Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Dr Garima Dubey And 3 Others v. Dr. Saurabh Anand Dubey

Allahabad High Court
Apr 21, 2026
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

This appeal arises from an impugned order dated 07.04.2025 in proceedings where the respondent-husband filed a divorce petition. The appellant (wife, Dr. Garima Dubey) and her three children (appellant nos.2–4) challenged the trial court's partial rejection of their maintenance application under Sections 24 and 26 of the Hindu Marriage Act, 1955. The trial court dismissed the wife's claim under Section 24 but allowed maintenance for the children under Section 26; the respondent is undisputedly paying Rs.60,000 per month for the children's maintenance. The wife appealed against the rejection of her Section 24 claim. The High Court delivered its decision on April 21, 2026.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the appellant-wife is entitled to maintenance under Section 24 of the Hindu Marriage Act, 1955 despite being a qualified M.D. (Gynecology).
  2. Whether the trial court correctly assessed the appellant's earning capacity (including reliance on ITRs indicating income exceeding Rs.31 lakhs per annum) when refusing maintenance under Section 24.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments

  • The appellant contended she is presently not working, having been removed from the hospital after the respondent filed the case.
  • She asserted entitlement to support from the respondent to sustain the standard of living enjoyed prior to separation.

Respondent's Arguments

  • The respondent submitted he has been faithfully paying Rs.60,000 per month for the children's maintenance.
  • He argued the appellant is a trained specialist (Gynecologist) capable of earning handsomely—potentially more than him—and the trial court rightly found her capable of self-support.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Chaturbhuj v. Sitabai reported in 2008 AIR SC 530 In that case the Supreme Court concluded the wife was unemployed and the husband had sufficient means; the husband's appeal against maintenance under Section 125 Cr.P.C. was dismissed. The High Court distinguished Chaturbhuj v. Sitabai on facts, noting the present appellant is a qualified MD (Gynecology) capable of earning, unlike the unemployed wife in Chaturbhuj.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court accepted as undisputed that the appellant is a postgraduate M.D. (Gynecology) and capable of earning substantially from her expertise. It rejected the appellant's claim of presently not working. The Court applied the legal principle that where a qualified person is capable of earning and refrains from doing so to impose a burden on the husband, maintenance under Section 24 may be denied. The Court reviewed the trial court's findings, including reliance on the appellant's Income Tax Returns indicating annual earnings in excess of Rs.31 lakhs, and found no error in the trial court's conclusion denying maintenance to the wife under Section 24.

Holding and Implications

APPEAL DISMISSED

Direct effect: The impugned order of 07.04.2025 is upheld—the appellant's application under Section 24 of the Hindu Marriage Act was properly dismissed, while maintenance for the children under Section 26 remains allowed and the respondent continues paying Rs.60,000 per month. The opinion does not assert any broader precedent beyond applying established principles on earning capacity and denial of maintenance where a qualified spouse refrains from earning.

Show all summary ...

HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT ALLAHABAD

FIRST APPEAL No. - 594 of 2025 Court No. - 2

HON'BLE ATUL SREEDHARAN, J. HON'BLE VIVEK SARAN, J.

1. Present appeal has been filed by the appellant who is a wife. The divorce petition has been filed by the respondent-husband. The appellant no.1 is M.D. (Gynaecologist) and the respondent-husband is Neurosurgeon. Both are residents of Prayagraj. Appellant nos..2,3 and 4 are the children of the appellant and the respondent out of which appellant nos.2 and 3 are daughters and appelant no.4 is a son. Their names are not being given in the order to protect their identity and privacy. The appellants are aggrieved by the impugned order dated 07.04.2025 by which an application for maintenance filed by the wife and the three children under Sections 24 and 26 of the Hindu Marriage Act, 1955 has been rejected in part. The application of the Appellant No.1 under Section 24 of the Hindu Marriage Act has been dismissed, however application under Section 26 for maintenance of the children has been allowed and undisputedly, the respondent is paying Rs.60,000/- per month towards their maintenance.

2. Learned counsel for the appellant submits that the learned trial court failed to appreciate that presently the appellant is not working Versus

Counsel for Appellant(s) : Akarsh Dwivedi, Mrigendra Singh, Suvrat Dwivedi

Counsel for Respondent(s) : Abhishek Tripathi, Firoz Haider, Priya Saxena, Sanjay Kumar Pal

Dr Garima Dubey And 3 Others

.....Appellant(s)

Dr. Saurabh Anand Dubey

.....Respondent(s)

1

as she was removed from the hospital after filing of the case by the respondent-husband. He further submits that the appellant-wife is entitled to be supported by the respondent-husband to ensure that she can sustain the same standard of living which she enjoyed before the separation.

3. Learned counsel for the respondent on the other hand submits that the respondent has faithfully been paying the maintenance amount of Rs.60,000/- per month to the children without demur. He further submits that the appellant herein is a trained specialized Gynecologist who could earn more than the respondent himself in a State like Uttar Pradesh. He further submits that learned trial court has dismissed her application under Section 24 precisely as applicant is more capable of maintaining herself because of her qualification.

4. Heard learned counsel for the parties and perused the records of the case.

5. Undisputedly, the appellant is a trained Gynecologist being a Post- Graduate possessing a degree in M.D. (Gynecology). The judgment of the Hon'ble Supreme Court placed before this Court by learned counsel for the appellant Chaturbhuj v. Sitabai reported in 2008 AIR SC 530 is a case where the husband was aggrieved by the maintenance awarded to the wife under Section 125 of the Cr.P.C.. In that case, the Supreme Court had come to the conclusion that the wife was unemployed and she was in a position to show that the husband has sufficient means to maintain her. In such a situation, the Supreme Court dismissed the appeal filed by the husband. However, in the present case the facts disclose a totally different set of circumstances. As already held hereinabove the appellant is a Gynecologist and is capable of earning handsomely in her line of FAPL No. 594 of 2025

2

expertise.

6. The contention putforth by learned counsel for the appellant that she is presently not working is rejected. Where a qualified person is capable of earning more than enough through the use of her expertise and still refrains from doing so only to impose a burden upon her husband, in such a situation the Courts can deny maintenance under Section 24. Therefore, having gone through the order passed by the learned trial court where the application under Section 24 was rejected where the learned trial court has held that the appellant was earning handsomely based upon her ITRs which reflected that she was earning more than Rs.31 lakhs per annum.

7. Under the circumstances, this Court is of the opinion that the impugned order cannot be faulted. Appeal is dismissed.

April 21, 2026

Deepika FAPL No. 594 of 2025

3

(Vivek Saran,J.) (Atul Sreedharan,J.)

3