Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

RUSTAM ALI AND OTHERS v. PRITAM SINGH

Himachal Pradesh High Court
May 16, 2025

1

IN THE HIGH COURT OF HIMACHAL PRADESH, SHIMLA

RSA No. 26 of 2021 a/w RSA No. 218 of 2020 Date of Decision: 16thMay, 2025

1 . RSA No. 26 of 2021 Rustam Ali …… appellant Versus Pritam Singh and others ……Respondents 2. RSA No. 218 of 2020 Rustam Ali …… appellant Versus Pritam Singh and others ……Respondents __________________________________________________________ Coram: The Hon'ble Mr. Justice Bipin Chander Negi, Judge Whether approved for reporting?1 For the appellant(s) : Mr. Sanjay Jaswal, Advocate, for the appellant(s) in both the appeal. For the respondents : Mr. Atharv Sharma, Advocate, for the respondents . Bipin Chander Negi, Judge(oral) Both these appeals under section 100 of the Code of Civil Procedure (for short, CPC), have assailed the judgment and decree dated 14.08.2019 passed by the learned Additional District Judge, Whether reporters of Local Papers may be allowed to see the judgment?

1

2

Kangra at Dharamshala H.P. in Civil Appeal No. 37-J/2014 affirming the judgment and decree dated 20-08-2014 passed by the learned Civil Civil Judge, Junior Division, Jawali, District Kangra, H.P. Hence they are being taken up together.

2. The appellant (plaintiff) had initially filed a suit in the lower court against the respondents (defendants) seeking a declaration qua his preferential right to purchase the suit property, comprising 1/23 shares of defendant No. 2 in the specified land situated in village Chandani, Mauza Bhali, Tehsil Jawali, District Kangra, HP, as per the jamabandi for the year 2000-2001. The plaintiff claimed this right as a Class-I heir under the Hindu Succession Act, 1956, subject to depositing the sale consideration of Rs. 42,000/- along with registration expenses. He further alleged that the sale deed dated 10.06.2004, executed by defendant No. 2 in favour of defendant No. 1, was illegal, null, and void. Additionally, he sought an injunction restraining defendant No. 1 from alienating the land, raising constructions, or cutting trees.

3. The plaintiff contended that the suit land was originally owned by Machala, son of Sukhia, and upon his death, it devolved upon the plaintiff and defendants No. 2 to 6 as Class-I heirs in equal shares. He asserted that defendant No. 6, being the son of Vidya Devi (who predeceased Machala), also inherited an equal share. While defendants No. 5 and 6 had relinquished their shares in favour of the plaintiff, defendant No. 2 sold her share to defendant No. 1 without offering it to

3

the plaintiff, despite his readiness to purchase it. The plaintiff claimed that, being a Class-I heir, he had a preferential right to acquire the land, rendering the sale deed void. Alternatively, he sought joint possession and a direction to defendant No. 1 to execute a sale deed in his favour for Rs. 42,000/-.

4. The suit was contested by defendants No. 1 to 3, who denied the plaintiff's claims and asserted that defendant No. 1 was in settled possession. They further alleged that the plaintiff had refused to purchase the land and instead demanded its relinquishment without consideration.

5. Upon the pleadings of the parties, the trial court framed the following issues on 29.08.2005:

(1) Whether the plaintiffs are having a preferential right to acquire suit property in consideration of Rs. 42,000/-, as alleged? OPP

(2) Whether the suit of the plaintiff is not maintainable?

OPD

(3) Whether the plaintiff has no locus standi to file the present suit? OPD.

(4) Whether the plaintiff is estopped from filing the suit due to his act and conduct? OPD.

(5) Whether the suit is not properly valued for the purposes of court fee and jurisdiction? If so, what is the valuation?

OPD.

(6) Relief.

4

6. After evaluating the evidence, the trial court partly decreed the suit in favour of the plaintiff, answering issue No. 1 partially in his favour and the remaining issues against the defendants.

7. Dissatisfied with the judgment and decree of the trial court, both the plaintiff and defendant preferred separate first appeals. The first appellate court, after hearing the parties, dismissed the appeals filed by defendant No 1 and allowed the appeal filed by the petitioner. Aggrieved by the same, the defendant No.1 has filed two second appeals, challenging the impugned judgment and decree primarily on the grounds that the courts below failed to appreciate the facts and law correctly, thereby rendering the decision unsustainable.

8. Perused the impugned judgment and heard counsel for the parties.

9. In the Present case the Trial Court held that as far as Defendant 1 was concerned the sale deed qua agricultural land was valid and qua non-agricultural land was invalid as the plaintiff was having a preferential right to purchase said land. However, the first Appellate court in view of law laid down by the Apex Court in case reported as Babu Ram V. Santokh Singh Civil Appeal No. 2553 of 2019 arising out of SLP(Civil) No. 31039 of 2018 held that provisions of section 22 of the Hindu Succession Act are equally applicable to the non-agricultural land, corrected the error of the trial court and held that the plaintiff has a

5

preferential right to purchase the agricultural as well as non-agricultural land of the sale deed.

10. The contention of the Ld. Counsel for the Defendants that Defendant No. 1 is a Bona fide purchaser and without notice is without merit as the said plea was never taken by the defendant No.1 in his written statement and hence was rightly rejected by both the Courts below.

11. In the aforesaid facts and attending circumstances, there arises no question of law, much-less a substantial question of law for consideration of the Court, therefore, the appeals are dismissed being devoid of any merit. Pending miscellaneous applications, if any, also stand disposed of.

( Bipin Chander Negi)

May 16th, 2025(Tarun/T.M) Judge