Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

BINDIYA KHATRI v. STATE OF UTTARAKHAND

Uttarakhand High Court
Jan 8, 2025

2025:UHC:344

I N THE HI GH COURT OF UTTARAKHAND

AT NAI NI TAL

SHRI JUSTI CE MANOJ KUMAR TI W ARI

W rit Pet it ion ( M/ S) No.5 1 3 of 2 0 2 0

8 TH JANUARY, 2 0 2 5

Bindiya Khat r i and others. …Pet it ioners

Versus

State of Ut tarakhand & others. ….Respondents

W ith W rit Pet it ion ( M/ S) No. 6 2 7 of 2 0 2 0 W rit Pet it ion ( M/ S) No. 8 9 0 of 2 0 2 0 W rit Pet it ion ( M/ S) No. 9 0 0 of 2 0 2 0 W rit Pet it ion ( M/ S) No. 9 1 4 of 2 0 2 0 W rit Pet it ion ( M/ S) No. 2 1 0 0 of 2 0 2 0 W rit Pet it ion ( M/ S) No. 8 9 8 of 2 0 2 2 W rit Pet it ion ( M/ S) No. 2 0 3 9 of 2 0 2 2 W rit Pet it ion ( M/ S) No. 3 4 3 6 of 2 0 2 2 W rit Pet it ion ( M/ S) No. 2 8 9 2 of 2 0 2 3 W rit Pet it ion ( M/ S) No. 5 7 6 of 2 0 2 4

Counsel for the pet it ioners: Mr. Abhijay Negi, Mr. Vinod Tiwari and Ms. Snigdha Tiwari, learned counsel.

Counsel for the respondents: Mr. Yogesh Chandra Tiwari, Standing Counsel for the State of Ut tarakhand

Mr. Sandeep Kothari, Advocate for

Ut tarakhand Ayurvedic Universit y.

Mr. Vipul Sharm a, Advocate for Dev

Bhoom i Medical College of Ayurveda &

Hospital.

Mr. Navneet Kaushik, Advocate for Om

Group of College, Ayurvedic Medical

College & Hospital and Research Cent re.

Mr. Aditya Pratap Singh, Advocate for

Motherhood Ayurved Medical College.

JUDGMENT

Pet it ioners are students of B.A.M.S. Course, who took admission in different Ayurvedic Colleges within State of Ut tarakhand, during Academic Year

1

2017-18 and 2018-19. According to them , a college can charge only such fee, as is determ ined by the Fee Regulatory Comm it tee and the determ inat ion of fee m ade by Regulatory Com mit tee can only be applied prospect ively, however, in their case, the colleges charged certain am ount as fee in the absence of determ inat ion by the Fee Regulatory Com mit tee, and thereafter, a provisional determ inat ion of fee m ade by the Regulatory Commit tee in its meet ing held on 29.04.2019 was ret rospect ively m ade applicable from the Academic Year 2017-18, which is not perm issible.

2. Since comm on quest ions of law and fact are involved in these writ pet it ions, therefore they are heard together and are being decided by a com m on judgment . However, for the sake of brevity, facts of Writ Pet it ion (M/ S) No.513 of 2020 alone are being considered and discussed.

3. The reliefs sought in Writ Pet it ion (M/ S) No.513 of 2020 are as follows:

"a) I ssue a writ , order or direct ion in the nature of Cert iorar i to quash the order dated 31.01.2020 vide which a decision was taken by two members of a three member commit tee to convene meet ing in the absence of the judicial member.

b) I ssue a writ , order or direct ion in the nature of Cert iorar i to quash the decision taken by two members of the Appellate Authorit y as ult ra v ires the Const itut ion and against the let ter and spir it of the judgements of the Honourable High Court .

c) I ssue a writ , order or direct ion in the nature of Mandamus direct ing the private educat ional inst itut ions to charge fee as last duly approved by the Fee Regulatory Commit tee at Rs. 80,500/ - from the students of these private educat ional inst itut ions."

2

4. Pet it ioners in Writ Pet it ion (M/ S) No. 513 of 2020 took admission in Doon I nst itute of Medical Sciences, Sahaspur, Dist r ict Dehradun in the Academic Session 2017-2018; in fact , pet it ioners were in the first batch of students, as the said college started in the sam e year. Pursuant to judgm ent rendered by Hon'ble Suprem e Court in the case of I slam ic Academ y of Educat ion and another v. State of Karnatak and others, (2003) 6 SCC 697, State Legislature enacted the Ut tarakhand Unaided Private Professional Educat ional I nst itut ions (Regulat ion of Admission and Fixat ion of Fee) Act , 2006 (hereinafter referred to as 'Act ') . The said Act applies to all Unaided Private Professional Educat ional I nst itut ions. Sect ion 4 of the said Act provides for a Fee Regulatory Commit tee. Sect ion 4(12) of the said Act ordains that the com mit tee shall determ ine the fee for admission to Private Professional Educat ional I nst itut ions.

5. A conjoint reading of sub-sect ions (12) (13) & (14) of Sect ion of 4 of the Act would reveal that every private inst itut ion is under the duty to place before the com mit tee the proposed fee st ructure before com mencement of an academic year, with all relevant documents and books of accounts, for determ inat ion of fee. Sub-sect ion (14) , however, provides that fee once determ ined, shall be applicable for a period of three years, and upon expiry of three years, the inst itut ion would be at liberty to apply for revision of fee, however, there is a r ider in sub-sect ion (14) that fee determ ined, shall be applicable to a student , who takes

3

admission in that academic year and the fee, which was applicable at the t im e of admission of a student shall not be revised t ill com plet ion of his / her course of study. Sub-sect ions (12) (13) & (14) of Sect ion of 4 of the Act are ext racted below for ready reference: -

" (12) The Commit tee shall determ ine the fees for adm ission to professional courses of pr ivate inst itut ions.

(13) Before the commencement of the academ ic year, it shall be compulsory for every pr ivate inst itut ion to place before the commit tee the proposed fee st ructure of professional courses with all relevant documents and books of accounts for determ inat ion of fees. The commit tee after consider ing all the documents placed before it , shall determ ine the fee within one month m aximum.

I n case the proposal for fixat ion of fee for professional courses is not placed before the commit tee, the pr ivate inst itut ion shall not run the course. Therefore the pr ivate inst itut ion shall not give adm ission in such course.

(14) The fee determ ined by the com mit tee shall be applicable on the pr ivate inst itut ion for a per iod of three years. After the expiry of the per iod of three years, the inst itut ion would be at liberty to apply for revision. The fee so determ ined shall be applicable to a candidate who is adm it ted to an inst itut ion in that academ ic year and that fees shall not be revised t ill the complet ion of his/ her course in the said pr ivate inst itut ion."

6. Sect ion 12 of the aforesaid Act provides for an Appellate Authority, which shall hear appeals against the order of Fee Regulatory Com mit tee. According to the pet it ioners, the Fee Regulatory Com mit tee had last determ ined the fee in the year 2007, and thereafter, the quest ion of fee determ inat ion was never taken to the Fee Regulatory Commit tee. Thus, it is contended on behalf of the pet it ioners that in view of the fee determ inat ion made by the Comm it tee in 2007, they were liable to pay ₹80,500/ - as fee. I t is further

4

contended that the fee determ ined in 2007 was in respect of all Ayurvedic Colleges within Ut tarakhand.

7. According to the pet it ioners, on the request of Ayurvedic Colleges, State Government issued a Government Order dated 14.10.2015, whereby the tuit ion fee payable by students of B.A.M.S. Course in different Ayurvedic Colleges was increased from ₹80,500/ - to ₹2,15,000/- without reference to the Fee Regulator Com mit tee const ituted under Sect ion 4 of the aforesaid Act . I t is contended that State Governm ent could not unilaterally have ordered upward revision of fee by the said Government Order. The said Government Order was challenged before this Court and by a judgment dated 09.07.2018 rendered in Writ Pet it ion (M/ S) No. 1849 of 2017 and other connected pet it ions, the said order was set aside.

8. I t is contended that despite the said judgment , students of Ayurvedic Colleges were illegally made to pay ₹2,15,000/- as tuit ion fee, without placing the m at ter before the Fee Regulatory Commit tee. Thus, it is contended that the act of the colleges of charging fee in excess and the fee determ ined by Fee Regulatory Commit tee is illegal and is liable to be refunded to the students.

9. I n this writ pet it ion, pet it ioners have challenged the order dated 31.01.2020 passed by the Appellate Authority. By the said order, the decision taken by Fee Regulatory Com mit tee in its meet ing held on 29.04.2019 was m ade applicable to the students of

5

Academic Session 2017-18. I t is contended on behalf of the pet it ioners that the enhanced fee, as determ ined by the Fee Regulatory Commit tee can be m ade applicable only prospect ively and the students, who took admission in preceding years cannot be asked to pay the enhanced fee, as was determ ined in subsequent years. I t is further contended that from the m inutes of the meet ing of the Fee Regulatory Commit tee held on 29.04.2019 (Annexure-2 to the writ pet it ion) , it is revealed that the fee determ ined by the Com mit tee in the said meet ing was only provisional and not final, therefore, such provisional fee could not have been m ade applicable, with ret rospect ive effect by the Appellate Authority. I n support of the content ion that fee determ ined by the commit tee was only provisional, learned counsel for the pet it ioners has drawn at tent ion of this Court to Annexure-2 to the writ pet it ion, relevant ext ract whereof is ext racted below: -

"After hearing all concerned including President of the Associat ion, Director Ayush, Secretary Ayush and Chartered Accountant , the Commit tee unanimously decided to fix inter im fee for sessions 2019-20, 2020-21 and 2021-22 as follows: -

a) BAMS - Rs. 2.15 lac per annum

b) BHMS - Rs. 1.10 lac per annum

c) MD/ MS (Ayurved) - Rs. 3.15 lac per annum The inst itut ions will inform the above fees in writ ing to the students along with the r ider that if the final fees fixed by the commit tee is less, the difference will be refunded to them and if it is more the difference will be charged from them addit ionally. This is being done as an inter im arrangement as the academic session is due to start very soon. Moreover, it has been brought to the not ice of the commit tee that proposals received from the inst itut ions are not complete in all respects. Associat ion is directed to get the shortcom ings in the proposals rect if ied by the concerned indiv idual inst itut ions and get the proposals submit ted to Director Ayush within a week.

6

The subcommit tee const ituted earlier and comprising of Director Ayush, Chartered Accountant and subject specialist will exam ine the above proposals and submit their recommendat ions to the commit tee at the ear liest . Put up on 13 May, 2019."

10. Learned counsel for the pet it ioners submits that the Fee Regulatory Commit tee had determ ined the interim fee for Academic Sessions 2019-20, 2020-21 and 2021-22 as per provision contained in Sect ion 4(14) of the aforesaid Act , however, the Appellate Authority illegally took a decision to m ake the revised fee applicable, even to students of Academic Sessions 2017-18 and 2018-19. Thus, it is contended that the Appellate Authority's order dated 31.01.2020 is liable to be set aside to the aforesaid extent .

11. At tent ion of this Court is also drawn to the provision contained in Sect ion 5(2) of the aforesaid Act , which provides that no professional educat ional inst itut ion shall collect any fee over and above the fee determ ined by the Com mit tee. I t is contended that the fee determ ined by the Commit tee was for Academic Sessions 2019-20, 2020-21 and 2021-22, therefore, the decision to apply the said fee determ inat ion, to earlier academic years, is unsustainable.

12. Learned counsel for respondents, however, supported the order passed by Appellate Authority on 31.01.2020 and submit ted that since fee st ructure of Ayurvedic Colleges was not revised for a considerable t im e and the colleges concerned were facing it difficult to m eet the expenditure, therefore, on the prayer of the concerned colleges, Appellate Authority r ight ly

7

decided to apply the revised fee st ructure from Academic Session 2017-18.

13. I t is not in dispute that after enforcem ent of the Act , decision regarding fee st ructure of an aided private professional educat ional inst itut ion has to be taken by the Fee Regulatory Commit tee alone and neither the m anagement of the college nor the State Government can decide the fee st ructure unilaterally. I t is not in dispute that after the fee determ ined by the com mit tee in the year 2007, the Fee Regulatory Commit tee determ ined the fee st ructure of Ayurvedic Colleges on 29.04.2019 and in between, there was no fee determ inat ion by the com mit tee. I n view of provision contained in Sect ion 5(2) of the aforesaid Act , Ayurvedic Colleges concerned could not have charged the fee over and above the am ount determ ined by the com mit tee.

14. I n these writ pet it ions, pet it ioners have quest ioned the authority of the Appellate Body to apply the fee determ inat ion m ade by the com mit tee to such students, who took admission in preceding years. I t is contended that fee determ inat ion can be applied only prospect ively and students who took admission in previous academic years cannot be asked to pay the enhanced fee determ ined by the commit tee in subsequent years.

15. This Court finds substance in the said submission. I n view of provision contained in sub- sect ions (12) , (13) and (14) of Sect ion 4 of the

8

aforesaid Act , the tuit ion fee payable by students of a pr ivate unaided professional college can be revised only as per determ inat ion m ade by the commit tee; every college, before com mencement of academic session, will have to require before the com mit tee, the proposed fee st ructure and the fee determ ined by the comm it tee, shall be applicable for a period of three years and after expiry of three years, the college would be at liberty to apply for revision. I t is further revealed that fee determ ined by the com mit tee shall be applicable to a student who takes admission in the same academic year in which the fee determ inat ion is m ade and the fee payable by such students shall not be revised t ill he / she com pletes the course.

16. Thus, the order passed by Appellate Authority is in teeth of provision contained in Sect ion 4 (14) of the Ut tarakhand Unaided Private Professional Educat ional I nst itut ions (Regulat ion of Admission and Fixat ion of Fee) Act , 2006, as such it is liable to be quashed.

17. The writ pet it ions are allowed. The im pugned order dated 31.01.2020 (Annexure-1 to the writ pet it ion) , passed by Appellate Authority to the extent it perm its upward revision of tuit ion fee, with ret rospect ive effect to students who took admission during Academic Sessions 2017-18 and 2018-19 is quashed. I t is provided that fee determ inat ion m ade by the Regulatory Commit tee in its meet ing held on 29.04.2019 would be applicable only prospect ively. Subject to paym ent of admissible fee by the

9

pet it ioners, Ayurvedic College concerned shall issue NOC to them and the University shall thereafter release pet it ioners' educat ional cert ificates, without any further delay.

__________________________________

MANOJ KUMAR TI W ARI , J.

Dt : 8hJanuary, 2025 Arpan

10

ARPAN

JAISWAL

Digitally signed by ARPAN JAISWAL DN: c=IN, o=HIGH COURT OF UTTARAKHAND, ou=HIGH COURT OF UTTARAKHAND, 2.5.4.20=eabb68a3895e41937c266c23964c0485 365445e3a20dddb7393398f9fe45ba3e, postalCode=263001, st=UTTARAKHAND, serialNumber=060FC17022BEAE3DE215D68D9D

454C5109CB987446351E4DF04AADAA2C2CEA6

6, cn=ARPAN JAISWAL

Date: 2025.01.13 11:13:10 +05'30'

10