Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

McWhirter & Anor, R (on the application of) v Secretary of State for Foreign and Commonwealth Affairs

England and Wales Court of Appeal (Civil Division)
Mar 5, 2003
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

This opinion concerns an application for permission to appeal against a refusal by a lower court judge to grant judicial review of two decisions: (1) the decision to bring into effect the provisions of the European Communities (Amendment) Act 2002 by depositing an instrument of ratification of the Treaty of Nice with the Italian government on 25 July 2002; and (2) the decision not to withdraw that instrument of ratification on 21 October 2002, with their consequent implications on the 2002 Act.

The applicants, described as vigorous campaigners for constitutional rights, challenged these decisions on the basis that the Treaty of Nice and the 2002 Act purported to transfer or cede sovereignty from the United Kingdom to European Union institutions that are not accountable to the UK Parliament or Government, thereby violating fundamental constitutional principles.

The lower court refused permission for judicial review, holding that the treaty-making power of the Crown is not justiciable and that the court cannot disapply or invalidate primary legislation such as the 2002 Act. The applicants seek permission to appeal this refusal.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the court has jurisdiction to judicially review the exercise of the Crown's treaty-making powers, specifically regarding the ratification of the Treaty of Nice.
  2. Whether the court can disapply or invalidate the European Communities (Amendment) Act 2002 on the grounds that it violates fundamental constitutional rights by transferring sovereignty to European institutions.
  3. Whether the incorporation of the Treaty of Nice into domestic law via the 2002 Act constitutes an unlawful transfer or abrogation of the United Kingdom's legislative and executive powers.
  4. Whether there exists a constitutional limit on Parliament’s power to transfer legislative authority to European institutions, and if so, whether that limit has been exceeded by the Treaty of Nice and the 2002 Act.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellants' Arguments

  • The Treaty of Nice and the 2002 Act unlawfully alienate or cede sovereignty of the United Kingdom to European Union institutions that are not accountable to UK democratic mechanisms.
  • This transfer of sovereignty violates fundamental constitutional principles, including rights derived from the common law and constitutional statutes such as Magna Carta.
  • The Treaty extends qualified majority voting and reduces the UK's influence in European institutions, thereby undermining the UK's constitutional governance.
  • The court should have jurisdiction to review the treaty ratification when it affects domestic constitutional rights and to invalidate legislation that interferes with those rights.

Respondent's Arguments

  • The treaty-making power of the Crown is not subject to judicial review.
  • The court cannot disapply or invalidate primary legislation such as the European Communities (Amendment) Act 2002, which was duly enacted by Parliament.
  • Ratification of treaties is an international act not governed by domestic law and may occur independently of domestic implementation.
  • Any challenge to the effect of the Treaty of Nice on domestic law should be addressed when specific European legislation is applied domestically, not by abstract challenges to ratification.
  • Parliament remains sovereign and may repeal or amend the 2002 Act, which is the ultimate constitutional safeguard.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
McWhirter v Attorney General [1972] CMLR 882 Established that treaty-making powers of the Crown are not justiciable. Supported the principle that courts cannot review the exercise of treaty-making powers.
CCSU v Minister for the Civil Service [1985] AC 375 Confirmed limits on judicial review of prerogative powers. Reinforced the non-justiciability of certain executive decisions including treaty ratification.
Abbasi [2002] EWCA Civ 1598 Recent authority on the limits of judicial review of executive powers. Used to illustrate the established principle of non-justiciability of treaty ratification.
Pickin v British Railways Board [1974] AC 765 Confirmed the sovereignty of Parliament and immunity of statute from judicial review. Supported the court's position that primary legislation cannot be invalidated by courts.
Factortame [1991] 1 AC 603 Illustrated that EU law can override inconsistent domestic legislation under the 1972 Act. Distinguished as a special case where EU law rights prevail, not applicable here.
Equal Opportunities Commission [1994] 1 WLR 409 Similar to Factortame, concerning the primacy of EU law. Referenced in discussion of limits on judicial invalidation of domestic legislation.
Thorburn [2002] 3 WLR 247 Discussed the concept of constitutional statutes and the relationship between EU and domestic law. Used to explain that the 1972 Act is a constitutional statute that cannot be impliedly repealed.
R v Lord Chancellor, ex parte Lightfoot [2000] QB 597 Considered limits on parliamentary power to legislate against fundamental rights. Referenced to leave open the question of fundamental rights not transferred to EU institutions.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court began by affirming the established legal principle that the Crown’s treaty-making power is not subject to judicial review, citing longstanding authoritative precedents. The applicants’ attempt to challenge the ratification of the Treaty of Nice on constitutional grounds was thus deemed non-justiciable.

Regarding the European Communities (Amendment) Act 2002, the court emphasized parliamentary sovereignty and the immunity of statute from judicial invalidation. Despite the applicants’ concerns that the 2002 Act unlawfully transfers sovereignty to European institutions, the court held that Parliament retains the ultimate authority to repeal or amend such legislation, which serves as the constitutional safeguard.

The court acknowledged the applicants’ argument that the Treaty of Nice significantly alters the UK's position within the European Union, including changes to voting arrangements and representation. However, it concluded that these political and constitutional concerns do not justify judicial intervention or invalidation of the statute.

The court also addressed the relationship between EU law and domestic law, noting that EU law rights incorporated by the 1972 Act have supremacy, but this does not extend to permitting courts to disapply primary legislation on the grounds asserted by the applicants.

Finally, the court agreed with the respondent’s submission that challenges to the effects of the Treaty of Nice on domestic law should be made when specific EU legislation is applied domestically, rather than by abstract challenges to the ratification process.

Holding and Implications

The court REFUSED PERMISSION TO APPEAL against the refusal to grant judicial review.

This decision upholds the principle that the Crown’s treaty-making power is not justiciable and reinforces parliamentary sovereignty by confirming that courts cannot invalidate primary legislation such as the European Communities (Amendment) Act 2002 on constitutional grounds raised by the applicants. The ruling clarifies that constitutional concerns about the transfer of sovereignty to European institutions must be addressed politically through Parliament rather than judicially. No new precedent was established beyond affirming existing legal principles. The applicants retain the possibility of challenging specific EU legislation domestically as it arises.