- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Herrmann & Anor v The Royal Borough of Kensington & Chelsea & Anor
Factual and Procedural Background
The case concerns the ownership and rights of access to a garden within a London garden square known as Ovington Square, situated in the Royal Borough of Kensington and Chelsea. The key legal framework is the Kensington Improvement Act 1851 ("the Act"), which regulates the upkeep and management of such gardens. The garden in question was brought under the Act's management provisions on 1 April 1954, with the Royal Borough now responsible for its control.
The Plaintiff couple, owners and occupiers of 37 Ovington Square ("No. 37"), claim a "garden right" under section 51 of the Act, entitling them to exclusive use of the garden. They seek a declaration against the Royal Borough (the first Defendant) that they possess this right. The second Defendant is the treasurer of the Ovington Square Garden Committee ("the Committee"), which manages the garden under the Act and has refused to provide the Plaintiffs with a key, leading to a claim in nuisance for interference with the claimed right.
The dispute centers on whether No. 37 is a house "in and encompassing" the Square for the purposes of section 51, thus qualifying for garden right. The Plaintiffs argue that their property is part of the Square, including the Terrace (the access road where No. 37 fronts), while the Defendants deny this entitlement.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the owners and occupiers of No. 37 Ovington Square are entitled to a right of access ("garden right") to the garden under section 51 of the Kensington Improvement Act 1851.
- What constitutes a "Square" and which houses are "in and encompassing such square" for the purposes of section 51 of the Act.
- Whether the Committee is liable in nuisance for refusing the Plaintiffs access to the garden.
Arguments of the Parties
Appellant's Arguments
- The term "Square" in the Act includes terraces and other forms such as crescents and circuses, not limited to conventional four-sided squares.
- The garden need not be physically surrounded by buildings; it suffices that the garden is associated with a defined entity comprising dwelling houses.
- The phrase "in and encompassing" should be interpreted disjunctively, allowing houses that surround or envelope the Square to qualify for garden right.
- No. 37 fronts the Terrace, which is an integral part of the Square’s design and has been known as part of Ovington Square since 1881.
- Architectural uniformity, historical development by the same builder, and access routes support including the Terrace within the Square.
- Excluding No. 37 would be unfair, as it is physically close to and visible from the Garden, unlike some properties that do enjoy garden right.
Defendant's Arguments
- The Act’s language and context require that houses qualifying for garden right must have a front or side facing the open square itself, not merely an access road.
- The concept of "line" of the square suggests a notional boundary traced along the front or side of houses facing the square, excluding properties like No. 37.
- Historical and settled practice of the Royal Borough and its predecessors consistently limited garden right to properties facing the open square area (Rectangular Area), excluding those on the Terrace.
- Allowing No. 37 garden right would disrupt long-standing arrangements and create uncertainty for many other properties.
- The Committee is not liable for nuisance because it acts under statutory duty to restrict access to those entitled and is not responsible for determining entitlement.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Isle of Anglesey County Council v Welsh Ministers [2009] EWCA Civ 94; [2010] QB 163 | Principle that long-established interpretation of a statute without dissent should be respected to ensure legal certainty. | The court applied this principle to uphold the Royal Borough’s settled practice of interpreting the Act, emphasizing the importance of certainty in an obscure area of law. |
| Re Ellenborough Park [1956] Ch 131 | Establishes that a garden right can be an easement, and interference with such a right can constitute actionable nuisance. | The court acknowledged the submission that the garden right claimed would be an easement and interference actionable as nuisance, but did not need to decide liability as the Plaintiffs’ claim failed on entitlement. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The court analyzed the statutory language of section 51 of the Act, focusing on the phrase "the several Houses in and encompassing such square" and the definition of "Square" in section 5 which includes terraces and similar formations. The court recognized the ambiguity and lack of precise definition but rejected the Plaintiff’s broad interpretation that would extend the Square to include access roads such as the Terrace.
The court interpreted "Square" as an entity that the average person would readily recognize, comprising houses that have a front or side wholly or substantially facing the open square or similar formation. Section 42 was seen as clarifying that houses partially facing the Square qualify, but a house like No. 37, which fronts an access road and not the open square, does not meet this criterion.
The court emphasized the importance of a workable and certain approach, noting the long-standing settled practice of the Royal Borough and its predecessors to limit garden right to properties facing the open square area. This practice had been consistently applied without dissent, reinforcing legal certainty.
The court rejected the Plaintiff’s reliance on historical development, architectural similarity, and street naming as irrelevant to the statutory interpretation and the practical application of the Act.
Regarding the nuisance claim against the Committee, the court agreed that the Committee was performing a statutory duty in restricting access and was not liable for nuisance, as liability would lie with the Royal Borough if at all. Permission to bring an indemnity claim against the Royal Borough was refused as too late.
Holding and Implications
The court held that the owners and occupiers of No. 37 Ovington Square do not have garden right under section 51 of the Kensington Improvement Act 1851 because their property does not have a front or side facing the open square as required by the Act.
As a consequence, the Plaintiffs’ claim for a declaration of garden right fails, and their nuisance claim against the Committee is not pursued. The court upheld the Royal Borough’s settled practice, thereby preserving legal certainty and the status quo regarding which properties enjoy garden right in Ovington Square. No new precedent was established beyond confirming the interpretation and application of the Act in this context.
Alert