- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Fateh Bahadur Dubey And Ors. v. The State Of U.P And Anr.
- 1 -
RESERVED
Court No. - 22 Case :- U/S 482/378/407 No. - 3830 of 2014
Applicant :- Fateh Bahadur Dubey And Ors.
Opposite Party :- The State Of U.P And Anr.
Counsel for Applicant :- Jai Pal Singh
Counsel for Opposite Party :- Govt. Advocate *****
Hon'ble Mahendra Dayal,J.
By means of this application under Section 482 CrPC, the applicants have prayed for quashing of the order dated 19.05.2014 passed by Judicial Magistrate, Ambedkar Nagar in Criminal Case No.116/2013, whereby the application of the applicants for discharge under Section 239 CrPC has been rejected. The applicants have further assailed the judgment and order dated 10.09.2014 passed by Additional Session Judge, Court No.3, Ambedkar Nagar in Criminal Revision No.139/2014, whereby the revision has been dismissed. The case against the applicants was registered on an FIR lodged by the opposite party NO.2 with the allegations that she had some trees at Gata No.100 and on 17.07.2012, the applicants along with some other persons reached at the spot along with a tractor-trolley and picked up the trees while cutting them into pieces. When the opposite party No.2 stopped them from doing so, the applicants not only chased the opposite party No.2 but also threatened her with dire consequences. It is further alleged that the applicants were armed with country made pistol and dangerous weapons. The police registered a case on an application of the opposite party No.2 and after investigation submitted charge-sheet against them. The applicants approached this Court by way of filing an application under Section 482 being Criminal Misc. Case No.268/2013 for quashing of the charge-sheet, which was disposed of by the order dated Neutral Citation No. - 2015:AHC-LKO:8249
- 2 -
12.06.2013 with liberty to the applicants to surrender before the court below and apply for bail. It appears that in pursuance of the aforesaid order, the applicants appeared before the court below and they were consequently released on bail. After being released on bail, they sought their discharge under Section 239 CrPC which after due consideration was refused by the Judicial Magistrate. Learned Additional Session Judge, before whom, the revision against the aforesaid order came up for hearing also dismissed the same on the ground that the order passed by the Magistrate refusing the discharge application was justified.
I have heard learned counsel for the applicants and learned AGA for the State.
The opposite party No.2 was sufficiently served, but no one has appeared on her behalf.
The learned counsel for the applicants has submitted that the applicant No.1 was a recorded tenure holder of Gata No.101 and in the month of May, 2012, the opposite party No.2 illegally grabbed the agricultural land of the applicant No.1 by breaking "Mend". The applicant No.1 filed an application under Section 41 of the Land Revenue Act upon which the Sub-Divisional Magistrate directed the revenue authorities to settle the boundary dispute. In pursuance of the order of the Sub-Divisional Magistrate, Lekhpal and Kanoongo visited the spot and demarcated the land. In retaliation to this, the opposite party No.2 filed a frivolous first information report against the applicants on which the police submitted charge-sheet without their being any evidence against the applicants. Learned revisional court also did not consider the fact that there was absolutely no
- 3 -
evidence to proceed against the applicants but both the courts below declined to discharge the applicants.
Learned AGA appearing on behalf of the State has argued that both the courts below have examined the material on record in detail and have come to the conclusion that there is sufficient evidence against the applicants and thus, the order of both the courts below is perfectly justified. Learned AGA has further submitted that the power under Section 482 CrPC is an extraordinary jurisdiction of this Court which should be exercised in a very rear case, where the Court finds that the prosecution is mala-fide or the continuance of proceedings amounts to abuse of process of law. It is not open for the Courts under the powers of Section 482 CrPC to re-examine and re-assess the evidence and record its own finding of fact.
In a case reported in AIR 2008 SC Page 2778, the Hon'ble Supreme Court has held that while exercising the jurisdiction under Section 482 CrPC, the High Court would not ordinarily embark upon an inquiry as to whether the evidence in question is reliable or not or whether the reasonable on a reasonable appreciation of evidence, accusation would not be sustainable. That is the functioning of a trial Judge. The inherent powers should not be exercised to stifle a legitimate prosecution.
In the instant case, after hearing learned counsel for the parties and having gone through the impugned orders, I am of the view that both the courts below have considered the material on record and have come to the conclusion that there is sufficient evidence to proceed against the applicants. Whether the prosecution story is true or not true is to be decided by the trial court on the basis of the
- 4 -
evidence which would be led during the course of trial. This Court, at this stage, cannot substitute its own finding of fact. In view of what has been discussed above, I am of the view that this application under Section 482 CrPC is devoid of merit and is liable to be dismissed.
In the result, the application under Section 482 CrPC is
dismissed.
Order Date :- 28th May, 2015
Rakesh/-
Alert