- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
KIRAN KUMAR HR v. INCOME TAX DEPARTMENT
1
OA.No.170/00185/2023/CAT/BANGALORE
CENTRAL ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL
BANGALORE BENCH, BENGALURU
ORIGINAL APPLICATION NO.170/00185/2023
ORDER RESERVED ON: 30.09.2024
DATE OF ORDER: 21.10.2024
CORAM:
HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE B.K. SHRIVASTAVA, MEMBER(J) Kiran Kumar HR S/o Shri H. Rajaiah, Aged about 50 years, Sr. TA,
O/o the Jt. Commissioner of Income-tax, Range-3(3), HMT Building, Bangalore- 560032. … Applicant (By Advocate Shri T.C. Gupta)
Vs.
1. Union of India, through the Finance Secretary, Govt. of India, Ministry of Finance, North Block, New Delhi - 110 001.
2. Pr. Chief Commissioner of Income Tax, Karnataka & Goa Region,
Queen Road, Bangalore - 560 001.
3. Director of Income Tax (CPC), Hosur Road, Bangalore - 560 500.
4. Addl. Commissioner of Income Tax, Central Range-2, C.R. Building, Bangalore - 560 001.
2
5. Nishi Padma, Addl. Commissioner of Income Tax (IT), Range -2, BMTC Building,
Koramangala, Bangalore - 560 095. …Respondents (By Shri N. Amaresh, Sr. Panel Counsel for Respondents No. 1 to 4, Respondent No.5 - Ex-parte)
O R D E R
PER: JUSTICE B.K. SHRIVASTAVA, MEMBER (J)
This OA has been filed on 15.05.2023 against the charge sheet dated 26.11.2018 (Annexure - A1), punishment order imposing penalty of "censure" dated 12.03.2021 (Annexure - A2) and the appellate order dated 15.03.2023 (Annexure - A3). The reliefs claimed in para 8 of the O.A. are as under: -
"A} In view of the facts and grounds enumerated above, it is most respectfully prayed that the respondents charge sheet dated 26.11.2018, penalty order dated 12.3.2021 and appeal order dated 15.3.2023, Ann. A/1, A/2 and A/3, being illegal, arbitrary and without jurisdiction, may kindly be quashed and set aside, with all consequential benefits, alongwith interest for the period of delay. B} Any other appropriate writ, order or direction, which may be considered just and proper in the facts and circumstances of the case, may be issued in favour of the Applicant."
3
2. At the time of final arguments on 30.09.2024, the learned counsel for the applicant restricted his arguments only upon the following three grounds: -
"1. The authority who issued the charge sheet was not competent because the appointment order (Annexure - A4) was issued by the Commissioner.
2. Rule 14(18) was not followed by the concerned authorities.
3. The inquiry has been completed beyond the prescribed limitation. For this purpose, the counsel also draws attention towards para 7 of the rejoinder affidavit."
3. It is not in dispute that the charge sheet dated 26.11.2018 (Annexure - A1) was issued under Section 14 of CCS (CCA) Rules, 1965. The Inquiry was conducted as per rules and the minor penalty of censure was imposed upon the applicant by order dated 12.03.2021 (Annexure - A2). Thereafter, the applicant filed OA No. 56/2022 before this Tribunal on 28.01.2022. The aforesaid OA was decided by the Tribunal vide order dated 16.01.2023 (Annexure - A5). In the aforesaid order, the following direction was given by the Tribunal: -
"6. In the given circumstances, we find it appropriate to direct the applicant to prefer an appeal before the appellate authority for redressal of his grievance as provided in the impugned order of the
4
Disciplinary Authority (Annexure A1). If such an appeal is submitted within two weeks from today, the appellate authority shall consider the same on merits without objecting to the period of limitation and shall pass a speaking and reasoned order on merits after providing an opportunity of hearing to the applicant, in an expedite manner, in any event not later than eight weeks from the date of filing of the appeal. Ordered accordingly."
4. In compliance with the aforesaid direction the applicant filed the appeal on 18.01.2023 before the Principal CCIT Bangalore (Annexure - A6). The aforesaid appeal was decided by the concerned appellate authority on 15.03.2023 by order Annexure - A3. The appellate authority came to the conclusion that Rule 14 (18) of CCS (CCA) Rules has not been complied. Therefore, in the appellate order Annexure - A3, the appellate authority remanded the case to the Inquiring authority and stated in para 9.4: -
"9.4 The official contends that the opportunity as per Rule 14(18) of the CCS (CCA) Rules has not been given.
As per Rule 14(18) of CCS (CCA) Rules, 1965, provides that, "the inquiring authority may, after the Government servant closes his case, and shall, if the Government servant has not examined himself, generally question him on the circumstances appearing against him in the evidence for the purpose of enabling the Government servant to explain any circumstances
5
appearing in the evidence against him". This is a formal action required to be taken by the inquiry officer before closing the inquiry. As seen from the Inquiry Report, as per Rule 14(18) of the CCS (CCA) Rules, the Inquiry Officer has not questioned the charged official on the circumstances appearing against him after he has closed his case. A question arises as to whether principles of natural justice (fair hearing in the case) are followed in this case.
As per Rule 27 of the CCS (CCA) Rules, in the case of an appeal against an order imposing any of the penalties specified in Rule 11 or enhancing any penalty imposed under the said rules, the Appellate Authority shall consider:
(a) whether the procedure laid down in these rules have been complied with and if not, whether such non- compliance has resulted in the violation of any provisions of the Constitution of India or in the failure of justice;
(b) whether the findings of the disciplinary authority are warranted by the evidence on the record; and
(c) whether the penalty or the enhanced penalty imposed is adequate, inadequate or severe;
and pass orders-
(i) confirming, enhancing, reducing, or setting aside the penalty; or
(ii) remitting the case to the authority which imposed or enhanced the penalty or to any other authority with such direction as it may deem fit in the circumstances of the case.
Accordingly, as per Rule 27(2)(ii) of the CCS (CCA) Rules, I hereby remit the case to the Inquiring authority with a direction to give him an opportunity of being heard in conformity with Rule 14(18) of the CCS
6
(CCA) Rules. After giving the said opportunity, the Inquiry Officer shall submit the final Inquiry Report to the present Disciplinary Authority i.e. the Pr.CIT, Bengaluru - 3 on or before 28.03.2023 to enable him to pass the final order."
5. In compliance with the aforesaid direction the concerned authority issued the notice dated 27.04.2023 (Annexure - A7). In the aforesaid notice it was stated: -
"सेवा म / To, Shri Kiran Kumar H R Office Superintendent O/o Additional Commissioner of Income Tax, Range-
3(3),
Bengaluru. Sub: Departmental Enquiry into the charges framed against ShriKiran Kumar HR, OS O/o Addl.CIT, Range-3(3), Bengaluru-reg.
कृपयाउपयु कासंदभल/ Kindly refer to the above.
2. A notice is hereby given to you under Rule 14(18) of CCS (CCA) Rules to appear and explain the circumstances appearing in the evidence collected during the course of Disciplinary Proceedings against you. You can also furnish a written submission in this regard. It may be noted that copies of all the evidence collected, statement recorded of various persons during the course of Disciplinary Proceedings was already provided to you. Further, vide order sheet noting dated 08.10.2020 the statements of Tulasi Raju and Poornima recorded on 28.08.2020 and those of Pawan and Ankit Jain recorded on 03.09.2020 and
7
09.09.2020 respectively was provided to you and you were also given an opportunity to offer your response to the same. Vide order sheet noting dated 13.10.2020 you were provided with the statement of Rajesh, ITI and Lammuanlal, ITI recorded on 12.10.2020 and duly accorded an opportunity to your comments on the same. Further you were also provided with the statement of Manjunath G recorded on 27.10.2020 and copy of the statement of Poornima, DEO recorded on 29.10.2020 on your requests for re-examination. Vide order sheet noting file 112020, you have expressed your satisfaction on the manner in which the defence witness were examined and did not want to re-examine any one of them. At here request, you were excused from being present before the Investigating Officer Srinivas Khanna, Deputy Commissioner of Income Tax, which is evident from Para-3 of the order sheet noting dated 05.11.2020. You were also provided with the copy of the statement of the Investigating Officer Srinivas Khanna recorded on 11.11.202 vide order sheet noting dated 17.11.2020. You are also accorded an opportunity to furnish your response to the said statement.
3. It can thus be seen that you have been provided with ample opportunities in accordance with the principal of natural justice to present the circumstances appearing against you in the evidence collected during the coursed of enquiry. However, despite the same, you had taken a plea before the Hon'ble CAT that you had not examined yourself and the IO did not question and pointed out any circumstances against you for explanation.
4. Notwithstanding the above, you are being once again accorded opportunity as per Rule 14(18) of
8
the CCS (CCA) Rules to explain any circumstances appearing in the evidence against you on 03.05.2023 िनिशपदमा / (Nishi Padma)
अपरआयकरआयु / Addl. Commissioner of Income Tax, अंतररा ीयकराधान / International Taxation रज-2, बगलु / Range-2 Bengaluru."
6. The applicant filed the reply dated 01.05.2023 (Annexure - A8) in which he stated: -
"To, Ms. Nishi Padma, Addl. Commissioner of Income-tax (IT), Range-2, BMTC Building,
Koramangala, Bangalore - 560095. Sub: Notice u/r 14(18) dated 27.4.2023 for 3.5.2023 - reg.
Madam,
Please refer to your alleged notice u/r 14(18) of CCS (CCA) Rules dated 27.4.2023 giving date of hearing for 3.5.2023.
2. In this connection, it is submitted that after submitting your inquiry report dated 30.12.2020, your office became Functus Officio. On the basis of your report, final order in the proceedings was also passed on 12.3.2021 by the alleged disciplinary authority. Therefore, now your office has no authority to conduct any further inquiry in the matter.
3. That before the Tribunal, your office was not a party, therefore, has nothing to do with the pleadings filed by the applicant before the Tribunal. Therefore, all the comments made by your office regarding the
9
pleadings before the Tribunal are without jurisdiction and of no consequence.
4. That the time granted in the Pr. CCIT, Bangalore alleged appellate order dated 16.3.2023 to again submit your final inquiry report was upto 28.3.2023, which has expired much ago.
5. That the appellate authority has not pointed out any defect in the inquiry report submitted by you, therefore, there is no ground to conduct any fresh inquiry and submit any further or final report in the matter.
6. That the order of the disciplinary authority has not been set aside by the appellate authority, therefore, submitting any fresh or final inquiry report by you, is of no consequence, as the disciplinary authority cannot pass any fresh order in this case.
7. Finally, as per facts of the case on record as well as your alleged notice, there are no circumstances appearing in the evidence against me, therefore, I am not required to submit any explanation in the matter. Yours faithfully,
Dated: 1.5.2023.
(Kiran Kumar HR)
OS, O/o the Addl. CIT, Range-3(3),
HMT Building, Bangalore"
7. After perusal of the aforesaid documents and the previous order passed by this Tribunal, it appears that this Tribunal vide order dated 16.01.2023 (Annexure - A5) issued the direction to the appellate authority. The applicant was also directed to prefer the appeal before the appellate authority because the applicant came before the Tribunal without filing
10
any departmental appeal. The Court gave the direction to the appellate authority to consider the appeal on merit and pass a speaking and reasoned order.
8. The appeal was preferred by the applicant and the appellate authority decided the aforesaid appeal by Annexure - A3 dated 15.03.2023. In the aforesaid order the appellate authority came to the conclusion that the opportunity as per Rule 14(18) of CCS (CCA) Rules has not been given. In the last para of the aforesaid order the direction was given to the authority in which it was directed to given an opportunity to the applicant as per Rule 14(18) of CCS (CCA) Rules. It is important to mention here that in the aforesaid order it was also mentioned that the Inquiry Officer shall submit the final inquiry report after giving the said opportunity to the disciplinary authority i.e. Principal CCIT Bangalore - 3. Therefore, in other words, it can be said that the Inquiry Officer was directed for giving the aforesaid opportunity and submit his report before the disciplinary authority and thereafter the disciplinary authority was also directed to pass the final order. In the aforesaid situation, the inquiring authority issued the notice (Annexure - A7) to the
11
applicant.Paras 3 & 4 of the aforesaid notice are important. In the aforesaid paras the opportunity was offered to the applicant and the applicant submitted the reply on 01.05.2023 (Annexure -
A8).
9. In the aforesaid situation, a fresh decision was required to be taken by the Inquiry Officer. Thereafter, the Inquiry Officer was already directed to submit his report to the disciplinary authority and the disciplinary authority was under obligation to pass the new order. But before the aforesaid action, the applicant again came before this Tribunal by filing this present OA. In view of this Tribunal, the O.A. is premature. The opportunity is available to the applicant to put his case before the Inquiry Officer in the light of appellate order. Thereafter, the right to appeal again will be available to the applicant if the disciplinary authority will pass the order against the applicant. Because the matter has not been finally decided by the departmental forums therefore, any finding by this Tribunal upon any of three issues raised by the applicant, in this OA, will not be justified and proper. If the fresh order is passed by the disciplinary authority and the appellate authority, then the applicant may file the fresh
12
OA and at that time all issues raised by the applicant may be considered.
10. In the aforesaid situation, the relief claimed cannot be granted. Therefore, this OA is disposed of with the following directions:-
(i) The Inquiry Officer will consider the reply of applicant (Annexure - A8) dated 01.05.2023 in the light of appellate direction and the notice (Annexure - A7) dated 27.04.2023. The authority will also consider the objection, if any raised by the applicant in reference to the Rule 14 (18) of CCS (CCA) Rules related to the proper compliance of the aforesaid rules. The officer will issue the notice to the applicant for appearance before him, within a period of one month from the date of receiving the certified copy of this order and after giving the opportunity of hearing he will submit his report to the disciplinary authority within a period of one month from the date of appearance of the applicant.
(ii) The disciplinary authority will also pass the appropriate order after receiving the report of Inquiry Officer within a period of one month from the date of receiving the aforesaid report.
13
(iii) Thereafter, (if required) the applicant may submit a fresh appeal before the appellate authority, and he will decide the aforesaid appeal (if any) within a period of further one month from the date of filing the aforesaid appeal.
11. The O.A. is disposed of with such direction.
12. Both parties shall bear their own costs.
(JUSTICE B.K. SHRIVASTAVA)
MEMBER (J)
/ms/
Alert