- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Atul Sharma v. SHINE.COM
C.C. No.322/2024 Atul Sharma Versus Shine.Com (HT Media Ltd.) 28.02.2025
1
ALLOWED
BEFORE THE DISTRICT CONSUMER DISPUTES REDRESSAL
COMMISSION KANGRA AT DHARAMSHALA, H.P.
Date of Institution: 10.07.2024 Date of final hearing: 27.02.2025 Date of Pronouncement: 28.02.2025 Consumer Complaint No.-322/2024
IN THE MATTER OF
Atul Sharma, Presently residing at: Village Brohal, P.O. Panchrukhi, Barohal (241), Kangra, Himachal Pradesh 176103. (Through: Mr. Lokender Singh, Advocate)
….........Complainant
Versus
The Authorised Signatories: Shine.com (HT Media Limited) Hindustan Times House Having registered office at: 18-20, Kasturba Gandhi Marg, New Delhi, India, Pin code 110001.
(Already Ex-parte)
……....Opposite Party(s)
CORAM:
President: Mr. Hemanshu Mishra Members: Ms. Arti Sood & Sh. Narayan Thakur Present:- Complainant in person. Opposite party already ex-parte.
PER: Mr. Hemanshu Mishra, President:-
O R D E R
The complainant has filed instant complaint seeking direction to the opposite party(s) as under :-
i). Direct the Opposite party to duly look into this matter with foremost importance to take necessary steps to render the proper service and refund Rs.1,04,781/- to the complainant. ii). Direct the Opposite party to provide Rs.2,00,000/- as compensation to the Complainant for the deficiency in service and mental harassment.
iii). Direct the Opposite party to pay the costs of litigation of Rs.10,000/- to the complainant.
1
2
2. Brief facts giving rise to the present complaint are that the complainant took services from the opposite party in the year of 2019 for highlighting the complainant's resume, so that recruiters can recruit the complainant and as a result the complainant paid charges for it and yet the complainant received no result from the opposite party's end, which highly disappointed the complainant. In the month of October 2023, the complainant again took services from the opposite party after paying basic amount payment. It is pleaded that the complainant received a call from the opposite party's manager Nitin Kalra and he informed the complainant that he will help the complainant to find suitable jobs. The opposite party informed the complainant that the complainant possesses 18 years+ experience in the field and told the complainant to make a payment of certain amount so that the complainant's resume can be highlighted. The complainant made a payment of Rs.48,192/- to the opposite party. The payments made to the opposite party's concern was as follows: Rs.9,399/- (Invoice ID IN497427), Rs.10,619/- (Invoice ID IN494889), Rs.8,259/- (Invoice ID IN494886), Rs.4,719/- (Invoice ID IN494886), Rs.3,292/- (Invoice ID IN494263), Rs.6,961/- (Invoice ID IN205353) and Rs.4,943/- (Invoice ID IN202059).
3. It is further pleaded that the complainant has received calls from the employees of opposite party in the month of January 2024 such as Shivani, Vijay Rathore, Rahul Khanna, Pankaj Kapoor and Vinod Kumar and all of them asked the complainant's issues, but the complainant received no response from the opposite party. The complainant received no favorable response from the opposite party's end nor did the complainant receive any job offer from the opposite party's end. The complainant was asked to pay more again and again and convinced to pay Rs.27000/-, Rs.13500/- (Via two Payments with UPI transaction ID 410853184207 and 410850991211 on 17/04/2024) and Rs.16,089/- (with UPI Transaction ID 410867282986 on 17/04/2024) to Sunil Kumar in several occasions. Despite these payments, the complainant still did not get any proper resolution from the opposite party and instead,
3
they are asking for more money again. Alleging deficiency in the service on the part of opposite party(s), the complainant has filed the present complaint.
4. Notices were sent to opposite party(s) by this Commission, which were duly served, but none appeared on behalf of opposite party(s) and opposite party(s) were proceeded ex-parte.
5. The complainant was called upon to produce evidence. In order to prove his complaint, complainant has filed affidavit Ext.CW-1 along
with documents Annexures C-1 to C-10.
6. On the other hand, opposite party despite of valid service did not bother to contest the complaint and opted to remain ex-parte.
7. We have heard learned counsel for the complainant and have gone through the case file minutely.
8. Admittedly, the complainant took the services from the opposite party for highlighting the complainant's resume. The complainant again took the services of the opposite party and thereafter received call from the opposite party's manager Sh. Nitin Kalra, but perusal of record reveals that the opposite party has not highlighted anywhere the complainant's resume and thus, as per complainant's affidavit, he has not received any favorable response or any job offers. The Opposite party despite of valid service did not bother to contest the complaint and opted to remain ex-parte. Thus, evidence adduced by the complainant remains unrebutted and unchallenged. There is no reason to disbelieve the cogent and convincing evidence adduced by the complainant.
9. The complainant upon allurement of the opposite party has paid Rs.9,399/- (Invoice ID IN497427), Rs.10,619/- (Invoice ID IN494889), Rs.8,259/- (Invoice ID IN494886), Rs.4,719/- (Invoice ID IN494886), Rs.3,292/- (Invoice ID IN494263), Rs.6,961/- (Invoice ID
4
IN205353) and Rs.4,943/- (Invoice ID IN202059). Rs.27000/-, Rs.13500/- (Via two Payments with UPI transaction ID 410853184207 and 410850991211 on 17/04/2024, Rs.16,089/- (with UPI Transaction ID 410867282986), i.e. in total Rs.1,04,781/-. As the opposite party has not appeared before this Commission and has not adduced any evidence to show that resume of the complainant was duly highlighted and the services agreed were duly rendered to the complainant. Thus, we observe that there is deficiency in service on the part of opposite party. Hence, complaint deserves to be allowed.
10. Accordingly, the complaint is allowed and opposite party is directed to refund an amount of Rs.1,04,781/- to the complainant alongwith interest @ 9% per annum from the date of complaint till its realization. Apart from this, opposite party is also directed to pay compensation to the complainant to the tune of Rs.25,000/-, besides litigation cost quantified as Rs.15,000/-.
11. Applications pending, if any, stand disposed of in terms of the aforesaid order.
12. A copy of this order be provided to all the parties free of cost as mandated by the Consumer Protection Act, 1986/2019. The order be uploaded forthwith on the website of the Commission for the perusal of the parties.
13. File be consigned to record room along with a copy of this order.
(Hemanshu Mishra)
President
(Narayan Thakur) (Arti Sood)
Member Member
Alert