Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Tabernacle v Secretary of State for Defence

England and Wales Court of Appeal (Civil Division)
Feb 5, 2009
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

This is an appeal against the decision of the Divisional Court dismissing the appellant's application for judicial review challenging the legality of paragraph 7(2)(f) of the Atomic Weapons Establishment (AWE) Aldermaston Byelaws 2007 (the 2007 Byelaws). The appellant, a long-time member of a peace camp protesting nuclear weapons near the AWE site, camped on land within the Controlled Areas where the byelaws prohibited camping. The core issue is whether the camping prohibition violates the appellant's right to freedom of expression under Article 10 of the European Convention on Human Rights (ECHR).

The peace camp has operated for approximately 23 years, assembling monthly for peaceful protests including vigils, meetings, and demonstrations. The land is divided into Protected Areas, where public access is forbidden, and Controlled Areas, where public access has been permitted since at least 1986. The 2007 Byelaws, effective from 31 May 2007, prohibit camping within the Controlled Areas, making contravention a criminal offence.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether paragraph 7(2)(f) of the 2007 Byelaws unlawfully interferes with the appellant's right to freedom of expression under Article 10 of the ECHR.
  2. Whether the interference with Article 10 rights is justified under the conditions set out in Article 10(2), including considerations of national security, public safety, prevention of disorder or crime, and protection of the rights of others.
  3. Whether there is a violation of Article 11 regarding freedom of peaceful assembly and association, as it relates to the mode of protest represented by the camping.

Arguments of the Parties

Secretary of State's Arguments

  • The Secretary of State bears the burden of justifying the interference with Article 10 rights and submits that paragraph 7(2)(f) serves legitimate aims such as national security, public safety, prevention of disorder or crime, and protection of others' rights.
  • The right of public access to the Controlled Areas is granted solely by the 2007 Byelaws, which include conditions such as the camping prohibition; there is no positive obligation to provide space for protest camping.
  • The prohibition only restricts the manner and form of the protest, not its essence, allowing the peace camp to protest by other means.
  • Precedents from Strasbourg jurisprudence support that restrictions on manner and form of expression may be proportionate if not arbitrary or blanket bans.
  • Camping is generally prohibited across the Defence Estate for operational and security reasons, including concerns about surveillance, use of camping as cover for terrorist activities, lack of sanitation, and complaints about nuisance.
  • The byelaw's interference is justified within a broad margin of appreciation afforded to the State in balancing competing interests.

Appellant's Arguments

  • The peace camp's camping is not merely the manner or form of protest but an inherent, symbolic part of the protest itself, constituting core political expression protected by Article 10.
  • The Secretary of State's argument that the public access is granted subject to conditions is a non sequitur; government property is held for public good without a private interest to restrict protest rights.
  • The Secretary of State failed to give adequate weight to the subject matter of the protest—nuclear weapons—which demands a high level of protection under Article 10.
  • The interference with the right is substantial, going to the essence of the right, and thus requires a substantial objective justification amounting to a pressing social need.
  • The security and nuisance concerns raised by the Secretary of State are either unsubstantiated or insufficient to justify the prohibition, especially given the peaceful nature of the protests.
  • Case law such as Redmond-Bate v DPP supports the principle that threats of disorder must be imminent and that the State should address disorderly conduct from others rather than restrict peaceful protestors.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Sunday Times v United Kingdom (1979) 2 EHRR 245 Establishes the requirement of a "pressing social need" for restrictions on freedom of expression to be justified. Used to frame the proportionality and necessity test for the byelaw interference with Article 10 rights.
Ziliberberg v Moldova (Application 61821/00) Recognition of distinction between the essence of a right and the manner and form of its exercise. Supports the Secretary of State's argument on manner and form restrictions.
Ashingdan v UK (1985) 7 EHRR 528 Further recognition of the essence versus manner and form distinction in freedom of expression rights. Supports the Secretary of State's argument regarding the scope of permissible restrictions.
F v Switzerland (1987) 10 EHRR 411 Similar recognition of the distinction between core rights and their exercise. Referenced in evaluating proportionality of restrictions.
Rai, Allmond & "Negotiate Now" v UK (1995) 19 EHRR CD93 Restrictions on manner and form of protest can be proportionate if not arbitrary or blanket bans. Used by the Secretary of State to argue the byelaw is a proportionate restriction on manner and form.
Chorherr v Austria (1993) 17 EHRR 358 Authorities have a margin of appreciation in choosing reasonable means to ensure peaceful lawful demonstrations. Supports the Secretary of State's position on proportionality and margin of appreciation.
Chapman v UK (2001) 10 BHRC 48 (Application No 272385/95) Minority lifestyle does not confer immunity from general laws; States enjoy margin of appreciation in balancing rights. Invoked by the Secretary of State to support broad discretion in justifying byelaw restrictions.
Vajna v Hungary (Application 33629/06) Acts as well as words may constitute political expression under Article 10. Supports the appellant's argument that camping is a form of political expression.
Lindon and others v France (2008) 46 EHRR 35 Political and militant expression on matters of general concern require high protection under Article 10. Supports appellant's argument for strong protection of the protest.
Redmond-Bate v DPP [1999] EWHC Admin 732 Police must identify source of threat of violence; peaceful protestors should not be restricted due to hostile crowd reactions. Relied upon by appellant to argue against justification based on public nuisance or disorder.
Wise v Dunning Provocative speech may justify police intervention if it risks violence. Referenced in Redmond-Bate to distinguish source of disorder.
Beatty v Gilbanks Disturbances caused by hostile parties to protestors should be addressed against those parties, not protestors. Referenced in Redmond-Bate to support protection of peaceful protestors.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court carefully examined whether paragraph 7(2)(f) of the 2007 Byelaws constituted an unlawful interference with the appellant's Article 10 rights. It acknowledged the distinction between the essence of a right and the manner and form of its exercise, but emphasized that this distinction depends on factual context. The court recognized that the camping prohibition restricts only the manner and form of protest, not the right to protest itself.

However, the court found that in this case the camping formed an integral and symbolic part of the protest, effectively constituting the protest itself. The longstanding and consistent nature of the camp over 23 years demonstrated that camping was not merely incidental but central to the expression.

The court rejected the Secretary of State's justification as insubstantial. It noted the absence of enforcement against the camp over many years, the lack of detailed evidence of operational or security incompatibility, and considered the nuisance arguments as insufficient to amount to a pressing social need. The court emphasized that rights to protest often involve inconvenience or nuisance, which do not justify disproportionate restrictions.

The court concluded that the Secretary of State had failed to demonstrate a substantial objective justification amounting to a pressing social need to justify the camping prohibition. The margin of appreciation claimed was not applicable to the extent argued, given the nature of the rights engaged.

Lord Justice Wall concurred, highlighting the vulnerability of the Secretary of State's argument and the absence of evidence that camping was incompatible with operational requirements. He also distinguished the margin of appreciation applicable in Article 8 cases from that in Articles 10 and 11 cases.

Lord Justice Stanley Burnton agreed with the judgments of Laws LJ and Wall LJ.

Holding and Implications

The court ALLOWED THE APPEAL, holding that paragraph 7(2)(f) of the 2007 Byelaws violates the appellant's rights guaranteed by Articles 10 and 11 of the ECHR.

The direct effect of this decision is to invalidate the camping prohibition as it applies to the appellant and the peace camp, affirming their right to camp as a form of protected political expression. The court did not establish new precedent beyond the application of existing principles to the specific facts, but it clarified the importance of recognizing symbolic modes of protest as core to freedom of expression and the limits of the State's margin of appreciation in such contexts.