Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

UNION OF INDIA v. K SASISEKHARAN NAIR

Kerala High Court
Jan 9, 2025

2025:KER:2727

IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM

PRESENT

THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE AMIT RAWAL

&

THE HONOURABLE MR.JUSTICE K. V. JAYAKUMAR

THURSDAY, THE 9THDAY OF JANUARY 2025 / 19TH POUSHA, 1946

OP (CAT) NO. 38 OF 2017

AGAINST THE ORDER DATED 17.05.2016 IN OA NO.311 OF

2015 OF CENTRAL ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL, ERNAKULAM BENCH

PETITIONERS/RESPONDENTS:

1 UNION OF INDIA REPRESENTED BY ITS SECRETARY,

DEPARTMENT OF POSTS, MINISTRY OF COMMUNICATIONS,

NEW DELHI-110011.

2 THE CHIEF POSTMASTER GENERAL

KERALA CIRCLE, TRIVANDRUM-695033.

ASSISTANT SOLICITOR GENERAL

SRI.T.V.VINU, CGC

RESPONDENT:

K SASISEKHARAN NAIR,

S/O.G.KRISHNA PILLAI, RETD. SENIOR

SUPERINTENDENT, RMS TV DIVISION, TRIVANDRUM,

RESIDING AT KRISHNA VILAS,

MALAYINKIL P.O., TRIVANDRUM-695571.

BY ADVS.

SMT.S.LAKSHMY

SRI.SHAFIK M.A.

THIS OP (CAT) HAVING COME UP FOR ADMISSION ON

09.01.2025, THE COURT ON THE SAME DAY DELIVERED THE

FOLLOWING:

1

2

JUDGMENT

AMIT RAWAL,J.

Present case arises out of the decision of the Central Administrative Tribunal dated 17.05.2016 in O.A.No.311/2015, whereby the claim of the respondent/applicant for interest on the pension has been allowed. The short question involved in the present original petition is whether, claim for interest on the pension is permissible or not.

2. Rule 69 of the Central Civil Service (Pension) Rules, 1972 deals with provisional pensions when judicial proceedings are pending. There is no provision for payment of the interest, in case, if the judicial proceedings resulted in favor of the delinquent employee. In the instant case, while working as Senior Superintendent of the Post Office, major penalty proceedings were initiated against the respondent/applicant on 22.02.2008 when the charge sheet was served. It was only seven days before the date of superannuation, ie., 29.02.2008. The aforementioned

3

disciplinary proceedings, ultimately, resulted into reduction in pension. The said decision was challenged before the Tribunal in O.A.No.1028/2011, which was allowed on 22.05.2013 and the penalty proceedings were quashed. It was declared that the applicant would be entitled to full pension and direction was also given to refund the withheld amount of pension but, the interest on pension was disallowed.

3. The aforementioned order was assailed by the respondent/applicant vide OP(CAT) No.39/2014 in this Court, seeking interest on the pension. This Court, vide order dated 30.06.2014, disposed of the original petition by holding that, any representation submitted by the applicant seeking interest on the Death Cum Retirement Gratuity (DCRG) and interest on withheld pension, shall be decided, uninfluenced by the findings rendered by the Central Administrative Tribunal. The department, vide order dated 17.10.2014, withdrew the charge sheet and allowed all consequential retirement benefits to respondent/ applicant including the interest on the GPF, but did not grant interest on the commuted value of pension. The aforementioned action was assailed vide O.A.No 311 of 2015, resulting into directions by the Tribunal in paragraphs 5, 6, 7

4

and 8, which reads as under:

5. The short question to be decided in this case is whether the applicant is entitled to get interest on the delayed payment of full pension and the commutation value thereof in the wake of Annexure A-3 order of this Tribunal? It is not in dispute that the applicant was shackled with disciplinary proceedings just one week prior to his retirement. The charge memo was issued on 22.2.2008 i.e, just a week before the applicant's retirement. After the retirement, the disciplinary Proceedings continued invoking Rule 9 CCS (pension) Rules 1972. Going by the contentions in the. reply statement in this O.A, the disciplinary proceedings continued for nearly 3 more years and came to a close by the presidential order dated 10.8.2011 imposing the penalty of reduction of pension. The applicant filed O.A 1028/2011 before this Tribunal challenging the order Imposing penalty. Nearly 2 years thereafter in 2013 this Tribunal allowed the Original Application quashing and setting aside the order imposing penalty. Though the applicant had prayed for awarding interest on the delayed payment of pension and pensionary benefits, the same was not allowed by the Tribunal as no malafide intention was attributed for initiating the disciplinary proceedings. However, when the aforesaid Annexure A-2 order was challenged in the High Court on the issue of interest, the High Court permitted the applicant to file a representation as the respondents expressed their willingness to consider such representation. Annexure A-5 representation submitted by the applicant has resulted in the impugned Annexure A-1 order whereby while granting interest at the rate of GPF deposits in respect of the with held DCRG, his request for interest on the pension and commuted portion of retirement benefits was rejected.

6. From the above factual matrix, it can be seen that when the charge sheet was withdrawn by Annexure A-3 order issued by the Government of India, the scenario acquired a different dimension, placing the applicant in the primordial state of blamelessness, not withstanding Annexure A-2 order of this Tribunal. The proceedings initiated by the applicant in the High Court has resulted in Annexure A-7 order enabling the applicant to challenge Annexure A-1 order in appropriate proceedings, obviating the ban of res judicata which

5

otherwise would have been attributed to the present Original Application. Thus, the applicant is perfectly within his right to seek adjudication of the issue of interest on the reduced pension as well as the commuted value of pension from its due date till the date of payment.

7. The gravamen of the respondents' pleas in this case is that there is no express law for payment of interest. Referring to the provisions in the pension rules and the Government of India decisions made in CCS CCA (Pension) Rules, 1977 respondents contend that payment of interest is allowable only in respect of delayed payment of gratuity, not for the delayed payment of pension and pensionary benefits.

8. Shri.Shafik.M.A, learned counsel for applicant was drawing sustenance for his contention on the decision of the Hon'ble Supreme Court of India in S.K Dua v. State of Haryana and Another (2008) 3 SCC

44). In that case the Apex Court held:

"In the circumstances, prima facie, we are of the view that the grievance voiced by the appellant appears to be well founded that he would be entitled to interest on such benefits. If there are statutory rules occupying the field, the appellant could claim payment of interest relying on such rules. If there are administrative instructions, guidelines or norms prescribed for the purpose, the appellant may claim benefit of interest on that basis. But even in absence of statutory rules, administrative instructions or guidelines, an employee can claim interest under Part III of the Constitution relying on Articles 14,19 and 21 of the Constitution. The submission of the learned counsel for the appellant, the retiral benefits are not in the nature of "bounty"is, in our opinion, well founded and needs no authority in support thereof. In that view of the matter, in our considered opinion, the High Court was not right in dismissing the petition in limine even without issuing notice to the respondents."

4. Adv. T.V.Vinu, learned Central Government Counsel

6

appearing for the petitioners contended that the judgment relied upon by the Central Administrative Tribunal was at the initial stage when the matter was remitted, there was no final adjudication, thus the interest is not entitled to be given on the commuted value of the pension as per the GPF rates in the absence of any provisions in the statutory rules.

5. On the other hand, Mr.Shafik M.A., learned counsel appearing on behalf of the respondent cited the judgment of this Court to contend that even if there is no rules, if a person is ultimately successful in getting the penalty proceedings quashed, he is entitled to interest, over and above, that has been granted on the DCRG.

6. We have heard the learned counsel for the parties and appraised the paper book.

7. We are in agreement with the submission of Adv. T.V. Vinu, with regard to the applicability of the decision in

S.K.Dua v. State of Haryana and Others (2008) 3 SCC 44)

in Civil Appeal No.184 of 2008 (Arising out of SLP (C) No.21311 of 2005), noticed by the Tribunal, whereby noticing all these facts, the matter was remanded to the High Court for hearing

7

the writ petition afresh. But the fact remains that the penalty proceedings imposed against the respondent/applicant were quashed by the Central Administrative Tribunal vide judgment dated 22.05.2013. We are unable to understand that, once the proceedings were quashed, there was no occasion for the Department/Union to withdraw the charge sheet dated 17.10.2014. This exercise could have been done at the initial stage, when the respondent/applicant was at the fag end of the superannuation. Be that as it may. The representation submitted in pursuance of the judgment of this Court dated 30.06.2014, resulted into rejection of interest on the delayed payment of the pension, whereas the interest on the delayed payment of GSD was accepted.

8. The Division Bench of this Court in State of Kerala v. Sojan [2024(4) KLT 467] in paragraphs 11 and 14 held as under:

"11. The next aspect to be considered is the argument of the learned Government Pleader that the respondent has no legal right to claim interest as the department had released the amounts without any unreasonable delay after receipt of the representation seeking the payments. The assertion of the learned Government Pleader is that no provision in the Service Rules provides support to the claim raised by the respondent. It may be true that a search for such an

8

enabling provision in the KSR or any other Rules applicable would be an exercise in vain. However, by long line of precedents it is clear that the pension and gratuity are no longer any bounty to be distributed by the Government to its employees on their retirement, but, have become, under the decisions of the Court, valuable rights and property in their hands and any culpable delay in settlement and disbursement thereof must be dealt with the penalty of payment of interest at the current market rate till actual payment to the employees. We find perfect answer to the above said contention in S.K. Dua v. State of Haryana & Anr. (2008

(3) KLT 58 (SC) = (2008) 3 SCC 44) the relevant portion from the said judgment is extracted hereunder:-

"........... If there are Statutory Rules occupying the field, the appellant could claim payment of interest relying on such Rules. If there are Administrative Instructions, Guidelines or Norms prescribed for the purpose, the appellant may claim benefit of interest on that basis. But even in absence Statutory Rules, Administrative Instructions or Guidelines, an employee can claim interest under Part III of the Constitution relying on Art. 14, 19 and 21 of the Constitution."

Therefore, an employee can claim interest on the strength of fundamental rights guaranteed under Articles 14, 19 and 21 of the Constitution even if no provision in the statutory rules governing the field enables him to raise the same. We note that the retirement benefits are also protected under Article 300 of the Constitution.

12. It is also well settled that pension and gratuity are valuable rights and property due to the employees on their retirement. The Hon'ble Supreme Court has declared in unmistakable terms that they are no longer any bounty to be distributed by the Government to the employees on their retirement. In State of Kerala & Ors. V.M.Padmanabhan Nair (1985 KLT 86 (SC) = (1985) 1 SCC 429) the Supreme Court held that any

9

culpable delay in settlement and disbursement of pension and gratuity must be visited with the penalty of payment of interest at the market rate.

13. It is relevant to note that in the case of employees governed by Payment of Gratuity Act, 1972 the right to get interest on delayed payment of gratuity is statutorily protected by Section 7(3A) of the Act. Under the said provision, if the amount of gratuity is not paid by the employer within the period stipulated under sub- section (3) the employer shall be liable to pay simple interest at such rate, not exceeding the rate notified by the Central Government from time to time for repayment of long term deposits.

14. In our view principles of equity also justify payment of interest in cases of this nature. By operation of law, right of an employee to receive DCRG crystallises on retirement. When gratuity is withheld for the reason that any disciplinary pro- ceedings/criminal proceedings are pending, the Government is deferring enjoyment of the statutory entitlement by the employee till the conclusion of such proceedings. The objective is to recover loss if any suffered by the Government depending upon the outcome of such proceedings. In the end, if the retired employee is absolved in the disciplinary proceedings or acquitted in the criminal proceedings the Government have to pay the entire amount. During the interregnum, it is to be presumed that the Government is holding the amount in trust. The employee is denied the benefit of the amount which is actually due to him. On the other hand, the employer Government can meanwhile utilise the sum of money for its purposes, though it is under obligation to restore the same to the retired employee once he egress blemishless in the departmental or criminal proceedings. Even when this situation is analysed solely on the basis of principles of equity, we are of the view that such restoration without an element of compensation would not do justice to the employee. This is for the reason that a trustee who utilises the amount held in trust for his purposes is liable to restore

10

the same to the beneficiary with an element of compensation usually by way of interest or a part of the profits earned out of utilization by the trustee. Therefore, we find that the claim regarding interest made by the applicant is justified on equitable considerations also."

9. We are of the view that the aforementioned dictum is clearly applicable to this case and therefore the finding of fact and law arrived at by the Tribunal in awarding the interest at the prevailing GPF rate is perfectly correct appreciation of law and does not warrant any interference in the absence of any material irregularity. The petitioners are directed to pay the interest, within a period of two months, from receipt of the certified copy of this judgment.

The OP(CAT) stands dismissed.

Sd/-

AMIT RAWAL

JUDGE

Sd/-

K. V. JAYAKUMAR

JUDGE

msp

11

APPENDIX OF OP (CAT) 38/2017

PETITIONER ANNEXURES

ANNEXURE A1 TRUE COPY OF THE LETTER NO.27-97/2014 -

PEN DATED 16.12.2014 ISSUED BY THE 2ND

RESPONDENT.

ANNEXURE A2 TRUE COPY OF THE ORDER DATED 22.05.2013

OF THE CAT, ERNAKULAM OA NO.1028/2011.

ANNEXURE A3 TRUE COPY OF THE ORDER NO.14-1/2008-VIG

DATED 17.10.2013 ISSUED ON BEHALF OF THE

1ST RESPONDENT.

ANNEXURE A4 TRUE COPY OF THE OM NO.F7(1)-PU/79 DATED 11.07.1979 AND NO.1(4)/PEN. UNIT/82

DATED 10.01.1983 ISSUED BY THE DOPT.

ANNEXURE A5 TRUE COPY OF THE REPRESENTATION DATED

06.05.2014 SUBMITTED BEFORE THE 1ST

RESPONDENT.

ANNEXURE A6 TRUE COPY OF THE JUDGMENT DATED

30.06.2014 OF THE HON'BLE HIGH COURT OF KERALA IN OP(CAT)NO.39/2014.

ANNEXURE A7 TRUE COPY OF THE JUDGMENT DATED

19.01.2015 OF THE HON'BLE HIGH COURT OF KERALA IN CCC NO.1215/2014.

ANNEXURE R1(A) TRUE COPY OF DIRECTORATE LETTER NO.99- 97/2014-PEN DATED 10.02.2015.

ANNEXURE R1(B) TRUE COPY OF DEPARTMENT OF PENSION AND

PENSIONER'S WELFARE OM NO.F-7/1/93-

P&PW(F) DATED 25.08.1994.

ANNEXURE R1(C) TRUE COPY OF EXTRACT OF THE RELEVANT

PORTION OF OM NO.7/20/89/P&PW DATED

22.01.1991 OF THE DEPARTMENT OF PENSION

AND PENSIONERS' WELFARE.

12

EXHIBIT P1 TRUE COPY OF THE O.A.NO.180/000311/2015

DATED 21/03/2015, FILED BY THE RESPONDENT DATED 21/03/2015.

EXHIBIT P3 TRUE COPY OF THE REJOINDER DATED

06/11/2015, FILED BY THE APPLICANT.

EXHIBIT P4 TRUE COPY OF THE ADDITIONAL REPLY

STATEMENT DATED 01/01/2016, FILED BY THE

PETITIONERS.

EXHIBIT P5 TRUE COPY OF THE ADDITIONAL REJOINDER

DATED 20/01/2016 FILED BY THE

RESPONDENT.

EXHIBIT P6 TRUE COPY OF THE 2ND ADDITIONAL REPLY

STATEMENT DATED 04/03/2016 FILED BY THE

PETITIONERS.

EXHIBIT P7 TRUE COPY OF THE ORDER IN

OA.NO.180/311/2016 DATED 17/05/2016 OF

THE CENTRAL ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL,

ERNAKULAM BENCH.

EXHIBIT P2 TRUE COPY OF THE REPLY STATEMENT DATED

22/09/2015 FILED BY THE PETITIONERS.