Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Hosking v Marathon Asset Management Llp

England and Wales High Court (Chancery Division)
Oct 5, 2016
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

The Defendant, Company A LLP ("Company A"), operates an investment management business initially established in 1986 by the Plaintiff and another individual. In 2004, Company A and its members entered into a deed ("the LLP Deed") governing the organisation, rights, and duties of the LLP and its members. The Plaintiff and other original members were designated as "Founding Members" and "Class A Members," with Class A Members classified as either Executive or Non-Executive Members. Executive Members were required to devote their time diligently to the business, while Non-Executive Members, including retired Founding Members, received reduced profit shares.

The Plaintiff retired as an Executive Member in December 2012, becoming a Non-Executive Member. That same month, Company A initiated arbitration proceedings against the Plaintiff. The Arbitrator found the Plaintiff had breached contractual and fiduciary duties by discussing starting a new business with certain employees and producing a related business plan. This breach caused Company A to lose a 5% chance of retaining three key employees ("the Global Three").

At a subsequent hearing, the Arbitrator awarded equitable compensation of approximately £1.38 million for the lost chance of retention. Crucially, the Arbitrator ordered the Plaintiff to forfeit £10,389,957.50, representing 50% of the "full rations" profit share payments received during the breach period. The Arbitrator reasoned that this forfeiture was proportionate and equitable, reflecting remuneration for executive duties, and consistent with the LLP Deed's structure.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the share of profits of a partner in a partnership or a member of a limited liability partnership, paid pursuant to a partnership or LLP deed, can be forfeited based on the partner's or member's breach of fiduciary duties.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments

  • The forfeiture principle does not apply to profit shares of partners or LLP members.
  • There is a conceptual distinction between profit share and remuneration: profit share reflects ownership interest, not payment for services.
  • Profit share remains payable as an ownership entitlement, even if it compensates for services.
  • The Partnership Act 1890, Limited Liability Partnerships Act 2000, and relevant regulations make no reference to forfeiture.
  • No provision for forfeiture exists in the LLP Deed; thus, allowing forfeiture would distort the commercial bargain.

Appellee's Arguments

  • The Arbitrator was correct that profit share can be forfeited where attributable to services rendered.
  • Profit share payable for specific duties can be considered remuneration and is susceptible to forfeiture.
  • Excluding profit share from forfeiture would prefer form over substance, conflicting with the forfeiture principle’s rationale.
  • Legislation does not comprehensively define partners’ or LLP members’ rights and duties; no authority excludes forfeiture for profit shares.
  • Forfeiture aligns with fiduciary principles such as the "no profit" rule, with safeguards against disproportionate or inequitable forfeiture.
  • The absence of contractual forfeiture provisions does not prevent forfeiture, as the forfeiture rule can override contractual entitlements.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Andrews v Ramsay & Co [1903] 2 KB 635 Principle that only honest agents are entitled to remuneration. Established foundational forfeiture principle for fiduciaries.
Keppel v Wheeler [1927] 1 KB 577 Distinction that not all breaches of fiduciary duty result in forfeiture if the breach is honest and the principal benefits. Highlighted exceptions to forfeiture; applied as a contrast to strict forfeiture cases.
Imageview Management Ltd v Jack [2009] EWCA Civ 63 Forfeiture applies where secret profits arise from a breach of fiduciary duty involving conflict of interest. Reaffirmed strict forfeiture rule and its policy rationale as a deterrent against fiduciary breaches.
Bank of Ireland v Jaffery [2012] EWHC 1377 (Ch) Forfeiture may be disproportionate and inequitable in some circumstances. Recognised exceptions to forfeiture principle based on equity.
Avrahami v Biran [2013] EWHC 1776 (Ch) Forfeiture of management fees due to fiduciary breach. Applied forfeiture principle to management fees.
Stevens v Premium Real Estate Ltd [2009] NZSC 15 Remuneration forfeited if not earned by good faith performance; distinguishes remuneration from profits. Supported the forfeiture of agent’s commission for breach of fiduciary duty.
Helmore v Smith (1) (1886) 35 Ch D 436 Strong fiduciary relationship between partners based on mutual trust. Confirmed fiduciary duties owed between partners.
Cassels v Stewart (1881) 6 App Cas 64 Partner’s fiduciary character arises from agency relationship with the firm. Confirmed partner as agent and fiduciary.
Dunne v English (1874) 18 Eq 524 Partner made secret profit; relief ordered to share profits equally. Illustrated fiduciary obligations and remedies among partners.
Olson v Gullo (1994) 17 OR (3d) 790 Partner not deprived of interest in partnership property despite wrongdoing. Indicated limits on forfeiture of partnership profits.
MacDonald Estate v Martin [1994] MJ No 398 Enforcement of partnership agreements despite breach of fiduciary duty. Supported respecting agreed profit shares notwithstanding fiduciary breaches.
Erikson v Carr (1945) 46 SR (NSW) 9 Distinction between partnership and agency in relation to forfeiture of commission. Highlighted different remedies in partnership vs agency contexts.
M Young Legal Associates Ltd v Zahid [2006] EWCA Civ 613 Partners may be remunerated by fixed sums or salaries, not only profit shares. Confirmed freedom to structure remuneration in partnerships; relevant to forfeiture scope.
F & C Alternative Investments (Holdings) Ltd v Barthelemy (No 2) [2011] EWHC 1731 (Ch) Members of LLP owe usual fiduciary duties as agents. Confirmed fiduciary obligations of LLP members.
Vercoe v Rutland Fund Management Ltd [2010] EWHC 424 (Ch) Fiduciary obligations must be interpreted in commercial contexts without distorting parties' bargains. Guided approach to fiduciary duties alongside contractual terms.
Hilton v Barker Booth & Eastwood [2005] 1 WLR 567 Fiduciary obligations may be moulded by contractual relationships. Supported contextual interpretation of fiduciary duties.
Reinhard v Ondra LLP [2015] EWHC 26 (Ch) Member’s share in LLP comprises contractual and statutory rights and obligations. Clarified nature of LLP membership rights.
Flanagan v Liontrust Investment Partners LLP [2015] EWHC 2171 (Ch) Rights of LLP members are determined by agreement and statutory default provisions. Confirmed contractual basis for LLP members’ rights.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court analysed whether the forfeiture principle, traditionally applied to fiduciaries such as agents, extends to profit shares of partners or LLP members. It recognised that partners and LLP members are fiduciaries and agents of the firm, thus subject to fiduciary duties. The Court rejected the Appellant’s strict distinction between profit share and remuneration, noting that profit share can sometimes represent remuneration for services rendered. The Court emphasised substance over form, concluding that where profit share can be identified as compensation for specific duties, it is susceptible to forfeiture upon breach of fiduciary duty.

The Court reviewed relevant statutes, noting that the Partnership Act 1890 and the Limited Liability Partnerships Act 2000 preserve common law and equitable rules, including fiduciary principles. The cited case law did not preclude forfeiture in this context. Furthermore, the absence of explicit forfeiture provisions in the LLP Deed did not exclude the application of the forfeiture principle, which can override contractual entitlements when a fiduciary breach occurs.

Applying these principles to the facts, the Court found the Arbitrator’s conclusion that the forfeited sums constituted remuneration for executive duties was sound. Therefore, the forfeiture ordered was lawful and consistent with established equitable principles.

Holding and Implications

The Court DISMISSED THE APPEAL.

The holding confirms that the forfeiture principle applicable to fiduciaries extends to profit shares of partners or LLP members when such shares represent remuneration for services and a breach of fiduciary duty occurs. The decision upholds the Arbitrator’s award requiring forfeiture of part of the Plaintiff’s profit share. No new precedent beyond the direct effect on the parties was established, but the ruling clarifies the applicability of forfeiture principles in the partnership and LLP context.