- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
MANVEER SINGH v. CABINET SECRETARIAT
:: 1 :: O.A. No. 826/2020
CENTRAL ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL
JAMMU BENCH, JAMMU (RESERVED)
Hearing through video conferencing
Original Application No. 826/2020
Reserved on:- 12.12.2025 Pronounced on: - 04.02.2026
HON'BLE MR. RAJINDER SINGH DOGRA, MEMBER (J) HON'BLE MR. RAM MOHAN JOHRI, MEMBER (A)
Manveer Singh, Age 30 years, S/o Sh. Kehar Singh, R/o Upper Gadigarh,
KaranBagh,Jammu
...Applicant
(By Advocate: - Ms. Surinder Kour, Sr. Adv.)
VERSUS
1. Union of India through Cabinet Secretary, Cabinet Secretariat, Government of India, New Delhi.
1
2. Special Secretary, Cabinet Secretariat, Government of India, Room no. 1001, B-1 Wing, 10th Floor, Pt. Deendayal Antoyodaya Bhawan, CGO Complex, Lodhi Road, New Delhi.
3. Additional Secretary (Pers), Cabinet Secretariat, Government of India, Room no. 1001, B-1 Wing, 10thFloor, Pt. Deendayal Antoyodaya Bhawan, CGO Complex, Lodhi Road, New Delhi.
4. Joint Secretary (Pers), Room No. 7, Bikaner House (Annexe) Shahjahan Road, New Delhi.
5. Director of Accounts, Cabinet Secretariat, (SW), New Delhi.
…Respondents.
(By Advocate: - Mr. Raghu Mehta, ld. Sr. CGSC)
2
ORDER
Per: - Rajinder Singh Dogra, Judicial Member
1. The applicant has filed the present Original Application under Section 19 of the Administrative Tribunals Act, 1985 seeking the following reliefs: -
a) to quash Order no. 8/145/2011-Pers.317244 dated 17-08-2017 issued by Additional Secretary (Pers), Cabinet Secretariat, Government of India, New Delhi by which the Additional Secretaryhas imposed the punishment of dismissal from service on the petitioner by issuance of writ of certiorari;
b) to quash the Order no. 8/145/2011-Pers.3 17836 dated 25-08- 2017 by which the petitioner has been struck off from the rolls of Cabinet Secretariat by issuance of writ of Certiorari;
c) To issue directions to the respondents to consider the case of the petitioner for reinstatement and to allow the petitioner to perform duties on the post of Field Assistant (GD) on which the petitioner was performing the duties prior to Order dated 17-
3
08-2017 and to give all consequential benefits of the service to the petitioner by issuance of writ of Mandamus;
d) To issue directions to the respondents to treat the period w.e.f. the date, the petitioner has been dismissed form service to the date, the petitioner rejoin the services as on duty by issuance of writ of Mandamus;
e) To restrain the respondents to treat the period w.e.f. the date of dismissal to the date; petitioner rejoin the unit as "break in service" by issuance of writ of Prohibition.
f) To procedure the original record of enquiry proceedings before the Hon'ble Court by issuance of writ of Mandamus;
g) to declare the Orders by which the respondents had imposed the punishment of dismissal from service and struck off the petitioner from the rolls of Cabinet Secretariat as ultra-virus, illegal, arbitrary, unconstitutional, unjust and contrary to the provisions of law and rules and against the provisions of principles of natural justice by issuance of writ of Mandamus.
4
h) Any other order which the Hon'ble Court may deem fit and proper may also be passed in favour of the petitioner and against the respondents."
2. The facts of the case as averred by the applicant in his pleadings, are as follows: -
a) The applicant, Manveer Singh, was appointed as Field Assistant (GD) in the Cabinet Secretariat vide Order No. 8/145/2011- Pers.31724465 dated 22.08.2012 in the pay band of ₹5200- 20200 with Grade Pay of ₹2000, and was allotted Identity No. 08723-W. Subsequently, vide Order dated 25.09.2012, he was formally appointed in the establishment of the Cabinet Secretariat with effect from 31.08.2012 and posted to Jammu, drawing pay at the minimum of the pay band along with admissible allowances.
b) The applicant states that during the course of his service, he remained posted at various sensitive and operational locations including S.B. Rajouri, Forward Intelligence Posts at Poonch and Nowshera, S.B. Amritsar and FIP Attari. It is averred that
5
he discharged his duties diligently, efficiently and with utmost sincerity, and that his performance was consistently appreciated by his superiors. The applicant asserts that he stood first during intelligence training and was awarded cash rewards and appreciation letters, including from senior officers. His Annual Confidential Assessment Reports for the years 2012-13 and 2013-14 were graded "Very Good", while for the year 2015- 16, he was graded "Outstanding"
c) It is further pleaded that while the applicant was continuing in service, the Additional Secretary (Personnel), Cabinet Secretariat, issued Order No. 8/145/2011-Pers.317244 dated 17.08.2017, imposing upon him the penalty of dismissal from service by invoking proviso (b) to Article 311(2) of the Constitution of India read with Rule 19(ii) of the CCS (CCA) Rules, 1965, on the ground that it was not reasonably practicable to hold a departmental inquiry. The order records that the applicant had allegedly indulged in acts of omission and commission unbecoming of a Government servant and that
6
his continuation in service was not in public interest. No charge-sheet or inquiry preceded the said order
d) Pursuant thereto, vide Order dated 25.08.2017, the applicant was struck off from the rolls of the Cabinet Secretariat. Aggrieved, the applicant preferred a statutory appeal on 27.10.2017 before the competent appellate authority, specifically contending that no inquiry had been conducted, no charges had been communicated, and no opportunity of representation had been afforded to him. It is pleaded that despite the lapse of considerable time and repeated reminders, the said appeal remained undecided, compelling the applicant to approach this Tribunal by way of the present Original Application
3. The respondents have filed their written statement wherein they have averred as follows: -
a) The respondents, while filing their written statement, do not dispute the appointment and posting history of the applicant. It is stated that at the time of joining service in the year 2012, the
7
applicant had furnished an undertaking acknowledging that he had read and understood the Departmental Security Instructions as well as the provisions of the Intelligence Organisations (Restriction of Rights) Act, 1985. According to the respondents, the applicant subsequently violated the departmental security instructions by indulging in acts of omission and commission, the details whereof are classified in nature and cannot be disclosed in open proceedings. It is asserted that the relevant material would be produced for the perusal of the Tribunal in a sealed cover.
b) The respondents emphasise that employees of intelligence and security organisations are entrusted with sensitive responsibilities directly bearing upon national security and are therefore required to maintain a higher standard of discipline, candour and integrity. Reference is made to Article 33 of the Constitution of India as amended by the Fiftieth Constitutional Amendment Act, 1984, and to the Intelligence Organisations (Restriction of Rights) Act, 1985, which authorises reasonable
8
restrictions on certain fundamental rights of personnel serving in such organisations in the interest of effective functioning and discipline.
c) It is contended that the applicant was dismissed from service on account of grave misconduct, and that the competent disciplinary authority, after due satisfaction and on the basis of material available on record, recorded reasons separately to the effect that it was not reasonably practicable to hold a regular departmental inquiry. The respondents assert that the impugned order was passed strictly in accordance with proviso (b) to Article 311(2) of the Constitution read with Rule 19(ii) of the CCS (CCA) Rules, 1965, and that the continuation of the applicant in service was found to be against public interest and detrimental to organisational security.
d) The respondents further contend that no appeal lies against an order of dismissal passed under Article 311(2)(b) of the Constitution, and that the applicant's challenge is misconceived. It is asserted that all procedural requirements
9
contemplated under the constitutional and statutory framework were duly complied with, and that any disclosure of the material relied upon would compromise national security. The respondents thus pray for dismissal of the Original Application, asserting that the applicant is not entitled to any relief
4. Heard learned counsel for the parties and perused the pleadings made by them.
5. The core issue that arises for consideration is whether the respondents were justified in invoking proviso (b) to Article 311(2) of the Constitution of India read with Rule 19(ii) of the CCS (CCA) Rules, 1965, to dispense with a regular departmental inquiry and impose the penalty of dismissal from service upon the applicant.
6. It is by now well settled that Article 311(2)(b) carves out a constitutional exception to the rule of audi alteram partem, where the competent authority, for reasons to be recorded in writing, is satisfied that it is not reasonably practicable to hold an inquiry. The satisfaction so recorded is not immune from judicial review; however, the scope
10
of such review is limited to examining whether the power has been exercised mala fide, arbitrarily, or without any material basis.
7. In the present case, the applicant was serving in an intelligence and security organisation entrusted with highly sensitive functions having a direct nexus with national security. The respondents have specifically pleaded that the applicant indulged in acts of grave misconduct in violation of departmental security instructions, rendering him vulnerable and posing a serious risk to organisational assets and national interest. The disciplinary authority, after considering the material available on record, recorded its satisfaction in writing that holding a regular inquiry was not reasonably practicable and that the continuation of the applicant in service was not in public interest. The respondents have further stated that the material forming the basis of such satisfaction is classified in nature and has been placed before the Tribunal in a sealed cover for its perusal
8. This Tribunal finds substance in the contention of the respondents that in matters concerning intelligence organisations, disclosure of
11
material, witnesses, or modus operandi during a regular inquiry may itself jeopardise national security and defeat the very purpose of disciplinary control. The standard of "reasonable practicability"
cannot be examined in isolation or by applying the same yardstick as applicable to ordinary civil departments. The constitutional scheme, read with Article 33 and the Intelligence Organisations (Restriction of Rights) Act, 1985, recognises the need for a higher threshold of discipline and secrecy in such establishments.
9. The applicant has primarily assailed the impugned orders on the ground of violation of principles of natural justice and absence of inquiry. However, once the competent authority forms a bona fide satisfaction, duly recorded, that an inquiry is not reasonably practicable due to the sensitive and security-related nature of the misconduct, the mere absence of a charge-sheet or oral inquiry cannot, by itself, vitiate the action. Judicial review in such cases does not extend to re-appreciation of classified material or substitution of the Tribunal's opinion for that of the disciplinary authority on issues of national security.
12
10. The Tribunal has also taken note of the fact that the dismissal order has been passed by the competent authority, invoking the correct constitutional and statutory provisions, and that no material has been placed on record by the applicant to demonstrate mala fides, colourable exercise of power, or total absence of material leading to the formation of satisfaction by the disciplinary authority.
11. In view of the foregoing discussion, this Tribunal is of the considered opinion that the impugned orders dated 17.08.2017 and 25.08.2017 do not suffer from any illegality, arbitrariness, or procedural infirmity warranting interference. The decision to dispense with a regular inquiry and dismiss the applicant from service was taken in the larger interest of national security and organisational integrity, which must prevail over individual claims of procedural fairness in such exceptional circumstances.
12. Accordingly, the Original Application is dismissed. No order as to costs.
(RAM MOHAN JOHRI) (RAJINDER SINGH DOGRA)
Administrative Member Judicial Member
/harshit /
13
Alert