Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

MANOJ KUMAR v. NHAI

Central Administrative Tribunal
May 2, 2025

1

O.A. No. 040/00105/2025

CENTRAL ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL

GUWAHATI BENCH

Original Application 040/00105/2025 Date of order: The 02ndday of May, 2025 HON'BLE RAJNISH KUMAR RAI, JUDICIAL MEMBER HON'BLE M. L. SRIVASTAVA, ADMINISTRATIVE MEMBER Sri Manoj Kumar, aged about 51 years Son of Sh. Uma Shankar Prasad,

Presently residing at3A, IIIrd Block, Gyan Konika Apartment, Basistapur, Byelane No.

3 Guwahati-781028

VERSUS.

1. The National Highway Authority of India, Ministry of Road Transport and Highways, Government of India, G-5 & 6, Sector 10, Dwarka, New Delhi- 110075, represented by its Chairman.

2. The Member (Adm)-cum Disciplinary Authority, The National Highway Authority of India, Ministry of Road Transport and Highways, Government of India,G-5 & 6, Sector 10, Dwarka, New Delhi-110075.

3. The General Manager, (HR/Admn) - II, The National Highway Authority of India, Ministry of Road Transport and Highways, Government of India, G-5 & 6, Sector 10, Dwarka, New Delhi-

110075.

.......Respondents. Present:

For applicant(s): Shri R.J. Das For respondent(s): Shri C. Baruah.

2

ORDER (ORAL)

PER: RAJNISH KUMAR RAI, MEMBER(J):

This matter has been taken up today in virtual mode.

2. Shri R.J. Das, learned counsel for applicant and Shri C. Baruah learned counsel for respondents are present.

3. Instant OA has been filed by the applicant being aggrieved by Memorandum of charges dated 25.06.2024 as well as subsequent order dated 17.03.2025 whereby the Inquiry under Rule-14 of the Central Civil Services (Classification, Control & Appeal) Rules, 1965 has been held and departmental proceedings under Rule 18 of the Central Civil Services (CCA) Rules, 1965 have been ordered hence the Instant Original Application seeking the following relief(s) :-

"8.1 To quash and set aside the Memorandum of Charge dated 25.06.2024

8.2 To quash and set aside the impugned order bearing No. 11019/1985/2015/Admn-1 (E- 171819)/6253 dated 17.03.2025

8.2 Cost of the application.

8.3 Any other relief/reliefs to which the applicant is entitled to under the facts and circumstances of the case and to pass any such order/orders as Your Lordships may deem fit and proper by this Hon'ble Tribunal upon consideration of the matter."

3

4. Facts of the case as revealed from the pleadings are that the applicant is presently serving as Assistant Manager (F&A), Regional Office, NHAI, Guwahati. He was initially appointed as an Accountant in the National Highway Authority of India (NHAI) vide letter dated 07.02.2007 on contractual basis. The appointment required the applicant to join the NHAI's Project Implementation Unit at Bongaigaon. The contractual term was set for an initial period of two years or co-terminus with the project, whichever is earlier.

5. Subsequently, after serving for 10 years, the service of the applicant was regularized w.e.f. 01.06.2018 vide office order dated 04.06.2018. Henceforth, upon evaluation and approval by the duly constituted Screening cum Selection Committees, the applicant was designated as Junior Accounts Officer, PIU-Bongaigaon who later was re-designated as

4

Assistant Manager (F & A), Regional Office, NHAI, Guwahati.

6. On 12.06.2022, an FIR was registered in CBI AC- 1, New Delhi under section 120-B of IPC read with Sections 7,8,9,10 and 12 of the Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988 on the basis of source information alleging therein that conspiracy was hatched among some of the officers of NHAI and the two officers namely Shri. Dipak Das, Accounts Officer and the applicant were demanding and accepting bribe for passing bills and release of Bank Guarantee, in respect of the work awarded to the firm by NHAI particularly M/s GR Infra Projects Ltd.

7. Subsequently, charge sheet dated 10.08.2022 was filed against the applicant and the other co- accused. During the investigation of the case, on 13.06.2022, the applicant along with other co-accused were arrested and produced before the Hon'ble Court of Special Judge, CBI, Assam, Addl. Court No. 2,

5

Chandmari, Guwahati. Consequently thereafter, the learned Special Judge, CBI Assam, vide order dated 29.09.2022 released the applicant on bail on 30.09.2022.

8. Since, the applicant's detention exceeded a period of 48 hours, the Member (Admin)-cum- Disciplinary Authority, NHAI, put the applicant under suspension vide order dated 09.03.2023 with effect from the date of arrest, in exercise of power under Rule 10 (2) of the Central Civil Services (Classification, Control and Appeal) Rules, 1965, Further, based on the recommendation of the Suspension Review Committee, the suspension of the applicant was revoked w.e.f. 09.03.2023. Subsequently, following the office order dated 09.03.2023, the applicant reported on duty at Regional Office, Guwahati and submitted his joining report at Regional Office, Guwahati vide letter dated 09.03.2023. Thereafter, the Deputy General Manager (HR/Admn)- IIB issued the impugned transfer order

6

dated 17.03.2023, posting the applicant from Regional Office, Guwahati to PIU-Guwahati.

9. A memorandum of charge dated 25.06.2024 under Rule 14 of the CCS (CCA) Rules, 1965 was served upon the applicant initiating a major penalty proceeding containing in as much as 3 (three) Article of charges.

"The Article- I charge contained allegations that the applicant, the then Jr. Account Officer (re-designated as Assistant Manager (F&A)) while posted at Regional Officer, Guwahati, NHAI in the year 2022 in connivance with his senior Sh. Dipak Das, Account Officer demanded illegal gratification of Rs. 6 Lakh (Rs Six Lakh) on 01.06.2022, for himself and Sh. Dipak Das from the contractor (M/s GR Infra Project Ltd) representative Sh. Pankaj Singh @ Pankaj Charan, Dy. Manager (Structure) for release of BG (Bank Guarantee) amounting to Rs.

2.58 Crore (Rs Two Crore Fifty-Eight Lakh) in favour of M/S GR Infra Project Ltd.

The Article- II charge is incidental to Article- I charge containing allegation that the applicant in the capacity ofthe then Jr. Account Officer (re-designated as Assistant Manager (F&A)), while posted at Regional Officer, Guwahati, NHAI had taken illegal gratification of Rs. 4 Lakh (Rs Four Lakh) on 12.06.2022 from contractor's (M/s GR Infra Project Ltd) representative Sh. Pankaj Singh @Pankaj Charan, Dy. Manager (Structure), M/s GR Infra Projects Ltd. Sh. Manoj Kumar was caught red-handed by the CBI team while taking illegal gratification from Shri Pankaj Charan (representative of M/s GR Infra Project Ltd) at road side near Survey Bus Stop, nearby of Health City Hospital, Khanapara, Guwahati, Assam in the presence of independent witnesses for smooth clearance of bills / BGs related to M/s GR Infra Project.

The Article- III charge contained allegations that the applicant, while posted at Regional Officer, Guwahati, NHAI unauthorizedly contacted and provide official information to

7

the representatives of M/s GR Infra projects Ltd. from 01.04.2022 to 12.06.2022."

10. In the statement of imputation of charges, the applicant was made responsible for taking illegal gratification for smooth clearance of bills and release of Bank Guarantee, in favour of M/s GR Infra Projects Ltd.

11. That, after receipt of the memorandum of charge dated 25.06.2024, the applicant filed his written statement of defence denying the Articles of Charge laid down in the aforementioned memorandum of charge asserting that the applicant has neither put up the proposal nor initiated any note sheet for release of payment to M/s GR Infra Projects Limited. The applicant further contended that being the Drawing and Disbursing Officer Central (DDO), he has no power or authority to pass/check the bill and the DDO can only initiate the banking transactions for payment if BPV is not authorised by the Head of F & A Unit. Moreover, the applicant contended that all the 3 (Three) charges have been framed on the basis of the information

8

collected from the FIR No. 216 2022 A 0007 dated 12.06.2022 lodged by the CBI AC-I, New Delhi and charge sheet filed by the CBI on 10.08.2022 being Special Case No. 05 of 2022 which is pending in the Additional CBI Court No. 2, Chandmari, Guwahati, Assam and prayed the NHAI authority to keep in abeyance the departmental proceeding initiated against him vide the Charge Memorandum dated

25.06.2024.

12. In the meantime, M/s GR Infra Projects Limited, which is one of the accused filed a criminal petition being Criminal Petition No. 1203 of 2024 before the Hon'ble Gauhati High Court whereby the petitioner prayed for quashing the FIR dated 12.06.2022, and to set aside the charge sheet dated 10.08.2022 along with other consequential proceedings pending before the learned Special Judge, CBI, Addl. Court No. 2, Guwahati, Assam.

9

13. The aforementioned criminal petition came on board on 27.09.2024 wherein the Hon'ble Gauhati High Court vide order dated 16.12.2024 directed that "until further order(s), further memorandum of charge asserting that the applicant has neither put up the proposal nor initiated any note sheet for release of payment to M/s GR Infra Projects Limited.

14. The applicant further contended that being the Drawing and Disbursing Officer Central (DDO), he has no power or authority to pass/check the bill and the DDO can only initiate the banking transactions for payment if BPV is not authorised by the Head of F & A Unit. Moreover, the applicant contended that all the 3 (Three) charges have been framed on the basis of the information collected from the FIR No. 216 2022 A 0007 dated 12.06.2022 lodged by the CBI AC-I, New Delhi and charge sheet filed by the CBI on 10.08.2022 being Special Case No. 05 of 2022 which is pending in the Additional CBI Court No. 2, Chandmari, Guwahati,

10

Assam and prayed the NHAI authority to keep in abeyance the departmental proceeding initiated against him vide the Charge Memorandum dated

25.06.2024.

15. That in the meantime M/s GR Infra Projects Limited, which is one of the accused filed a criminal petition being Criminal Petition No. 1203 of 2024 before the Hon'ble Gauhati High Court whereby the petitioner prayed for quashing the FIR dated 12.06.2022, and to set aside the charge sheet dated 10.08.2022 along with other consequential proceedings pending before the learned Special Judge, CBI, Addl. Court No. 2, Guwahati, Assam. The aforementioned criminal petition came on board on 27.09.2024 wherein the Hon'ble Gauhati High Court vide order dated 16.12.2024 directed that "until further order(s), further proceedings of Special Case No. 05 of 2022 pending in the court of the learned Special Judge, CBI, Additional Court No.2, Chandmari, Guwahati, Assam shall remain stayed.

11

16. That at this juncture, startlingly and unexpectedly for the Applicant, Respondent No. 3 passed an order dated 17.03.2025 whereby it is stated that an inquiry under Rule- 14 of the Central Civil Services (Classification, Control & Appeal) Rules, 1965 against the applicant is being held and departmental proceedings under Rule 18 of the Central Civil Services (Classification, Control & Appeal) Rules, 1965 have been ordered against the applicant. Accordingly, the inquiry officer vide order dated 17.03.2025 appointed Sri D. K. Chaturvedi, GM (Tech) as Presenting officer to inquire into the allegations. Also, the deferred filing of this instant application stems from the fact that the applicant was under bonafide belief that the disciplinary proceeding was kept in abeyance by the disciplinary authorities awaiting the outcome of the Special Case No. 05 of 2022 which was pending in the Additional CBI Court No. 2, Chandmari, Guwahati, Assam since both the criminal proceeding and

12

departmental proceeding were based on the same facts, evidences and witnesses.

17. That since the allegations levelled in the disciplinary proceeding arises out of the same incidents basing on which the Criminal Petition is filed before the Hon'ble Gauhati High Court being Criminal Petition No. 1203 of 2024 which is still pending disposal before the Hon'ble Gauhati High Court, any attempt to proceed with regular departmental enquiry would cause serious prejudice to the applicant andalso the instant matter being similar to aforementioned Criminal Petition wherein interim order dated 16.12.2024 has been passed, the instant application filed by the applicant is therefore entitled to same relief.

18. Applicant has also referred the judgement passed by the Hon'ble Supreme Court in case of AVINASH SADASHIV BHOSALE (D) THR. LRS vs U.O.I. CIVIL APPEAL NO. 7005 OF 2012 (Arising out of SLP (C) No.20394/2005) and relied upon para 44 which is as under :-

13

"44. This Court recently reiterated the legal principle that departmental proceedings can be conducted simultaneously to the criminal trial in the case of Divisional Controller, Karnataka State Road Transport Corporation Vs. M.G.Vittal Rao (supra). In this case, making reference to almost all the previous precedents, this Court has reiterated the legal position as follows:-

(a) There is no legal bar for both proceedings to go on simultaneously.

(b) The only valid ground for claiming that the disciplinary proceedings may be stayed would be to ensure that the defence of the employee in the criminal case may not be prejudiced. But even such grounds would be available only in cases involving complex questions of facts and law.

(c) Such defence ought not to be permitted to unnecessarily delay the departmental proceedings. The interest of the delinquent officer as well as the employer clearly lies in a prompt conclusion of the disciplinary proceedings.

(d) Departmental proceedings can go on simultaneously to the criminal trial, except where both the proceedings are based on the same set of facts and the evidence in both the proceedings is common.

In our opinion, the principles culled out by this Court would be a complete answer to all the submissions made by Mr. Jain."

19. He also relied upon the judgement of Hon'ble Apex Court passed in Depot Manager, A.P. SRTC v. Mohd. Yousuf Miya (1997) 2 SCC 699, (GM tank v State of Gujrat and others (2006) 5 SCC 466), and M. Paul Anthony v. Bharat Gold Mines Ltd and another (1999) 3 SCC 679.

20. Learned counsel for respondents has relied upon the Circular No. 08/07/2018 dated 31stJuly 2018 issued by the Central Vigilance Commission and drawn attention to the para-4 of the affidavit which was issued after considering the nature of Departmental Proceedings as well as Criminal Proceeding which was

14

issued after reliance made over the Hon'ble Supreme Court in the case of State of Rajasthan vs B.K. Meena & ors (1996) 6 SCC 417 and accordingly he submitted that the OA against the Charge sheet is not maintainable. The Circular No. 08/07/2018 dated 31st July 2018 is reproduced as under :

Circular No. 08/07/2018

िदनांक / Date 31stJuly 2018

Subject: Simultaneous action of prosecution and initiation of departmental proceedings - guidance thereof.

As per judgements of the Hon'ble Supreme Court and guidelines of Department of Personnel & Training issued thereon, it has been reaffirmed that there is no bar in conducting simultaneous criminal and departmental proceedings. Attention is invited to the Department of Personnel & Training O.M. No.11012/6/2007- Estt.(A-III) dated 1st August, 2007 and 21st July 2016 in this regard.

2. The Commission while examining the disciplinary cases referred to it for advice has noticed that in cases where simultaneous action of prosecution and initiation of departmental proceedings are advised, the departmental proceedings are unduly delayed by Departments/Organisations by keeping them in abeyance on the ground that the matter is under trial in the Court. Such an approach in finalizing disciplinary matters is a matter of serious concern and is also not a correct approach.

3. The Disciplinary Authority has been vested with the powers to carry out its statutory duty / obligations by initiation of appropriate departmental actions. This is as much to ensure that a delinquent public servant does not get undue benefit either by the long pendency of court proceedings or by the higher standard of proof required as it is to protect innocent public servant from vexatious proceedings. It is not open to the Disciplinary Authorities to await the outcome or decision of investigating / prosecuting agency or the Court trial.

4. The Commission would like to clarify that Disciplinary Authorities are vested with responsibility to ensure that employees under their control, against whom criminal trial is pending are proceeded against forthwith for simultaneous departmental proceedings. Further, a view as to whether simultaneous disciplinary proceedings are to be initiated need to be

15

invariably taken by the Competent Authorities at the time of considering the request for grant of sanction for prosecution itself. However, the Disciplinary Authority may withhold departmental proceedings only in exceptional cases wherein the charge in the criminal trial is of grave nature which involves questions of fact and law. In other words, in complex matters where, in case it is not possible to delineate the misconduct for the purpose of RDA. If the charge in the criminal case is of a grave nature which involves complicated questions of law and fact, it would be desirable to stay the departmental proceedings till the conclusion of the criminal case. Further, even if stayed at one stage, the decision may require reconsideration, if the criminal case gets unduly delayed. It may be noteworthy to mention that the Hon'ble Supreme Court in State of Rajasthan vs. B.K.Meena & Ors. (1996) 6 SCC 417 emphasised the need for initiating departmental proceedings and stated as below:

"It must be remembered that interests of administration demand that the undesirable elements are thrown out and any charge of misdemeanor is enquired into promptly. The disciplinary proceedings are meant not really to punish the guilty but to keep the administrative machinery unsullied by getting rid of bad elements. The interest of the delinquent officer also lies in a prompt conclusion of the disciplinary proceedings. If he is not guilty of the charges, his honour should be vindicated at the earliest possible moment and if he is guilty, he should be dealt with promptly according to law. It is not also in the interest of administration that persons accused of serious misdemeanor should be continued in office indefinitely, i.e., for long periods awaiting the result of criminal proceedings."

5. The Commission would, therefore, advise all concerned Administrative Authorities that in cases where it is appropriate to initiate disciplinary proceedings along with criminal prosecution, the disciplinary proceedings must be initiated simultaneously. 6. All

Ministries/Departments/Organisations may apprise the above guidelines to the concerned officers for compliance in cases of simultaneous proceedings.

Arshef (M. A. Khan)

Officer on Special Duty"

21. The learned counsel for the applicant has contended that complex questions of fact and law are involved in the present case; therefore, the disciplinary proceedings ought to be stayed in light of the Hon'ble Supreme Court's decision in Avinash Sadashiv Bhosale (supra). It is necessary to peruse the charges framed in the

16

disciplinary proceedings as well as in the criminal proceedings to ascertain whether the charges are identical or distinct, and whether they have any bearing or consequential effect upon each other.

22. Heard the parties, perused the records as well as the charge sheet filed by the Department dated 25.06.2024, the article of charges 1,2 & 3 are quoted herein below :-

Article of Charge No. 1

Shri Manoj Kumar, the then Jr. Account Officer (re-designated as Assistant Manager (F&A)) while posted at Regional Officer, Guwahati, NHAI In the year 2022 in connivance with his senior Sh. Dipak Das, Account Officer demanded illegal gratification of Rs 06 Lakh (Rs Six Lakh) on 01.06.2022, for himself and Sh. Dipak Das from the contractor (M/s GR Infra Project Ltd) representative Sh. Pankaj Singh @ Pankaj Charan, Dy. Manager (Structure) for release of BG (Bank Guarantee) amounting to Rs. 2.58 Crore (Rs Two Crore Fifty-Eight Lakh) in favour of M/s GR Infra Project Ltd.

By this act, Shri Manoj Kumar has acted in a manner which is unbecoming of a Government Servant and contrary to any law, rules regulations and established practices, he has failed to maintain absolute integrity, he has failed to maintain devotion to duty, he has also falled to maintain high ethical standards and honesty, failed to maintain accountability and transparency, did not discipline in the discharge of his duties, not performed his duties with the highest degree of professionalism and dedication, thereby, contravening the provisions of Rule 3(1)(1), 3(1)(8), 3(1)(ⅲ), 3(1)(vi), 3(1)(ix), 3(xviii), 3(1)(xix) & 3(1)(xxi) of the Central Civil Service(Conduct) Rules, 1964. Article of Charge No. 2

Shri Manoj Kumar, the then Jr. Account Officer (re-designated as Assistant Manager (F&A)), while posted at Regional Officer, Guwahati, NHAI had taken illegal gratification of Rs. 4 Lakh (Rs Four Lakh) on 12.06.2022 from contractor's (M/s GR Infra Project Ltd) representative Sh. Pankaj Singh Pankaj Charan, Dy. Manager (Structure), M/s GR Infra Projects Ltd. Sh. Manoj Kumar was caught red- handed by the CBI team while taking illegal gratification from Shri Pankaj Charan (representative of M/s GR Infra Project Ltd) at road side near Survey Bus Stop, nearby of Health City Hospital, Khanapara, Guwahati, Assam in the presence of independent witnesses for smooth clearance of bills / BGs related to M/s GR Infra Project Ltd.

17

By this act, Shri Manoj Kumar has acted in a manner which is unbecoming of a Government Servant and contrary to any law, rules regulations and established practices, he has failed to maintain absolute integrity, he has falled to maintain devotion to duty, he has also falled to maintain high ethical standards and honesty, failed to maintain accountability and transparency, did not discipline in the discharge of his duties, not performed his duties with the highest degree of professionalism and dedication, thereby, contravening the provisions of Rule 3(1)(1), 3(1)(8), 3(1)(if), 3(1)(vi), 3(1)(fx), 3(xvill), 3(1)(xlx) & 3(1)(xxl) of the Central Civil Service(Conduct) Rules, 1964. Article of Charge No. 3

Shri Manoj Kumar, Jr. Account Officer (re-designated as Assistant Manager (F&A)), while posted at Regional Officer, Guwahati, NHAI unauthorizedly contacted and provide official information to the representatives of M/s GR Infraprojects Ltd. from 01.04.2022 to

12.06.2022.

Thus, the sald Shri Manoj Kumar has communicated to provide official information to representative of M/s GR Infraprojects Ltd., to whom he is not authorized to communicate such information. The above act on the part of Shri Manoj Kumar, Jr. Account officer, Guwahati, amounts to contravening the provisions of Rule 11 of CCS (Conduct) Rules, 1964 and has falled to maintain absolute integrity and has acted in a manner which is unbecoming of a Government Servant, thereby contravening the provisions of Rule 3(1) (1) (iii) of CCS Conduct Rules, 1964.

And also gone through the charge sheet filed by the CBI. The relevant para of charge sheet which needs to be discussed in the light of the argument made by the applicant is herein under :-

"16.41 That evidence collected during investigation clearly establishes that accused Dipak Das (A-1) and Manoj Kumar (A-2) were a public servant and by abusing their official position as à public servant, entered into a criminal conspiracy with other co-accused, demanded and accepted illegal gratification from accused Pankaj Charan (A-4) for themselves himself by corrupt and illegal means for extending undue favours to M/s. GR Infraprojects Ltd. Shri Alok Kumar (A-7), while abusing his official position as public servant, entered into criminal conspiracy with other accused public servants viz. Sushil Kumar Verma (A-8), Ram Pavitra Singh (A-9), Jitendra Prasad (A-10) & Rajendra Narayan Sahoo (A-11)as well as the accused private persons viz. Sunil Kumar Agarwal (A-3), Pankaj Charan (A-4), Dilip Kumar Rajput (A-5) & M/s G R Infraprojects Ltd. (A-6), to get favourable reports for M/s G. R. Infraprojects Ltd., timely processing of it's bills/BG requests without any objection and payment/release of same to accused company. Thus,

18

offences U/s. 120-B IPC r/w Sections 7, 8, 9, 10 & 12 of the P.C. Act (As Amended in 2018), 1988 and substantive offence are made out.

16.42 Thus, the aforesaid acts of omission and commission on the part of accused persons namely Dipak Das (A-1), Manoj Kumar (A-2), Sunil Kumar Agarwal (A-3), Pankaj Charan@Pankaj Singh(A-4), Dilip Kumar Rajput (A-5), M/s GR Infraprojects Ltd. (A-6) Alok Kumar (A-7), Sushil Kumar Verına (A-8), Ram Pavitra Singh (A-9), Jitendra Prasad (A-10) and Rajendra Narayan Sahoo (A-11) constitute offences punishable U/s. 120-B IPC r/w Sections 7, 8, 9, 10 & 12 of the P.C. Act (As Amended in 2018), 1988 and substantive offences thereof.

16.43 That investigation in respect of obtaining CFSL Opinion on voice samples, recovered amount of Rs. 15,50,000/- made from the house search of relative of accused Alok Kumar and handwriting of accused Dilip Kumar Rajput on the sheets recovered in office search of Dilip Kumar Rajput and any other point, which may crop up during further investigation, is continuing. These points require to be covered during further investigation and separate supplementary report will be submitted U/s 173(8) Cr.P.C. after conclusion of investigation."

23. From a perusal of the two sets of charges — one in the departmental proceedings and the other in the criminal proceedings — it is evident that the charges framed against the applicant in the departmental proceedings pertain to misconduct committed by the applicant, constituting violations of Rule 3(1)(i), 3(1)(iii), 3(1)(vi), 3(1)(viii), 3(1)(ix), 3(1)(xviii), 3(1)(xix), and 3(1)(xxi) of the Central Civil Services (Conduct) Rules, 1964. On the other hand, the charges framed in the criminal proceedings primarily relate to offences punishable under Section 120-B of the Indian Penal Code read with Sections 7, 8, 9, 10, and 12 of the Prevention of Corruption Act. Accordingly, the charges in the two proceedings are distinct and not identical. Interfering with the issuance of a charge sheet or the appointment of a

19

Presenting Officer can be a form of obstruction of justice and a violation of fair process. The disciplinary proceedings must ordinarily be allowed to run their course without premature interference by the courts or tribunals. Ordinarily a writ application does not lie against a charge-sheet or show cause notice for the reason that it does not give rise to any cause of action. It does not amount to an adverse order which affects the right of any party unless the same has been issued by a person having no

jurisdiction/competence to do so. A writ lies when some right of a party is infringed. In fact, charge-sheet does not infringe the right of a party. It is only when a final order imposing the punishment or otherwise adversely affecting a party is passed, it may have a grievance and cause of action. Thus, a charge-sheet or show cause notice in disciplinary proceedings should not ordinarily be quashed by the Court.

In State of Orissa v. Sangram Keshari Misra, (2010) 13 SCC 311: 2010 AIR SCW 6948: 2011 Lab IC 625, the Supreme Court held that normally a charge-sheet is not quashed prior to the conclusion of the enquiry on the ground that the

20

facts stated in the charge are erroneous for the reason that correctness or truth of the charge is the function of the disciplinary authority.

Further, the Hon'ble Supreme Court in Union of India v. K.K. Dhawan, AIR 1993 SC 1478: 1993 AIR SCW 1361: 1993 Lab IC 1028, very heavily relied upon its earlier judgment in S. Govinda Menon (supra) and observed that the officer who exercises judicial or quasi-judicial powers, acts negligently or recklessly or in order to confer undue favour on a person, is not acting as a Judge, and in the disciplinary proceedings, it is the conduct of the officer in discharge of his official duties and not the correctness or legality of his decisions of judgments which are to be examined, as the legality of the orders can be questioned on or revisional forum. In such a case the Government cannot be precluded from taking the disciplinary action for violation of the Conduct Rules. The Court summarised appellate some circumstances in which disciplinary action can be taken, which are:

"(i) Where the Officer had acted in a manner as would reflect on his reputation or integrity or good faith or devotion of duty;

21

(ii) if there is, prima facie, material to show recklessness or misconduct in the discharge of his duty;

(iii) if he has acted in a manner which is unbecoming of a Government servant,

(iv) he had acted negligently or that are essential for the exercise of the statutory powers;

(v) if he had acted in order to unduly favour a party:

(vi) if he had been actuated by corrupt motive, however, small the bribe may be, because Lord Coke said long ago "though the bribe may be small, yet the fault is great."

The Court further observed that the said instances were not exhaustive. However, it was further observed by the Supreme Court that each case would depend upon the facts and circumstances of that case and no absolute rule can be postulated.

While dealing with a similar issue, the Supreme Court in Ajit Kumar Nag v. Indian Oil Corpn. Ltd., (2005) 7 SCC 764:

AIR 2005 SC 4217: 2005 AIR SCW 4986, held:

... Acquittal by a criminal Court would not debar an employer from exercising power in accordance with the Rules and Regulations in force. The two proceedings, criminal and departmental, are entirely different. They operate in different fields and have different objectives. Whereas the object of criminal trial is to inflict appropriate punishment on the offender, the purpose of enquiry proceedings is to deal with the delinquent departmentally and to impose penalty in accordance with the service rules. In a criminal trial, incriminating statement made by the accused in certain circumstances or before certain officers is totally inadmissible in evidence. Such strict rules of evidence and procedure would not apply to departmental proceedings. The degree of proof

22

which is necessary to order a conviction is different from the degree of proof necessary to record the commission of delinquency. The rule relating to appreciation of evidence prosecution and unless the prosecution is able to prove the guilt of the accused "beyond in the two reasonable doubt", he cannot be convicted by a Court of law. In a departmental enquiry. other hand, penalty can be recorded on the basis of

"preponderance of probability."

A Three-Judges Bench of the Supreme Court in Management of Krishnakali Tea Estates v. Akhil Bharatiya Chah Mazdoor Sangh, (2004) 8 SCC 200: AIR 2004 SC 4647:

2004 AIR SCW 5256, reconsidered all earlier judgments and reiterated the same view, as the approach and the objective of the criminal proceedings, and the disciplinary proceedings are distinct and different. There can be no bar in carrying on the criminal trial and disciplinary proceedings simultaneously.

24. Since the Original Application has been filed challenging the memorandum of charge sheet dated 25.06.2024 as well as the order dated 17.03.2025, whereby the Presenting Officer was appointed, we have carefully perused the charge sheet and the said order. Upon such perusal, we do not find any illegality committed by the respondents either in issuing the charge sheet or in

23

appointing the Presenting Officer, nor is there any violation of Rule 18 of the Central Civil Services (Classification, Control and Appeal) Rules, 1965. The applicant has failed to substantiate his contention regarding any illegality or procedural irregularity in the issuance of the charge sheet or the appointment of the Presenting Officer. The argument advanced appears to be merely apprehensive, without any factual foundation, and therefore cannot be accepted.

25. Accordingly, the Original Application is dismissed as being devoid of merit. The respondents are, however, directed to complete the disciplinary proceedings arising out of the charge sheet dated 25.06.2024 expeditiously, preferably within a period of six months from the date of receipt of a certified copy of this order. (M.L. Srivastava) (Rajnish Kumar Rai)

Member (Administrative) Member (Judicial) mks