Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Revenue & Customs v Mayes

England and Wales Court of Appeal (Civil Division)
Apr 12, 2011
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

These are two linked second appeals under the Taxes Management Act 1970 concerning a tax-saving scheme known as SHIPS 2, marketed by Company A as an "innovative tax solution" offering higher-rate income tax relief. The scheme involved a non-resident company purchasing non-qualifying life assurance policies ("AIG Bonds"), followed shortly by partial surrender and withdrawal of funds. The main legal dispute is whether these pre-ordained, composite, artificial, and tax-motivated events are to be disregarded for fiscal purposes.

The scheme targeted high-earning UK residents, promising income tax and capital gains tax (CGT) loss relief through "corresponding deficiency relief." The appeals focus on whether SHIPS 2 achieved its intended tax consequences, specifically the availability of deductible income tax losses and the proper amount deductible for CGT purposes.

The Special Commissioner decided in favor of the tax authority at first instance. The lead participant, Plaintiff, appealed, with the court partially allowing the appeal on the income tax issue but remitting the CGT issue for further fact-finding. Both parties subsequently brought second appeals to the court, with permission granted due to the general importance and prospects of success on points of statutory interpretation relating to life policy taxation under the Income & Corporation Taxes Act 1988 (ICTA).

The case is complex due to the interaction of statutory construction principles developed in tax avoidance jurisprudence and the highly artificial nature of the SHIPS 2 transactions, which are structured around ICTA provisions that themselves operate in a formulaic and arguably artificial manner. The court anticipates that the final resolution may not be reached at this appeal level.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether, for income tax purposes, the payments made and partial surrenders under SHIPS 2 constitute premiums and surrenders within the meaning of ICTA, thereby generating corresponding deficiency relief.
  2. Whether, for CGT purposes, the consideration paid by the Plaintiff for the acquisition of the life assurance policies is wholly and exclusively for the policies themselves, entitling him to claim a deductible loss on surrender.
  3. How the Ramsay principle of statutory construction applies to the interpretation of ICTA provisions in the context of composite, pre-ordained, self-cancelling transactions designed for tax avoidance.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments (Plaintiff)

  • The payments made at Step 3 were genuine premiums securing benefits under the policies.
  • The withdrawal at Step 4 constituted a partial surrender, triggering a chargeable event under ICTA.
  • The Ramsay principle is an aid to statutory construction but does not override the clear legislative language; thus, the legal steps cannot be disregarded merely because they were inserted for tax avoidance.
  • The corresponding deficiency relief is properly claimable as the statutory provisions apply to each legal step individually.
  • Regarding CGT, the entire consideration paid under the Deed of Assignment was for the acquisition of the policies, entitling the Plaintiff to claim a deductible loss without the need for further fact-finding.

Respondent's Arguments (Tax Authority)

  • Steps 3 and 4 form a single composite, self-cancelling transaction with no commercial purpose, inserted solely for tax avoidance.
  • Under the Ramsay principle, these steps should be disregarded for tax purposes as they do not produce genuine chargeable events under ICTA.
  • The Special Commissioner's factual findings supporting this characterization are binding and should not be reopened.
  • On the CGT issue, the consideration paid by the Plaintiff exceeds the surrender value of the policies, with the excess representing payment for tax benefits rather than the policies themselves.
  • The CGT issue requires remission for further fact-finding as the Special Commissioner did not determine the appropriate amount deductible.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
WT Ramsay Ltd v. IRC [1982] AC 300 Established the "new approach" to purposive statutory construction in tax avoidance cases, allowing composite transactions to be viewed as a whole for tax purposes. Served as the foundational principle guiding the court's analysis of SHIPS 2's composite transactions and their fiscal consequences.
Furniss v Dawson [1984] AC 474 Applied and expanded the Ramsay principle to tax avoidance schemes. Referenced to illustrate the development of purposive interpretation in tax law.
MacNiven (Inspector of Taxes) v Westmoreland Investments Ltd [2001] UKHL 6 Clarified the application of Ramsay, emphasizing that the court must consider the composite transaction realistically but not disregard genuine legal steps. Distinguished from SHIPS 2 as MacNiven did not involve purely self-cancelling steps; used to critique the Special Commissioner's approach.
Carreras Group Ltd v. Stamp Commissioner [2004] STC 1377 Confirmed that revenue statutes concern the entirety of transactions with commercial unity, possibly disregarding individual steps. Supported the principle that composite transactions may be treated as single units for tax purposes.
Edwards v. HMRC [2009] EWCA Civ 1010 Reinforced the application of Ramsay in tax avoidance contexts. Relied upon by the tax authority to support their case that Steps 3 and 4 should be disregarded.
HMRC v. Drummond [2008] EWHC 1758 Addressed the "wholly and exclusively" test for CGT consideration. Bound the Special Commissioner on the CGT issue, indicating factual inquiry is needed to determine deductible consideration.
Drummond v. HMRC [2009] EWCA Civ 608 Confirmed that determination of consideration under the "wholly and exclusively" test is a question of fact for the tribunal. Supported the court's decision to remit the CGT issue for fact-finding.
Spectros International plc v Madden (Inspector of Taxes) [1997] STC 114 Held that agreed consideration between parties is conclusive for CGT purposes. Considered but distinguished due to the factual complexities in the present case.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court conducted a detailed purposive construction of the ICTA provisions governing life assurance policies, focusing on whether payments and partial surrenders under SHIPS 2 fall within the statutory definitions of premiums and chargeable events. It acknowledged the artificial and self-cancelling nature of Steps 3 and 4 but emphasized that the legislation operates formulaically, taxing deemed gains rather than actual commercial gains.

The court held that the Ramsay principle requires a purposive and contextual interpretation of tax statutes but does not authorize disregarding genuine legal steps solely because they lack commercial purpose or were inserted for tax avoidance. The court agreed with the Appellant that Steps 3 and 4 were legally valid premiums and partial surrenders, triggering fiscal consequences under ICTA.

The court found that the Special Commissioner erred in law by treating Steps 3 and 4 as fiscally irrelevant. It endorsed the reasoning of the lower appellate court that the statutory language and scheme do not support ignoring these steps, even if they produce outcomes contrary to commercial reality or legislative intent.

On the CGT issue, the court recognized that the Special Commissioner failed to make necessary factual findings regarding what part of the consideration paid by the Plaintiff was wholly and exclusively for the acquisition of the policies. The court held that this is a factual question for the tribunal and thus remitted the matter for further fact-finding. It rejected the Plaintiff's submission that the issue could be resolved as a matter of law without further inquiry.

Holding and Implications

The court issued the following rulings:

  • DISMISSED the tax authority's appeal on the corresponding deficiency relief issue, affirming that the payments and partial surrenders constitute premiums and chargeable events under ICTA despite their artificial and self-cancelling nature.
  • DISMISSED the Plaintiff's appeal on the CGT issue, ordering that the question of the deductible consideration must be remitted to the First-tier Tribunal for factual determination.

The direct effect is that the Plaintiff is entitled to claim corresponding deficiency relief for income tax purposes, but the precise amount of CGT loss deductible remains to be determined after further factual inquiry. The decision does not establish new precedent beyond applying established principles of purposive statutory construction and the Ramsay principle. The court acknowledged the legislative scheme's potential for unintended outcomes and emphasized that any correction lies with Parliament, not the judiciary.