Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Danasingh v. Jeyaraj Nadar (died) 1.Leela

Madras High Court
Jan 28, 2025

C.R.P.(PD)(MD) Nos. 156 and 157 of 2025

BEFORE THE MADURAI BENCH OF MADRAS HIGH COURT

Reserved on 28.01.2025

Pronounced on 10.03.2025

CORAM

THE HON'BLE MRS.JUSTICE K.GOVINDARAJAN

THILAKAVADI

C.R.P.(MD) Nos. 156 and 157 of 2025 and CMP(MD).No.1058 of 2025

Danasingh ... Revision petitioner in both cases

Vs.

Jeyaraj Nadar (died)

1. Leelavathi 2.Jeba Elizabeth 3.Jeyaseelan ... Respondents / Appellants Prayer in CRP(MD).No.156 of 2025: Civil Revision Petition filed under Article 227 of the Constitution of India against the fair and decreetal order, dated 30.08.2024 passed in I.A.No.7 of 2023 in A.S.No.1 of 2023 on the file of the Subordinate Judge, Srivaikundam. Prayer in CRP(MD).No.157 of 2025: Civil Revision Petition filed under Article 227 of the Constitution of India against the fair and decreetal order, dated 14.11.2024 passed in I.A.No.9 of 2024 in A.S.No.1 of 2023 on the file of the Subordinate Judge, Srivaikundam.

1

For Petitioner in both cases : Mr. P. Senthil For Respondent in both cases : Mr. G. Aravinthan *****

COMMON ORDER

CRP(MD).No. 156 of 2025 is filed against the fair and decreetal order, dated 30.08.2024 passed in I.A.No.7 of 2023 in A.S.No.1 of 2023 on the file of the Subordinate Judge, Srivaikundam. CRP(MD).No.157 of 2025 is filed against the fair and decreetal order, dated 14.11.2024 passed in I.A.No.9 of 2024 in A.S.No.1 of 2023 on the file of the Subordinate Judge, Srivaikundam.

2. The respondent herein as plaintiff filed the above suit in O.S.No. 49 of 2012 on the file of the District Munsif, Srivaikundam for the relief of declaration of title and for the consequential relief of permanent injunction and also to declare the settlement deed, dated 06.01.2012 executed by one Inbam ammal as null and void. The first respondent's husband (Late) Jeyaraj Nadar in the plaint averred that the suit property belonged to one Inbam ammal, who is the mother of the revision

2

petitioner. In order to meet out the marriage expenses of the petitioner's sister viz., Santha, the said Inbam ammal sold the suit property in favour of the deceased Jeyaraj Nadar / plaintiff under the sale deed, dated 13.06.1986. It is further averred that the survey number of the property was wrongly mentioned as S.No.131/1A6 instead of S.No.131/1A7A. Therefore, in order to rectify the said mistake, she executed a rectification deed, dated 17.11.2011 in favour of the deceased Jeyaraj Nadar. It is further averred that in the mean time, he fraudulently obtained the settlement deed, dated 06.01.2012 from Inbam Ammal and filed the above suit.

3. The revision petitioner filed the written statement specifically denying the averments stated in the plaint. It is specifically contended that 56 cents of property which was shown as plaint schedule property is situated on the northwest corner in Survey No.131/1 and it does not belong to his mother Further, the survey number was intentionally mentioned by his mother wrongly for the purpose of obtaining loan and it is a sham and nominal document. Further the possession of the suit schedule property was not handed over to the deceased plaintiff and the revenue records are still stands in the name of his mother, which itself

3

would show that the sale deed was not acted upon. On these contentions among others, he sought for dismissal of the suit.

4. According to the learned counsel for the petitioner, the Learned District Munsif on consideration of oral and documentary evidence dismissed the suit by judgment and decree dated 30.06.2014. Aggrieved over the same, the respondents 1 to 3 preferred an appeal in A.S.No.272 of 2017 on the file of Learned Sub-Court, Thiruchendur. Subsequently it was transferred and re-numbered as A.S.No. 1 of 2023 on the file of Learned Sub-Court, Srivaikundam. He further submits that along with the above appeal, respondents 1 to 3 moved an application in I.A. No. 7 of 2023 under Order 41 Rule 27 of C.P.C. seeking to receive the original rectification deed dated 17.11.2011 executed by the petitioner's mother in favour of the deceased Jeyaraj Nadar as an additional document, in which, the petitioner filed his counter specifically contending that the said rectification deed dated 17.11.2011 is totally irrelevant to decide the issue arose in the present suit. Further it is an insufficiently stamped instrument and the same cannot be admitted in evidence unless and until the respondents 1 to 3 pay and remit an additional stamp duty in view of the embargo provided under Section 35 of the Indian Stamp Act.

4

5. He further submits that rectification deed, dated 17.11.2011 was initially withheld by the Sub-Registrar, Nazareth for want of additional stamp duty. Challenging the proceedings initiated by the Sub-Registrar under Section 47B of Indian Stamp Act, the deceased Jeyaraj filed the writ petition in W.P. No. 6042 of 2017 before this Hon'ble Court. This Hon'ble Court by order dated 03.01.2020 directed the Sub-Registrar to register and release the document. However, the fact remains that the rectification deed dated 17.11.2011 is an insufficiently stamped document and the same cannot be admitted in evidence in view of the embargo provided under Section 35 of the Indian Stamp Act. Therefore, the petitioner moved an application in I.A.No.9 of 2024 seeking for a direction, directing the respondents to pay additional stamp duty with respect to the rectification deed dated 17.11.2011, reiterating the above said contentions.

6. According to the learned counsel for the revision petitioner, the First Appellate Court without adverting to the specific contentions made by the revision petitioner in I.A.No.7 of 2023 on mis-conception of law, on sympathy allowed the said application by its order, dated 30.08.2024. Hence, the revision petitioner was constrained to file the above Civil

5

Revision Petition in CRP(MD).No.156 of 2025.

7. CRP(MD).No.157 of 2025 was filed by revision petitioner against the order, dated 14.11.2024 passed in I.A.No.9 of 2024 in A.S.No. 1 of 2023 on the file of the Sub Court, Srivaikundam and the said application was filed by the revision petitioner for collection of additional stamp duty leviable on the registered rectification deed, dated 17.11.2011, which according to the plaintiff was executed for the sake of amending the sale deed, dated 13.06.1986 in respect of Survey Number mentioned in the sale deed and if the said deed of rectification, dated 17.11.2011 is produced, the dispute between the parties can be resolved. It is further held that as per the direction in W.P(MD).No.6042 of 2017, the rectification deed was obtained by the plaintiff after registration. Hence, the first appellate Court dismissed the said application by stating that the rectification deed, dated 17.11.2011 do not require any payment of additional stamp duty. Assailing the said order, the above revision is filed.

8. The learned counsel appearing for the petitioner submits that the learned Sub-Judge failed to take note of the fact that by virtue of the

6

rectification deed, dated 17.11.2011, the deceased plaintiff attempted to claim right over the property comprised in Survey No. 131/1A7A. The extent, four boundaries as well as the market value of the said property are entirely different from the property comprised in Survey No. 131/1A6 and the same would be elucidated from the F.M.B sketch marked as Ex.B1. In such circumstances the Learned Sub-Judge ought to have forwarded the original rectification deed dated17.11.2011 as well as the sale deed dated 13.06.1986 in exercise of his powers vested under Sections 33 & 38 of Indian Stamps Act, to ascertain whether the stamp duty paid under the sale deed dated 13.06.1986 is adequate to cover the property comprised in Survey No.131/1A7A. He further submits that the Learned Sub-Judge completely overlooked the fact that this Hon'ble Court in earlier occasion while deciding the writ petitions in W.P.(MD)No.15924 of 2013 as well as W.P.(MD)No.6042 of 2017, had not ascertained whether the stamp duty paid under the sale deed dated 13.06.1986 is adequate to cover the property comprised in Survey No.131/1A7A. Therefore, there is no impediment for the Learned Sub-Judge to forward the documents to the Collector of Stamps to ascertain the same. He further submitted that the learned Sub-Judge failed to advert that the four boundaries with respect to the 2nd item of property as mentioned in the sale deed dated 13.06.1986

7

as well as in the rectification deed dated 17.11.2011 dose not tally with the property comprised in Survey No.131/1A7A. In such circumstances, the Learned Sub-Judge ought to have ascertained whether the stamp duty paid under the sale deed dated 13.06.1986 is adequate to cover the property comprised in Survey No.131/1A7A or property comprised in Survey No.131/1A6, which would resolve the entire dispute arose between the parties.

9. Heard on both sides. Records perused.

10. It is the specific contention of the revision petitioner that the plaintiffs are attempting to claim right over the property in S.No. 131 /1A7A, in which an extent and four boundaries as well as the market value of the property are entirely different form the property comprised in S.No.131/1A6 and the same is evident from the FMB sketch marked as Ex. B1. Therefore, the trial Court ought not to have received the rectification deed, dated 17.11.2011 and erred in dismissing the application. Whereas the respondents / plaintiffs contended that the property mentioned in the rectification deed and in the sale deed are one and the same and only by adjudication the said dispute can be resolved.

8

The trial Court also in the impugned order has categorically rendered a finding that the said rectification deed, dated 17.11.2011 is essential for effectively determining the issues raised in the appeal. Moreover, this Court by its order, dated 03.01.2020 in W.P(MD).No.6042 of 2017 quashed the order passed by the District Registrar, Thirunelveli and directed the Sub Registrar to register and deliver the rectification, deed, dated 17.11.2011. In pursuance of the said order, the rectification deed, dated 17.11.2011 was duly registered and handed over to the respondent. Therefore, the trial Court has rightly held that there is no need to collect additional stamp duty in respect of the rectification deed and by saying so, the trial Court has dismissed the above applications. No perversity or infirmity found in the order of trial Court to interference by this Court.

11. Accordingly, these Civil Revision Petitions are dismissed confirming the orders, passed in I.A.Nos.7 of 2023 and 9 of 2024 in A.S.No.1 of 2023 on the file of the Subordinate Judge, Srivaikundam, dated 14.11.2024 and 30.08.2024 respectively. No costs. Consequently, the connected Miscellaneous Petition is closed.

10.03.2025

Index: Yes/ No

9

Neutral Citation: Yes / No Speaking Order/Non-Speaking Order trp

Copy To:

The Subordinate Judge, Srivaikundam.

10

K.GOVINDARAJAN THILAKAVADI , J.

trp Pre-Delivery Order made in

C.R.P.(MD) Nos. 156 and 157 of 2025 and CMP(MD).No.1058 of 2025

10.03.2025

11