- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
STATE OF KARNATAKA, v. GURUBASAVARAJ
- 1 -
NC: 2024:KHC-D:2078 CRL.A No. 100330 of 2016
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA, DHARWAD BENCH
DATED THIS THE 30TH DAY OF JANUARY, 2024
BEFORE
THE HON'BLE MR JUSTICE RAJESH RAI K
CRIMINAL APPEAL NO. 100330 OF 2016 (A)
BETWEEN:
STATE OF KARNATAKA,
REPRESENTED BY THE
SUB INSPECTOR OF POLICE,
KANA HOSAHALLI POLICE STATION,
KUDLIGI, BALLARI DISTRICT,
THROUGH THE ADDL. STATE PUBLIC PROSECUTOR,
ADVOCATE GENERAL OFFICE,
HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA, DHARWAD BENCH.
…APPELLANT
(BY SRI. M.B. GUNDAWADE, ADDL. SPP)
AND:
1. GURUBASAVARAJ S/O. HANUMANTHAPPA,
AGED ABOUT 27 YEARS,
R/O: KYASANAKEREI VILLAGE,
KUDLIGI TALUK, BALLARI DISTRICT.
2. HANUMANTHAPPA S/O. DASAPPA,
AGED ABOUT 60 YEARS,
R/O: KYASANAKEREI VILLAGE,
KUDLIGI TALUK, BALLARI DISTRICT.
3. GOURAMMA W/O. HANUMANTHAPPA,
AGED ABOUT 40 YEARS,
R/O: KYASANAKEREI VILLAGE,
KUDLIGI TALUK, BALLARI DISTRICT.
…RESPONDENTS
(BY SRI. RANJITAREDDY NAIK AND SRI KUSHAL N. KAMBLE,
ADVOCATES FOR R1 AND R3; APPEAL ABATED AGAINST R2) THIS CRIMINAL APPEAL IS FILED UNDER SECTION 378 (1) &
(3) OF CR.P.C., PRAYING TO GRANT SPECIAL LEAVE TO APPEAL AND
TO SET ASIDE THE JUDGMENT AND ORDER OF ACQUITTAL
DATED:05.07.2016 PASSED BY THE LEARNED III ADDITIONAL
DISTRICT AND SESSIONS JUDGE, BALLARI (SITTING AT HOSAPETE)
IN SESSION CASE NO.5064 OF 2014 AND TO CONVICT THE
RESPONDENT/ACCUSED FOR THE OFFENCE PUNISHABLE UNDER
SECTION 306 READ WITH 34 OF IPC. IN THE INTEREST OF JUSTICE
AND EQUITY.
- 2 -
THIS APPEAL, COMING ON FOR FINAL HEARING, THIS DAY,
THE COURT DELIVERED THE FOLLOWING:
JUDGMENT
The State has preferred this appeal against the acquittal judgment passed in SC No.5064/2014 dated 05.07.2016 by the III Additional District and Sessions Judge, Ballari, (sitting at Hosapete), wherein, the learned Sessions Judge, acquitted the accused/ respondent Nos.1 to 3 for the offences punishable under Section 306 r/w Section 34 of IPC.
2. The factual matrix of the prosecution case in brief are that:
The deceased-Sakamma is the daughter of PW.1- Marappa and wife of the accused No.1/ respondent No.1. The deceased-Sakamma fell in love with the accused No.1/ respondent No.1 and they both got married three years prior to the date of incident i.e., on 06.12.2013, at Anjineya Temple of Thirthahalli. Thereafter, the parents of the accused No.1 i.e, accused Nos.2 and 3/ respondent
- 3 -
Nos.2 and 3 disliked the deceased as she married the accused No.1 without their consent and thereby instigated the accused No.1 i.e., their son to ill-treat the deceased and all the accused subjected her to cruelty by harassing her mentally and physically. On 06.12.2013 at about 8:00 am, the accused picked up a quarrel with the deceased- Sakamma at Kyasanakere village and the deceased being fed up with the ill-treatment given by the accused Nos.2 and 3, committed suicide by hanging herself to the roof of her house at Kyasanakere village in between 9:00 am to 10:00 am. The said aspect was informed by the brother of accused No.1 namely one Hanumantappa-PW.4 through phone to PW.1. Hence, PW.1- Marappa, father of the deceased, rushed to the house of her daughter and on witnessing the incident that has turned out to be traumatic, he lodged a complaint against the accused persons before the respondent/ Police as per Ex.P.1 which was registered in Crime No.140/2013 dated 07.12.2013 for the offence punishable under Section 306 r/w Section 34 of IPC against the accused Nos.1 to 3 as per Ex.P.7.
- 4 -
Subsequently, the PW.16-Nagaraj, ASI, who conducted the investigation and CW.25 laid the chargesheet against the accused for the offence punishable under Section 306 r/w Section 34 of IPC before the committal Court.
3. After committal of the case before the Sessions Court, the learned Sessions Judge framed the charges against the accused for the aforesaid offences and read over the same to the accused. However, the accused denied the same and claimed to be tried.
4. In order to prove the charges leveled against the accused before the trial Court, the prosecution in total has examined 16 witnesses as PW.1 to 16 and got marked 7 documents at Ex.P.1 to 7 and also got identified one material object at MO.1.
5. After the completion of the prosecution evidence, the learned Sessions Judge read over the incriminating portion of the evidence of the material witnesses to the accused as per Section 313 of Cr.P.C. The accused denied the same. However, the accused did not
- 5 -
choose to examine any witness on their behalf and got marked one document i.e., Ex.D.1-the portion of the statement of PW.9.
6. After assessment of the oral and documentary evidence placed before the learned Sessions Judge, the learned Sessions Judge acquitted the accused for the charges leveled against them in the impugned judgment and the same is challenged under this appeal by the State.
7. Heard the learned Additional State Public Prosecutor Sri. M.B.Gundawade for the appellant/ State, so also, the learned counsel Smt. Ranjita reddy Naik and Sri. Kushal N. Kamble for the respondents/ accused.
8. Learned Additional State Public Prosecutor vehemently contends that the judgment under this appeal suffers from perversity and illegality. The learned Sessions Judge acquitted the accused without going through the evidence of material witnesses i.e., PW.1-the father of the victim, PW.4 -the brother of PW.1 and uncle of the deceased and also PW.5-the mother of the deceased. All
- 6 -
these witnesses have categorically deposed in their evidence about the ill-treatment committed by the accused Nos.1 to 3 against the deceased-Sakamma for the reason that she got married with the accused No.1 without the consent of accused Nos.2 and 3. The learned Additional State Public Prosecutor would also contend that the other material witnesses i.e., PWs.1, 2, 4, 6 and 8 have supported the case of the prosecution.
9. He would further vehemence his submission that, on conjoint reading of all these material witnesses who have supported the case of prosecution, the prosecution has clearly made out a case for the offence punishable under Section 306 r/w Section 34 of IPC against the accused. In spite of the same, the learned Sessions Judge acquitted the accused for the charges leveled against them.
10. He would further contend that admittedly, the incident caused in the matrimonial house of deceased i.e., in the house of accused No.1. The incident is well within
- 7 -
the knowledge of the accused No.1. As such, an inference can be drawn against the accused under the provisions of Section 106 of the Indian Evidence Act. In case, the accused failed to offer any explanation for the alleged suicidal death of his wife, then the Court can draw a presumption against the accused. As such, he would contend that the learned Sessions Judge totally erred by acquitting the accused for the charges leveled against them. Accordingly, he prays to allow the appeal and to convict the accused for the charges leveled against them.
11. Per contra, the learned counsel for the respondents/accused vehemently contend that, the learned Sessions Judge passed the impugned judgment after meticulously examining the evidence and documents available on record. The said well reasoned judgment of the trial Court does not call for any interference. He would further contend that though the father, mother and uncle of the deceased supported the case of the prosecution, none of them deposed about the specific and continuous
- 8 -
harassment meted out by the accused to the deceased. Nevertheless, the PWs.1 and 5 in their evidence categorically admitted that the accused Nos.2 and 3 being the parents of the accused No.1 were residing separately. In such circumstances, there is no reason or occasion to accused Nos.2 and 3 to harass the deceased either physically or mentally.
12. Further, the learned counsel would also contend that, on perusal of the evidence of PWs.1 and 5, they deposed that the accused No.1 and their daughter were residing cordially till 1 day prior to the incident. Thereafter, they came to know about the death of the deceased in the matrimonial home. There is no such evidence in respect of the harassment meted out by the accused Nos.1 to 3 to the deceased to drive her to commit suicide. He also submits that respondent No.2/accused No.2 is no more and he died during the pendency of the case. Hence, this Court passed an order of abatement
- 9 -
against the accused No.2 on 28.05.2018. Accordingly, he prays to dismiss the appeal.
13. Having heard the learned Additional State Public Prosecutor Sri. M.B.Gundawade for the appellant/ State, so also, the learned counsel Smt. Ranjitareddy Naik and Sri. Kushal N. Kambe for the respondent/ accused. The only Point that would arise for my consideration is that:
1. Whether the judgment under this appeal suffers from any perversity or illegality?
14. This Court being the appellate Court, on careful perusal of the evidence adduced by the prosecution before the trial Court, I find;
PW.1-Mareppa, father of deceased-Sakamma, re- iterating the contents of his complaint-Ex.P.1, deposed that his daughter Sakamma was performed in marriage due to the relationship of love among them, to the deceased and thereafter, they both were residing
- 10 -
separately. After seven months, she came to his house and returned post giving birth to a child, to her husband's house. Thereafter, the accused started to harass her both physically and mentally. He also deposed that, 10 days prior to the date of incident, the accused No.1 and the deceased came along with him for coolie work at Mavinakatti near Dharmasthala and on 05.12.2013 the accused No.1 and the deceased left to Kukke- Subramanya. Later, on the next day, he received the telephonic message that his daughter has committed the suicide in the house of the accused. Hence, on hearing the same, he rushed to the house of the accused and on witnessing the scene, traumatized, he lodged the complaint as per Ex.P.1 before the jurisdictional Police. PW.2-S.Yallappa, witness for the Inquest Panchnama as per Ex.P.2. PW.3-Hanumakka is also a witness for Ex.P.3-Spot Panchnama.
PW.4-Hanumanthappa-uncle of the deceased, deposed that, accused Nos.1 to 3 used to harass the
- 11 -
deceased in the matrimonial home and compel her to seek Dowry. Hence, as such, the deceased committed suicide in the matrimonial home. Thereafter, He along with PW.1 and 5 visited the spot.
PW.5-Marekka-mother of deceased and wife of PW.1, she is an hearsay witness to the case, she reiterated the version of her husband PW.1 about the harassment meted out by the accused persons to the deceased, post she giving birth to a child.
PW.6-Nagarathnamma-native of Kyasanakere village, where the accused No.1 and the deceased were residing. Though, she is a circumstantial witness in respect of the strained relationship of the accused No.1 and the deceased and she turned hostile to the prosecution case. PW.7-H.Kotresh-witness for Spot Mahazar Ex.P.4. However, he turned hostile to the prosecution case. PW.8 -Gurubasavaraj, uncle of the deceased, he is also a hearsay witness, according to him, the parents of
- 12 -
the deceased informed him about the ill-treatment given by the accused Nos.1 to 3. He is also the witness for Ex.P.4-Spot Mahazar drawn at suicide place. PW.9-Marthavva-hearsay witness from the native of PW.1, according to her, PW.1 and his wife informed her about the ill-treatment and harassment meted out by the accused Nos.1 to 3 to the deceased-Sakamma. PW.10-M.Nagaraj is a witness for the Spot Mahazar- Ex.P.4, turned hostile to the prosecution case. PW.11-Thimmaiah-cousinf brother of the deceased and he is a hearsay witness deposed about the strained relationship between the accused Nos.1 and deceased- Sakamma and the same was informed to him by the parents of the deceased.
PW.12-Hanumanthappa-step-brother of the accused No.2, this circumstantial witness has turned hostile to the prosecution case.
- 13 -
PW.13-Dr.Pavithra- conducted the autopsy over the dead body and issued the Post-Mortem Report as per Ex.P.6.
PW.14-Jawaregouda, Tahasildar, conducted the Inquest Panchnama on the dead of body of the deceased as per Ex.P.2.
PW.15-Manjunath, the Police constable, carried the FIR to the Jurisdictional Court.
P.W.16-H.Nagaraj, ASI who received the complaint from P.W.1 as per Ex.P.1 and registered the FIR against the accused as per Ex.P.7 and subsequently conducted the investigation by drawing Spot Mahazar-Ex.P4 and also recorded the statement of some of the witnesses. Subsequently, he handed over the investigation to C.W.25 who being the Investigating Officer has not been examined before the trial Court.
15. On perusal of the evidence of the above witnesses, in order to prove the suicidal death of the deceased, the prosecution relied on the evidence of
- 14 -
P.W.13-Doctor, who conducted the Post-Mortem and issued the Report as per Ex.P.6. On perusal of Ex.P.6, the same depicts that the death is due to respiratory failure- hanging as a result of asphyxia. Further, P.W.14-Tahsildar who conducted Inquest Panchanama on the dead body of the deceased opined that the death is due to hanging. Nevertheless, PW.2 and 3, who are Inquest Panchas to Ex.P.2 supported the case of the prosecution. In such circumstances, in my considered view, the prosecution has proved the suicidal death of the deceased in this case.
16. In order to connect the accused in abatement of the suicidal death of the deceased, the prosecution mainly relied on the evidence of PW.1-the father of the deceased, PW.5-the mother of the deceased and PW.4-the uncle of the deceased. On careful perusal of the evidence of PW.1- the father of the deceased, deposed in his evidence that, the deceased-Sakamma after her marriage with the accused No.1, were staying together in a separate house, contrary to the case of the prosecution that accused Nos.1 to 3 were residing together and harassing the deceased in
- 15 -
the matrimonial house, both physically and mentally. This version corroborates with the evidence of PW.5. Further, it is admitted by PW.1 and 5 that the accused No.1 and the deceased-Sakamma were residing in the Shed before the date of incident. According to PW.1 also, 10 days prior to the date of incident, the accused No.1 along with the deceased-Sakamma went to the Dharmasthala for Coolie work with him. At that time, the deceased and accused No.1 were residing together in a Shed and they both were cordial to each other. It is on 05.12.2013, they both left Dharmasthala by informing PW.1 that they will visit the Kukke-Subrahmanya temple and thereafter they proceeded to their native place and on the next day i.e., on 06.12.2013, the alleged incident has occurred.
17. Hence, on perusal of the evidence of PW.1-the father of the deceased and PW.5-the mother, absolutely there are no such allegation is forthcoming that the accused has harassed the deceased which compelled her to commit such act. Per contra, it is the specific case of
- 16 -
the PW.1 and 5 that, they both were in cordial relationship with each other till 05.01.2013 i.e., one day prior to the date of incident. However, the fact that they were residing cordially and the accused himself took her to Dharmasthala and they both were engaged in Coolie work at Dharmasthala post pregnancy and they were there for a period of 15 days and thereafter they returned to their native house would clearly indicate that, post delivery of the child also the accused had taken care of her cordially. Hence, inference cannot be drawn from the evidence of PW.5, that accused has harassed the deceased post returning from her pregnancy.
18. On careful perusal of the PW.1 and 5, absolutely there is no evidence worthwhile is forthcoming to connect the suicidal death of the deceased in this case. Though, the prosecution has relied on the evidence of PW.4-the uncle of the deceased in this case, as he deposed that the deceased informed him about the harassment meted out by the accused, in his cross-
- 17 -
examination he admits that, the relationship between the accused No.1 and the deceased were cordial for about 11 months prior to the date of incident and accused used to come to the house of the deceased. Further, no such call registers were produced by the prosecution to prove that the deceased called PW.4 and informed about the harassment meted out by the accused No.1.
19. Further, the Hon'ble Apex Court in the judgment rendered in the case of Gurucharan Singh Vs. State of Panjab reported in 2020 (10) SCC 200, opined that, the Court in cases of offences alleged under Section 306 of IPC , before holding accused guilty of the charges must ponder upon to meticulously examine the evidences and documents produced before it to draw the inference as to cruelty and harassment meted out by the accused to the deceased before the incident which left out no room but to commit such act on the part of the deceased. The Apex Court has further opined that, it is also to be borne in mind that there must be a proof directly or indirectly
- 18 -
linking the accused to alleged act of abetment which forced the deceased to commit to such act. Apex Court would opine that, no person should be found guilty of the offence merely on the allegations of harassment meted out without there being any positive action proximate to the time of occurrence on the part of the accused which laid or compelled a person to commit the suicide. Hence, conclusively it was opined by the top Court that in the absence of such proofs, offence charged under Section 306 of IPC is not maintainable.
20. In the case on hand, on perusal of the evidence of the parents of the deceased i.e., PW.1 and PW.5, it is evidently clear that the witnesses have not deposed as to the fact that the accused persons have instigated or intentionally aided by acting in a particular manner or committing an illegal omission which would otherwise implicate the commission of the offence, that a person can be said to have been abated in doing that thing. Hence, when such act or omission of abetment itself is not proved
- 19 -
beyond reasonable doubt by the prosecution, the inference cannot be drawn against the accused persons under Section 107 of Indian Penal Code (for short 'IPC'). It is the primary burden of the prosecution to convince this Court, so also to prove beyond reasonable doubt as to the mensrea of the accused persons in committing the act of abetment and in order to prove the abatement as specified under Section 107 of IPC, the state of mind to commit a particular crime must be visible to determine the culpability. In order to prove the mensrea, there has to be something on record to establish or to show that the accused/ respondent No.1 had a guilty mind and in furtherance of the said state of mind, he abated suicide of the deceased. This view is fortified by the finding of this Court in Santhosh Yamanappa Maang vs State of Karnataka reported in 2023 Crl.LJ 3502, wherein paragraph No. 38 of the order reads as under-
"38. Thus, by perusal of the dictum laid down by the Hon'ble Apex Court, it is clear that in order to convict an accused under Section 306 of IPC,
- 20 -
the state of mind to commit the crime must be visible with regard to determining the culpability. There has to be a clear mens rea to commit the offence by the accused. It also requires an active act or direct act which led the deceased to commit suicide, seeing no option and that act must have been intended to push the deceased into such a position that she committed suicide. The person who is said to have committed the abetment must have played an active role by act of instigation or doing certain act to facilitate the commission of suicide."
21. In the case on hand, there is no such evidences are forthcoming to say that that, accused No.1 abated the deceased to commit suicide. Hence, I am of the considered view that the learned Sessions Judge has rightly come to a conclusion that, the prosecution has failed to prove the guilt of the accused for the offence punishable under Section 306 of IPC. Moreover, this is an appeal against the acquittal order passed by the Learned Sessions Judge, the Hon'ble Apex Court in the case of Mahendra Pratap Singh Vs. State of Uttar Pradesh reported in (2009) 1 and 11 SCC 334 opined that if, on perusal of the
- 21 -
evidence and on considering the relevant attending circumstances, it is found that multiple views are possible i.e., one as held by the trial Court for acquitting the accused and the other for convicting the accused, in such a situation the rule of prudence should guide the High Court, not to disturb the acquittal Order made by the trial Court. Unless, the conclusions of the trial Court drawn on the evidence on record are found to be unreasonable and perverse or unsustainable.
22. In the case on hand, there is no such evidence on record is forthcoming to hold that the reasoning recorded by the Learned Sessions Judge is unreasonable, perverse or un-sustainable. The learned Additional State Public Prosecutor would vehemently contend that the accused No.1 and the deceased are residing together in a rented house and the deceased committed suicide in the said house. In such circumstance, the accused has to explain as to circumstances under which she has committed suicide or the reason behind to commit the
- 22 -
suicide by the deceased as contemplated under Section 106 of the Indian Evidence Act and if the accused is failed to explain the said circumstance then the Court can draw a presumption against the accused. However, the Hon'ble Apex Court in the case of Balvir Singh v. State of Uttarakhand, reported in 2023 SCC OnLine SC 1261
held that it is trite law that only after the prosecution discharged its burden proving the case beyond reasonable doubt, the burden would shift on the accused. Section 106 of the Indian Evidence Act, does not intend to relieve the prosecution of it's burden to prove the guilt of the accused beyond reasonable doubt. But, the Section would apply to cases where the prosecution has succeeded in proving the facts for which a reasonable inference can be drawn regarding the existence of certain other facts, unless the accused by virtue of special knowledge regarding such facts failed to offer any explanation which might drive the Court to draw a different inference. In the present case, the prosecution has failed to prove its initial burden by proving the case beyond reasonable doubt by placing
- 23 -
cogent evidence. Since, as discarded supra, the evidence of PWs.1 and 5 i.e., the parents of the deceased and PW.4 i.e., the uncle of the deceased does not inspire the confidence of this Court to prove the charges leveled against the accused, it is for this reason, I am of the considered view that there is no such compelling reason to interfere in the acquittal order passed by the trial Court. Accordingly, I answer the point raised above in the
affirmative and proceed to dismiss the appeal filed by the state being devoid of merits.
Sd/-
JUDGE
PJ,MBS
LIST NO.: 1 SL NO.: 1
Alert