- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Amit Kumar Sethia (Deceased) v. State of U.P. and Another
Factual and Procedural Background
This petition challenges the order dated 17.11.2023 passed under Section 73(9) of the Goods and Services Tax Act, 2017, which raised a demand of Rs. 21,49,585.60 in the name of the deceased petitioner, Amit Kumar Sethia. The petitioner in the writ petition is Alka Sethia, wife of the deceased. Amit Kumar Sethia died on 20.04.2021, and the GST registration of his proprietorship firm, M/s. Sethia Trading Company, was cancelled effective 13.05.2021 by an order dated 02.06.2021. Despite this, a show cause notice dated 13.09.2023 was issued in the name of the deceased under Section 73 of the Act, followed by reminders on 17.10.2023 and 31.10.2023. As these notices were uploaded on the GST portal and the registration had already been cancelled, the petitioner had no occasion to access the portal or respond. This led to the passing of the impugned order raising the demand against the deceased.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether a show cause notice and subsequent determination of tax demand can be validly issued and made against a deceased person under the GST Act.
- Whether the liability to pay tax, interest, or penalty after the death of a proprietor can be enforced against the legal representative without issuing notice to the legal representative.
Arguments of the Parties
Petitioner’s Arguments
- Amit Kumar Sethia had died prior to issuance of the show cause notice and cancellation of GST registration of the proprietorship firm.
- Since the GST registration was cancelled and the show cause notice was issued in the name of the deceased, the petitioner had no opportunity to respond.
- The proceedings conducted against the deceased are void ab initio and the impugned order ought to be quashed and set aside.
Respondent’s Arguments
- The respondents relied on Section 93 of the GST Act to support the order.
- Section 93 authorizes recovery of tax, interest, or penalty from legal representatives even after the death of the proprietor.
Table of Precedents Cited
No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The court observed that the show cause notice, reminders, and tax determination were all issued after the death of the proprietor. Section 93 of the GST Act provides special provisions regarding liability to pay tax, interest, or penalty in case of death of a person liable under the Act. It distinguishes between two scenarios: where the business is continued after death by legal representatives, and where the business is discontinued. The provision makes legal representatives liable to pay dues out of the deceased’s estate but does not authorize determination of tax demand against the deceased person themselves.
The court emphasized that for the legal representative to be held liable, the show cause notice and opportunity to respond must be issued to the legal representative, not to the deceased. Since the impugned proceedings were initiated against the deceased without issuing notice to the legal representatives, the proceedings were invalid and unsustainable.
Holding and Implications
The writ petition is allowed. The impugned order dated 17.11.2023 is quashed and set aside.
The respondents are at liberty to initiate appropriate proceedings in accordance with law by issuing notice to the legal representatives of the deceased. The decision directly affects the parties by invalidating the demand raised against the deceased but does not establish any new precedent beyond the application of Section 93 of the GST Act.
Neutral Citation No. - 2025:AHC:45317-DB
Chief Justice's Court Case :- WRIT TAX No. - 917 of 2025
Petitioner :- Amit Kumar Sethia (Deceased)
Respondent :- State of U.P. and another
Counsel for Petitioner :- Ajay Kumar Yadav
Counsel for Respondent :- C.S.C., Ankur Agarwal (S.C.)
Hon'ble Arun Bhansali, Chief Justice Hon'ble Kshitij Shailendra, J.
1. This petition is directed against order dated 17.11.2023 passed under Section 73(9) of the Goods and Services Tax Act, 2017 (for short 'the Act') wherein a demand of Rs. 21,49,585.60 has been raised in the name of Amit Kumar Sethia.
2. The petitioner Alka Sethia, wife of deceased Amit Kumar Sethia has filed the petition inter alia with the submissions that Amit Kumar Sethia had died on 20.04.2021 and on account of his death, the GST registration of the proprietorship firm M/s. Sethia Trading Company, which was in the name of deceased Amit Kumar Sethia, was cancelled with effect from 13.05.2021 by order dated 02.06.2021. Whereafter a show cause notice dated 13.09.2023 was issued in the name of deceased Amit Kumar Sethia under Section 73 of the Act, followed by reminders dated 17.10.2023 and 31.10.2023, however, as the same were uploaded on the portal and the GST registration had already been cancelled, there was no occasion for the petitioner to have accessed the said portal, the show cause notice remained unanswered which resulted in passing of the order dated 17.11.2023 raising demand against the deceased.
3. Submissions have been made that once the Department was well aware of the fact that Amit Kumar Sethia, proprietor of the firm
1
has already died and the registration of the firm has already been cancelled, there was no occasion for issuing a show cause notice in the name of the deceased and as the proceedings have been conducted in the name of the deceased Amit Kumar Sethia, the same are void ab initio and, therefore, the order impugned deserves to be quashed and set aside.
4. Learned counsel for the respondents supported the order impugned with the aid of provisions of Section 93 of the Act. Submissions have been made that under the provisions of Section 93, the recovery can be made from the legal representatives even after the determination has been made after the death of the proprietor of the firm.
5. We have considered the submissions made by counsel for the parties and have perused the material available on record.
6. Undisputed facts are that the show cause notice, reminders and determination of tax have been made after the death of the proprietor of the firm. Provisions of Section 93 of the Act, insofar as relevant, reads as under:
"93. Special provisions regarding liability to pay tax, interest or penalty in certain cases:
(1) Save as otherwise provided in the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, 2016 (31 of 2016), where a person, liable to pay tax, interest or penalty under this Act, dies, then -
(a) if a business carried on by the person is continued after his death by his legal representative or any other person, such legal representative or other person, shall be liable to pay tax, interest or penalty due from such person under this Act; and
(b) if the business carried on by the person is discontinued, whether before or after his death, his legal representative shall be liable to pay, out of the estate of the deceased, to the extent to which the estate is capable of meeting the charge, the tax, interest or penalty due from such person
2
under this Act, whether such tax, interest or penalty has been determined before his death but has remained unpaid or is determined after his death."
7. A perusal of the above provision would reveal that the same only deals with the liability to pay tax, interest or penalty in a case where the business is continued after the death, by the legal representative or where the business is discontinued, however, the provision does not deal with the fact as to whether the determination at all can take place against a deceased person and the said provision cannot and does not authorise the determination to be made against a dead person and recovery thereof from the legal representative.
8. Once the provision deals with the liability of a legal representative on account of death of the proprietor of the firm, it is sine qua non that the legal representative is issued a show cause notice and after seeking response from the legal representative, the determination should take place.
9. In view thereof, the determination made in the present case wherein the show cause notice was issued and the determination was made against the dead person without issuing notice to the legal representative, cannot be sustained.
10. Consequently, the writ petition is allowed. The order dated 17.11.2023 (Annexure-1 to the writ petition) is quashed and set aside. The respondents would be free to take appropriate proceedings in accordance with law.
Order Date :- 2.4.2025 AHA/AKShukla
(Kshitij Shailendra, J) (Arun Bhansali, CJ)
3
Alert