Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Paramount Home Entertainment & Anor v British Sky Broadcasting & Ors

England and Wales High Court (Chancery Division)
Feb 18, 2014
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

The case concerns an application for website blocking orders under section 97A of the Copyright, Design and Patents Act 1988, aimed at combating online copyright infringement in films and television programmes. The Applicants, major film studios acting on behalf of their groups, brought the claim against the six main Internet service providers in the United Kingdom (the Respondents). The application targets four websites known collectively as the "Target Websites," which facilitate access to copyrighted content without authorization. The Respondents do not oppose the application, and the terms of the proposed court orders have been agreed, subject to the Court's approval.

Section 97A was introduced to implement Article 8(3) of the European Information Society Directive, enabling injunctions against service providers who have actual knowledge of copyright infringement occurring through their services. This provision addresses the challenge that, under English law, injunctions cannot typically be granted against parties lacking a substantive cause of action. The section was first applied in 2011 in a case involving a major Internet service provider, and subsequent jurisprudence has established principles guiding such applications.

The Court summarized four jurisdictional requirements for granting an injunction under section 97A: (1) the Respondents must be service providers; (2) the operators of the Target Websites must infringe copyright; (3) the infringing activity must use the Respondents' services; and (4) the Respondents must have actual knowledge of the infringement. If these are met, the Court then considers proportionality and discretion before granting relief.

The evidence, including witness testimony from a legal representative of the Applicants, establishes that the Target Websites operate without licenses, primarily to make copyrighted film and television content available to the public, including users in the UK. The operators are mostly offshore and aware of the infringement. Investigations show that the vast majority of content available on these sites is likely protected by copyright. The Target Websites do not themselves host the infringing content but provide categorization, editorial oversight, and search functions, linking users to separate hosting sites where the content is streamed.

The Respondents are undisputedly service providers. The Court accepted the Applicants' submissions that the operators of the Target Websites either directly communicate copyrighted works to the public or authorize such communication by others, and are liable as joint tortfeasors. The communication to the public is targeted at UK users, as evidenced by website popularity, English language use, and UK-focused advertising. The Respondents’ services are used to facilitate the infringement, and they have actual knowledge of it, having been notified and served with the application and evidence.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the Respondents qualify as service providers under section 97A of the Copyright, Design and Patents Act 1988.
  2. Whether the operators of the Target Websites infringe copyright by communicating protected works to the public.
  3. Whether the infringing activity uses the services of the Respondents.
  4. Whether the Respondents have actual knowledge of the infringement.
  5. Whether the Court should exercise its discretion to grant injunctions, considering proportionality and competing rights.

Arguments of the Parties

The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the parties' legal arguments.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Twentieth Century Fox Film Corpn v BT [2011] RPC 28; [2011] EWHC 2714 (Ch) Initial application and form of relief for website blocking under section 97A. Established the framework and principles for granting injunctions against ISPs for copyright infringement.
Paramount Home Entertainment International Ltd & Others v British Sky Broadcasting Ltd & Others [2013] EWHC 3479 (Ch) ("Paramount v BSB") Clarification of principles for applications under section 97A, including the broad interpretation of "communication to the public". The Court adopted the principles as settled law and applied them to the present facts, particularly regarding operators’ intervention and targeting of a new public.
ITV Broadcasting Ltd v TV Catchup Ltd (Case C-607/11) Definition of "communication to the public" includes retransmission by internet streaming to subscribers, even within original broadcast area. Supported the broad interpretation of communication to the public encompassing retransmissions via different technical means.
Nils Svensson and Others v Retriever Sverige AB (Case C-466/12) Provision of access by hyperlink generally constitutes a communication to the public; no new public if access is to the same public as original communication. Distinguished on facts; link provision is communication, but here the infringing content was not previously authorized, so the case did not affect the present application.
EMI Records Ltd v British Sky Broadcasting Ltd [2013] EWHC 379 (Ch) Factors indicating targeting of the UK public for communication acts. Applied factors such as website popularity in the UK, English language use, and UK-targeted advertising to conclude targeting was established.
Rugby Football Union v Consolidated Information Ltd [2012] UKSC 55 Approach to proportionality in injunction applications balancing competing rights. Guided the Court’s proportionality analysis, balancing rights to privacy, data protection, and freedom of expression against copyright protection.
Golden Eye (International) Ltd v Telefonica UK Ltd [2012] RPC 28 Proportionality test in copyright injunctions. Supported the proportionality approach adopted by the Court in balancing rights and interests.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court began by confirming the jurisdictional requirements under section 97A of the Act, all of which were satisfied on the evidence. The Respondents are undisputedly service providers. The operators of the Target Websites infringe copyright by making protected works available to the public without authorization. The Court accepted the Applicants' submissions that the operators either directly communicate the works or authorize others to do so, and are liable as joint tortfeasors. The infringing communication is targeted at UK users, supported by evidence of website usage, language, and advertising.

The Court noted that the Target Websites do not host the infringing content but facilitate access through categorization, editorial oversight, and embedded streaming players linking to offshore hosts. This activity constitutes communication to the public within the meaning of the law, including the Information Society Directive and relevant case law.

The Court considered the recent ECJ decision in Svensson but found it factually distinguishable, as the infringing content in the present case was not previously authorized or publicly available. The Court accepted established principles that hyperlinking normally amounts to communication to the public, but emphasized the importance of identifying the relevant public and whether it is new compared to the original communication.

On the issue of actual knowledge, the Court found that the Respondents had acquired such knowledge through notice and evidence served on them. The Court then proceeded to consider proportionality and discretion, balancing the Applicants' copyright rights against the Respondents' and users' rights to privacy, data protection, and freedom of expression under Article 10 of the ECHR.

The Court concluded that the Applicants' rights prevail, given the illegitimacy of the Target Websites' activities and the availability of lawful alternatives for users. The Respondents, as intermediaries, did not oppose the relief and have the technical means to comply with the orders. The cost and burden of compliance are modest, and liberty to apply is preserved for any arising issues.

Accordingly, the Court found it appropriate to grant the injunctions sought.

Holding and Implications

The Court granted the injunctions sought under section 97A of the Copyright, Design and Patents Act 1988 against the Respondents (the Internet service providers), requiring them to block access to the Target Websites.

The direct effect of this decision is to prevent the Respondents from providing access to the infringing websites, thereby assisting in the protection of copyright holders' rights. The decision follows established precedent and does not set new legal principles but reaffirms the application of existing law to online copyright infringement and intermediary liability. The Court emphasized the balance of rights and the proportionality of the relief, ensuring that the injunctions are justified and not unduly burdensome.