Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Shripal v. Bhartiya Jain Milan Hospital Sardhana And 3 Others

Allahabad High Court
Nov 19, 2024

Neutral Citation No. - 2024:AHC:180635

Court No. - 36 Case :- SECOND APPEAL No. - 752 of 2024

Appellant :- Shripal

Respondent :- Bhartiya Jain Milan Hospital Sardhana And 3 Others

Counsel for Appellant :- Anil Kumar Singh,Dharmendra Singh,Indrajeet Singh,Rajendra Kumar

Hon'ble Kshitij Shailendra,J.

1. Heard Sri Dharmendra Singh, learned counsel for the defendant- appellant and perused the record appended along with the memo of appeal and stay application.

2. The appellant was defendant in a suit for eviction. Both the courts below have concurrently decided the lis against him directing his dispossession.

3. Assailing the impugned decrees, it is contended by the learned counsel for the appellant that the appellant was a Ward-Boy and his wife was Ward-Maid in Bharathi Jain Milan Hospital, Sardhana, District Meerut. Services of both the persons were terminated. Whereas, the appellant's services were terminated in 2003 and lis praying for reinstatement and other reliefs is still pending before the Labour Court, in so far as the appellant's wife is concerned, in her writ petition being No.56854 of 2005, an order was passed staying operation of the award passed by the Labour Court, subject to certain conditions including reinstatement. Further contention is that when the order of the writ court was not complied with, another writ petition being No.23508 of 2007 was filed, which is pending. He, therefore, submits that so long as the lis in relation to the appellant's wife is not decided, decree of ejectment should not be executed, inasmuch as both husband and wife are residing in the same accommodation.

1

4. Having heard learned counsel for the appellant, this Court finds that the documents relating to the services of either husband or wife including the orders passed by the Labour Court and the writ court in all the proceedings were not brought on record. There is no discussion of these orders in either of the orders impugned and learned counsel for the appellant has admitted this fact that these documents could not be brought on record as the appellant was not properly advised.

5. Be that as it may, second appeal arises out of an appellate decree and consideration of those documents cannot be made which did not form part of the record of the trial court and first appellate court, unless, for the reasons recorded, an application under Order

41 Rule 27 CPC read with Order 42 Rule 1 CPC is filed and is allowed. There being no such application in the instant case, the documents on which arguments were based cannot be entertained by this Court.

6. Even otherwise, admittedly, the appellant is more than 70 years of age and his wife is also more than 65 years of age. Both these persons have already crossed the age of superannuation and there is no dispute that accommodation in dispute was given to them in connection with the services in the hospital. As these persons have already been terminated from services, this Court is of the considered view that both the courts below have not erred in granting decree for ejectment.

7. No substantial question of law arises for consideration.

8. The appeal has no merit and is, accordingly, dismissed under Order 41 Rule 11 CPC.

Order Date :- 19.11.2024 AKShukla/-

2