Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

M/s. Mohan Spintex India Limited , v. Commercial Tax Officer,

Andhra Pradesh High Court
Jan 22, 2025
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

Multiple writ petitions were filed by taxpayers (e.g., M/s. Mohan Spintex India Limited) challenging the assessing authorities' refusal to receive certificates in Form 'H' which the petitioners sought to produce after the relevant assessment proceedings had been completed. The petitions rely on earlier Division Bench decisions of this Court and of the erstwhile High Court of Judicature at Hyderabad which, according to petitioners, permit filing of Form 'H' after assessment on parity with Forms 'C' and 'F'. The matter was heard by a Division Bench and considered in light of Rules 12(7) and 12(10)(b) of the Central Sales Tax (R&T) Rules and related State rules.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether certificates in Form 'H' can be received and acted upon by the assessing authority after completion of assessment proceedings.
  2. Whether Rule 12(10)(b) of the CST (R&T) Rules makes the provisions applicable to declaration in Form 'C' mutatis mutandis applicable to certificate in Form 'H' even in the absence of State rules framed in relation to Form 'H'.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioners' Arguments

  • There is no time limit for receipt of Form 'H' and such forms can be filed even after assessment proceedings are completed.
  • Earlier Division Bench judgments of the erstwhile High Court of Judicature at Hyderabad and this Court (including W.P.No.1466 of 2017; W.P.No.16718 of 2019; W.P.No.12450 of 2019; W.P.No.18205 of 2020 and batch) support receipt of Form 'H' on par with Forms 'C' and 'F'.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
W.P.No.1466 of 2017 dated 24.01.2027 Held that Form 'H' should be accepted beyond the period of assessment, similar to acceptance of Forms 'C' & 'F' under Rule 12(7). The Court noted this earlier view as part of the line of decisions petitioners rely on; it recorded the decision but re-examined the statutory basis (Rule 12(10)(b)) for extending Rule 12(7) treatment to Form 'H'.
W.P.No.16718 of 2019 dated 30.10.2019 Applied the decision in M/s. Godrej Agrovet Ltd. to hold that Form 'H' can be received on par with Form 'C'. The Court recorded that this Division Bench followed the earlier decision, but considered whether Rule 12(10)(b) actually permits such parity absent State rules.
W.P.No.12450 of 2019 dated 07.10.2023 Directed receipt of Form 'H' on par with Forms 'C' & 'F'. The Court observed this Direction as part of the consistent line of previous orders and then analysed the statutory text to test its correctness.
W.P.No.18205 of 2020 and batch dated 11.09.2024 Interpreted Rule 12(10)(b) to mean that the terms applicable to production and filing of Form 'C' would mutatis mutandis apply to certificate in Form 'H'. The Court noted this understanding by an earlier Division Bench but scrutinised Rule 12(10)(b) and the existence (or absence) of State rules before accepting that view.
M/s. Godrej Agrovet Ltd., China Pothapally & another vs. Commercial Tax Officer, Eluru & another Interpreted Rule 12(7) -- including its proviso -- to allow Forms 'C'/'F' filed beyond the assessment period to be considered after sufficient cause is shown, and applied that reasoning to allow post-assessment filings to be taken into account for recalculation of tax liability. The Court acknowledged that this precedent applied Rule 12(7)'s proviso to permit post-assessment acceptance of Forms 'C'/'F'; it examined whether the same reasoning extends to Form 'H' via Rule 12(10)(b) and concluded that extension depends on State rules for Form 'H'.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court examined the textual differences between Rule 12(7) and Rule 12(10)(b) of the CST (R&T) Rules. Rule 12(7) expressly permits the prescribed authority to allow filing of Forms 'C' or 'F' beyond the three-month period where sufficient cause is shown (proviso), and earlier decisions applied that proviso to accept post-assessment Forms 'C'/'F' (as in M/s. Godrej Agrovet Ltd.).

By contrast, Rule 12(10)(b) provides that rules framed by State Governments concerning Form 'H' shall, so far as they apply to declaration in Form 'C' under these rules, mutatis mutandis apply to certificate in Form 'H'. The Court observed that Rule 12(10)(b) is triggered only if the State Government frames rules relating to Form 'H'.

Since the State of Andhra Pradesh has framed Central Sales Tax (Andhra Pradesh) Rules, 1957, but those rules do not provide for filing of Form 'H', Rule 12(10)(b) does not operate. Therefore, the Court concluded that the earlier view equating the filing regime of Form 'H' with Forms 'C'/'F' (i.e., permitting post-assessment filing by mutatis mutandis application) lacks a statutory foundation in the absence of State rules for Form 'H'.

The Court identified the logical consequence that filing of Form 'H' would not be mutatis mutandis with filing of Forms 'C' and 'F' unless and until State rules are made applicable under Rule 12(10)(b). Given the existence of earlier co-ordinate Division Bench decisions taking a different view, the Court considered it appropriate to place the matter before the Chief Justice for reference to a Full Bench.

Holding and Implications

The Court held that Rule 12(10)(b) becomes applicable only when the State Government frames rules in relation to Form 'H'; in the absence of such State rules, Rule 12(10)(b) does not come into play, and therefore filing of Form 'H' is not mutatis mutandis with filing of Forms 'C' and 'F'.

Implications: As a direct effect, the court concluded that there is no statutory basis to accept Form 'H' after assessment on the same footing as Forms 'C'/'F' unless State rules for Form 'H' are in place. Because there are earlier co-ordinate Division Bench decisions adopting the contrary position, the Court directed that the matter be placed before the Hon'ble Chief Justice for reference to a Full Bench to resolve the conflict. No new precedent beyond this interpretation and the referral was declared.

Show all summary ...

1

APHC010920822017

IN THE HIGH COURT OF ANDHRA PRADESH

AT AMARAVATI

(Special Original Jurisdiction)

[3508]

WEDNESDAY ,THE TWENTY SECOND DAY OF JANUARY

TWO THOUSAND AND TWENTY FIVE

PRESENT

THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE R RAGHUNANDAN RAO

THE HONOURABLE SRI JUSTICE MAHESWARA RAO KUNCHEAM

WRIT PETITION NOs: 7158/2018,10587/2016, 2514/2020, 6480/2020, 6597/2020, 3111/2021, 40351/2022, 40354/2022, 23960/2023 & 29854 of

2024

W.P.No.7158 of 2018 Between:

M/s. Mohan Spintex India Limited , ...PETITIONER

AND

Commercial Tax Officer and Others ...RESPONDENT(S) Counsel for the Petitioner:

1. SRINIVASA RAO KUDUPUDI

Counsel for the Respondent(S):

1. GP FOR COMMERCIAL TAX (AP)

The Court made the following order:

Heard Sri K.A. Siva Vara Prasad, Sri Kudupudi Srinivasa Rao, Sri G. Narendra Chetty and Sri SAV. Sai Kumar, the learned Assistant Government Pleader for Commercial taxes.

2

2. In all these cases, the petitioners have approached this Court being aggrieved by the refusal of the assessing authorities to receive 'H' Forms that were sought to be produce after the assessment proceedings had been completed.

3. The petitioners contend that there is no time limit for receipt of 'H' Forms, and that such 'H' Forms can be filed even after the assessment proceedings have been completed, in view of the Judgments of the erstwhile High Court of Judicature at Hyderabad for the State of Telangana and the State of Andhra Pradesh and this Court in W.P.No.1466 of 2017 dated 24.01.2027, W.P.No.16718 of 2019 dated 30.10.2019, W.P.No.12450 of 2019 dated 07.10.2023 and W.P.No.18205 of 2020 and batch dated 11.09.2024.

4. In all these Judgments, the Division Bench, in each case, had taken the view that the Judgment of the erstwhile High Court of Judicature at Hyderabad for the State of Telangana and the State of Andhra Pradesh in the case of M/s. Godrej Agrovet Ltd., China Pothapally & another vs. Commercial Tax Officer, Eluru & another1, relating to 'C'&'F' forms and the time within the such 'C'&'F' Forms can be filed would apply to the production and filing of 'H' Forms also.

5. In W.P.No.1466 of 2017, a Division Bench of the erstwhile High Court of Judicature at Hyderabad for the State of Telangana and the State of Andhra Pradesh had held that 'H' Forms also should be accepted beyond the

(2007) 007 VST 0730

1

3

period of assessment, as 'C' & 'F' Forms were being accepted in this manner by virtue of Rule 12(7) of the Central Sales Tax (R&T) Rules.

6. A Division Bench of this Court, by an order dated 07.10.2023, in W.P.No.12450 of 2019, following the said Judgment, had directed the receipt of 'H' Forms, on par with 'C & F' Forms.

7. Another Division Bench of this Court, by an order, dated 30.10.2019, in W.P.No.16718 of 2019, following the Judgment in W.P.No.1466 of 2017, and applying the decision of M/s. Godrej Agrovet Ltd., China Pothapally & another vs. Commercial Tax Officer, Eluru & another

had held that 'H' Forms can be received, on par with 'C' Forms.

8. Another Division Bench of this Court, (in which one of us RRR,J was a member) had held that Rule 12(10)(b) of the CST (R&T) Rules stipulated that the terms applicable to production and filing of Form 'C' would mutatis mutandis apply to certificate in Form 'H'.

Rule 12(7) and Rule 12(10) of the CST (RNT) Rules read as follows:

Rule 12(7):

The declaration in Form 'C' or Form 'F' or the certificate in Form 'E-1' or Form 'E-II' shall be furnished to the prescribed authority within three months after the end of the period to which the declaration or the certificate relates :

Provided that if the prescribed authority is satisfied that the person concerned was prevented by sufficient cause from furnishing such declaration or certificate within the aforesaid time, that authority may allow

4

such declaration or certificate to be furnished within such further time as that authority may permit.

Rule 12(10)(b):

The provisions of the rules framed by the respective State Governments under sub-sections (3), (4) and (5) of Section 13 relating to the authority from whom and the conditions subject to which any form of certificate in Form 'H' may be obtained, the manner in which such form shall be kept in custody and records relating thereto maintained and the manner in which any such forms may be used and any such certificate may be furnished in so far as they apply to declaration in Form 'C' prescribed under these rules shall mutatis mutandia apply to certificate in Form 'H'.

9. Rule 12(7) states that 'C' forms or 'F' forms would have to be filed, before the prescribed authority, within three months after the end of the period to which the declaration or the certificate relates. However, the proviso to Rule 12(7) states that the prescribed authority could permit processing or filing of such declaration or certificate beyond the time set out in Rule 12(7), if sufficient cause is made out as to why the forms could not be filed within time. Interpreting this provision, a Division Bench of the erstwhile High Court of Judicature at Hyderabad for the State of Telangana and the State of Andhra Pradesh in M/s. Godrej Agrovet Ltd., China Pothapally & another vs. Commercial Tax Officer, Eluru & another had taken the view that the proviso extends the time for filing of Form 'C' or Form 'F', beyond the date of assessment and that the said forms could be taken into account, after due cause is shown, for the purpose of recalculating the tax liability arising out of the assessment order.

5

10. Under Rule 12(10) the declaration in Form 'H' can be furnished to the prescribed authority only up to the time of assessment by the first assessing authority. There is no proviso to this provision, akin to Rule 12(7) of the Rules. This would mean that the time frame set out under Rule 12(10) is absolute and there is no leeway for grant of any further time by the authority.

11. Rule 12(10)(b), which has already been extracted above, was understood by the earlier Division Bench in W.P.No.18205 of 2020 and batch to mean that the furnishing of declaration in Form 'H' can be done in the manner in which a declaration under Form 'C' can be filed even beyond the time of assessment.

12. However, a closer look at Rule 12(10)(b) shows that the said view may not be correct. Rule 12(10)(b) states that if any rules are made by the respective State Governments, relating to the filing of Form 'H', then the rules as they applied to the declaration in Form 'C', prescribed under the CST (R&T) Rules, would mutatis mutandia apply to filing of a certificate in Form 'H'.

13. The State of Andhra Pradesh has framed rules under the provisions of Section 13 titled Central Sales Tax (Andhra Pradesh) Rule, 1957. These rules do not provide for filing of Form 'H'. In the view of this Court, Rule 10 (b) would become applicable only when the State Government frames rules in relation to Form 'H'. In the absence of such rules, the provisions of Rule 12(10)(b) would not come into play.

6

14. The logical consequence of this interpretation would be that filing of Form 'H' would not be mutatis mutandia with the filing of Form 'C' and 'F'.

1 5. In view of the earlier Judgments of the Division Benches of this Court which are co-ordinate with this bench, it would only be appropriate that the matter is placed before the Hon'ble The Chief Justice for reference to a Full Bench to resolve this issue. _______________________ R RAGHUNANDAN RAO,J ______________________________________ MAHESWARA RAO KUNCHEAM,J RJS