Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

TULSA DEVI TRIPATHI v. STATE OF HARYANA AND ANOTHER

Punjab & Haryana High Court
Mar 1, 2025

114 IN THE HIGH COURT OF PUNJAB AND HARYANA

TULSA DEVI TRIPATHI

STATE OF HARYANA AND

CORAM: HON'BLE MR.

Present: Mr. for the petitioner.

HARPREET SINGH BRAR

1. The present petition has been filed 2023 for quashing of order dated learned Judicial Magistrate No.19718/2017 titled as

Devi Tripathi' whereby the petitioner was declared as proclaimed person the consequential FIR bearing

Section 174-A IPC at Police Station

(Annexure P-2)

2. The brief facts of the present case are that a complaint under Section 138 of Negotiable Instruments Act, 1881 petitioner, wherein the petitioner was declared as proclaimed person vide order dated 03.11.2022 (Annexure P

registered against him.

3. Learned counsel for the petitioner submits that order has been passed in a cryptic manner and

AT CHANDIGARH

V/S

ANOTHER

JUSTICE HARPREET SINGH BRAR

Pardeep Panwar, Advocate

****

, J. (ORAL)

03.11.2022 (Annexure P First Class, Gurugram in a case bearing NACT 'M/s India Infoline Housing Finance Ltd. vs. Tulsa No.2041 dated

Shivaji Nagar

and all consequential proceedings emanating therefrom. -1) and subsequently, FIR (

the impugned order is liable to

CRM-M-8496-2025 Date of decision: 01.03.2025

...PETITIONER

...RESPONDENTS

under Section 528 BNSS, -1) passed by the and

03.12.2022 registered under , District Gurugram was filed against the supra) was

the impugned

1

be set aside on the ground th been followed in its letter and spirit by the trial Court. conditions as laid down in Section 195

the proceedings against the petitioner, which encompasses Section 174 IPC within its purview.

4. Notice of motion.

5. Mr. accepts notice on behalf of respond passed by the learned trial Court by contending that the petitioner did not put in appearance before the trial Court intentionally and deliberately and, therefore, having left with no other option, proclamation was iss his presence.

6. I have heard learned counsel for the parties and perused the record of the case with their able assistance and with the consent of parties, the matter is taken up for final disposal.

7. Section 174 Amendment Act of 2005, and a corresponding amendment was made to Schedule 1 of the Criminal Procedure Code (Cr provision as a cognizable offence. However, no corresponding amendment was made to Section 195 of

scope. The proposition that Section 174

as laid out in Section 195 Cr.P.C.

174-A IPC and the corresponding Section 209 of

2023, are essentially identical. However, Section 209 has been explicitly removed from the purview of Section 215 of the Bhartiya Nag

2

at the mandate of Section 82 of Cr.P.C. has not Cr.P.C.

Vikas Bhardwaj, AAG, Haryana

ent No.1-

-A of the IPC was

the Cr.P.C. to exclude Section 174 -A IPC is governed by the procedure is further supported by the fact that Section He further submits that

have not been followed before

-A of

, who is present in the Court,

State and supports the order

ued to secure

introduced through the

.P.C.), classifying this

-A IPC from its

the Bhartiya Nyaya Sanhita

arik Suraksha

2

Sanhita, 2023 which mirrors Section 195 of Section 195 of the Cr

legislature in its wisdom this time Bhartiya Nyaya

Suraksha Sanhita

195(1)(b) of the

Therefore, it is evident

under Section 174

8. As it is c 195, it would be apposite to Cr.P.C. is mandatory the Hon'ble Supreme Court's

Tamil Nadu, (2010) 9 SCC 567

made:

"20. Section taking cognizance of any offence punishable under Section Penal Code or abetment or attempt to commit the same, unless, there is a written complaint by the public servant concerned for contempt of his lawful order. The object of this provision is to pr procedure in a case of contempt of the lawful authority of the public servant. The

of offences enumerated therein. The legislative intent behind such a provision has been tha

prosecution instituted upon insufficient grounds by persons actuated by malice, ill

criminal courts being wasted by endless prosecutions. This provision has been carved out as an exception to the general rule contained under Section 190

in motion by making a complaint, as it prohibits the cognizance of certain offences until and unless a complaint has been made by some particular authority or person. Other provisions in the Criminal Procedure Code like sections 196 and 198 do not lay down any rule of procedure, rather, they only create

3

Cr.P.C. .P.C. clearly encompasses Section 174 has specifically excluded Section 209 of the Sanhita from the ambit of Section 215

. Furthermore, in 2006, an amendment was made to Section Cr.P.C., but Section 195(1)(a)(i) was left unchanged. that Section 195 of the

-A IPC.

onclusive that Section 174

emphasize that the drill of

in nature. This position is supported by the rendered in C. Muniappan & O

, wherein the following observations were 195(a)(i) Criminal Procedure Code bars the court lacks competence to take cognizance in certain types t an individual should not face criminal

-will or frivolity of disposition and to save the time of the Criminal Procedure Code that any person can set the law In its present form, thus,

-A IPC, as the

of the Bhartiya Nagarik

Cr.P.C. applies to the offence

-A IPC is governed by Section

Section 195 of the

judgment of

thers. v. State of

court from

188 Indian ovide for a particular court from taking a bar that unless some

3

requirements are complied with, the an offence described in those Sections. (vide

of Bihar, AIR 1971 The State of Gujarat, Ors. v. Balbir Singh, 1996(3) RCR (Criminal) 240 : (1996) 3 SCC 533; State of Punjab v. Raj Singh & Anr., 1998(1) RCR (Criminal) 576 : (1998) 2 SCC 391;

Ors., (2005) 7 SCC

Meenakshi Marwah & Anr., 2005(2) RCR (Criminal) 178 : 2005(1) Apex Criminal 581

21. The test of whether there is evasion or non Section 195

disclose primarily and essentially an offence for which a complaint of the court or of a public servant is required. In

The State of West Bengal, AIR 1953 and Durgacharan

1966 Supreme

Section cannot be evaded by describing the offence as one being punishable under some other sections of Indian Penal Code, though in truth and substa

Section 195

offence cannot be taken by mis

on it.

22. In M.S (Criminal) 718

under :

"....Provisions of Section are

any of the offences mentioned therein in writing as required under that section." (Emphasis added)

23. In Sachida Nand Singh & Anr. v. State of Bihar & Anr., 1998(1) RCR (Criminal)

this issue observed as under :

"7. ..Section 190 of the Code empowers "any magistrate of the first class" to take cognizance of "any offence" upon receiving a complaint, or police report or information

knowledge. Section 195 restricts such general powers of the magistrate, and the general right of a person to move the

recognised canon of interpretation that

4

court

Supreme Court 1708; AIR 1971 Supreme K. Vengadachalam v. K.C. Palanisamy & 352; and Iqbal Singh Marwah & Anr. v.

).

Criminal Procedure Code or not, is whether the facts

Naik & Ors. v. State of Orissa, AIR Court 1775, this Court held that the provisions of this nce, the offence falls in a category mentioned in Criminal Procedure Code Thus, cognizance of such an -describing it or by putting a wrong label

. Ahlawat v. State of Haryana & Anr., 1999(4) RCR

, this Court considered the matter at length and held as

195 Criminal Procedure Code mandatory and no court has jurisdiction to take cognizance of

823 : (1998) 2 SCC 493,

court with a complaint to that extent curtailed. It is a well shall not take cognizance of

Govind Mehta v. The State

Patel Laljibhai Somabhai v.

Court 1935; Surjit Singh &

-compliance of Basir-ul-Haq & Ors. v. Supreme Court293;

unless there is a complaint this Court while dealing with or upon his own

-

provision curbing the

4

general jurisdiction of the interpretation

otherwise."

24. In Daulat Ram v. State Of Punjab ., AIR 1962

this Court Section 195 been taken on the police report by the Magistrate and the appellant therein had been tried and convicted, though the concerned publi servant, the Tahsildar had not filed any complaint. This under :

"The cognizance of the case was therefore wrongly assumed by the

namely, the Tahsildar in this case.

jurisdiction ab initio and the conviction cannot be maintained.

of the appellant and the sentence passed on him are set aside."

25. Thus, that there must be a complaint by the public servant whose lawful order has not been complied with. The complaint must be in writing. The provisions of Section

Non-compliance of it wou

consequential orders. The

case without such complaint. In the absence of such a complaint, the trial and conviction will be void ab initio being without jurisdiction.

9. Section 195(1)(a)(i) of the take cognizance of any offence punishable under Sections 172 to 188 of the IPC unless a written complaint is made by the concerned public servant or another public servant to whom they are a

provision serves as an explicit bar, stating that the court cannot take cognizance of a matter based on a

complaint, as defined under Section 2(d) of the

Report or Final

complaint filed in

5

court unless the statute or the context requires considered the nature of the provisions of Criminal Procedure Code In the said case, cognizance had court without the complaint in writing of the public servant, The appeal is, therefore, allowed and the conviction in view of the above, the law can

195 Criminal Procedure Code are mandatory. ld vitiate the prosecution and all other Court cannot assume the cognizance of the Cr.P.C.

dministratively subordinate. This Final Report under Section 173 of Cr.P.C Report. Thus, cognizance can only be taken on a Court under Section 200 of the

must normally receive strict

(Emphasis supplied)

Supreme Court 1206, c

Court held as The trial was thus without (Emphasis added)

be summarised to the effect

" specifies that no court shall

. A

Cr.P.C., excludes a Police written

Cr.P.C.. Further, Section

5

21(3) of the IPC defines "public servant" to include every judge or any person empowered by law to perfor

part of a body.

Cr.P.C., it is clear that c

IPC can only be initiated through a

public servant or another public servant to whom they are administratively subordinate. (See:

41656-2023 decided on

Punjab, CRM-M Channi CRM-M

10. In the present case, the learned Magistrate, being a public servant as defined under Section 21 of the IPC, was required to follow the procedu prescribed by law if he intended to initiate proceedings against the petitioner for the offence under Section 174

would have been to file a written complaint before the competent jurisdictional court. However, i

Magistrate merely forward

them to initiate proceedings under Section 174

the registration of

of Section 195 of the

provisions. Consequently, both the order passed by the Magistrate directing the initiation of proceedings and the resulting FIR stand contrary procedural safeguards enshrined in Section 195 of

11. While the scheme of criminal justice system necessitates curtailment of personal liberty to some extent, it is of the utmost importance

6

m adjudicatory functions, either individually or as As a result, from the plain language of Section 195 of the riminal prosecution under Sections 172 to 188 of the written compl

Pardeep Kumar vs. State of Punjab and Another, CRM 23.08.2023; Jarnail Singh @ Rana vs. State of -48718-2019 decided on 17.04.2024 -453-2023 pronounced on 06.12.2023

-A of the IPC. The proper course of action nstead of adhering to this legal requirement, the ed a copy of its orders to the local police, directing -A IPC, which effectively led to

the impugned FIR. Given the mandatory nature and scope Cr.P.C., such an approach is in clear violation of its aint filed by the concerned

-

and Charanjit Singh @

)

re learned to the Cr.P.C.

6

that the same is done in line with the procedure a healthy balance between personal liberty of the individual interests of the society in promoting law and order. Such procedure must be compatible with Article 21 of the Constitution of India i.e. it must be fai and not suffer from the vice of arbitrariness or unreasonableness. Additionally, i

certain thing in a certain way, the thing must be done in that way or not at all. Other methods are necessa

judgment of the Hon'ble Apex Court in

Dharani Sugars

SCC 480.

12. In the eventuality of his non accused first ought to have been secured by issuing summons or bailable warrants, and non

issued at the first instance. A perusal of the impugned order reveals that the trial Court has issued a proclamation s

reasons to indicate that the petitioner has absconded or is concealing from the process of law. Conspicuously, no summons or bailable warrants were issued prior to issuance of the proclamation. This Court in the passed in Major Singh @ Major Vs. State of Punjab 2023 (3) RCR (Criminal) 406; 2023 (2) Law Herald 1506

required to record its satisfaction before issuance of process under Section 82 Cr.P.C. and non

from incurable illegality. Furthermore, the learned counsel for the petitioner has taken a specific stand that the petitioner was declared to be a proclaimed

7

t is a settled law that where a power is given to do a rily forbidden. Reference can be made to

and Chemicals Ltd. v. Union of India

-appearance, the presence of the -bailable warrants or proclamation should not generally be traight away, without recording any

has held that the Court is first

-recording of the satisfaction itself makes such order suffering established by law to maintain

-accused and

r, just

the

reported in (2019) 5

himself judgment

7

person without following the drill of Section 8 proclamation was never served on the petitioner, all actions taken post non execution of the proclamation stand vitiated.

13. Learned aforesaid facts and the position of law as laid down in the aforesaid judgment.

14. In view of the aforesaid facts and circumstances, the present petition is allowed

vide which the pet

bearing No.2041

Police Station Shivaji Nagar, District Gurugram proceedings emanating therefrom, are hereby quashed qua the petitioner.

March 01, 2025

manisha (i)

(ii)

8

State counsel has not been able to and the impugned order dated itioner was declared as proclaimed person as well as dated 03.12.2022 registered under Section 174

(HARPREET SINGH BRAR

Whether speaking/reasoned Whether reportable

2 Cr.P.C. Since the -

controvert the 03.11.2022 (Annexure P-1)

FIR

-A IPC at and all the consequential

)

JUDGE

Yes/No Yes/No

8