- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Sonu @ Amar Kumar v. The State Of Madhya Pradesh
IN THE HIGH COURT OF MADHYA PRADESH
AT JABALPUR
BEFORE
HON'BLE SHRI JUSTICE ATUL SREEDHARAN &
HON'BLE SHRI JUSTICE DEVNARAYAN MISHRA ON THE 27thOF MARCH, 2025
CRIMINAL APPEAL No. 1245 of 2015 SONU @ AMAR KUMAR
Versus
THE STATE OF MADHYA PRADESH
Appearance:
Shri Pradeep Kumar Naveria - Advocate for the appellant. Shri Akshay Namdeo - Government Advocate for the respondent- State.
JUDGMENT
Per: Justice Atul Sreedharan The present appeal has been filed by the appellant who is aggrieved by the judgment of conviction and sentence dated 31.01.2015 passed in S.T. No.653/2012 passed by IV Additional Sessions Judge, Sagar (M.P.) whereby the appellant was tried for offences punishable under Sections 449, 302, 392 read with 397 of IPC. Inter alia, he has been convicted for the offence under Section 302 of IPC for which he is suffering life imprisonment.
2. The case of the prosecution is that on 23.10.2012, between 3:00- 4:00 pm, the appellant is said to have broken and entered into the house of the deceased for the purpose of theft and in the process found the deceased in the house, strangulated him and took away Rs.25,600/- from the house. The
1
star witness in this case is Harshit Soni (PW-8), who at the time of his testimony was 14 years. He has stated that on the date of the incident at around 02:00 pm, he first saw the accused standing in the balcony of the house, which is the scene of crime, and then, he saw the accused going down the stairs. He further states that he went off to sleep and an hour later, he was woken up by the shout of the father of the deceased and upon reaching the scene of occurrence, he found that the deceased lying dead. In his examination-in-chief, he states that he suspects, it is the appellant as he had seen him standing in the balcony of the house and thereafter leaving the house using the staircase. In cross-examination, this witness has stated that he is not a witness to the crime itself and neither did he see the appellant going up the stairs into the house of the deceased. The deceased is about 13 years of age (as per the post-mortem report). The F.I.R. was registered on the same day and inter alia it discloses that the amount that went missing from the home was Rs.25,600/-. As regards the testimony of Harshit Soni (PW-8), the defence has not been able to bring out any contradictions or improvisations from his statement under Section 164 of Cr.P.C given earlier during investigation. He has stated exactly as he had stated earlier in his statement under Section 164 of Cr.P.C before the Magistrate. They are no embellishments, additions, deletions in his Court testimony and he has stated exactly what he has seen and nothing more. Thereafter, the appellant was arrested on the very next day i.e. 24.10.2012, as is reflected in his arrest memo which is Ex.P-11. The FSL report relating to the nail clippings of the deceased is Ex.P-16 which reflects that there was blood discovered in the
2
scrapings. However, it does not disclose whether the blood is human blood and neither does it disclose the blood group, as the blood had disintegrated. The post-mortem report records multiple abrasion injuries and a ligature mark around the neck of the deceased and the opinion relating to the cause of death is asphyxia on account of strangulation which is homicidal in nature. After the appellant was arrested, upon his disclosure, the bag containing the money was recovered from a public toilet and the exact amount of Rs.25,600/-, as mentioned in the FIR, was recovered. The F.I.R. has been registered by Kailash Soni (PW-11) who is the father of the deceased. This money was received by Kailash Soni (PW-11) from Deepak Soni (PW-14) who had handed over the amount to Kailash Soni as he (Deepak Soni) was going to Katni. The F.I.R. was registered by Sandeep Soni @ Mintu (PW-3) who is a neighbour of Kailash Soni, who upon hearing the shouts of Kailash Soni between 3-4 pm, he reaches the house and sees that the door of the almirah in the bedroom, was broken and so was the lock. He further states that at the time of incident, the mother and the younger sister of the deceased had gone out to perform religious rituals and the father of the deceased was in the shop. Two other witnesses who are relevant in this case are PW-11 and PW-14 who are proving the seizure of the notes from the purse and have stated that there were 42 notes of Rs.500/- denomination and 25 notes of Rs.100/- denomination. Deepak Soni (PW-14) is a person who had given this amount to Kailash Soni (PW-11) and both of them had testified to the number of notes and the value of the currency notes. No major discrepancy has been brought out in cross-examination. PW-6 and PW-7 are Jaynarayan
3
and Manoj respectively. The 27 memorandum of the accused was recorded in their presence in which he has disclosed about the money hidden by him. Both these witnesses have supported the case of prosecution by proving the 27 memorandum and the seizure memorandum. They are independent witnesses who are not related to the deceased or his family. PW-16 is Rajesh Singh Parihar who is an Investigating officer of this case who has recovered the bag containing the stolen amount upon the indication given by the appellant. Dr. Virendra Pathak (PW-15) is the witness to the identification of the bag containing the currency notes by PW-11 and PW-14.
3. Learned counsel for the appellant has argued that learned trial Court has convicted the appellant on the basis of suspicion. He has further submitted that suspicion cannot take the place of proof for the purpose of recording a conviction. He has further submitted Harshit Soni (PW-8) does not speak about seeing the appellant leave with the bag. He further states that the presence of the appellant at the house of the deceased could be natural as the appellant is related to the deceased and his father. Therefore, his presence at 2:00 pm, as so stated by Harshit Soni (PW-8), is not suspicious. He has further argued that it was for the prosecution to prove that after the appellant, left no other person had access to the deceased and that was a circumstance that had to be excluded by adducing evidence, failing which the doubt would always remain about a third person having entered the house and killed the deceased. As regards the recovery of the bag containing the money, learned counsel for the appellant submits as the same was planted subsequently and that it absurd to even think that the appellant had stolen the bag with money
4
and would have hidden the same in a public toilet to which the general public had access. He further submits that the place where the money was recovered from was not an isolated place and the same was accessible to the general public.
4. Learned counsel for the State on the other hand submits that the conviction recorded by the learned trial Court is just and proper and no interference is called for by this court. He too, refers to the testimony of Harshit Soni (PW-8) and says that he is a witness of sterling quality and has not stated anything more than what he has actually seen. He further submits that the witness corroborated his statement under Section 164 of Cr.P.C. recorded at the time of investigation. He further submits that the answers given by this witness upon cross-examination to the effect that he has not seen the witness going into the house and neither is he a witness to the of murder, goes to reflect that he is only stated the facts and is not an interested witness who seeks to secure the conviction of the appellant.
5. As regards Harshit Soni (PW-8), the witness to last seen at scene of crime before the body was discovered, learned counsel for the State submits that Harshit Soni (PW-8) states that he had seen the appellant peeping from the balcony of the house of the deceased at about 2:00 pm on the date of incident and thereafter, he sees the appellant leave by the staircase. He says that the testimony of PW 8 that he woke up hearing the shouts of the father of the deceased an hour later is also corroborated by the statement of Sandeep @ Mintu (PW-3) who says that he had heard the shouts between 3:00-4:00 pm which coincides with the approximate time given by Harshit
5
Soni (PW-8).
6. Under the circumstances, learned counsel for the State submits that the testimony of the witnesses corroborated the time at which the crime was discovered. He further states that the father of the deceased who had gone to his shop earlier that day and he had have spoken to the deceased (as per the testimony of PW-11) during the day and the deceased had informed his father that he has had his food and is at home.
7. Learned counsel for the State also submits that PW-11 asked the deceased to close the channel gate before he goes to sleep. He has also referred to statement of Sandeep @ Mintu (PW-3) who says that the mother and the sister of the deceased were not at home as they had gone to perform some religious rituals. Therefore, the statement of this witness (PW-3) reflects that the deceased was in all probability alone at home at the time of incident.
8. Learned counsel for the State further submits that the appellant used to indulge in gambling and therefore, he had broken into the house and robbed the money for his nefarious hobby. As regards the recovery of the amount at the behest of the appellant, learned counsel for the State submits that there is no reason to dispute or suspect the recovery, as the disclosure memorandum under Section 27 of Evidence Act has been proved by two independent witnesses Jaynarayan (PW-6) and Manoj (PW-7) and the recovery was effected by the Police (PW-16) at the behest of the accused and the precise amount stolen from the house was recovered from the accused.
9. As regards the amount of Rs.25,600/- that was allegedly stolen from
6
the house, learned counsel for the State submits that the F.I.R. which is the first document at the point of time also mentions the precise amount of money that was stolen from the house and the same was recovered from the appellant herein. Therefore, there is no reason to doubt any of the prosecution witnesses or the prosecution's case.
10. Heard learned counsel for the parties and perused the record of the trial Court.
11. There are no undisputed facts in this case. The conviction has largely been based upon the statement of Harshit Soni (PW-8) and the recovery of the amount at the behest of the appellant. Harshit Soni (PW-8), as already stated hereinabove, is a sterling witness aged about 14 years and has unequivocally reiterated what he has stated in his statement recorded under Section 164 Cr.P.C at the time of investigation without any embellishments or improvements. His cross-examination also reflects that the witness has stated truthfully that he has neither seen the appellant coming up to the house and that he has neither witnessed the murder. His statement inspires confidence that the appellant was present at the house of the deceased at around 2:00 pm and that he left the place, and after an hour, the crime was discovered.
12. The post-mortem report and the FSL report are also significant circumstances. The post-mortem report discloses that the deceased was strangulated, and the cause of death was asphyxia on account of strangulation which was homicidal. The FSL report discloses the presence of blood in the scrapings taken from the fingernail of the deceased though, FSL
7
report does not disclose that it is either human blood.
13. The some totality of the facts when seen starting from the statement of Harshit Soni (PW-8) where he has seen the appellant at 2:00 pm in the house of the deceased and thereafter leaving by stairs, the discovery of the crime between 3-4 pm by the father of the deceased who on suspicion that there was something wrong as the deceased did not respond to his phone call, came and discovered the body at home, the statement of Sandeep @ Mintu (PW-3) who also states that he heard the screams of the father between 3-4 pm and arrived at the scene of crime, and a non-explanation of these circumstances in the statement of the appellant recorded under Section 313 of Cr.P.C. which is only bare denial goes to strengthen the case of prosecution.
14. As regards the submission of the learned counsel for the appellant that suspicion cannot take the place of proof, this Court is an agreement with the legal proposition. Though the settled law is that the suspicion cannot take the place of proof, the principle of beyond reasonable doubt should not be stretched to an argument that it is beyond fanciful doubt. Once the presence of the appellant was proved at the scene of occurrence one hour before the body was discovered, which is a place where the appellant does not reside, the onus was upon him under Section 106 of the erstwhile Evidence Act to explain his presence at the scene of occurrence, why did he go there, and what happened there till he left. The opportunity was there in the statement under Section 313 of Cr.P.C. but the appellant has not given any satisfactory answer with regard to his presence at the scene of occurrence, but for a bare
8
(ATUL SREEDHARAN)
JUDGE
(DEVNARAYAN MISHRA)
JUDGE
denial. There are no reasons to doubt the independent witnesses in this case who supported the 27 memorandum and the seizures memorandum or the statement of Harshit Soni (PW-8) and Sandeep @ Mintu (PW-3).
15. Under the circumstances, this Court is of the opinion that the prosecution has been able to prove the case against the appellant beyond reasonable doubt and that there is no reason to interfere with the impugned order. Hence, the appeal being devoid of merits is dismissed.
HK
9
Alert