Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

AHMED MANSOOR v. THE STATE REP. BY

Madras High Court
Oct 1, 2024
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioners—Ahmed Mansoor, Hameed Hussain, and Abdur Rahman—filed a writ petition under Article 226 of the Constitution of India challenging the legality and constitutionality of their arrest and subsequent remand dated 23.05.2024 in connection with Crime No.173 of 2024 registered by the first respondent, the Assistant Commissioner of Police, Cyber Crime Branch, Chennai. The second respondent, the Union of India represented by the Inspector of Police, National Investigation Agency, was impleaded later. The arrests arose from allegations that the second petitioner, leader of the Hizb-ut-Tahrir organisation, incited young Islamists via his YouTube channel to overthrow the democratic government, invoking offences under Sections 34, 153B IPC and Section 13 of the Unlawful Activities (Prevention) Act, 1967 (UAPA). The petitioners contend that mandatory procedural requirements under Section 43B of UAPA and Section 41A CrPC were not complied with prior to their arrests, rendering the arrests illegal.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the arrest and subsequent remand of the petitioners in connection with Crime No.173 of 2024 were illegal and unconstitutional for non-compliance with Section 43B of the UAPA and Section 41A of the Code of Criminal Procedure.
  2. Whether the grounds of arrest were properly communicated in writing to the petitioners as mandated by the Supreme Court in Prabir Purkayastha v. State (NCT Delhi) 2024 INSC 414 and related precedents.
  3. Whether oral communication of grounds of arrest suffices to meet constitutional and statutory requirements under Article 22(1) of the Constitution and Section 43B of the UAPA.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioners' Arguments

  • The grounds of arrest under Section 43B of the UAPA were not served in writing prior to arrest, violating mandatory procedural safeguards.
  • No Section 41A notice was issued by the competent authority before arresting the petitioners.
  • Oral communication of grounds of arrest is insufficient and contrary to the Supreme Court’s rulings in Prabir Purkayastha v. State (NCT Delhi) and Pankaj Bansal v. Union of India 2023 INSC 866.
  • The failure to comply with these procedural requirements renders the arrest illegal, unconstitutional, and violative of the petitioners’ fundamental rights.

Respondents' Arguments

  • The arrest procedures under both the Code of Criminal Procedure and UAPA were scrupulously followed by the police.
  • The remand requisition report containing the grounds of arrest was served to the petitioners and orally explained by the police officer concerned in the presence of the petitioners’ counsel.
  • The learned Magistrate recorded the service of the remand requisition report and passed the remand order accordingly.
  • Compliance with Article 22(1) of the Constitution and Section 43B of UAPA was achieved by informing the petitioners of the grounds of arrest, which suffices under the law as interpreted in Vijay Madanlal Choudhary v. Union of India (2022) SCC OnLine SC 929.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Prabir Purkayastha v. State (NCT Delhi) 2024 INSC 414 Mandatory written communication of grounds of arrest under Section 43B of UAPA; grounds must convey basic facts to allow defense and bail application. The Court relied on this precedent to analyze whether the petitioners were provided written grounds of arrest before remand, distinguishing the present facts from the cited case.
Pankaj Bansal v. Union of India 2023 INSC 866 Oral reading or explanation of grounds of arrest is insufficient; written grounds must be furnished to fulfill constitutional and statutory mandates. Supported the Court’s conclusion that written grounds of arrest are constitutionally required and must be furnished to the arrested person.
V.Senthil Balaji v. The State (2023) SCC OnLine SC 934 Reinforces the necessity of furnishing written grounds of arrest to the arrested person to protect constitutional rights. Referenced to emphasize the constitutional and statutory protections regarding communication of grounds of arrest.
Vijay Madanlal Choudhary v. Union of India (2022) SCC OnLine SC 929 Informs that informing the arrested person of grounds of arrest suffices for Article 22(1) compliance. Respondents relied on this case to argue that oral and written communication together satisfy the constitutional requirement.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court examined the statutory language of Section 43B(1) of the UAPA, which requires that the arresting officer inform the arrested person of the grounds for arrest "as soon as may be." It noted that the Supreme Court in Prabir Purkayastha clarified that written grounds of arrest must be provided to enable the accused to defend against custodial remand and seek bail, distinguishing between "grounds of arrest" and "reasons of arrest." The Court acknowledged the petitioners’ contention that oral communication alone is insufficient, supported by Supreme Court precedents.

However, the Court found the facts of the present case distinguishable from Prabir Purkayastha. Here, the petitioners were not only orally informed but were also served with the remand requisition report containing detailed written grounds of arrest prior to remand, in the presence of their counsel. The petitioners themselves produced the remand requisition report in the writ petition, evidencing compliance. The Court also noted that the special provisions of UAPA prevail over the general provisions of the Code of Criminal Procedure (Section 48 UAPA).

Accordingly, the Court concluded that the fundamental rights under Article 22(1) of the Constitution and the procedural safeguards under Section 43B of the UAPA were complied with in this case. There was no procedural irregularity or infirmity in effecting the arrest and remand of the petitioners.

Holding and Implications

The writ petition is dismissed.

The Court held that the arrest and remand of the petitioners complied with the constitutional and statutory requirements, including the mandatory communication of grounds of arrest in writing under Section 43B of the UAPA. The decision results in the petitioners remaining in custody as per the criminal process. No new precedent was set; the ruling reaffirms existing Supreme Court jurisprudence and underscores the necessity of furnishing written grounds of arrest, but finds compliance in the present facts.

Show all summary ...

W.P.No.17007 of 2024

IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT MADRAS

DATED: 01.10.2024

CORAM :

THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE S.M.SUBRAMANIAM

AND

THE HON'BLE MR.JUSTICE V.SIVAGNANAM W.P.No.17007 of 2024

1. Ahmed Mansoor S/o Shahul Hameed

2. Hameed Hussain S/o Ahmed Mansoor

3. Abdur Rahman S/o Ahmed Mansoor .. Petitioners

v.

1. The State represented by Assistant Commissioner of Police Cyber Crime Branch

CCB, Vepery, Chennai

(Ref: Cr.No.173/2024)

2. Union of India rep.by its Inspector of Police

National Investigation Agency Branch Office, Chennai Purasaivakkam, Chennai 600 010 (Ref.RC-02/2024/NIA/CHE)

Page 1 of 13

(R2 impleaded vide order of Court dated 23.08.2024 in WMP.26473/2024 in WP.17007/2024) .. Respondents

Writ Petition filed under Article 226 of the Constitution of India, praying for issuance of a Writ of Declaration, declaring the arrest and the subsequent remand dated 23.05.2024 of the petitioners in connection with Cr.No.173 of 2024 on the files of the first respondent as illegal, unconstitutional and against the law laid down by the Hon'ble Apex Court in Prabir Purkayastha vs State (NCT Delhi) 2024 INSC 414 and consequently direct the immediate release of the petitioners from the custody in connection with Cr.No.173 of 2024 dated 21.05.2024 on the file of the first respondent.

For Petitioners :: Mr.I.Abdul Basith

For Respondents :: Mr.E.Raj Thilak

Additional Public Prosecutor for R1

Mr.AR.L.Sundaresan

Additional Solicitor General of India

assisted by Mr.R.Karthikeyan

Special Public Prosecutor for R2

ORDER

(Order of the Court was made by S.M.SUBRAMANIAM,J.) W.M.P.No.18741 of 2024 seeking to permit the petitioners to file a single writ petition stands allowed.

Page 2 of 13

2. The present writ of declaration has been instituted to declare the arrest and the subsequent remand dated 23.05.2024 of the petitioners in connection with Crime No.173 of 2024 on the file of the first respondent as illegal, unconstitutional and violative of the legal proposition laid down by the Hon'ble Apex Court in Prabir Purkayastha vs State (NCT Delhi) 2024 INSC 414 and to release the petitioners from the custody in connection with Crime No.173 of 2024.

3. The first respondent registered a First Information Report in Crime No.173 of 2024 on 21.05.2024 against the second petitioner for the alleged offence under Sections 34, 153B of Indian Penal Code and Section 13 of the Unlawful Activities (Prevention) Act, 1967 (hereinafter referred to as "the UAPA"). It is alleged that the second petitioner is the leader of Hizb-ut- Tahrir (HuT) organisation, which is banned in several countries across the world. The police claim that through his YouTube channel, "Dr.Hameed Hussain Talks", the second petitioner incites young Islamists to secretly implement Islamic rule to overthrow the democratic government in India.

Page 3 of 13

4. On 23.05.2024 at 6.05 A.M., the police arrested the second petitioner at his residence. The police interrogated the second petitioner and formed an opinion that the petitioners 1 & 3 were accomplices. Subsequently, the first and third petitioners, who are the father and brother of the second petitioner respectively, were arrested at their residence at 6.55 A.M., on the same day and were listed as A2 and A3 in the First Information Report.

5. The learned counsel for petitioners Mr.Abdul Basith would mainly raise two issues to declare the arrest of the petitioners as illegal. Firstly, the grounds of arrest, as contemplated under Section 43B of UAPA, had not been served on the petitioners before arrest. Secondly, Section 41A notice had not been issued by the competent authority. These two requirements are mandatory, both under the UAPA and as per the ratio laid down by the Hon'ble Supreme Court of India in the case of Prabir Purkayastha v. State (NCT Delhi) reported in 2024 INSC 414 and in the case of Pankaj Bansal v. Union of India reported in 2023 INSC 866.

Page 4 of 13

6. Mr.Abdul Basith would mainly contend that the Supreme Court in unequivocal terms held that the grounds of arrest must be served in writing to the persons sought to be arrested under Section 43B of UAPA, which has not been complied with in the present case. In this context, he would rely on the observations made by the Apex Court in the two cases cited supra. It is further contended that the oral information provided to the petitioners regarding the grounds of arrest would be insufficient and would result in non-compliance of the ratio laid down by the Supreme Court. Thus the arrest is to be declared as illegal and violative of the legal proposition laid down by the Supreme Court in the cases cited supra.

7. The learned Additional Public Prosecutor Mr.Raj Thilak appearing on behalf of the first respondent would submit that the procedures as contemplated were scrupulously followed by the first respondent while executing arrest. The remand requisition report had been served to the petitioners and before serving, the contents therein were also explained orally to the petitioners by the police officer concerned. At the time of providing information and serving of the remand requisition report, the

Page 5 of 13

counsel for the petitioners Mr.A.Rawther Naina Mohamed was also present. The learned Magistrate recorded the same and passed an order of remand thereof. That being so, the procedures as contemplated both under the Code of Criminal Procedure and under the UAPA have been complied with and thus the present writ petition is to be rejected.

8. The learned Additional Solicitor General of India Mr.AR.L.Sundaresan appearing on behalf of the second respondent would submit that the Supreme Court, while interpreting the scope of Section 43B of UAPA, held that the grounds for arrest must be informed in writing to the persons sought to be arrested. The objective of the interpretation is to achieve the purpose for which the provision contemplates that the grounds for such arrest is to be informed to the persons. In Vijay Madanlal Choudhary v. Union of India reported in (2022) SCC OnLine SC 929, the Supreme Court held that so long as the person is informed of the grounds of his/her arrest, that would be sufficient compliance with the mandate of Article 22(1) of the Constitution. It is further reiterated that Article 22(1) of the Constitution provides inter alia that no person who is arrested shall be

Page 6 of 13

detained in custody without being informed, as soon as may be, of the grounds for such arrest.

9. Let us now consider the language employed in Section 43B of UAPA, which deals with procedure of arrest, seizure, etc. Sub-section (1) stipulates that "any officer arresting a person under Section 43A shall, as soon as may be, inform him of the grounds for such arrest". Though the language employed under Section 43B(1) is "as soon as may be inform him of the grounds for such arrest", the Apex Court interpreted in order to ensure that the object of such a provision is sought to be achieved by informing the person of the grounds for arrest.

10. The question arises whether oral information regarding the grounds of arrest would be sufficient. In this context, it is relevant to rely on the case cited by the petitioners in Prabir Purkayastha supra. The Supreme Court has held in paragraph-49 that the grounds of arrest informed in writing must convey to the arrested accused all basic facts on which he was being arrested so as to provide him an opportunity to defend himself against the

Page 7 of 13

custodial remand and to seek bail. Thus the mere "grounds of arrest" would invariably be personal to the accused and cannot be equated with the

"reasons of arrest" which are general in nature. The Apex Court distinguished the "grounds of arrest" and the "reasons of arrest". The distinguishable factors are clarified in paragraph-50 of the said judgment, which reads as under:-

"50. From the detailed analysis made above, there is no hesitation in the mind of the Court to reach to a conclusion that the copy of the remand application in the purported exercise of communication of the grounds of arrest in writing was not provided to the accused appellant or his counsel before passing of the order of remand dated 4th October, 2023 which vitiates the arrest and subsequent remand of the appellant."

11. In Pankaj Bansal's case, the Supreme Court in paragraph-32 referred to the case of V.Senthil Balaji v. The State represented by Deputy Director and others reported in (2023) SCC OnLine SC 934 and held that the grounds of arrest readout and explained to the person would be insufficient. Importantly it is observed that the very purpose of this

Page 8 of 13

constitutional and statutory protection would be rendered nugatory by permitting the authorities concerned to merely readout or permit reading of the grounds of arrest, irrespective of their length and detail, and claim due compliance with the constitutional requirement under Article 22(1) and the statutory mandate under Section 19(1) of the Prevention of Money- laundering Act, 2002. In paragraph-35, it is observed that to give true meaning and purpose to the constitutional and the statutory mandate of Section 19(1) of Prevention of Money-laundering Act of informing the arrested person of the grounds of arrest, it would be necessary henceforth that a copy of such written grounds of arrest is furnished to the arrested person as a matter of course and without exception.

12. Thus we have no doubt that the grounds of arrest must not only be orally informed, but the grounds of arrest must be given in writing to the persons sought to be arrested.

13. The question arises whether the first respondent in the present case had complied with the provisions of Section 43B of UAPA and in

Page 9 of 13

consonance with the interpretation made by the Supreme Court in the cases cited supra, more specifically, in the case of Prabir Purkayastha.

14. Reading the facts of the case in Prabir Purkayastha, it is found that indisputably First Information Report No.224 of 2023 came to be registered on 17thAugust, 2023 in the said case decided by the Supreme Court. The copy of the First Information Report was never brought in the public domain, as the same was not uploaded in the website by the investigating agency. This exactly is the reason why the Supreme Court in paragraph-50 of the judgment clarified that the copy of the remand application in the purported exercise of communication of the grounds of arrest in writing was not provided to the accused in the said case or to his counsel before passing the order of remand.

15. However, in the present case, the facts are distinguishable. In the present case, the petitioners were not only orally informed about the grounds of arrest, but the grounds of arrest contained in the remand requisition report was served to the petitioners and they have acknowledged the same, which

Page 10 of 13

had been produced by the petitioners themselves in the typedset filed in the present writ petition. The counsel for the petitioners was present before the learned Magistrate at the time of receiving the remand requisition report which would contain the grounds of arrest. A perusal of the remand requisition report reveals that the grounds of arrest are stated elaborately which, in our opinion, would be sufficient to form an opinion that the grounds of arrest as required under Section 43B with reference to the ratio laid down by the Supreme Court in the judgments cited supra, have been complied with.

16. It is unnecessary to reiterate that the provisions of special enactment would prevail over the general law. Section 48 of the UAPA stipulates the effect of the Act and Rules inconsistent with other enactments. Accordingly, the provisions of UAPA would prevail over the Code of Criminal Procedure, which is a general law and in the present case, the grounds of arrest made available in the remand requisition report was served on the petitioners before arrest in the presence of their lawyer and thus we have no hesitation to arrive at a conclusion that the fundamental rights

Page 11 of 13

enshrined under Article 22(1) of the Constitution along with Section 43B of the UAPA had been complied with and thus we do not find any infirmity or procedural irregularity in effecting the arrest of the petitioners in the case in Crime No.173 of 2024. Thus the writ petition fails and stands dismissed. Consequently, W.M.P.No.18742 of 2024 is also dismissed. No costs. Index : yes/no (S.M.S.,J.) (V.S.G.,J.)

Neutral citation : yes/no 01.10.2024

ss

To

1. The Assistant Commissioner of Police Cyber Crime Branch

CCB, Vepery, Chennai

2. The Inspector of Police National Investigation Agency Branch Office, Chennai Purasaivakkam

Chennai 600 010

3. The Public Prosecutor High Court, Madras

4. The Special Public Prosecutor for NIA cases High Court, Madras

Page 12 of 13

S.M.SUBRAMANIAM,J.

AND

V.SIVAGNANAM,J.

ss

W.P.No.17007 of 2024

01.10.2024

Page 13 of 13