- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
SHRI MAHENDRA SABHARU MAJHI Vs M/S MAHALXMI ENTERPRISES.... v. 25/02/2026 (J-R) BOMBAY(Civil)
Factual and Procedural Background
The appeal arises from an order of the Commissioner for Workmen's Compensation under the Employees' Compensation Act, 1923 dismissing the applicant's claim. The original applicant, Mahendra Sabharu Majhi (aged about 27 years), was employed by respondent no.1 at a construction site in Thane and suffered back injuries after a fall. He was hospitalized at Lok Hospital, Thane from 22 March 2010 to 29 March 2010. The applicant claimed Rs.5,95,584/- from opponent nos.1 and 2. Evidence of the applicant and opponent no.1 was recorded. The Commissioner dismissed the application solely because the disability certificate was issued by a doctor who did not attend the injured applicant, though that doctor had given evidence. The present appeal (First Appeal No.1627 of 2012) challenges that order. The appeal was admitted on 20 January 2014 but a substantial question of law was framed later. Respondent no.2 (insurance company) failed to appear despite notice and the appeal was proceeded with ex parte against them.
Legal Issues Presented
- "Whether the Commissioner for Workmen's Compensation was justified in rejecting the application for compensation on the sole ground that the disability certificate was issued by a doctor who did not attend to the injured applicant ?"
Arguments of the Parties
Appellant's Arguments
- The Commissioner erred in rejecting the claim solely because the disability certificate was issued by a doctor who did not personally attend the injured applicant.
- The doctor who issued the certificate is a "qualified medical practitioner" within the Act and may assess disability on the basis of medical records and give evidence subject to cross-examination.
- The depositions and certificate of a qualified medical practitioner who did not treat the workman are admissible and should have been considered to determine percentage of disability and compensation; reliance was placed on the Karnataka High Court decision Mukesh Kumar vs. Kulhari Tours and Travels Prof. Mahipal Singh & Anr.
- Respondent no.2 failed to appear despite service of notice.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Mukesh Kumar vs. Kulhari Tours and Travels Prof. Mahipal Singh & Anr. | There is no provision in the Employees' Compensation Act mandating assessment of loss of earning capacity only by a doctor who treated the workman; deposition of any qualified medical practitioner who examined the claimant and substantiates disability is admissible. | The court relied on this decision to hold that the Commissioner erred in rejecting the claim solely because the certifying doctor had not personally treated the injured; the precedent supported remand for consideration of the doctor's evidence to determine disability percentage. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The court noted the Commissioner dismissed the application solely because the disability certificate was issued by a doctor who had not attended the injured, despite that doctor having given evidence. The court examined the Act: Section 4(1)(c)(ii) and Explanation II require a disability certificate from a "qualified medical practitioner"; Section 2(1)(i) defines "qualified medical practitioner" by registration under a medical register. The court found no provision in the Act requiring that the certificate must be issued only by the doctor who treated the injured. The court observed that a qualified medical practitioner who did not treat the injured may assess disability based on medical records and give evidence subject to cross-examination. Therefore, rejecting the entire claim on that sole ground was erroneous. The court held that issues such as employer-employee relationship and course of employment, which had been decided against the applicant solely for that reason, are precluded from being re-examined except insofar as they depend on the disability certificate issue. The matter was remanded to the Commissioner for the limited purpose of considering the evidence of the doctor who issued the certificate, determining the disability percentage, and calculating compensation. The court proceeded ex parte as respondent no.2 did not appear.
Holding and Implications
DISPOSED OF: The appeal is allowed.
The impugned order dated 19 June 2012 is set aside and the matter is remanded to the Commissioner to consider the evidence of the doctor who issued the disability certificate, determine the percentage of disability and calculate compensation. The Commissioner is directed to conclude the compensation application by 30 June 2026; the appellant is to appear before the Commissioner on 23 March 2026 at 11:00 a.m. No other issue is to be re-examined by the Commissioner beyond the limited purpose stated. The opinion does not purport to set a new precedent beyond applying existing authority.
ppn 1 49.fa-1627.12.doc
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY
CIVIL APPELLATE JURISDICTION
FIRST APPEAL NO.1627 OF 2012
Mahendra Sabharu Majhi ) aged about 27 years, Occ: Nil, ) residing at : Gram Teveri, Post Budel, ) Taluka : Budel, Orissa. ) ….Appellant (Orig. Applicant)
V/s.
1. M/s. Mahlaxmi Enterprises ) 402, Mahalaxmi Apartment, ) Cama Lane, Ghatkopar (West) ) Mumbai 400 077. )
2. The Bajaj Allianz General Indusrance Co. Ltd. ) At 6thFloor, Sun Magnetica, Service Road, ) Near New R. T. O. Teen Naka, Lois Wadi, ) Tahne (West). ) .…Respondents
(Orig. Opponents)
----
Ms. Varsha Nichani for the appellant. Mr. Vijay Sardal for respondent no.1. ----
CORAM : JITENDRA JAIN, J.
DATED : 25 February 2026
Judgment :
1. This appeal arises out of an order passed by the Commissioner for Workmen's Compensation ('Commissioner') under the Employees' Compensation Act, 1923.
2. On 20 January 2014, the appeal was admitted, but no substantial question of law was framed. Therefore, the substantial question of law is framed now which reads as under :
PRACHI
PRANESH
NANDIWADEKAR
Digitally signed by PRACHI
PRANESH
NANDIWADEKAR
Date: 2026.02.25 18:02:36 +0530
2026:BHC-AS:9667
1
"Whether the Commissioner for Workmen's Compensation was justified in rejecting the application for compensation on the sole ground that the disability certificate was issued by a doctor who did not attend to the injured applicant ?"
3. On 14 January 2026, an order was passed issuing notice to respondent no.2-insurance company to engage an advocate to defend the appeal. It was mentioned that if after the service of the notice there is no appearance, then the appeal will be decided in their absence.
4. Ms. Nichani, learned advocate for the appellant has produced a letter acknowledged by respondent no.2 whereby an order dated 14 January 2026 was enclosed which is self-explanatory. However, there has been no appearance on behalf of respondent no.2 today.
5. The appeal is of the year 2012 and inspite of notice, respondent no.2 chose not to appear. Therefore, I have no option but to decide this appeal ex parte.
6. The original applicant was employed with opponent no. 1 for doing work at a construction site at Thane. While carrying out work at the construction site, the applicant fell and suffered back injuries. The injured was taken to Lok Hospital, Thane for treatment. The injured was in hospital from 22 March 2010 to 29 March 2010.
7. The applicant made an application to the Commissioner claiming compensation of Rs.5,95,584/- from opponent nos.1 and 2 jointly and severally. Evidence of opponent no.1 and the applicant was recorded. The Commissioner, after hearing all the parties, dismissed the application on the sole ground that the disability certificate was issued by a doctor who did not attend to the injured applicant, though the said doctor entered the witness box and gave evidence. On the basis of this reasoning, the Commissioner decided all the issues against the applicant. Therefore, the
2
present appeal is filed challenging the said order.
8. I have heard Ms.Nichani, learned counsel for the appellant.
9. At the outset, the Commissioner was not justified in answering the issues against the applicant, which do not have any relation with the disability certificate which was issued by the doctor. For example, whether employer-employee relationship has been established or whether the accident occurred in the course of employment etc. are issues which ought to have been decided independently and same does not have any relation whatsoever with respect to the disability certificate for the purpose of calculating compensation. However, since all the issues are decided against the applicant solely on the ground of disability certificate, for the reasons stated hereinafter, the said reasoning is erroneous. Insofar as other issues are concerned, same stands concluded based on my finding on the issue of disability certificate.
10. Section 4(1)(c)(ii) and Explanation-II thereto of the Employees' Compensation Act, 1923 provides for disability certificate to be issued by a
"qualified medical practitioner" for ascertaining loss of earning capacity in relation to injuries specified in the Schedule.
11. Section 2(1)(i) of the Employees' Compensation Act, 1923 defines
"qualified medical practitioner" to mean any person registered under any Central Act, Provincial Act or an Act of the Legislature of a State providing for the maintenance of a register of medical practitioners, or, in any area where no such last-mentioned Act is in force, any person declared by the State Government, by notification in the Official Gazette, to be a qualified medical practitioner for the purposes of this Act.
12. I have not been shown any provision in the Act nor any provision has been referred to in the judgment which states that the disability certificate has to be issued only by the doctor who attended the injured. There is no
3
dispute that the doctor who issued the disability certificate in the present case is a qualified medical practitioner. The object of obtaining a medical disability certificate from a medical expert is to arrive at the percentage of disability by taking the help of an expert in the field. Therefore, in the absence of any specific provision in the Act requiring disability certificate to be issued only by the doctor who has treated the injured reasoning of the Commissioner to reject application is not correct.
13. A qualified medical practitioner who has not treated the injured can always give evidence on the basis of the medical reports of the injured and give a certificate on the loss of earning capacity or disability. Such a doctor is always open for cross examination.
14. In the instant case, merely because the doctor gave a medical certificate who did not attend the injured but entered the witness box after one year cannot be a ground for discarding and rejecting the whole claim. The Commissioner should have considered the evidence of the doctor and could have arrived at independently the percentage of loss of earning capacity. Therefore, in my view, the approach of the Commissioner in rejecting the application was erroneous and the Commissioner ought to have considered the certificate issued by a doctor who did not treat the injured applicant, but was subjected to cross-examination and after considering the same should have arrived at the disability percentage. Therefore, the impugned order is set aside and is remanded back to the Commissioner for the limited purpose of considering the evidence on record and giving a finding on loss of earning capacity. Insofar as other issues are concerned like employer-employee relationship, accident having occurred in the course of employment etc. are concerned, same are precluded from being re-examined since the only ground for rejection even on these issues was the certificate having issued by a non-treating doctor, which as opined
4
earlier is erronesous.
15. Ms. Nichani, learned counsel for the appellant is justified in relying upon the decision of the Karnataka High Court in the case of Mukesh Kumar vs. Kulhari Tours and Travels Prof. Mahipal Singh & Anr.1wherein in paragraph 9, it is specifically observed that there is no provision in the Act mandating assessment of loss of earning capacity only by a doctor who has treated the workman and there is no bar for consideration of deposition of any qualified medical practitioner who examined the claimant and substantiates the disability. In my view, this decision supports the case of the appellant.
16. In view of above, the appeal is allowed by answering the question in favor of the appellant and against the respondents and the impugned order dated 19 June 2012 is set aside and the Commissioner is directed to consider the evidence on record of the doctor who has issued the certificate and arrive at a disability percentage and calculate the compensation. It is made clear that other than this issue, no other issue will be examined by the Commissioner.
17. The appellant to appear before the Commissioner on 23 March 2026 at 11:00 a.m. so that the Commissioner can fix up the date for hearing.
18. The Commissioner is requested to dispose of the application for compensation on or before 30 June 2026.
19. Appeal is allowed in above terms.
(JITENDRA JAIN, J.)
1 2025 SCC OnLine Kar 808
5
Alert