Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Vinod Kumar v. Smt. Manorama Devi

Madhya Pradesh High Court
Mar 24, 2025

IN THE HIGH COURT OF MADHYA PRADESH

A T J A B A L P U R

BEFORE

HON'BLE SHRI JUSTICE DWARKA DHISH BANSAL ON THE 24thOF MARCH, 2025

MISC. PETITION No. 4811 of 2024

VINOD KUMAR AND OTHERS

Versus

SMT. MANORAMA DEVI AND OTHERS

Appearance:

Shri Sankalp Kochar - Advocate for the petitioners. None for the respondents though served.

ORDER

After arguing at length, learned counsel for the petitioners in the light of decision of this Court in the case of Arvind Jain and others vs. Sakunbai and others given on 22.12.2016 in W.P. No.6888/2016 (Gwalior Bench), prays for withdrawal of this misc. petition in respect of application under Order 26 Rule 9 CPC with liberty to file fresh application for the same purpose after completion of evidence of both the parties.

2. Prayer being reasonable is accepted and this misc. petition is permitted to be withdrawn and is hereby disposed off with the aforesaid liberty in respect of the application under Order 26 Rule 9 CPC.

3. So far as the order dismissing the application under Order 16 Rule 1 CPC is concerned, learned counsel submits that in support of their case the plaintiffs want to examine Executive Engineer of the Municipal Corporation, whose name was mentioned by the plaintiffs, in the list of witnesses, but without considering

1

this aspect of the matter and on the ground of non mentioning of the reason and relevancy of the witness, in the application itself, trial Court has dismissed the application illegally, in spite of the fact that the prayer made by the petitioners was not opposed by the respondents by filing reply. He submits that parties to the suit are free to adduce evidence of their choice, hence the application filed by the plaintiffs under Order 16 Rule 1 CPC ought to have been allowed.

4. Apparently, trial Court has dismissed the application on the ground of non mentioning of the reason and relevancy of said witness, in the application under Order 16 Rule 1 CPC and has not considered that the plaintiffs or defendants have right to lead evidence of their choice and if they have fulfilled the requirement of getting summoned any of the witnesses by mentioning name in the list of witnesses, the Court cannot refuse to summon such witness and relevancy of testimony given by such witness, can be seen only after his examination before the Court.

5. In view of the aforesaid discussion, this Court has no option but to allow the application under Order 16 Rule 1 CPC, with the direction to trial Court to issue summons for examination of said Executive Engineer, however only after examination of the plaintiffs or any of the plaintiffs.

6. With the aforesaid observation, instant misc. petition is allowed.

7. Misc. application(s), pending if any, shall stand closed.

(DWARKA DHISH BANSAL)

JUDGE

SN

2