- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Y Srinvasa Reddy v. Srinivasa Reddy
IN THE DEBTS RECOVERY TRIBUNAL - II
AT HYDEMBAD
DATED THIS THE TWENTYFOURTH DAY OF JULY, 2025
PRESENT: SH. RAMESHWAR KOTHE, B.COM., L.LB. (HONS.), M.A.
PRESIDING OFFICER
SECURITISATIoN APPLICATION No' 111 OF 2023 Between:
Sri Y. Srinivas ReddY
S/o Y. Bali Reddv
Aged: 50 years
Occ: Business, H. O.1-229
Ganesh Nagar, TadiPatri
Ana nthapu r Dist. 51 541 1'
And
Sriram Finance Limited
Surya Towers, C.B.Road
Tadipatri. Rep by its-
Authorised Officer.
.......Applicant.
.....Respondent.
Counsel for the Applicant : Mr. S. MarutiRao. Counsel for Respondent : Mr. M. Indrasen. -:g-B-D-EB:-
1. The Applicant filed the present Securitisation Application u/s.17 of the Securitization and Reconstruction of Financial Assets and Enforcement of Security Interest Act, 2002 (hereinafter referred to as "SARFAESI Act 2002") assaiting possession notice dated 27,Ot,2O23 issued by the respondent agai[st the SA schedule property. ,/ryon
1
2.
sA 111,/2023 The case of the applicant, in brief, is he is the borrower. He availed a loan of Rs.25 lakhs from the respondent to meet his business requirements. The loan was to be repayable in monthly instalments of Rs.1,02,659/- each. The loan is secured by way of mortgage of SA schedule property. Applicant has been paying the EMIS regularly. Applicant has repaid nearly Rs.22,32,683/-. Due to Covid pandemic situation, adverse business operations coupled with personal reasons, applicant could not pay some instalments. Applicant,s request for OTS neither considered nor rejected. Respondent increased rate of interest contrary to RBI guidelines. During the pendency of OTS proposal, respondent issued demand notice dated 26.09.2022 which was received on L9.L0.2022. Applicant raised objections to the demand notice. Respondent has not given reply to the objections and instead proceeded with possession notice dated 27.07.2023, The possession notice has neither been affixed on the secured asset nor published in two newspapers. Therefore, the possession notice dated 27.07.2023 is false, frivolous and baseless. The omcer issuing notices is not authorised to do so. The notice does not provide informatlon on rate of interest/ penal interest charged from time to time, capitalisationof interest/penal interest due dates of instalments. The Arbitral Tribunal passed award for an amount of Rs'25,15,973l- whichis under challenge before the Chief Judge.
The respondent filed reply statement. The submissions of the respondent, ln brief are; the averments of applicant thathe could not pay EMIs on account of adverse business operations due to Covid.19 Pandemic is not correct. An amountof Rs.16,86,493l- was already due from ^t-he applicant ason /2Qk)<)>Y
((/.t""
3.
2
sAlLLl2023 08.06.2019 and accordingly the account became NPAon 08.06.2019. On the date of issuance of demand noticeu/s 13(2), the outstanding dues stood at Rs.31,19,726/-' fhe demand notice was received by the wife of applicant, who is a guarantor. Photostat copies of demand notice as well asthe acknowledgements of respondent are filed with the reply statement. Where after, respondent issued possession notice u/s13( ) on 27.0L.2023. The possession notice wasalso received by the wife of the applicant' The possession noticewas published in Telugu and English newspapers. The other objections raised by the applicant are false and are therefore, denied.
4. Both side counsels reported no oral arguments. Perused the written arguments filed by the respondent and the material placed on record.
5. Now the points that arise for adjudication are:-
l(hether the Applicant made out
any valid ground for quashing the
possession notice dated 27.01.2023
issued under section 13(4) of
Securitisation Act?
To what reliefl
Point No.(i),
Applicant filed the present SA challenging the possession notice dated 27.01.2023. It is the contention of the applicant that respondent proceeded issued possession notice dated 27.01.2023 under Section 13(3A) without giving reply tohis obiections to the demand notice. Arrordi"wljgplgn,, n"
i,
6.
3
sa tLLl2023 received the demand notice dated 26.0g.2022 on 16.10.2022 at his end. Applicant placed photocopy of each of his objections to the demand notice dated 16.720.2022, postal registration receipts and acknowledgements of respondent vide material papers from pages 13 to 17 annexed to the SA. However, the respondent did not choose to give any specific reply on this issue both in the reply statement as well as the written arguments. Hence, it is to be construed that the respondent has not given any reply to the objections to the demand notice and thus violated the mandatory requirement of compliance of Section 13(3A) of the SARFAESI Act. Therefore, all further proceedings under the SARFAESI Act are vitiated. Further, it is noticed that the respondent has not filed any proof of aFfixture of possession u/r 8(1) of the Security Interest (Enforcement) Rules, 2002. In view of the foregoing facts and circumstances, the SA deserves to be allowed by setting aside the possession notice dated 27.0L.2023 issued by the respondent u/s 13(4) of the SARFAESI Act.
7.
Point No.(ii):
In the result, the SA is allowed by quashing the possession notice dated 27.0t,2O23 issued by the respondent. However, this order does not preclude the respondent Company from issuing possession notice u/s 13(4) afresh stricuy in accordance with the provisions of the SARFAESI Act and the Rules, 2OO2 there under.
8. Consequently. Interlocutory Applicatjelns penC_ing if any, shall stand closed. No order as to costs. ffil-'l
-
4
sA 111/2023
9. Communicate a copy of this order to the parties concernedand upload in Web Site.
(Dictoted to the Steno, signed ond pronounced by me in the open couft on this the 24h doy ol Juty, 202s.)
, ,7finry,...rgrq
'/'.-*tl
( RAiVI.ESHWAR KOTHE)
PRESIDING OFFICER
5
Alert