- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Kasif Khan v. Union Of India
Judgment Summary — High Court of Madhya Pradesh (Jabalpur)
Case: Criminal Appeal No. 5755 of 2024 — Kasif Khan v. Union of India. Heard 13/12/2024; Pronounced 06/01/2025. Bench: Justice Sushrut Arvind Dharmadhikari & Justice Anuradha Shukla. Appeal under Section 21(4) of the NIA Act against rejection of bail dated 12/04/2024 in SC NIA No.02 of 2023.
Factual and Procedural Background
The appellant, Kasif Khan, was arrested on 21/08/2023 in connection with FIR/RC-14/2023/NIA/DLI (registered 24/05/2023) investigated by the National Investigation Agency pursuant to an MHA order. The charge-sheet and case materials allege offences under Sections 120-B, 153-A, 153-B, 295-A IPC and various provisions of the Unlawful Activities (Prevention) Act, 1967 (UAPA), including Sections 13, 17, 18, 20, 38, 39 and 40.
The prosecution's brief factual account (as set out in the charge-sheet and investigation summary) alleges that the appellant and co-accused were radicalized by extremist content (including lectures and ISIS-related material), formed and used a WhatsApp group (initially named "Pics", later renamed "Fisabilillah"), shared violent and extremist content, discussed Shari'at, Jihad, Khilafat and ISIS ideology, distributed pamphlets, and conspired to attack the Ordnance Factory, Jabalpur to procure weapons and/or to blast it. The NIA contends it seized electronic material, literature, pamphlets, CDRs and recorded witness statements (Sections 161 and 164 Cr.P.C.) implicating the appellant.
Procedurally, the appellant's application for bail in SC NIA No.02 of 2023 was rejected by the trial court on 12/04/2024. The appellant challenged that order before the High Court by filing the present Criminal Appeal under Section 21(4) of the NIA Act. The High Court heard submissions of both sides and reserved judgment, pronouncing judgment on 06/01/2025.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the appellant is entitled to bail under Section 43D(5) of the UAPA in view of the material in the charge-sheet and case diary.
- Whether, on perusal of the charge-sheet and case diary, there are reasonable grounds for believing that the accusation against the appellant is "prima facie true" as required by Section 43D(5) of UAPA (i.e., whether the materials on their face show complicity such that the first limb of the twin-prong test is satisfied).
- If the first limb is not satisfied, whether the appellant nonetheless deserves bail under the general bail principles (the "tripod test": flight risk, tampering with evidence, influencing witnesses) and in light of Article 21 concerns such as delay of trial and period of incarceration already undergone.
Arguments of the Parties
Appellant's Arguments
- The appellant is falsely implicated and the prosecution case rests on suspicion; the necessary ingredients of the alleged offences are missing vis-à-vis the appellant.
- No incriminating weapons were seized from the appellant; the material against him is prima facie insufficient and largely based on memoranda of co-accused.
- Mere exchange/discussion of religious beliefs does not constitute an offence; mere association or support is insufficient to attract Sections 38 and 39 of UAPA unless intention to further the activities of the terrorist organization is shown.
- The appellant has no criminal antecedents; continued detention would cause irreparable harm to his family; he is a permanent resident of Jabalpur and not likely to abscond; he is ready to furnish surety and comply with conditions.
- Reliance was placed on authority (inter alia): Sudesh Kedia v. Union of India; Sheikh Javed Iqbal @ Asfhaq Ansari @ Javed Ansari v. State of Uttar Pradesh; Jalaluddin Khan v. Union of India; Tawaha Fasal v. Union of India (as authorities relevant to bail standards under UAPA and Article 21 considerations).
Respondent's (NIA) Arguments
- The offences are grave and threaten national integrity and public peace; there is incriminating material (audio/video, literature, pamphlets, handwritten diary entries, digital devices) recovered from accused including the appellant.
- Statements recorded under Sections 161 and 164 Cr.P.C. implicate the appellant; the appellant was aware of ISIS and its activities and actively participated in dissemination and preparatory acts.
- Section 43D(5) of UAPA imposes statutory restrictions on granting bail and requires the court to be satisfied that the accusation is not prima facie true before granting bail; the NIA asked the Court to hear the Public Prosecutor and rely on the case diary and charge-sheet.
- Reliance was placed on authorities including Gurwinder Singh v. State of Punjab; Jayanta Kumar Ghosh v. NIA; Golan Daulagupu v. NIA to support refusal of bail in such cases.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Zahoor Ahmad Shah Watali, (2019) 5 SCC 1 | The definition and meaning of "prima facie true" under Section 43D(5) UAPA; matters to be considered on a bail application (including whether there are reasonable grounds to believe accusation is prima facie true); courts must form an opinion on broad probabilities and not conduct detailed evidence evaluation. | The Court reiterated Watali's principles (including the test for "prima facie true") as foundational to the enquiry and used them to assess whether the charge-sheet materials, on their face, show the appellant's complicity. |
| K.A. Najeeb v. Union of India, (2021) 3 SCC 713 | Held that rigour of statutory restrictions may "melt" where trial cannot be completed within reasonable time and pre-trial incarceration has exceeded a substantial part of prescribed sentence; statutory restrictions do not oust constitutional courts' power to grant bail in such circumstances. | The Court cited this authority to recognize that exceptions exist to the strict approach where Article 21 and speedy-trial concerns warrant bail; however, the Court found those circumstances not established in the present case. |
| Tawaha Fasal (Thwaha Fasal) v. Union of India, (2022) 14 SCC 766 | If court, after examining material on record, is satisfied that there are no reasonable grounds to believe accusation is prima facie true, the accused is entitled to bail; examination limited to charge-sheet material; mere association insufficient to attract Section 38 UAPA unless intention to further activities is shown. | The Court relied on this principle in framing its approach: it examined the charge-sheet material as presented and reached a finding that there were reasonable grounds for believing the accusation against the appellant was prima facie true. |
| Gurwinder Singh v. State of Punjab, (2024) 5 SCC 403 | Summarised and applied the twin-prong test under Section 43D(5): (1) whether accusations are prima facie true on perusal of case diary/charge-sheet; (2) if not, apply the tripod test (flight risk, tampering with evidence, influencing witnesses) under Section 439 Cr.P.C. | The Court adopted the twin-prong/two-stage framework set out in Gurwinder Singh and applied the first prong (whether accusations are prima facie true) to the charge-sheet material in this case. |
| Sheikh Javed Iqbal @ Asfhaq Ansari @ Javed Ansari v. State of U.P., 2024 (8) SCC 293 | Held that where trial is prolonged, seriousness of charges alone cannot defeat bail; constitutional courts can grant bail if Article 21 rights (e.g., speedy trial) are infringed despite restrictive statutory provisions. | The Court cited this decision to note the primacy of Article 21 and to acknowledge that prolonged trial and violation of fundamental rights can justify bail — but found that such grounds were not made out in the instant case. |
| Jalaluddin Khan v. Union of India, 2024 SCC OnLine SC 1945 | The Court must examine material forming part of the charge-sheet "as it is" to decide whether accusations are prima facie true; when a case for bail is made out courts should not hesitate to grant bail. | The High Court invoked this principle to emphasize that it must take the charge-sheet material at face value for the prima facie assessment and, after doing so, concluded the material was sufficient to show prima facie complicity. |
| Athar Parwez v. Union of India, Criminal Appeal No. 5387 of 2024 (decided 17-12-2024) | Reiterated and clarified principles for deciding bail under UAPA; emphasized right to speedy trial under Article 21 and that prolonged detention without timely trial is unconstitutional; seriousness of crime not determinative if Article 21 is engaged. | The Court referred to this recent reiteration to underscore the balance between statutory restrictions and constitutional protections, while applying the settled framework to the facts and concluding that Article 21-based relief was not warranted in the present record. |
| Sudesh Kedia v. Union of India, 2021 (4) SCC 704 | The specific rule/principle cited from this decision is not detailed in the provided opinion text; it was relied upon by the appellant in submissions. | The opinion records that the appellant relied on this authority but does not set out in the judgment the particular principle from this case or discuss its application in detail. |
| Jayanta Kumar Ghosh v. National Investigation Agency, (2013) (Gauhati Law Reports 374) | The opinion records this case as relied upon by the respondent; the specific rule/principle from this report is not set out in the provided text. | The Court notes that the NIA relied on this authority in opposing bail, but the judgment does not elaborate the case law principle or apply it expressly in reasoning beyond recording reliance. |
| Golan Daulagupu v. National Investigation Agency, (2013) (Gauhati Law Reports 791) | The opinion records this case as relied upon by the respondent; the specific rule/principle from this report is not set out in the provided text. | The Court notes reliance by the NIA but the judgment does not extract or apply a specific principle from this authority in the body of its reasoning as reproduced in the provided text. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court first set out the established framework for deciding bail under Section 43D(5) of UAPA, drawing on binding Supreme Court precedents (including Zahoor Ahmad Shah Watali, K.A. Najeeb, Thwaha Fasal, Gurwinder Singh and subsequent clarifications). The framework adopted was the twin-prong approach:
- First, whether on perusal of the case diary and the final report/charge-sheet, there are reasonable grounds for believing that the accusation against the accused is prima facie true (the statutory proviso under Section 43D(5)); and
- Second (only if the first test is not satisfied), whether the accused deserves bail in light of general bail principles (the "tripod test": flight risk, tampering with evidence, influencing witnesses) and Article 21 considerations (speedy trial, period of incarceration already undergone).
The Court explained the meaning of "prima facie true" (as set out in Watali): materials collected by the investigating agency must, on their face, show the complicity of the accused in commission of the offence and must prevail until contradicted. The Court emphasized that this stage requires examination of the charge-sheet material "as it is" and does not require a mini-trial or detailed dissection of the evidence; the Court is to form an opinion on broad probabilities.
Applying this approach to the present record, the Court summarized the incriminating material appearing on the face of the charge-sheet and case diary:
- Allegations of association with ISIS and involvement in activities aligned with that banned organization, including creation/administration of a WhatsApp group where extremist content was shared (group created by appellant and later renamed).
- Possession/access to violent ISIS-related videos and literature (including downloads from a Telegram "Dawlah" bot); seizure of audio/video files, pamphlets, handwritten diary entries, and digital devices; CDRs showing interconnections among accused; and recorded witness statements under Sections 161 & 164 Cr.P.C. (witnesses A–H) asserting conspiracy and preparatory acts.
- Specific allegation that the accused conspired to attack the Ordnance Factory, Jabalpur (a defence entity), planned to procure weapons and prepare explosives, and that the appellant shared a link to a video demonstrating preparation of an explosive from commonly available materials.
- Recovery of an audio conversation between the appellant and co-accused discussing Jihad and Jaziya; derogatory posts against Hindu deities; and active participation in "Dawah" and related organizing activity.
The Court observed that, on the totality of the charge-sheet material taken "as it is", there was sufficient material showing active participation of the appellant in the alleged unlawful activities and conspiracy to commit a terrorist act. The Court noted statutory definition of "terrorist act" under Section 15(1) UAPA and found that the material demonstrated conspiracy to commit an act directed at a defence establishment, which falls within that definition.
The Court considered arguments that mere association or exchange of religious beliefs does not suffice under Sections 38/39 UAPA; however, on the charge-sheet the Court found specific inculpatory material (electronic downloads, group administration, audio discussions, pamphlets, planned explosives and conspiracy to attack an ordnance factory) that established, on broad probabilities, prima facie guilt for the purposes of Section 43D(5).
The Court also considered Article 21 / speedy trial arguments and the line of authorities which permit bail where trial delay or excessive incarceration violates fundamental rights (K.A. Najeeb, Sheikh Javed Iqbal, Athar Parwez). The Court concluded that the trial was "set at full motion" and there was no demonstrable ground that the trial would be unreasonably delayed or that the appellant had suffered incarceration amounting to a substantial portion of the prescribed sentence such as to warrant bail on Article 21 grounds.
On balance, after applying the statutory test (first prong) and considering the material in the charge-sheet as a whole (not piecemeal), the Court found reasonable grounds for believing the accusation against the appellant to be prima facie true and therefore did not proceed to the second prong in a manner that would favour bail.
Holding and Implications
Holding:
The Criminal Appeal is dismissed. The High Court affirmed the trial court's order dated 12/04/2024 in SC NIA No.02 of 2023 rejecting the appellant's bail application.
Implications / Direct effect:
- The appellant remains in custody pending trial; bail is denied at this stage.
- The trial is to proceed in the trial court; the High Court expressly stated that findings recorded in this judgment are only for the limited purpose of deciding the bail application and shall not prejudice the trial court's conduct of the case.
- The decision applies the existing jurisprudential framework on bail under Section 43D(5) UAPA and does not purport to lay down a new legal principle; the judgment applies established precedents to the facts and the materials in the charge-sheet.
Note: Where the provided opinion did not specify particular principles drawn from certain cited Gauhati reports or other authorities relied upon by the parties, the Court recorded reliance on those decisions but did not elaborate their contents in the reproduced judgment text. Accordingly, where the judgment itself did not state the precise rule from a cited case, the summary records that the opinion did not specify those details.
1
NEUTRAL CITATION NO. 2025:MPHC-JBP:257
IN THE HIGH COURT OF MADHYA PRADESH
AT JABALPUR
BEFORE
HON'BLE SHRI JUSTICE SUSHRUT ARVIND DHARMADHIKARI &
HON'BLE SMT. JUSTICE ANURADHA SHUKLA CRIMINAL APPEAL No. 5755 OF 2024
KASIF KHAN
Versus
UNION OF INDIA
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Appearance :
Shri Manish Datt - Senior Advocate with Shri Satyam Rai - Advocate for the appellant.
Shri Deepesh Joshi - Advocate with Shri Qasim Ali - Advocate for the respondent NIA.
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Heard on : 13/12/2024
Pronounced on : 06/01/2025
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
J U D G M E N T
Per: Justice Sushrut Arvind Dharmadhikari The instant Criminal Appeal under section 21(4) of the National Investigation Agency Act, 2008 has been filed on behalf of the appellant
1
against the order dated 12/04/2024 passed in SC NIA No.02 of 2023; whereby the application filed by the appellant for grant of bail, has been rejected.
2. The appellant has been arrested on 21/08/2023 relating to FIR/Crime No.RC-14/2023/NIA/DLI registered at Police Station NIA, Delhi, regarding commission of offence punishable under Sections 120-B, 153-A, 153-B, 295- A of the Indian Penal Code (hereinafter referred as IPC) and Sections 13, 17, 18, 20, 38, 39 and 40 of Unlawful Activities (Prevention) Act, 1967 (hereinafter referred as UAPA).
3. Prosecution story in short is that in compliance of the order of Government of India, Ministry of Home Affairs, dated 24/05/2023, the National Investigation Agency registered a case bearing No.RC- 14/2023/NIA/DLI dated 24/05/2023 under Sections 120-B, 295-A of the IPC and Sections 16, 17, 18, 18(B), 20 of UAPA against co-accused Syed Mamoor Ali, Adil Khan and other unknown persons. The NIA took up the investigation wherein it was revealed that during nationwide lockdown in the year 2020, the accused persons started gaining knowledge about comparison of religion through watching the videos of Zakir Naik, an Islamic Preacher, reading Quran and Hadeeth..
(3.1) Further, investigation revealed that co-accused Mohd. Adil Khan got influenced by the thoughts of Zakir Naik and started gaining knowledge about basics of geopolitics (learnt about Syria @ Sham, Israel, America, Saudi Arabia, Khurasan etc.). He also expressed interest towards Jihad and started corroborating Jihad with Quran. He developed radicalized bent of mind and started believing that there must be Shariyat all over the world and no one should follow the man-made laws. The NIA found that the co-accused-Syed Mamoor was also listening and watching Islamic lectures delivered by Islamic orators such as Zakir Naik, Syed Faiz, Dr. Israr Ahmad etc. and was also watching videos of Anwar-Al-Awlaki. He started searching about Jihad and
2
corroborated the same with Quran for developing Jihadis ideology as he wanted to spread Sharia law all over the world.
(3.2) The investigation also revealed that co-accused-Syed Mamoor started giving Dawah to Hindus and started distribution of pamphlets related to Islam. Further, during the investigation, the NIA also found that the present appellant and other co-accused Shahid Khan were also involved in said unlawful activities. All the accused persons were watching Islamic lectures to provoke Jihad and implement Sharia law all over the world including India. All the accused persons became close friends and started discussing Quran and Hadeeth and Jihad too. They all started sharing radicalized thoughts with each other. They had a common mind of establishing Sharia law in India through violent means. They used to visit Falah Darain Masjid for offering Namaz, where they used to discuss Jihad through violent means and Khilafat based on Shariyat. They also prepared the pamphlets similar to the flags of ISIS and Al- Qaeda. They affixed one of the samples of pamphlets on the wall of nearby Ahle Hadees mosque in order to attract likeminded people, whom they can influence towards ideology of ISIS. The Investigation further shows that in the month of August, 2022, the appellant created a WhatsApp group namely
"Pics" and added Mohd. Adil Khan, Shahid Khan and some other persons. After creating the said group, co-accused Mohd. Adil khan started sharing videos, audios, photos, related to ISIS/Jihad/Shariyat in order to motivate the group members towards the ideology of ISIS. They also started sharing derogatory posts on Hindu deities. In the month of December, 2022, appellant added co-accused - Syed Mamoor Ali @ Mamoor Bhai, who changed the name of group as "Fisabillilah" and also changed the Display Picture of the group, which was similar to the flag of ISIS with slight modifications. In the said WhatsApp group, the accused persons started discussing Shariyat, Khilafat and Jihad. In order to escape themselves from the radar of
3
Investigation Agency, they decided to use code names for ISIS such as "eye S", "eye ass", "eye as", "eye sis", "eye see", "Dhadiwale", "Dawlah", "1515",
"15", "Mujahideen" and "Eye s fisabilillah". They also decided co-accused Syed Mamoor Ali would be the Ameer of the group.
(3.3) The investigation further revealed that co-accused Adil Khan came in contact with one Faris Nazdi through social media, who provided contents related to ISIS. It is further alleged that co-accused Adil Khan also downloaded several contents relating to ISIS. The said contents were also seen by other co-accused persons in laptop of co-accused Shahid Khan. Further, co- accused Adil Khan created a bot channel namely "Dawlah @ baqiyah_bot)"
on Telegram. He used to upload links of the Dawlah bot in his Instagram account named as "abdullahadawallah". He also took backup of said data on Mega application. Thereafter, the other co-accused persons also created accounts on Social Media in order to fulfill their motive. (3.4) The investigation further shows that the present appellant and other co- accused persons conspired to attack Ordnance Factory, Jabalpur, to procure the weapons in large quantity in furtherance of their terror activity. They also decided to blast the Jabalpur Ordnance Factory, if they could not succeed in capturing the Factory. The co-accused Syed Mamoor Ali also suggested to have three Mujahids behind each security personnel in order to capture the Factory. They wanted to expand their violence to whole India. It is further alleged that the co-accused- Syed Mamoor gave responsibility of technical head to co-accused Mohd. Adil Khan and preparation of explosive to present appellant. In furtherance thereof, appellant shared a link of one YouTube video to prepare highly inflammable explosive by using daily used material and chemical. The accused persons did not believe in the concept of Nationalism, Democracy, Constitution and Voting system and motivated others too for doing so. They wanted to recruit like-minded people in large number to
4
strengthen their organization. They also decided to make monthly contribution for their cause and wanted to raise funds through Bait-ul-mal. During the course of the investigation, various audios/videos/PDFs of ISIS publications as well as incriminating handwriting diary, digital devices, literature, pamphlets, mobile phones were seized from possession of the accused persons. The investigating agency also procured CDR between the accused persons. The accused persons got arrested by the investigating agency.
4. It is submitted by the learned counsel for the appellant that the appellant has falsely been implicated in the case. The prosecution case is based on suspicion and indeed, there is nothing on record against the present appellant. No offence, as alleged is made out against him as necessary ingredients to constitute the alleged offence are completely missing. The appellant has no criminal antecedents and if the appellant is kept in jail, it will adversely affect his family and cause irreparable loss. Only on the basis of memorandum of co- accused, the present appellant has been impleaded as an accused in the case. Mere exchange of religious beliefs does not constitute any offence. The material collected by the investigating agency prima facie does not constitute any offence against the present appellant. No weapons have been seized from the possession of the present appellant. It is further submitted that investigation is over and charge-sheet has been filed. He has also submitted that while considering the bail application under Section 43(D)(5) of UAPA, the court is duty bound to apply its mind to examine the entire material available on record for the purpose of satisfying itself as to whether prima facie case is made out against the accused or not ? The period of custody and probability of conclusion of trial in near future should be considered by the Court. In the present case, the learned trial Court failed to consider the provisions of law in proper manner. Mere association with terrorist organization is not sufficient to attract Section 38 of UAPA and mere support
5
to a terrorist organization is not sufficient to attract Section 39 of UAPA. The association and support have to be with an intention and in furtherance of the activities of the terrorist organization. In addition to above submissions, the learned Senior counsel for the appellant has submitted that the appellant is a permanent resident of District Jabalpur and there is no likelihood of his absconding or tampering with the prosecution evidence. The appellant is ready to furnish adequate surety and shall abide by all the directions and conditions which may be imposed by the Court. In support of his contentions, learned Senior counsel for the appellant placed reliance on the following citations:- (1) Sudesh Kedia Vs. Union of India, 2021 (4) SCC 704 (2) Sheikh Javed Iqbal@Asfhaq Ansari@Javed Ansari Vs. State of Uttar Pradesh, 2024(8) SCC 293 (3) Jalaluddin Khan Vs. Union of India, 2024 SCC OnLine SC 1945 and (4) Tawaha Fasal Vs. Union of India, (2022) 14 SCC 766. On these grounds, prayer is made to allow the appeal and enlarge the appellant on bail.
5. Per contra, learned counsel appearing for the respondent has vehemently opposed the appeal. He submitted that the offence committed by the appellant is serious in nature and against the integrity and peace of country. The prosecution has collected incriminating material viz. audio clips, video clips, objectionable literatures, pamphlets, handwritten documents from the possession of all the accused persons including present appellant which show his involvement in the alleged crime. He has further submitted that Section 43 D(5) of UAPA imposes restrictions upon the Court in granting bail to accused person. The statements of witnesses recorded under Sections 161 and 164 of Cr.P.C., clearly establishes the complicity of present appellant in the alleged crime. He further submitted that it is not necessary that every person who are involved in terrorist activities must have criminal antecedents. The appellant was fully aware about the banned terrorist organization ISIS and its activities
6
in India and worldwide. As per Section 19 of NIA Act, 2008, the trial will be conducted having precedence over other matters and therefore, there is no delay in trial proceedings. If the appellant is released on bail, there is every possibility of his fleeing away. In support of his contentions, learned counsel for the respondent has placed reliance on the following decisions (1) Gurwinder Singh vs. State of Punjab and another, reported in (2024) 5 SCC 403 (2) Jayanta Kumar Ghosh Vs. National Investigation Agency, 2013 (1) Gauhati Law Reports 374 (3) Golan Daulagupu Vs. National Investigation Agency, 2013 (2) Gauhati Law Reports 791.
6. We have heard the submissions advanced by learned counsel for the parties and perused the charge-sheet along with other documents available on record and also the case laws referred by the counsel for the parties.
7. Before examining the facts of the case, we think it appropriate to reiterate the settled legal position laid down by Hon'ble Supreme Court in the case of Zahoor Ahmad Shah Watali, reported in (2019) 5 SCC 1, for deciding an application for bail, which reads that:-.
Before we proceed to analyse the rival submissions, it is apposite to reiterate the settled legal position about matters to be considered for deciding an application for bail, to wit,
(i) whether there is any prima facie or reasonable ground to believe that the accused had committed the offence;
(ii) nature and gravity of the charge;
(iii) severity of the punishment in the event of conviction;
(iv) danger of the accused absconding or fleeing, if released on bail;
(v) character, behaviour, means, position and standing of the accused;
(vi) likelihood of the offence being repeated;
(vii) reasonable apprehension of the witnesses being tampered with; and
(viii) danger, of course, of justice being thwarted by grant of bail.
8. Now, we come to the provisions relating to bail under the UAPA i.e. sub-section 5 of Section 43D, same reads as under:
"43-D. Modified application of certain provisions of the Code
".......................................................................
7
(5) Notwithstanding anything contained in the Code, no person accused of an offence punishable under Chapters IV and VI of this Act shall, if in custody, be released on bail or on his own bond unless the Public Prosecutor has been given an opportunity of being heard on the application for such release:
Provided that such accused person shall not be released on bail or on his own bond if the Court, on a perusal of the case diary or the report made under Section 173 of the Code is of the opinion that there are reasonable grounds for believing that the accusation against such person is prima facie true.
(6) The restrictions on granting of bail specified in Sub-Section (5) is in addition to the restrictions under the Code or any other law for the time being in force on granting of bail.
(7) Notwithstanding anything contained in Sub-Sections (5) and (6), no bail shall be granted to a person accused of an offence punishable under this Act, if he is not an Indian citizen and has entered the country unauthorizedly or illegally except in very exceptional circumstances and for reasons to be recorded in writing."
9. In the case of Zahoor Ahmad Shah Watali (supra), the Hon'ble Supreme Court has laid down the principle for considering the bail application under UAPA, the relevant para is quoted as under:
"17. By virtue of the proviso to sub-section (5), it is the duty of the Court to be satisfied that there are reasonable grounds for believing that the accusation against the accused is prima facie true or otherwise. Our attention was invited to the decisions of this Court, which has had an occasion to deal with similar special provisions in TADA and MCOCA. The principle underlying those decisions may have some bearing while considering the prayer for bail in relation to offences under the 1967 Act as well. Notably, under the special enactments such as TADA, MCOCA and the Narcotic Drugs and Psychotropic Substances Act, 1985, the Court is required to record its opinion that there are reasonable grounds for believing that the
8
accused is "not guilty" of the alleged offence. There is degree of difference between the satisfaction to be recorded by the Court that there are reasonable grounds for believing that the accused is "not guilty" of such offence and the satisfaction to be recorded for the purposes of the 1967 Act that there are reasonable grounds for believing that the accusation against such person is "prima facie"
true. By its very nature, the expression "prima facie true" would mean that the materials/evidence collated by the Investigating Agency in reference to the accusation against the concerned accused in the first information report, must prevail until contradicted and overcome or disproved by other evidence, and on the face of it, shows the complicity of such accused in the commission of the stated offence. It must be good and sufficient on its face to establish a given fact or the chain of facts constituting the stated offence, unless rebutted or contradicted. In one sense, the degree of satisfaction is lighter when the Court has to opine that the accusation is "prima facie true", as compared to the opinion of accused "not guilty" of such offence as required under the other special enactments. In any case, the degree of satisfaction to be recorded by the Court for opining that there are reasonable grounds for believing that the accusation against the accused is prima facie true, is lighter than the degree of satisfaction to be recorded for considering a discharge application or framing of charges in relation to offences under the 1967 Act……."
10. Thereafter, in the case of K.A.Najeeb Vs. Union of India, reported in (2021) 3 SCC 713, the Hon'ble Supreme Court distinguishing the law laid down in the case of Zahoor Ahmad Shah Watali (supra) held that Courts are expected to appreciate legislative policy against grant of bail but rigour of such provisions will melt down where there is no likelihood of trial being completed within a reasonable time and period of incarceration already
9
undergone has exceeded a substantial part of prescribed sentence. Presence of statutory restrictions like Section 43D(5) of UAPA per se do not oust ability of Constitutional Courts to grant bail on grounds of violation of Part III of Constitution.
11. After considering the decisions passed in the cases of Zahoor Ahmad Shah Watali (supra) and K.A.Najeeb (supra), the Hon'ble Supreme Court in the case of Thwaha Fasal (supra) dealing with the scope of Section 43D(5) of UAPA, held that if Court, after examining material on record, is satisfied that there are no reasonable grounds for believing that accusation against accused is prima facie true, then accused is entitled for bail. The Court while examining the issue of prima facie case as required by sub-section (5) of Section 43-D is neither expected to hold a mini trial nor is supposed to examine the merits and demerits of the evidence. If a charge-sheet is already filed, the Court has to examine the material forming a part of charge-sheet for deciding the issue whether there are reasonable grounds for believing that the accusation against such a person is prima facie true or not. While doing so, the Court has to take the material available in the charge-sheet as it is. Mere association with a terrorist organization as a member or otherwise will not be sufficient to attract offence under Section 38 of UAPA unless association is with an intention to further its activities. Stringent restrictions imposed by sub-section (5) of Section 43D of UAPA, do not negate the powers of Constitutional Court to grant bail keeping in mind violation of Part III of the Constitution.
12. The learned counsel for the NIA relied upon a recent decision of Hon'ble Supreme Court passed in the case of Gurwinder Singh (supra) wherein the Hon'ble Supreme Court has considered its earlier decisions including Zahoor Ahmad Shah Watali (supra) as well as K.A.Najeeb (supra) which deal with interpretation of Section 43D(5). In the said case, the
10
Hon'ble Supreme Court dismissed the appeal challenging the dismissal of the bail application by the trial Court and that was upheld by the High Court. Further, the Hon'ble Supreme Court explained in detail the principles governing consideration of bail application in case under the UAPA. Paragraph 20 to 23 of the said decision reads thus:
"20. In this background, the test for rejection of bail is quite plain. Bail must be rejected as a 'rule', if after hearing the public prosecutor and after perusing the final report or Case Diary, the Court arrives at a conclusion that there are reasonable grounds for believing that the accusations are prima facie true. It is only if the test for rejection of bail is not satisfied - that the Courts would proceed to decide the bail application in accordance with the 'tripod test' (flight risk, influencing witnesses, tampering with evidence). This position is made clear by Sub- section (6) of Section 43D, which lays down that the restrictions, on granting of bail specified in Sub-section (5), are in addition to the restrictions under the Code of Criminal Procedure or any other law for the time being in force on grant of bail. 21. On a textual reading of Section 43 D(5) UAP Act, the inquiry that a bail court must undertake while deciding bail applications under the UAP Act can be summarised in the form of a twin-prong test :
1) Whether the test for rejection of the bail is satisfied?
1.1 Examine if, prima facie, the alleged 'accusations' make out an offence under Chapter IV or VI of the UAP Act
1.2 Such examination should be limited to case diary and final report submitted under Section 173 CrPC;
2) Whether the accused deserves to be enlarged on bail in light of the general principles relating to grant of bail under Section 439 CrPC ('tripod test')?
On a consideration of various factors such as nature of offence, length of punishment (if convicted), age, character, status of accused etc., the Courts must ask itself :
2.1 Whether the accused is a flight risk?
2.2. Whether there is apprehension of the accused tampering with the evidence?
11
2.3 Whether there is apprehension of accused influencing witnesses?
22. The question of entering the 'second test'of the inquiry will not arise if the 'first test'is satisfied. And merely because the first test is satisfied, that does not mean however that the accused is automatically entitled to bail. The accused will have to show that he successfully passes the 'tripod test'.
23. In the previous section, based on a textual reading, we have discussed the broad inquiry which Courts seized of bail applications under Section 43D(5) UAP Act r/w Section 439 Cr.P.C. must indulge in. Setting out the framework of the law seems rather easy, yet the application of it, presents its own complexities. For greater clarity in the application of the test set out above, it would be helpful to seek guidance from binding precedents. In this regard, we need to look no further than Watali's case which has laid down elaborate guidelines on the approach that Courts must partake in, in their application of the bail limitations under the UAP Act. On a perusal of paragraphs 23 to 29 and 32, the following 8-point propositions emerge and they are summarised as follows:
(i) Meaning of 'Prima facie true' [Para 23]: On the face of it, the materials must show the complicity of the accused in commission of the offence. The materials/evidence must be good and sufficient to establish a given fact or chain of facts constituting the stated offence, unless rebutted or contradicted by other evidence.
(ii) Degree of Satisfaction at Pre-Chargesheet, Post Chargesheet and Post-Charges - Compared [Para 23]: Once charges are framed, it would be safe to assume that a very strong suspicion was founded upon the materials before the Court, which prompted the Court to form a presumptive opinion as to the existence of the factual ingredients constituting the offence alleged against the accused, to justify the framing of charge. In that situation, the accused may have to undertake an arduous task to satisfy the Court that despite the framing of charge, the materials presented along with the charge-sheet (report under Section 173 Cr.P.C.) do not make out reasonable grounds for believing that the accusation against him is prima facie true. Similar opinion is required to be formed by the Court whilst considering the prayer for bail, made after filing of the first report made under Section 173 of the Code, as in the present case.
(iii) Reasoning, necessary but no detailed evaluation of evidence [Para 24]: The exercise to be undertaken by the Court at this stage-of giving reasons for grant or non-grant of bail-is markedly different from
12
discussing merits or demerits of the evidence. The elaborate examination or dissection of the evidence is not required to be done at this stage.
(iv) Record a finding on broad probabilities, not based on proof beyond doubt [Para 24]: "The Court is merely expected to record a finding on the basis of broad probabilities regarding the involvement of the accused in the commission of the stated offence or otherwise."
(v) Duration of the limitation under Section 43D(5) [Para 26]: The special provision, Section 43-D of the 1967 Act, applies right from the stage of registration of FIR for the offences under Chapters IV and VI of the 1967 Act until the conclusion of the trial thereof.
(vi) Material on record must be analysed as a 'whole' no piecemeal analysis [Para 27]: The totality of the material gathered by the investigating agency and presented along with the report and including the case diary, is required to be reckoned and not by analysing individual pieces of evidence or circumstance.
(vii) Contents of documents to be presumed as true [Para 27]: The Court must look at the contents of the document and take such document into account as it is.
(viii) Admissibility of documents relied upon by Prosecution cannot be questioned [Para 27]: The materials/evidence collected by the investigation agency in support of the accusation against the accused in the first information report must prevail until contradicted and overcome or disproved by other evidence......In any case, the question of discarding the document at this stage, on the ground of being inadmissible in evidence, is not permissible."
13. Thereafter, the law laid down in the case of Gurwinder Singh (Supra), has been distinguished by the Hon'ble Supreme Court in the case of Sheikh Javed Iqbal (supra) holding that when trial gets prolonged, it is not open to prosecution to oppose bail of accused-under trial on the ground that charges are very serious. Bail cannot be denied only on the ground that charges are very serious though there is no end in sight for trial to conclude. The Constitutional Court cannot be restrained from granting bail to accused on account of restrictive statutory provisions in a penal statute if it finds that right of accused-under trial under Article 21 of Constitution of India has been
13
infringed. Further, Section 43D(5) of UAPA does not oust ability of Constitutional Courts to grant bail on the ground of violation of Part III of the Constitution.
14. Thereafter, the Hon'ble Supreme Court again reiterated the principle in the case of Jalaluddin Khan (supra) wherein it is held that the Court has to examine the material forming part of the charge-sheet to decide whether there are reasonable grounds for believing that the accusations against the person applying for bail are prima facie true. While doing so, the Court must take the charge-sheet as it is . When a case is made out for grant of bail, Courts should not have any hesitation in granting bail. If Courts start denying bail in deserving cases, it will be a violation of rights guaranteed under Article 21 of the Constitution.
15. Recently, The Hon'ble Supreme Court referring the verdict given in Ahmad Shah Watali (supra), K.A.Najeeb (supra), Thwaha Fasal (supra) and Jalaluddin Khan (supra), passed the judgment in the case of Athar Parwez Vs. Union of India, in Criminal Appeal No. 5387 of 2024 [Arising Out Of Slp (Crl) No. 9209 of 2024]
decided On 17-12-2024, and again reiterated and clarified the principle regarding deciding the bail application under UAPA holding that the right to a speedy trial under Article 21 of the Constitution is paramount, and prolonged detention without charges is unconstitutional. Giving precedence to the protection of Fundamental Rights and emphasizing upon their primacy over the statutory provisions in case of delayed trial, in the above judgments, the Hon'ble Court had even gone to the extent of asserting that the seriousness of the crime for which the accused is facing the trial would not be material as an accused is presumed to be innocent until proven guilty.
16. In the light of above referred judgments, we sum-up the legal position by saying that while considering the bail application under UAPA, it is the
14
duty of the Court to be satisfied that there are reasonable grounds for believing that the accusation against the accused is prima facie true or otherwise. By its very nature, the expression "prima facie true" would mean that the material/evidence collected by the investigating agency in order to establish the accusation against the accused concerned in the first information report, must prevail until contradicted or disproved by other evidence, and on the face of it, shows the complicity of such accused in the commission of the alleged offence. It must be sufficient on its face to establish the given facts. The restriction on the powers of the Court to grant bail is less stringent and if the Court, having regard to the material brought before it, is satisfied that in all probability, the accused may not be ultimately convicted, an order granting bail may be passed. What would further be necessary on the part of the Court is to see the culpability of the accused and his involvement in the commission of an organized crime either directly or indirectly. The Court at the time of considering the application for grant of bail shall consider the question from the angle as to whether he was possessed of the requisite mens rea. The Court must consider the nature and manner in which the accused is alleged to have committed the offence. Further, for the purpose of considering an application for grant of bail, although detailed reasons are not necessary to be assigned, but the order granting bail must demonstrate application of mind at least in serious cases as to why the applicant has been granted or denied the privilege of bail. The duty of the Court at this stage is not to weigh the evidence meticulously but to arrive at a finding on the basis of broad probabilities. While deciding the bail, the Court should not conduct a mini-trial to determine the admissibility of certain evidence, which exceeded the limited scope of a bail petition. This not only was beyond the statutory mandate of a prima facie assessment under Section 43-D(5) UAPA, but it was premature and possibly would have prejudiced the trial itself. The findings recorded by the Court
15
while granting or refusing bail undoubtedly would be tentative in nature, which may not have any bearing on the merits of the case and the trial Court would, thus, be free to decide the case on the basis of evidence adduced at the trial, without being prejudiced thereby in any manner.
17. Further, in the referred judgments, the Hon'ble Apex Court has also taken care of the liberty guaranteed by Part III of the Constitution of India which covers not only due procedure and fairness but also access to justice and a speedy trial. The Hon'ble Supreme Court has time and again reiterated that under-trials cannot indefinitely be detained in pending trial even in UAPA. Once it is obvious that a timely trial would not be possible and the accused has suffered incarceration for a significant period of time, the Courts would ordinarily be obligated to enlarge them on bail. The Hon'ble Supreme Court clarified that the presence of statutory restrictions like Section 43-D(5) of the UAPA per-se do not oust the ability of the constitutional Courts to grant bail on grounds of violation of Part III of the Constitution. Whereas, at commencement of proceedings, the Courts are expected to appreciate the legislative policy against grant of bail but the rigorous of such provisions will melt down where there is no likelihood of trial being completed within a reasonable time and the period of incarceration already undergone has exceeded a substantial part of the prescribed sentence.
18. If the above principal is considered more precisely, there are two conditions for granting bail to accused under trial in UAPA; first, if the Court is satisfied that the entire material collected by the investigation agency do not constitute prima facie case against the accused person and investigation agency has failed to show as to whether there are reasonable grounds for believing that the accusation against the accused is prima facie true, and secondly, a timely trial would not be possible and the accused has suffered
16
incarceration for a significant period for a substantial part of prescribed sentence which amounts to violation of his Fundamental Rights.
19. Now adverting to the facts of the case at hand, we are conscious of the fact that the allegations levelled against the appellant are grave and a serious threat to societal harmony. On perusal of charge-sheet, following allegations have been made against the present appellant -
"(I) He was associated with banned terrorist organization, Islamic State of Iraq and Syria (ISIS) alongwith other co-accused persons.
(II) The present appellant was in possession of several incriminating articles viz. violent videos, literature against the democracy and nationalism etc.
(III) The present appellant created a WhatsApp group namely, "Pics", which got renamed by the co-accused Syed Mamoor Ali as "Fisabilillah".
In the said WhatsApp group, accused persons shared the radicalized thoughts.
(IV) The present appellant discussed Shariyah, Jihad, Khilafat and ISIS alongwith other co-accused persons. They also planned to disseminate the ideology of ISIS through Dawah programs and started organizing Dars in Falah Darain Masjid and started radicalizing the persons who came close to them to recruit them in ISIS.
(V) Present appellant took part in offering Dawah (invitation to religious discussion) to people in Penchkari Masjid to spot the radicalized persons to take them into ISIS.
(VI) Present appellant along with other co-accused persons conspired to attack Ordnance Factory, Jabalpur, to procure weapons in large quantity for furtherance of the activities of ISIS.
(VII) Present appellant was the person, who shared the video in the WhatsApp group relating to preparation of explosives in order to capture
17
the Ordnance factory. He also provoked other co-accused persons to prepare the explosives.
(VIII) The present appellant did not have belief in the concepts of Nationalism, Democracy, Principles of Constitution and voting system.
(IX) The present appellant was using the social media account and he used to share derogatory posts on Hindu Deities.
(X) The NIA recovered one audio conversation between present appellant and co-accused Mohd. Adil Khan, wherein both are discussing about Jihad and Jaziya.
20. In order to strengthen their case, the NIA got analysed the phone of present appellant wherein they found the present appellant accessed the telegram Dawlah bot of co-accused Mohd. Adil Khan and downloaded ISIS contents from there. The said videos are pertaining to violent Jihad, suicide bombing, throat cutting, killing of people wearing saffron clothes etc. The present appellant was creator of WhatsApp group, wherein radicalized things were being discussed. The NIA has also recovered the audio clip from the mobile phone of co-accused Adil Khan, wherein the present appellant and co- accused were discussing about the Jihad and Jaziya. The charge-sheet further shows that apart from the videos, various literatures/books against the nationalism and democracy were also found.
21. Further, the investigation agency recorded the statements of various witnesses u/s 161 & 164 of Cr.P.C. denoting them as 'A' to 'H', which indicate entire conspiracy and activities of the present appellant and other accused persons in commission of the alleged crime. The witnesses also stated that the present appellant and other co-accused persons shared the derogatory posts on Hindu Deities. They decided to make explosives from house hold material wherein present appellant took initiative to prepare the same and he provoked others to do so, through which the accused persons wanted to attack Ordnance
18
Factory, Jabalpur. The NIA also procured the CDR report of all the accused persons to show interconnection between them.
22. In view of the above discussion, it is clear that there is sufficient material available in the charge-sheet showing that the appellant has actively participated in and has committed unlawful activities as defined in the UAPA. There is specific material to show that the appellant advocated, abetted, or incited commission of many unlawful activities.
23. The terrorist act is defined in Section 15(1) of UAPA, which inter-alia says that whoever does any act with intent to threaten the unity, integrity, security, economic security or sovereignty of India or with intent to strike terror or likely to strike terror in the people or any section of the people in India or any foreign country by using bombs, dynamite or other explosive substances or inflammable substances or firearms or other lethal weapons or poisonous or noxious gases or other chemical or by any other substances (whether biological radioactive, nuclear or otherwise) of a hazardous nature or by any other means of whatever nature to cause or likely to cause (i) death of, or injuries to, any person or persons, or (ii) loss of, or damage to, or destruction of property, or (iii) disruption of any supplies or services essential to the life of the community in India or in any foreign country; or (iv) damage or destruction of any property in India or in a foreign country used or intended to be used for the defence of India or in connection with any other purposes of the Government of India, any State Government or any of their agencies, commits a terrorist act.
24. The material collected by the NIA shows that the present appellant was the active member of conspiracy by which, the accused persons were going to attack upon Ordnance Factory, Jabalpur, which is an entity of defence. We find sufficient material to show that there was conspiracy to commit a terrorist act to which the appellant was a party. The NIA produced sufficient material
19
on record to show that the appellant was involved in the alleged terrorist acts and other preparatory activities. The accused persons were not only supporting the activities of terrorist organization but also they wanted to stand their own organization with the intention to ruin the Constitution of India.
25. Religious terrorism is a tragic and dangerous phenomenon that distorts the true teachings of faith and causes immense harm to individuals and societies. While the roots of religious terrorism are deep and complex, it is crucial to understand that no religion inherently supports violence or terror.
26. This Court cannot express undue leniency to a person who is facing serious charge of terrorism and unlawful activities. The trial is also set at full motion and there is every possibility of trial being completed in its due course. Therefore, considering the overall facts and circumstances, at this stage, we are not inclined to grant bail to the appellant.
27. Accordingly, the instant Criminal Appeal is hereby dismissed. The order passed by the learned trial Judge, dated 12/04/2024 in SC NIA No. 02 of 2023 is hereby affirmed.
28. However, we make it clear that the findings recorded in this judgment are only for considering the prayer for bail and the learned trial Court may proceed in the case without being prejudiced from any finding given by this Court.
(SUSHRUT ARVIND DHARMADHIKARI) (ANURADHA SHUKLA)
JUDGE JUDGE
skt
20
Alert