- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Dhanani v Crasnianski
Factual and Procedural Background
The Plaintiff, a Belgian national residing in London with experience in private equity investing, and the Defendant, a Swiss resident scientist and inventor, met in November 2006. By March 2007, after limited meetings, they signed a letter and term sheet envisaging the Defendant providing £50 million for investment in a private equity fund managed by the Plaintiff. By June 2007, their relationship deteriorated, and the Defendant declined to proceed with the investment opportunity. The Plaintiff alleges breach of contract damages exceeding £11.3 million, while the Defendant denies liability and counterclaims repayment of £312,500 advanced to the Plaintiff.
The court received oral evidence from both parties and two additional witnesses, including the Defendant's daughter and a legal representative from a law firm involved in drafting fund documents. The court placed greater reliance on contemporaneous documents and probabilities due to inconsistencies and subjective presentations in witness testimonies.
The parties had a prior acquaintance dating back to 2001, but their relationship was limited. The key events include a chance meeting on the Eurostar in November 2006, subsequent meetings in early 2007, presentations of the Plaintiff’s private equity fund proposal, drafting and signing of a letter and term sheet by March 2007, and negotiations regarding fund structure, control, and expenses. By late June 2007, the Defendant terminated the venture, citing loss of trust and concerns over fund structure and expenses.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the signed letter and term sheet constituted a legally binding contract between the parties to establish a private equity fund.
- Whether the parties intended to create legal relations at the time of signing.
- Whether the terms of the letter and term sheet were sufficiently certain and enforceable or amounted to an unenforceable agreement to agree.
- Whether the Defendant repudiated any enforceable agreement and was entitled to terminate it.
- The measure and quantum of damages, if any, recoverable by the Plaintiff for breach of contract.
- The validity and extent of the Defendant’s counterclaim for repayment of the advanced funds.
Arguments of the Parties
Plaintiff's Arguments
- The signed letter and term sheet evidenced a binding agreement obliging both parties to set up a fund with defined characteristics.
- Outstanding details could be agreed or, failing agreement, resolved by the Plaintiff during the soft launch period.
- The parties intended to create legal relations, as evidenced by the signing of each page and conduct following signing.
- The Plaintiff was entitled to determine outstanding matters unilaterally within the term sheet’s framework.
- The Defendant repudiated the agreement by terminating the venture without justification.
- The Plaintiff claimed damages based on lost opportunity to earn carried interest from investments using the Defendant’s funds.
Defendant's Arguments
- The letter and term sheet did not constitute a binding contract but rather a letter of intent or agreement to agree.
- There was no intent to create legal relations, and the agreement was too vague and uncertain to be enforceable.
- The Defendant only accepted liability for repayment of the advance of £312,500.
- The Defendant repudiated the agreement due to loss of trust arising from concerns over expenses, bonuses, and fund structure changes.
- Any damages claimed by the Plaintiff could not be proven because the Defendant would have exercised veto rights over investments.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| RTS Ltd. v Molkerei Alois Muller GmbH [2010] 1 WLR 753 | Objective test for intention to create legal relations and enforceability despite some terms not finalised. | Applied to determine that the parties objectively intended to create legal relations by signing the letter and term sheet. |
| Pagnan SpA v Feed Products Limited [1987] 2 Lloyd's Rep. 601 | Clarification on parties’ intention and enforceability of agreements subject to further terms or conditions. | Used to analyze whether the parties intended to be bound despite outstanding terms and to interpret the letter and term sheet. |
| Hillas and Co. Ltd. v Arcos Ltd. (1932) 147 LT 503 | Court's duty to construe commercial agreements fairly and broadly without undue technicality. | Supported the approach to interpret the parties’ agreement in a commercially sensible manner. |
| Nea Agrex SA v Baltic Shipping Co. Ltd. [1976] 1 QB 933 | Reluctance to find contractual clauses too vague to enforce. | Reinforced the court's approach to uphold contractual intentions where possible. |
| Maple Leaf Macro Volatility Master Fund v Rouvroy [2009] 1 Lloyd's Rep 475 | Enforceability of agreements with discretionary powers and assessment of intention to create legal relations. | Distinguished on facts; used to assess enforceability and intention in the present case. |
| Walford v Miles [1992] 2 AC 128 | Agreement to negotiate or agree lacking sufficient certainty to be enforceable. | Applied to conclude the letter and term sheet were, in essence, an unenforceable agreement to agree on outstanding fund structure details. |
| Little v Courage [1995] CLC 164 | Agreement to agree is not enforceable and lacks certainty. | Supported the conclusion that the parties’ agreement was not sufficiently certain to be binding. |
| Multiplex Constructions v Cleveland Bridge [2006] EWHC 1341 (TCC) | Enforceability of agreements to agree and requirements for certainty. | Referenced to support the unenforceability of agreements lacking objective criteria for outstanding terms. |
| Durham Tees Valley Airport Limited v BMIBaby Limited [2010] EWCA Civ 485 | Principle of "minimum performance" in assessing damages based on how contract would likely have been performed. | Applied to assess that the Defendant would have vetoed investments, negating the Plaintiff’s claim for lost carried interest. |
| Omak Maritime Limited v Mamola Challenger Shipping [2010] EWHC 2026 | Damages based on reliance cannot put claimant in better position than performance would have. | Used to reject reliance damages claim exceeding what Plaintiff would have earned under the contract. |
| Chaplin v Hicks [1911] 2 KB 786 | Valuation of lost opportunities in damages assessments. | Referenced in relation to valuing the Plaintiff’s lost chance to earn carried interest. |
| Petromec v Petroleo Brasilero [2006] 1 Lloyd's Rep 121 | Interpretation of incomplete agreements in line with parties’ intentions. | Considered in assessing whether the court could construe the agreement to give effect to parties’ intentions despite incompleteness. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The court undertook an objective assessment of the parties’ intentions, focusing on the signed letter and term sheet and the subsequent conduct of the parties. It found that the signing of each page of the documents indicated an intention to create legal relations and be bound, despite acknowledgment in the documents that certain fund structures and legal agreements remained to be defined.
However, the court identified that the letter and term sheet left essential matters outstanding, such as the domicile and nature of entities forming the fund and other structural details. These were to be agreed later, without objective criteria or mechanisms for resolving disagreements. The court held that this amounted to an unenforceable agreement to agree, as established in precedent, and thus no binding contract to set up the fund existed.
The court rejected the Plaintiff’s submission that he could unilaterally determine outstanding details during the soft launch period, finding no clear words in the agreement to support such a construction. It emphasized that matters with fiscal implications required mutual consent.
Regarding repudiation, the court found no evidence that the Plaintiff was unwilling to grant the Defendant control of the General Partner as required. The Defendant’s termination was based on loss of trust arising from disagreements over expenses, bonuses, and fund structure changes.
On damages, the court applied the minimum performance principle, concluding that the Defendant would likely have vetoed investments due to lack of trust, negating the Plaintiff’s claim for lost carried interest. The reliance damages claim based on lost salary and bonuses was limited to a reasonable salary expectation over three years, reflecting what the Plaintiff would have earned had the contract been performed.
Finally, the court addressed the Defendant’s counterclaim for repayment of the advance payment. It held that since the soft launch had commenced, the Defendant was not entitled to full repayment, but was entitled to restitution of the advance less fees and expenses reasonably incurred during the soft launch period.
Holding and Implications
The court's final decision is that the Plaintiff's claim is DISMISSED and the Defendant's counterclaim succeeds in part.
The court held that the signed letter and term sheet did not constitute an enforceable contract to set up the private equity fund because essential terms remained unresolved without objective criteria, rendering the agreement an unenforceable agreement to agree.
The Defendant was not liable for damages for breach of contract, as no enforceable contract existed and, even if it did, the Defendant would have exercised veto rights preventing the Plaintiff from earning claimed profits.
The Defendant is entitled to partial repayment of the advanced funds, less reasonable fees and expenses incurred by the Plaintiff during the soft launch period.
No new legal precedent was established; the decision applies existing principles on intention, certainty, and agreements to agree to the facts of this case. The ruling directly affects the parties' rights and obligations but does not alter broader contract law doctrine.
Alert