Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Anish Kumar v. Indian Army

Central Information Commission
Mar 9, 2026

Page 1 of 7 केȾीय सूचना आयोग Central Information Commission बाबा गंगनाथ मागŊ, मुिनरका Baba Gangnath Marg, Munirka नई िदʟी, New Delhi - 110067 File No: CIC/IARMY/A/2024/120710 Anish Kumar ….अपीलकताŊ/Appellant

VERSUS

बनाम

….Ůितवादीगण /Respondent The CPIO,

Bengal Engineer Group Records PIN - 908779, C/o 56 APO

Date of Hearing : 26.02.2026 Date of Decision : 09.03.2026

INFORMATION COMMISSIONER : SANJEEV KUMAR JINDAL

Relevant facts emerging from second appeal:

RTI application filed on : 27.11.2023 CPIO replied on : 09.01.2024

First appeal filed on : 23.01.2024 First Appellate Authority's

order

: 26.02.2024

2nd Appeal dated : 24.06.2024 1 / 8

1

Page 2 of 7 Information sought:

1. The Appellant filed an RTI application dated 27.11.2023 seeking the following information:

"I above named JCO presently serving at GE (Central) Khadki required the following information under RTI Act 2005 :-

(a) Not issuing promotion on due date after receiving clearance of present Med Cat asked vide BEG Record Roorkee.

(b) Copy of disciplinary / vigilance clearance from respective unit of JCOs already promoted.

(c) Authority for non-issuing promotion order in respect of JCOS/OR who involved in any Court of Inquiry related to Medico Legal Case.

(d) Present status of Med Category / Involvement in disciplinary /vigilance case in respect of JC-334285H Nb Sub / JE (Civ) Anish Kumar as per record held with BEG Records Roorkee.

(e) Copy of Noting Sheet / Copy of DV Ban/ Authority / any details for not issuing promotion of JC-334285H Nb Sub / JE (Civ) Anish Kumar.

(f) Is Medico Legal Case comes under Disciplinary case. if yes, then provide authority."

2. The CPIO furnished a reply to the Appellant on 09.01.2024 stating as under:

"(a) Para (a), (c) & (f). As per para 2 (a) (ix) of guidelines for handling of RTI applications issued by RTI Cell, ADG AE G-6, D1 wing vide letter No A/810027/RTI/Policy dated 16 Apr 2012 the term, "Information" as defined in the RTI Act 2005 does not include "answers to the Question like Why, What, When and Whether amounting to seeking

reasoning/clarification/interpretations/drawing inferences".

(b) Para (b).lt It is intimated that the information sought by you in ibid RTI application is a "Third Party Information" and there is no longer public interest in seeking information of other persons, but an invasion on the privacy of such personnel. Provisioning of such information is exempted under Section 8

(1) (j) of Right to Informaiton Act-2005 2 / 8

2

Page 3 of 7

(c) Para (d). As per records held with BEG Records Roorkee, your med cat is SHAPE-I. However, as per detailed report (physical casualty) received vide GE (Central). Khadki, Pune letter No 1220/235/E1M dated 21 Apr 2023, you sustained 'Closed head injury with laceration, Contusion left wrist and dislocation 1st IP Joint' on 18 Apr 2023 due to quarrel with your neighbour Nb Sub Virendra. Inspite of repeated reminders, med documents including copy of Medico Legal Case No 41/04/2023 duly authenticated by medical authority regarding said injury have not been recd. so far.

(d) Para (e) As per guidelines issued vide RTI Cell, IHQ of MoD (Army) letter No A/810027/RTI/Policy dated 19 Mar 2010, info on ACR grading, selection Bd and DPCs in respect of Armed Forces personnel is beyond the purview of RTI Act 2005 or as of now exempted from providing info under said Act."

3. Being dissatisfied, the appellant filed a First Appeal dated 23.01.2024. The FAA vide its order dated 26.02.2024 stated as under:

"(1) WHEREAS, JC334285H Nb Sub/JECIV Anish Kumar vide application dated 27 Nov 2023 sought the following information:-

(a) Not issuing promotion on due date after receiving clearance of present Med Cat asked vide BEG Records Roorkee.

(b) Copy of disciplinary/vigilance clearance from respective unit of JCOs already promoted.

(c) Authority for non-issuing promotion order in respect of JCOS/OR who involved in any Court of Inquiry related to Medico Legal Case.

(d) Present status of Med Category/Involvement in disciplinary/vigilance case in respect of JC334285H Nb Sub/JE (Civ) Anish Kumar as per record held with BEG Records Roorkee.

3 / 8

3

Page 4 of 7

(e) Copy of Noting Sheet/copy of DV Ban/Authority/any details for not issuing promotion of JC334285H Nb Sub/JE (Civ) Anish Kumar.

(f) Is Medico Legal Case comes under Disciplinary case. If yes, then provide authority.

(2) AND WHEREAS, PIO at Bengal Engineer Group Records vide letter No 23405/0340-23/Gen/RTI dated 09 Jan 2024 has provided details available on the subject.

(3) AND WHEREAS, aggrieved by the response of the PIO at Bengal Engineer Group Records, the applicant has now preferred an appeal dated 23 Jan 2024 received by BEG Records Roorkee on 31 Jan 2024 and 05 Feb 2024 respectively under the provisions of Section 19(1) of the said Act.

(4) AND NOW THEREFORE, after having perused all the records in the light of relevant rules and after hearing views of the PIO, I find that information sought by you have been correctly and adequately provided by the PIQ at Bengal Engineer Group Records vide letter No 23405/0340-23/Gen/RTI dated

09 Jan 2024. Moreover, para wise information as sought for vide your ibid appeal is as under:-

(a) Para 2 (a). As per the information regarding your involvement in a physical assault for which a court of Inquiry has been convened to investigate the fact is under progress as per Station Headquarters Khadki convening order No 1071/2/A(AK/VY) dated 26 Apr 2023, intimation to this effect was furnished by GE (Central) Khadki vide letter No 1231/355/E1M dated

12 Oct 2023 read with GE (Central) Khadki letter No 1220/248/E1M dated 11 Sep 2023.

(b) Para 2 (b). In this connection, it is intimated that you are involved in a Court of Inquiry which is not yet finalized. Your promotion has been kept in hold until finalization of the said Court of Inquiry as per Para 3(a) of AO 1/2018/DV (copy enclosed), for which the due clarification has already been sought from higher HQ vide our letter No 4751/Vol-53/30/CA1 dt. 26 Feb

2024.

4 / 8

4

Page 5 of 7

(5) The appeal is accordingly disposed off."

4. Feeling aggrieved and dissatisfied, appellant approached the Commission with the instant Second Appeal.

Relevant Facts emerged during Hearing:

The following were present: -

Appellant: Anish Kumar

Respondent: Major Kuldeep Singh, BG Records, Roorkee, CPIO

5. Proof of having served the copy of second appeal to the respondent while filing the same in CIC is not available on record.

6. The Appellant inter alia submitted that vide RTI application dated 27.11.2023 he had sought information regarding the policy/authority under which his promotion was withheld by the Record Office. He further submitted that CPIO reply dated 09.01.2024 is vague and unsatisfactory.

7. Written submissions dated 14.02.2026 filed by the appellant is taken on record which states that reply dated 09.01.2024 was vague and unsatisfactory. The Appellant submitted that there is misinterpretation of Army Rule 177(i), as a Court of Inquiry is merely a fact-finding body and not an adjudicatory proceeding, and therefore cannot be used as a legal basis to withhold promotion. It was further contended that the respondent CPIO and FAA misapplied Army Order 01/2018/DV by equating a Court of Inquiry with a disciplinary or vigilance case under Para 3(a), whereas a promotion ban applies only when formal cognizance of an offence is taken or a prima facie case is established by investigating agencies. The Appellant also alleged suppression of the specific policy/authority, as despite specifically seeking the Army policy that permits withholding promotion solely on the basis of a pending Court of Inquiry, no such policy was provided, thereby violating the RTI Act.

8. The respondent while defending their case inter alia submitted that a reply had already been provided vide letter dated 09.01.2024 based on the records available with the them. The respondent further submitted that the appellant is involved in a Court of Inquiry pertaining to a medico- legal case and therefore his promotion has been kept on hold till finalization of the said Court of Inquiry as per the applicable rules. 5 / 8

5

Page 6 of 7 Decision:

9. The Commission after adverting to the facts and circumstances of the case, hearing both the parties and perusal of the records, notes that the respondent CPIO had provided a reply on dated 09.01.2024. However, the Commission observes with regard to Para (f) of the RTI application, the reply given by the respondent CPIO appears inadequate. The Commission is of the view that if any authority, rule, or policy exists with the public authority clarifying whether a medico-legal case is treated as a disciplinary case, the same should be provided to the Appellant.

In view of the above, the Commission directs the respondent CPIO to re- examine the RTI application and provide a revised reply on Para (f) of the RTI application to the Appellant strictly in accordance with the provisions of the RTI Act, within 15 days from the date of receipt of this order, under intimation to the Commission.

With the above observations and directions, the appeal is disposed of. Sd/-

SANJEEV KUMAR JINDAL(संजीव कुमार िजंदल)

Information Commissioner (सूचना आयुƅ)

date: 09.03.2026

Authenticated true copy

(अिभŮमािणत सȑािपत Ůित)

(Col Prabhat Kumar)

Dy Registrar

011- 26107051

6 / 8

6

Page 7 of 7 Addresses of the Parties:

1. The CPIO Bengal Engineer Group Records PIN - 908779, C/o 56 APO

2. Shri Anish Kumar 7 / 8

7

Recomendation(s) to PA under section 25(5) of the RTI Act, 2005:-

Nil Powered by TCPDF (www.tcpdf.org) 1 / 18 8

8