Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

New Look Retailers Ltd v London Fire & Emergency Planning Authority

England and Wales Court of Appeal (Criminal Division)
Jun 16, 2010
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

This appeal arises from a sentencing decision by HHJ Rivlin QC, Recorder of Westminster, imposing a total fine of £400,000 on the Appellant, a private company operating approximately 612 retail premises across the United Kingdom, for two offences under the Regulatory Reform (Fire Safety) Order 2005. The offences related to failures in fire risk assessment and employee fire safety training at one of the Appellant’s retail premises located on a major shopping street in London.

On 26 April 2009, a serious fire broke out at the premises, requiring extensive fire service intervention and evacuation of approximately 400 people. Investigations revealed multiple deficiencies in fire safety precautions, risk assessment, and training. The Appellant pleaded guilty to two counts of breaching Articles 9 and 21 of the Order, respectively, relating to inadequate fire risk assessment and failure to provide adequate safety training to employees.

The sentencing judge imposed fines of £250,000 and £150,000 for the two counts and ordered the Appellant to pay prosecution costs. The Appellant appealed against the sentence with leave granted by the single judge, raising, among other issues, whether sentencing under the Fire Safety Order should align with principles applied under the Health and Safety at Work Act 1974.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether and to what extent the approach to sentencing offences under the Regulatory Reform (Fire Safety) Order 2005 should follow the principles applied to offences under the Health and Safety at Work Act 1974.
  2. Whether the sentencing judge erred in imposing a fine that failed to sufficiently consider that the breaches did not cause fire, injury, or death.
  3. Whether the fines imposed were manifestly excessive or disproportionate to the breaches and the Appellant’s circumstances.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments

  • The sentencing judge gave insufficient weight to the fact that the breaches were not causative of the fire, injury, or death.
  • The judge applied a higher presumed standard of seriousness to fire safety breaches than would be appropriate under the Health and Safety at Work Act 1974.
  • The fine imposed was disproportionate to the admitted breaches and exceeded fines typically imposed for breaches causing death under health and safety legislation.
  • The sentencing judge’s starting point of £600,000 indicated an intention to impose a disproportionate fine.
  • Reliance on Sentencing Guidelines for Corporate Manslaughter and Health and Safety Offences causing death suggested fines for breaches without death or injury should be lower.

Respondent's Arguments

  • The sentencing judge correctly applied established principles for corporate sentencing, including seriousness of breach, capacity to pay, and deterrence.
  • The Regulatory Reform (Fire Safety) Order 2005 creates offences requiring proof that breaches placed relevant persons at risk of death or serious injury, aligning it closely with health and safety legislation.
  • The judge appropriately considered the potential for disaster given the location and scale of the premises and the magnitude of risk created by the breaches.
  • The fines were severe but not manifestly excessive or disproportionate given the facts and the Appellant’s financial position.
  • The judge did not intend to set a new sentencing standard or impose fines based on the occurrence of the fire itself, but on the risk created by the breaches.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
F. Howe & Sons Engineers Ltd [1992] 2 Cr App R(S) 37 Correct approach to sentencing corporate offences. The court confirmed the sentencing judge followed these principles in assessing seriousness and fines.
R v Balfour Beatty Rail Infrastructure Services Limited [2006] EWCA Crim 186 Principles of sentencing for corporate health and safety offences, including consideration of seriousness, means, and deterrence. The court referenced this case to affirm the balancing of seriousness, capacity to pay, and impact on shareholders.
ESB Hotels Limited [2005] EWCA Crim 132 Assessment of fines in fire safety offences contributing to death; consideration of culpability, causation, means, and mitigation. The court found no benchmark for the present case but supported fact-sensitive sentencing and reduction of fines where appropriate.
TDG UK Plc [2008] EWCA Crim 1963 Use of decided cases to obtain a "feel for the appropriate sentence". The sentencing judge used this guidance to inform but not dictate the fine imposed.
R v. Friskies Petcare UK Ltd (No 99/5226/W5, 10 March 2000) Fines exceeding £500,000 typically reserved for major public disasters involving risk to large numbers of people. The court noted the fine in that case was reduced, illustrating that high fines are not automatic absent major disasters.
John Pointon & Sons [2008] EWCA Crim 513 Fines for health and safety breaches causing death can be below £500,000 depending on circumstances. The court used this case to demonstrate that fines vary with facts even where death occurs.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court began by examining the nature of the offences under the Regulatory Reform (Fire Safety) Order 2005, noting that it parallels the Health and Safety at Work Act 1974 in requiring responsible persons to take reasonable fire safety precautions to protect employees and others. Article 32 creates offences where breaches place persons at risk of death or serious injury in case of fire.

The court acknowledged that the sentencing judge properly considered established sentencing principles for corporate offenders, including seriousness of breach, the offender’s means, and the need for deterrence impacting shareholders and senior management.

The court rejected the Appellant’s contention that a higher standard of seriousness or presumption of greater fines applied to fire safety breaches compared to health and safety breaches generally. It held that the sentencing judge did not intend to set a new standard but applied conventional principles recognized in prior case law.

The court emphasized that although no death or injury resulted from the breaches, the risk created by the Appellant’s failures was substantial, especially given the location and scale of the premises. The judge was entitled to impose a substantial fine to reflect this risk and to send a clear message about the importance of fire safety.

The court considered the mitigating factors accepted by the sentencing judge, including the Appellant’s guilty pleas, cooperation, and remedial steps, but shared the judge’s view that the response was insufficient given the scale of the risk.

Ultimately, the court found that the fines imposed were severe but not manifestly excessive or disproportionate to the breaches or the Appellant’s financial capacity.

Holding and Implications

The appeal is DISMISSED. The court upheld the fines imposed by the sentencing judge, affirming that the fines were appropriate given the seriousness of the breaches and the risk posed, notwithstanding the absence of actual injury or death.

The decision confirms that sentencing for breaches under the Regulatory Reform (Fire Safety) Order 2005 should follow established principles applied in health and safety legislation, balancing seriousness, means, and deterrence without assuming a higher tariff solely due to the nature of fire safety legislation.

No new precedent altering sentencing principles was established. The ruling underscores that courts may impose substantial fines based on the risk created by breaches, even where no harm has occurred, particularly in cases involving large organizations and premises with significant public exposure.