Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

MUKESH KUMAR BANSAL  v. CENTRAL BANK OF INDIA & ANR.

Delhi High Court
Jan 7, 2025
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

This petition (W.P.(C) 4138/2021) was decided by the High Court of Delhi (Coram: Hon'ble Mr. Justice Manoj Jain). Judgment was reserved on 05.12.2024 and delivered on 07.01.2025. The petition challenges a decision of respondent no.1 (Central Bank of India) dated 11.02.2021 whereby the bank placed on hold funds (Rs. 38,60,000) in current account No. 3688550290 maintained by the partnership firm M/s Imperial Finance Company.

Material facts (as recorded in the opinion):

  • The petitioner, Mukesh Kumar Bansal, and his wife Mrs. Jyoti Bansal are partners in M/s Imperial Finance Company, which maintains current account No. 3688550290 at the Saraswati Bal Mandir, Uttam Nagar Branch of the respondent bank.
  • Mrs. Jyoti Bansal, in her capacity as sole-proprietor of M/s Next World Technologies, maintains a separate CC account No. 3163455860 with the same bank at a different branch (Parliament Street Branch).
  • On 10.02.2021 the petitioner found he could not operate the partnership firm's account; he discovered the bank had put the partnership account "on hold".
  • The bank's letter dated 11.02.2021 informed Mrs. Jyoti Bansal that Rs. 80,47,000 was overdue in her CC account of M/s Next World Technologies and that, as she had not regularized the account, it was classified as NPA. The letter stated that because she was a partner in M/s Imperial Finance Company, the bank had put a sum of Rs. 38,60,000 in the partnership firm's current account "on hold" to secure the outstanding dues of the proprietorship concern.
  • The present petition under Article 226 challenges the bank's action of putting on hold the partnership firm's account to secure the alleged dues of the separate proprietorship concern.

Procedural note: the petition was supported and opposed by counsel for the respective parties; respondents included Central Bank of India and another. Recovery proceedings by the bank against M/s Next World Technologies were already pending before the Debt Recovery Tribunal and there was an order restricting alienation/transfer of hypothecated assets of the proprietorship concern.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether a bank may validly "put on hold" or otherwise freeze the account of one entity (here, a partnership firm) in order to secure or recover dues allegedly owed by a different entity (here, a sole proprietorship) where the two accounts are maintained in the bank but belong to distinct legal entities.
  2. Whether principles of set-off, banker’s lien or general lien permit a bank to combine or adjust accounts held in different capacities or by distinct entities (including a partnership firm and a partner's separate/proprietorship account) in the absence of mutuality of obligation.
  3. Whether the absence of notice, or principles of natural justice and applicable RBI/banking guidelines, provide grounds to challenge the bank's action of placing an account on hold.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Arguments

  • The two accounts are distinct and have no nexus: one belongs to a partnership firm (M/s Imperial Finance Company) and the other to a separate proprietorship (M/s Next World Technologies).
  • Merely because Mrs. Jyoti Bansal is both a partner in the firm and the sole proprietor of the proprietorship, the bank cannot freeze the firm's account to secure her proprietorship liability.
  • The partnership firm and the proprietorship have separate PANs, distinct beneficiaries, and different modes of operation.
  • No notice was given prior to putting the account "on hold"; the action contravenes principles of natural justice and applicable RBI/guidelines and banking rules.
  • The partnership firm is a separate entity and the bank has no right of set-off against the firm's funds for the debt of a different concern; the amount on hold belongs to the partnership, not to an individual partner.
  • Both partners (petitioner and respondent no.2) have equal rights in the partnership and the held amount does not belong to any individual partner.
  • The bank's action amounts to double jeopardy because recovery proceedings against the proprietorship concern are already underway.
  • The petitioner relied on several authorities (listed in the judgment) to support the contention that set-off or lien could not be validly applied across distinct entities/accounts.

Respondent Bank's Arguments

  • The petition should have been filed by the partnership firm itself; a partner alone is not the proper party to challenge the bank's action.
  • The petitioner failed to disclose that he is an authorised signatory on the CC account of M/s Next World Technologies; in fact, he acknowledged receipt of the OTS (One Time Settlement) sanction letter dated 17.03.2021 under his signature.
  • The petitioner and respondent no.2 (Mrs. Jyoti Bansal) allegedly siphoned funds from M/s Next World Technologies to the partnership firm's account, directly or via other accounts in which the petitioner was a signatory.
  • The OTS in respect of M/s Next World Technologies has been revoked/recalled for non-compliance, and the bank claims a right to secure outstanding loan amounts under the banker's "General Lien".

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Gurbax Rai and Others v. Punjab National Bank, New Delhi (1984 SCC OnLine SC 73) Illustration that pledged goods belonging to a firm (and insurance proceeds) must be credited to the firm's cash credit account; rights in respect of pledged firm property belong to the firm. The court treated the observation about firm property and credit to the firm's account as germane, noting the principle that pledged assets and proceeds belong to the firm and cannot be treated as individual partner's collateral for personal debts.
Anumati v. Punjab National Bank (2004 SCC OnLine SC 1344) That a fixed deposit jointly owned by spouses with an "either or survivor" clause could not be pledged/adjusted by the bank against claims solely against one spouse; the contract is between the bank and both account-holders. The court relied on the case to show the crux that a bank cannot set off or appropriate amounts that are not mutually due between the bank and the same contracting party — principle applied analogously to separate-entity accounts.
Punjab National Bank Ltd. v. Arura Mal Durga Das and Others (1960 SCC OnLine Punj 126) Banker has a right to combine one or more accounts of the same customer but cannot combine the account belonging to another; accounts must be in the same capacity for set-off or lien to operate; no lien on a partner's separate account for firm's debt. The court relied heavily on these observations to conclude that banker's lien/set-off requires mutuality and same capacity; partnership deposits cannot be applied to individual indebtedness of a partner and vice versa.
Anantkoti Fabrics A Partnership Firm v. Bank of Baroda (AIRONLINE 2021 Gujarat 147) Reiterated proposition that a bank cannot exercise lien/set-off across distinct accounts lacking mutuality (as between partner’s separate account and partnership account). The High Court noted that Gujarat High Court reiterated the same proposition, supporting the conclusion that lien was not permissible in the present facts.
Shiv Developers v. Aksharay Developers and Others (AIR 2022 SC 772) The opinion cites the case among authorities relied upon by petitioner. The judgment cites the case but the provided text does not elaborate a specific rule from it or its application to the present facts.
Garnett v. McEwan [(1872) L.R. 8 Ex 10] Authority cited for the proposition that it is essential to the validity of a banker's lien that there should be mutuality of claim between the bank and the depositor; bank can combine accounts kept in the same right by the customer. Quoted and relied upon in the discussion to support the principle that mutuality (same contractual capacity) is necessary for set-off/lien.
Lloyds Bank Ltd. v. Administrator General of Burma [A.I.R. 1934 Rangoon 66] Authority emphasizing that to create a banker's lien on several accounts, the accounts must belong to the payer "in one and in the same capacity" and trustee/private accounts cannot be set off against each other. The court referenced this authority to reinforce that accounts differing in capacity (e.g., trustee vs private; firm vs individual) cannot be combined for set-off.
Watts v. Christie [50 E.R. 928] English authority that courts do not allow a banker a lien on the deposit of a partner on a separate account for a balance due to the bank from the firm. Referred to support the rule that partnership deposits cannot be applied to individual indebtedness of a partner.
Section 171, Indian Contract Act, 1872 Statutory provision governing the right of set-off. The court held that the bank had muddled the application of Section 171: the statutory right of set-off requires mutuality of obligation which was not present on the facts, so Section 171 did not justify the bank's action.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court's analysis proceeded in the following steps, as recorded in the opinion:

  1. The court first identified the dispositive factual feature: the two contested accounts belong to different legal entities (a partnership firm and a proprietorship) and are maintained at different branches of the bank.
  2. Relying upon precedent, the court emphasized a foundational principle: a bank may combine or set-off accounts only where there is mutuality of obligation and the accounts belong to the same party in the same capacity. Authorities such as Punjab National Bank v. Arura Mal Durga Das, Garnett v. McEwan, Lloyds Bank Ltd. v. Administrator General of Burma, and Watts v. Christie were invoked to explain this requirement.
  3. The court analysed Gurbax Rai and Anumati to extract principles about application of receipts or joint-account rights; while the factual matrices differed, the court considered their core holdings relevant by analogy (e.g., that assets/deposits belonging to one capacity cannot be appropriated to satisfy obligations in another capacity without proper mutuality).
  4. The court observed that "lien" is a right by which a banker can retain security coming into its possession for the purpose of a loan due by the customer. In the present case, nothing offered by the partnership firm as security justified a lien over the partnership firm's account to satisfy the proprietorship’s dues.
  5. The court held that the bank had misapplied the principle of set-off (Section 171, Indian Contract Act), because the essential element of mutuality of obligations was absent: the proprietorship's debt could not be set off against the partnership firm's account merely because one partner was common to both entities.
  6. The court acknowledged procedural and standing contentions by the bank (that the firm should have filed the petition and that the petitioner had certain signatory connections and OTS acknowledgments) but concluded that the absence of ideal party-pleading did not bar relief when there was a clear violation of law.
  7. Having applied the legal principles to the facts, the court concluded that the bank's action of placing the partnership firm's account on hold to secure the proprietorship's dues was legally impermissible in the circumstances of the case.

Holding and Implications

HOLDING: The petition is allowed. The court directed respondent-bank to immediately lift the "on hold" status from current account No. 3688550290 maintained by M/s Imperial Finance Company at Saraswati Bal Mandir, Uttam Nagar Branch, New Delhi.

IMPLICATIONS:

  • Direct effect on the parties: The bank must remove the hold on the partnership firm's account forthwith, thereby restoring the petitioner's ability to operate that account and withdraw funds subject to other lawful encumbrances not shown in the opinion.
  • The bank remains free to pursue and take any further steps permissible under law to recover dues from M/s Next World Technologies (the proprietorship). The court explicitly noted the bank's liberty to continue lawful recovery proceedings.
  • The judgment applies established principles regarding mutuality, banker’s lien and set-off to the facts and reaffirms that a bank cannot, by its own act, freeze the account of one distinct entity to satisfy the debt of another distinct entity merely because of common personnel or signatory connections.
  • The opinion does not purport to create a novel legal principle; it applies and reiterates existing authorities and principles to the facts before the court.

Order signed: (Manoj Jain) JUDGE — January 7, 2025.

Show all summary ...

W.P.(C) 4138/2021 Page 1 of 10

* IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI

% Judgment reserved on: 05.12.2024 Judgment delivered on: 07.01.2025 + W.P.(C) 4138/2021 & CM APPL. 12582/2021 & CM APPL. 4469/2024

MUKESH KUMAR BANSAL .....Petitioner

versus

CENTRAL BANK OF INDIA & ANR. .....Respondents

Memo of Appearance

For the Petitioner: Mr. Rakesh Khanna, Sr. Advocate with Mr. Abdhesh Chaudhary, Ms. Geetanjali Setia, Mr. Vinayak Mishra and Mr. Sunil Kumar, Advocates.

For the Respondent: Mr. Anuj Jain with Mr. Mritunjai Singh, Advocates for Central Bank of India.

CORAM:

HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE MANOJ JAIN

JUDGMENT

MANOJ JAIN, J

1. This petition poses question whether it is permissible for any bank to „put on hold" bank account of one entity to secure its dues to be recovered from another entity.

2. The broad facts are not in dispute.

3. Petitioner and his wife Mrs. Jyoti Bansal (respondent No. 2 herein) are partners in a partnership firm - M/s Imperial Finance Company. Such partnership firm maintains current account no. 3688550290 in one of the branches of the respondent no.1-Bank. Such branch is at Saraswati Bal Mandir, Uttam Nagar Branch, Rajouri Garden, Delhi.

1

4. Notably, Mrs. Jyoti Bansal, the other partner of the above said partnership firm, as sole- proprietor of M/s Next World Technologies is maintaining a separate current account i.e. CC Account no. 3163455860 with the respondent Bank, albeit, in another branch i.e. Parliament Street Branch, New Delhi, 110001.

5. Apparently, the bank accounts are of two different entities, maintained at different branches.

6. As averred, the petitioner, when, attempted to conduct an online transaction on 10.02.2021 in his abovesaid partnership firm's current account, he could not do so. He, eventually, learnt that the bank had placed their said partnership bank account „on hold". Consequently, the petitioner was unable to operate his said account and was unable to withdraw money from said partnership account.

7. The respondent bank also sent a letter to Mrs. Jyoti Bansal on February 11, 2021, informing her that she owed Rs. 80,47,000 in her said CC account related to M/s Next World Technologies. It was also mentioned therein that since despite several communication, she had not regularized said account and overdue was not paid, her said account had been classified as NPA (Non-performing Asset). The bank also stated in the abovesaid letter that she was partner in partnership firm M/s Imperial Finance Company and said firm was maintaining current account with Saraswati Bal Mandir, Uttam Nagar Branch, a sum of Rs. 38,60,000 lying therein had been put „on hold" for the aforementioned outstanding sum payable by her proprietorship concern. She was advised to regularize her own account, else to face appropriate action under right to set off.

2

8. Such letter dated 11.02.2021 issued by respondent No. 1-Bank, whereby it has put on hold the current account of a partnership firm - M/s Imperial Finance Company, is under challenge before this Court by way of the present petition filed under Article 226 of the Constitution of India.

9. The above action of the bank has been assailed while contending as under: -

1) There is no relation or nexus between the two accounts. One account is of partnership firm; the other is of the proprietorship concern.

2) Merely because, respondent no.2 is also partner of M/s Imperial Finance Company, the bank would not get any right to freeze said firm account, when the same is being maintained as per the banking norms.

3) These entities - the partnership firm and the proprietorship firm - are distinct entities, having separate PAN, distinct beneficiary and different mode of operation.

4) No notice was, even otherwise, ever given by the bank to put the account „on hold" and, therefore, also, such action of the bank is against the principles of Natural Justice as also against RBI Guidelines and Banking Rules.

5) Partnership firm is separate legal entity and no right of set-off is available to the bank. The amount put „on hold" vests with partnership firm whereas the amount alleged to be due was from different concern i.e sole proprietorship concern.

6) Mrs. Jyoti Bansal and Mr. Mukesh Bansal have equal rights in the partnership firm and are entitled to apportion of profit as per Partnership Act, 1932 and the amount put in hold (i.e. Rs. 38 lacs) does not belong to any individual partner.

7) Respondent Bank has already initiated recovery proceedings against the proprietorship concern M/s Next World Technologies and the present action of attaching the account, therefore, amounts to double jeopardy."

10. Learned counsel for petitioner also relies upon Gurbax Rai And Others Vs. Punjab National Bank, New Delhi 1984 SCC OnLine SC 73; Anumati Vs. Punjab National Bank 2004 SCC OnLine SC 1344; Punjab

3

National Bank Ltd. Vs. Arura Mal Durga Das And Others 1960 SCC OnLine Punj 126; Anantkoti Fabrics A Partnership Firm Vs. Bank of Baroda AIRONLINE 2021 Gujarat 147 and Shiv Developers Vs. Aksharay Developers And Others AIR 2022 SC 772.

11. All such contentions have been refuted by Respondent No. 1/Central Bank of India.

12. It is submitted that since the present petition challenges the decision to "put on hold" the bank account of partnership firm, such firm - M/s Imperial Finance Company should have filed the petition whereas it has been filed by a partner only. It is also claimed that the petitioner has, purposely and knowingly, failed to disclose that he himself is the authorised signatory to the CC account of M/s Next World Technologies (sole proprietorship firm of respondent no.2). In fact, the OTS (One-Time Settlement) sanction letter dated 17.03.2021 qua M/s Next World Technologies has been received/acknowledged by petitioner under his own signatures. It is submitted that the petitioner, jointly and severally alongwith respondent no. 2, has siphoned off the funds of M/s Next World Technologies to the account of partnership firm M/s Imperial Finance Company, either directly or by channelizing the same from two other accounts i.e. one of petitioner himself bearing account no.3211486691 and another of M/s Europa Digital Limited (in which petitioner and respondent no.2 are signatories) bearing account no. 3132953622. It is further contended that OTS has already been revoked/recalled for not adhering to the terms of OTS. It has thus been submitted that respondent no. 1 bank has

4

every right to secure the outstanding amount of loan of M/s Next World Technologies under the right of "General Lien" of Banker.

13. In the backdrop of the above factual matrix and rival contentions, it is to be evaluated whether the action of the bank is legally permissible and sustainable or not.

14. As noted already, the two accounts are of different entities. It would be, in the present context, hardly of any real significance even if such sole proprietor is also one of the partners in the firm.

15. In Gurbax Rai (supra), a cash credit account was opened in the name of the firm with Punjab National Bank. There were numerous transactions in said cash credit account. The Bank, eventually, terminated the facility and called upon the firm to clear the account in which there was a debit balance of Rs. 3 lacs. The Bank also filed a recovery suit against the firm and its partners. The firm also filed a suit against the Bank praying for rendition of accounts in respect of cash credit account. The principal contention in the suit by the firm was that the firm had pledged certain goods with the Bank and the Bank, as a pledge, had not taken reasonable care of the goods pledged. It appeared that the goods were destroyed in a fire and the Bank recovered from the insurer which the Bank was bound to give credit. The suit of the Bank was dismissed. Initially, the suit of the firm was also dismissed but later on decreed and, the first appellate Court eventually, also confirmed the same. However, in Letters Patent Appeal, such decree was set aside and, resultantly, the firm filed SLP before Hon"ble Supreme Court. While allowing such appeal decreeing the suit of the firm, the Apex Court held that the pledged goods belonged to the firm and were not offered as

5

collateral for each partner's personal debt and, therefore, when the insurance was reimbursed for the sum due to the firm's pledged goods being destroyed, it must be given credit only in the cash credit account and, to that extent, the liability in the cash credit account would be reduced. Such observation seems little germane in the present context as well.

16. In Anumati Vs. Punjab National Bank (supra), the question was whether a fixed deposit jointly owned with an "either or survivor" clause opened together by husband and wife could be pledged by one of the account-holders with the bank and whether the bank could adjust the amount of fixed deposit against such pledge, without the authority, knowledge or concurrence of the other account-holder. Such other account holder filed a complaint before District Forum claiming deficiency in service which was upheld and the bank was directed to pay proportionate amount with interest and compensation. Though, State Commission and National Commission set aside the same, the order of District Forum was restored by Hon"ble Supreme Court observing that the contract in respect of the joint account was between the respondent Bank and the „husband and wife". The fixed deposit was not a „debt due" by the Bank to the husband alone which could be set off by the Bank against any claim that the Bank may have had against such husband. Besides the right of husband was to receive the money deposited only after it matured, if he survived. Supposing he had died before the fixed deposit matured, the only person entitled to get the money would be the appellant i.e his wife and her right could not have been taken away without her consent. Though, the situation therein was little different but the crux remains the same.

6

17. The observations made in Punjab National Bank, Ltd. v. Arura Mal Durga Das (supra) are noteworthy wherein it has been held that Banker has a right to combine one or more accounts of the same customer but it cannot combine the account belonging to another. It also, while referring to Lloyds Bank Ltd. v. Administrator General of Burma [A.I.R. 1934 Rangoon 66], observed that in order to create Banker's lien on several accounts, it was necessary that they must belong to the „payer in one and in the same capacity" and that where the person has two accounts, one a trustee account and another private account at a Bank, deposits in the two accounts cannot be set off, the one against the other. It also observed as under:-

"Similarly, the Banks have no lien on the deposit of a partner, on his separate account, for a balance due to the Bank from the firm. Therefore, the banker is entitled to combine all accounts kept in the same right by the customer. It does not matter whether the accounts are current or deposit or whether they are in the same or different branches [Garnett v. MKewan [(1872, L.R. 8 Ex 10.]. It is of essence to the validity of a banker's lien, that there should be a mutuality of, claim between the Bank and the depositor. In order that it should be permissible to set off one demand against another both must mutually exist between the same parties. On this reasoning the joint and several accounts operated by two or more persons cannot be adjusted against the individual deposit of one of them. It is not open to the bank to claim the deposit of one partner made on his separate account in order to utilise other deposit against the debit due from the firm. In other words partnership deposits cannot be applied to the individual indebtedness of one of the partners (vide 7 A.M. Jur., page 458). Courts in England do not allow a lien to the banker on the deposit of a partner on separate account for a balance due to the Bank from partnership firm [vide Watts v. Christie [50 E.R. 928 (931).]]"

18. It was further held therein that there was no doubt with the proposition that a bank has no lien on a partner's private account for an overdraft on partnership account or vice versa, for want of reciprocity.

7

19. The above proposition was reiterated by Gujarat High Court in Anantkoti Fabrics A Partnership Firm (supra).

20. Thus, bank can exercise lien only where there is mutuality of obligation between the two accounts.

21. Here, clearly, the lien is not permissible.

22. The accounts are of different bodies.

23. Money due to the bank by a proprietorship concern cannot be recovered from the account of partnership firm, even if such sole proprietor is one of the partners in such firm. It also really does not matter whether the petitioner herein had been operating both the accounts and certain amount was transferred from one account to the other. Bank could have only exercised some lien over the goods pledged by sole proprietorship concern but in the garb of set off, it had no business to touch account of an altogether different entity, on its own. Moreover, the bank is already before Debt Recovery Tribunal and there is judicial order, restraining the sole proprietorship concern from alienating or transferring hypothecated assets.

24. The bank has multiple roles to play. It is, at times, debtor, bailee, agent, assignee and trustee too.

25. In a case, where bank opens any deposit account for its customer, it essentially plays the role of a debtor. This means when a banker receives deposit from a customer or someone else deposits any amount therein, such deposit, being to the credit of the customer, the banker becomes a debtor and the customer a creditor. The bank becomes trustee when it undertakes to

8

collect cheques on behalf of its customers and after realizing those, the bank has to credit the proceeds to the account of the customer, whereby the customer becomes the beneficiary. The bank also becomes agent for its account holder, inter alia, when it makes payment to others, as per instructions of such account-holder. Bank will act as a bailee when goods are entrusted to it for a specific purpose.

26. Thus, any account-holder, invariably, banks on its bank, considerably.

27. Such trust and faith cannot be shattered by a bank in a monopolistic and exploitative style.

28. Being banker, the bank has certainly access to the details of all its accounts but that would not mean that it can freeze somebody"s account in such arbitrary and whimsical manner, while acting itself as a judge, that too in its own cause.

29. Quite clearly, the bank muddled up in applying principle of set off as enumerated under Section 171 of Indian Contract Act, 1872, which is not attracted keeping in mind the peculiar facts of the case in hand. Lien is a right of a banker, by which it can retain any security coming to its possession for the purpose of any loan due by customer. Here, there was nothing offered as security by the partnership firm. Thus, there being no mutuality of obligation, which is an essential element in the right to set off, such right was not exercisable.

30. The firm in question comprises of two partners and both are parties to the present lis. Though ideally, the petition should have been filed by the firm but the fact that it has been filed by one of the partners does not mean

9

that the case has to be discarded, more so, when there is found to be clear- cut violation of law.

31. In view of foregoing discussion, the present petition is hereby allowed and, consequently, respondent-bank is directed to lift „on hold" from current account No.3688550290 maintained by partnership firm M/s Imperial Finance Company at Saraswati Bal Mandir, Uttam Nagar Branch, New Delhi immediately.

32. Needless to say, respondent-bank is always at liberty to pursue and/or to take any further step, as permissible under law, to recover its dues from M/s Next World Technologies.

(MANOJ JAIN)

JUDGE

JANUARY 7, 2025/HMJ

10