- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Surendra Mohan Bist v. State Of Chhattisgarh and Ors
1 / 10
NAFR
HIGH COURT OF CHHATTISGARH AT BILASPUR
WPC No. 562 of 2013
Order reserved on 15/10/2024 Order passed on 25/10/2024
• Surendra Mohan Bist S/o Hoshiyar Singh Aged About 50 Years R/o Vill Pil Champa, Distt Janjgir Champa, Cg, Chhattisgarh
... Petitioner versus
1. State of Chhattisgarh and Ors S/o Through Secretary Dpett Of Revenue, Mahanadi Bhawan, Naya Raipur, Ps Mandir Hasaud, Raipur, Dist Raipur, Chhattisgarh
2. Land Acquistion Officer/s.D.O.,champa Distt. Janjg Champa P.S. Chmpa C.G.
3. Municpal Council Champa , Through Chief Municipal Officr Chmpa , P.S. Champa , Distt. Janjgir -Champa , C.G.
4. M/s Prakesh Industriers Chamapa Through Genreal Manager, P.S. Champa, Distt. Janjgir - Champa , C.G.
5. Joint Director, Town And Country Planning, Bilaspur, Collectorate Campus, P.S Civil Line Bilapur, distt. Bilaspur,
C.G.
... Respondents
For Petitioner : Mr. Siddharth Ojha on behalf of Mr. Rakesh Kumar Jha, Advocate.
For Respondent/State
For Respondent No.5
:
:
Mr. D.K. Singh, Panel Lawyer. Mr. Abhishek Sinha, Senior Advocate assisted by Ms. Khusboo Dua, Advocate.
1
Hon'ble Shri Justice Amitendra Kishore Prasad CAV Order
1. The petitioner is challenging acquisition proceedings as well as the award passed by the Land Acquisition Officer-cum-SDO Champa, District - Janjgir Champa for the land bearing Khasra No. 1756/2T area 0.03 acres (121.56) square meter situated at Railway Colony Champa in Patwari Halka No.2. according to the petitioner he has purchased the aforesaid land vide registered sale deed dated 30.03.2006 and after taking due permission he has constructed the house upon the same on 19.03.2013, when an application was moved by the petitioner for demarcation for the said land, for the first time he was informed that his land has been acquired by the State Government for construction of Rail line for M/s. Prakash Industries, Champa and award has also been passed on 30.12.2010.
2. According to petitioner no opportunity was granted to him for raising his objection and he could not aware about the acquisition proceedings and the respondents authorities in contravention of Section 9(2) and Section 12(2) of the Land Acquisition Act, 1984 has proceeded for acquisition of the land, the petitioner has invested huge amount in construction of three storyed house however, none of the authorities have informed him about the acquisition as such the entire acquisition proceeding in the respect of the land of the petitioner is required to be quashed. It was urged by the petitioner that no notice has been issued to him by the Land
2
Acquisition Officer as such he could not aware about the acquisition proceeding and for the first time when he applied for demarcation on 19.03.2013, thereafter facts regarding acquisition of the land was revealed. The petitioner by way of this petition is seeking following reliefs:-
10.1 That, this Hon'ble Court may, kindly, be pleased to pass an appropriate writ, order or direction quashing the entire proceeding of land Acquisition in Land Acquisition Case No. 1A-82/08-09 in respect of lands of petitioner bearing Khasra No. 1756/2T, area 0.03 acre Patwari Halka No. 02, Ward No.17, Near Railway Station Champa, District - Janjgir-Champa (Chhattisgarh) and quashing the award dated 30.12.2010, in respect of the lands of the petitoner bearing Khasra No. 1756/2 T, area
0.03 acre Patwari Halka No. 2, Ward No. 17, Near Railway Station Champa, District - Janjgir-Champa (Chhattisgarh)
10.2 Any other relief which this Court deems fit under the facts of the case including the cost of the petition.
3. Mr. Siddharth Ojha, learned counsel for the petitioner submits that without complying provisions under Section 9(2) and 12(2) of the Act of 1984, the acquisition proceedings have been completed which is perse illegal. The petitioner was not noticed before acquisition of land, no objections were called and behind the back of the petitioner the proceedings have been initiated as such prime facie the award passed in respect of land of the petitioner is not in accordance with law and the land acquisition proceeding so far it relates to the petitioner is concerned is required to be quashed. The learned counsel for the petitioner has placed reliance upon a judgment of Hon'ble Supreme Court in the matter of Kolkata Municipal Corporation and Ors. Vs Vimal Kumar Shah and Ors. reported in 2024 SCC Online Supreme Court 968.
3
4. On the other hand learned State counsel has objected the submissions advanced by the learned counsel for the petitioner and it was argued that due procedure has been followed by the Land Acquisition Officer everything has been within the specific knowledge of the petitioner, notices have been issued, objections were called and after due process award dated 30.12.2010 was passed in respect of above 65 persons hence, it is incorrect to say that the petitioner has not been informed and land acquisition proceedings were against the procedure of law.
5. Mr. Abhishek Sinha, Senior Advocate assisted by Ms. Khusboo Dua, counsel for respondent No. 5 has submitted that entire proceedings of land acquisition has been carried out by following due procedure of law, everything was black and white, the petitioner was aware about the acquisition proceedings however, only for the petitioner the land acquisition proceedings can not be quashed. Everyone except the petitioner have accepted the award passed by the Land Acquisition Officer. The land was acquired for public purpose, as a Railway track has been constructed over the same and the land was acquired way back in the year 2010 and after laps of about 14 years only on the basis of singular objection raised by the petitioner entire proceedings of acquisition can not be quashed. The petitioner has been given due opportunity of hearing, everything has been complied as per Land Acquisition Act 1894. It was further submitted that only for the sake of one petitioner even if he was not aware about the land acquisition proceedings the
4
acquisition can not be held tobe bad in law. He also submit that in the matter of May George vs special Tehsildaar and Ors.
reported in 2010(13) SCC 98. The supreme Court has held that when the acquisition of large portion of land belonging to different persons has been challenged after possession taken by the State by one person owning negligible area of the total acquired area on allegation that she was not served with the notice under Section 9(3) the entire land acquisition proceeding can not be quashed likewise in the matter of Mutha Associates and Ors vs State of Maharashtra and Ors. reported in
(2013)14 SCC 304 while considering view taken by the constitution Bench of Supreme Court in the matter of Aflatoon vs. Lt. Governor of Delhi reported in (1975) 4 SCC 285, the Supreme Court has considered various judgments in which it has been held that the failure of interested persons to seek redress at an appropriate stage and without undue delay would in such cases give rise to an interference that they have waived of their objections to the acquisitions and it was submitted that the petition is sense merits and same is liable to be set-aside.
6. I have heard learned counsel for the parties and have gone through with the documents annexed with the petition as well as reply filed by the concerned respondents and perused the records of the case.
7. From the records, it appears that vide award dated 30.12.2010 a junk of land has been acquired by the Land Acquisition Officer and all the persons whose land have been acquired have
5
received their compensation and accordingly except the petitioner no one has objected for acquisition of their land. A very small piece of land in respect of the petitioner can not be excluded from a large junk of the land at present, as the entire land which was acquired for public purpose. In the matter of
Kolkata Municipal Corporation (Supra) as cited by the petitioner the Supreme Court has directed the Land Acquisition Officer to pay compensation whereas in the present petition award has already been calculated in respect of land of the petitioner however, he has not withdrawn the same that will not give a right to the petitioner to get the entire proceedings quashed only for his land as such the judgment cited by the petitioner is of no help to him because as many as lands of 65 persons were acquired and all they have been granted compensation however, except by the petitioner. In the matter of
May George(Supra) the Supreme Court has held as under-
8. Land measuring 30.80 acres stood notified and acquired. The land consisted of large survey numbers and belonged to a large number of persons. It is not the case of the appellant that the notification under Section 4 and declaration under Section 6 were not published or given publicity as mandatorily required under the law:
Once award was made and possession had been taken, land stood vested in the State free from all encumbrances, it cannot be divested even if some irregularity is found in the award. As huge area of land had been acquired for planned development of industrial town. the land of the appellant cannot be exempted on any ground whatsoever. More so, the appellant's land was of negligible area in comparison to the total land acquired and therefore, at the behest of only one person, the acquisition proceedings cannot be disturbed. 9.Admittedly, acquisition proceedings/award have been challenged at a belated stage after a decade of taking possession of the land in dispute. In the facts and circumstances of this case, it is difficult to presume that the appellant had no knowledge of the acquisition proceedings.
14. Section 9 of the Act provides for an opportunity to the
"person interested" to file a claim petition with
6
documentary evidence for determining the market value of the land and in case a person does not file a claim under Section 9 even after receiving the notice, he still has a right to g make an application for making a reference under Section 18 of the Act. Therefore, the scheme of the Act is such that it does not cause any prejudicial consequence in case the notice under Section 9(3) is not served upon the person interested.
26. The instant case is required to be examined in the light of the aforesaid settled legal provision. In fact, failure of issuance of notice under Section 9(3) would not adversely affect the subsequent proceedings including the award and title of the Government in the acquired land. So far as the person interested is concerned, he is entitled only to receive the compensation and therefore, there may be a large number of disputes regarding the apportionment of the compensation. In such an eventuality, he may approach the Collector to make a reference to the Court under Section 30 of the Act. 28.In fact, the land vests in the State free from all encumbrances when a possession is taken under Section 16 of the Act. Once land is vested in the State, it cannot be divested even if there has been some irregularity in the acquisition proceedings. In spite of the fact that Section 9 notice had not been served upon the person interested, he could still claim the compensation and ask for making the reference under Section 18 of the Act. There is nothing in the Act to show that non-compliance therewith will be fatat or visit any b penalty.
29. In fact, the land vests in the State free from all encumbrances when a possession is taken under Section 16 of the Act. Once land is vested in the State, it cannot be divested even if there has been some irregularity in the acquisition proceedings. In spite of the fact that Section 9 notice had not been served upon the person interested, he could still claim the compensation and ask for making the reference under Section 18 of the Act. There is nothing in the Act to show that non-compliance therewith will be fatat or visit any b penalty.
8. Likewise in the matter of Mutha Associates (Supra) alongwith connected petitions vide para 22 the Supreme Court has held as under:-
22.The view taken by the Constitution Bench in Aflatoon case has been reiterated by another Constitution Bench decision in Indrapuri Griha Nirman Sahakari Samiti Ltd.
v. State of Rajasthan. To the same effect are the d decisions of this Court in Municipal Corpn. of Greater Bombay v. Industrial Development Investment Co. (P) Ltd., Ramjas Foundation v. Union of Indias and Larsen & Toubro Ltd. v. State of Gujarat. The common thread that runs through all these decisions is that in order to succeed in a challenge to the acquisition proceedings the interested person must remain vigilant and watchful. If instead of doing so, the interested person allows grass to grow under his feet, he cannot invoke the powers of judicial review exercisable under Article 226 of the Constitution. The failure of the interested persons to seek
7
redress at the appropriate stage and without undue delay would in such cases give rise to an inference that they have waived of their objections to the acquisitions. The bottom line is that the High Court can legitimately decline to invoke their powers of judicial review to interfere with the acquisition f proceedings under Article 226 of the Constitution if the challenge to such proceedings is belated and the explanation offered a mere moonshine as is the position in the case at hand. The High Court has in the fact situation of this case rightly exercised its discretion in refusing to interfere with the acquisition proceedings.
9. Now while examining the present case in light of judgment rendered by the Supreme Court, I am not in hesitation in holding that the land acquisition proceeding is not required to be quashed only on the basis of one objection raised by one person out of 65 persons even if notices were not served upon the petitioner for there is any other alimony in execution proceedings. The constitution bench in Aflatoon's case has been retreated by another Constitution Bench decision in Indrapuri Grih Nirman Sehkari Samiti vs State of Rajasthan reported in 1975 SCC (4) 296. In all the constitution Bench decision the person interested should be vigilant and watchful. The petitioner can not invoke powers of judicial review under Article
226 Constitution of India, in a belated stage.
10. In the present case the entire land has been given to the respondent No.5 M/s Prakash Industries Champa and only on the basis of one person the entire project can not be canceled a solitary objection has made by the petitioner can not be a ground to quash the entire land acquisition proceedings as held by the Supreme Court, even if Section 9, notice has not been served upon the persons interested he could still claim compensation and ask for making reference under Section 18 of
8
the Act. There is nothing in the Act that non compliance of Section 9 will be fetal or visit any penalty, it appears that the petitioner was well known about the acquisition proceedings however, purposely he has not approached before the authorities and has not raised any objection at the time of acquisition proceedings and after acquisition of the land in the year 2010 he has started filing applications while raising objection which can not be termed to be bonafied one. In light of decision rendered by Supreme Court I am of the view that the petitioner has failed to make out the case for interference under Article 226 of the Constitution of India. Accordingly, the writ petition fails and it is hereby dismissed however, the petitioner is at liberty to approach the concerned Land Acquisition Officer while filing an application under Section 18 of the Act in which the Land Acquisition Officer can decide the matter in accordance with law.
11. At this juncture it has been submitted by the petitioner that he has constructed three storied house in the land in question and residing their with his family members. There was an order of stay granted by this Hon'ble Court vide order dated 21.11.2023 by which an order of status quo was granted as such the petitioner alongwith his family member is residing with in the said house hence, the respondent authorities may be directed not to take any coercive steps until the application under Section 18 of the Act is decided.
9
12. The respondent/State as well as respondent No. 6 are directed not to take any coercive step till the decision of application under Section 18 of the decided or the petitioner get the compensation calculated by the respondent authorities along with interest.
13. The respondent authorities are also directed to deicide the application under Section 18 within a period of three months and in case the application is not filed within such period, calculate the compensation in accordance with law including the house constructed upon the land in dispute and to disburse the compensation to the petitioner as expeditiously preferably within a period of three months.
14.With aforesaid observations and directions the instant writ petition is disposed of.
Sd/-
(Amitenedra Kishore Prasad )
Judge
vaishali
10
Alert