonial home under the Married Women's Property Act 1882. The parties, referred to as the wife and husband, are Swedish nationals who cohabited from 1994 and married in 2000. They have two children aged 12 and 8. The marriage broke down in 2014, with proceedings initiated in Sweden by the husband and in England by the wife; the English proceedings took precedence. The husband has substantial assets, including a portfolio worth approximately £9 million and a family home valued at around £3 million in Berkshire. The wife primarily cared for the children and home after their birth. The key dispute centers on the wife’s entitlement to a share of the assets, with the husband contending she is entitled only to her half share of the matrimonial home, while the wife claims a full half share of the total assets worth approximately £11 million. The court also considered the validity and effect of three prenuptial agreements and a prorogation clause conferring jurisdiction on Swedish courts.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the court has jurisdiction to determine the wife's maintenance and ancillary relief claims in light of the prorogation clause conferring exclusive jurisdiction on Swedish courts.
  2. The validity and enforceability of the three prenuptial agreements executed by the parties, including allegations of misrepresentation and unfairness.
  3. The effect of the prenuptial agreements and the Maintenance Regulation (EC No. 4/2009) on the wife’s entitlement to ancillary relief and sharing claims.
  4. The valuation and disposition of the former matrimonial home, including whether it should be sold and how the proceeds should be divided.
  5. The appropriate financial provision for the wife and children under Schedule 1 of the Children Act 1989, given the restrictions on maintenance claims.

Arguments of the Parties

Wife's Arguments

  • The prenuptial agreements should not be upheld due to misrepresentation by the husband, who allegedly assured her they would not be implemented and that she would receive financial provision on divorce.
  • The agreements are unfair, as they would leave her with only a small fraction of the assets after a long marriage and significant contributions to the family.
  • The wife claims entitlement to a full half share of the total assets, approximately £11 million.
  • She seeks provision for the children’s housing needs and maintenance despite jurisdictional challenges.

Husband's Arguments

  • The prenuptial agreements are valid, having been freely entered into with independent legal advice, and reflect the parties' intention to keep their property separate.
  • The prorogation clause validly confers exclusive jurisdiction on Swedish courts for maintenance claims, limiting this court’s jurisdiction to property rights only.
  • The wife is entitled only to her half share of the former matrimonial home and no further ancillary relief.
  • Maintenance claims should be stayed pending determination by the Swedish court.
  • The husband contends that tax deductions on assets should be considered in valuing the estate.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Van den Boogard v Laumen [1997] 2 FLR 399 Distinguishes between maintenance claims and property rights; transfer of property may be maintenance if intended to support a spouse. Used to interpret scope of Maintenance Regulation and to assess whether wife's sharing claim is maintenance or property right.
Radmacher v Granatino [2011] AC 534 Effect to be given to prenuptial agreements freely entered into unless unfair; courts to respect individual autonomy. Guided the court's approach to fairness and enforceability of the prenuptial agreements in this case.
Agbaje v Agbaje [2010] 1 FLR 1813 Clarification of when transfers of property constitute maintenance versus property rights. Supported the distinction between maintenance and property claims under the Maintenance Regulation.
White v White [2000] Establishes principle of fairness and equal sharing in matrimonial property division. Underpinned the court’s recognition of the wife’s entitlement to a fair share of matrimonial assets.
Miller v Miller; McFarlane v McFarlane [2006] Reinforces equal sharing principle and fairness in financial provision on divorce. Supported the court’s view that the wife’s claim is a property right, not mere maintenance.
Kremen v Agrest [2012] EWHC 45 (Fam) Approach to disregarding prenuptial agreements found to be unfair or vitiated. Distinguished from current case due to lack of misrepresentation or undue pressure here.
Sharland [2015] UKSC 60 “Fraud unravels all” maxim applies to matrimonial consent orders. Analogous reasoning applied to prenuptial agreements regarding vitiating factors.
Z v Z [2011] EWHC 2878 (Fam) Upholds foreign separation of property agreements but meets reasonable needs of spouse. Used to justify meeting wife’s needs despite separate property regime.
Luckwell v Limata [2014] Similar approach to Z v Z regarding foreign matrimonial property regimes. Supported court’s discretion to meet reasonable needs within separate property context.
CG v IF [2010] 2 FLR 1790 Ancillary relief awards containing maintenance elements are not solely property division. Supported finding that court’s jurisdiction is limited to property rights excluding maintenance under Maintenance Regulation.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court began by identifying the jurisdictional issues arising from the prenuptial agreements and the prorogation clause conferring exclusive jurisdiction on Swedish courts for maintenance claims. It found the prorogation clause valid under the Maintenance Regulation (EC No. 4/2009), which requires written agreement and consent, both of which were present. The court held that this clause excludes the English court's jurisdiction to make maintenance orders but does not exclude jurisdiction over property rights arising out of the marriage.

The court carefully distinguished between maintenance claims and property rights, relying on established case law such as Van den Boogard and Agbaje. It found that the wife's sharing claim is a claim to property rights, not maintenance, and thus not excluded by the Maintenance Regulation. However, the prenuptial agreements, which provide for separate property and exclude sharing, are binding unless unfair or vitiated.

The court found no misrepresentation or vitiating factors affecting the validity of the prenuptial agreements. The wife had independent legal advice and understood the agreements. The husband’s evidence was preferred on these points despite his unsympathetic demeanor.

Applying the principles from Radmacher, the court acknowledged the prenuptial agreements’ validity but found their effect in this case to be unfair, as they would leave the wife with a disproportionately small share of the assets after a long marriage and significant contributions. The court rejected the wife’s claim that the agreements should be disregarded entirely due to unfairness, emphasizing the importance of respecting autonomy and the residual discretion to mitigate unfairness.

Accordingly, the court adopted an approach of meeting the wife’s reasonable needs by invading the husband’s separate property, rather than disregarding the prenuptial agreements altogether. Yet, because maintenance claims are excluded by the prorogation clause, the court’s power is limited to property rights only, preventing it from making lump sum or periodical payments to the wife for maintenance until the Swedish court has ruled.

The court found the family home’s value to be approximately £3 million with net equity of about £1.82 million after mortgage and sale costs. It ordered the sale of the home and equal division of proceeds. It also ordered the husband to provide £2 million under Schedule 1 of the Children Act 1989 to meet the housing needs of the children and wife as carer, to be held until the children cease full-time education. The husband was ordered to pay a carer’s allowance and periodical payments totalling £95,000 per annum for the wife and children.

The court emphasized the complexity and expense of ongoing litigation, encouraged settlement, and noted the husband’s ability to meet these obligations from his income and assets.

Holding and Implications

DISPOSED OF

The court ordered the sale of the former matrimonial home with net proceeds to be divided equally between the parties. The wife’s ancillary relief and maintenance claims are stayed pending determination by the Swedish court pursuant to the valid prorogation clause. The husband is to provide £2 million for the children’s housing needs under Schedule 1 of the Children Act 1989 and to pay a combined annual carer’s allowance and periodical payments of £95,000. The court recognized the prenuptial agreements as valid but mitigated their unfair effect by meeting the wife’s reasonable needs from the husband’s separate property, within the constraints of the Maintenance Regulation and jurisdictional limits.

The direct effect is to limit the wife’s current financial claims in England and require her to pursue maintenance claims in Sweden. No new precedent was set; the decision applies established principles on prenuptial agreements, jurisdiction, and the distinction between maintenance and property rights under EU law.