Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Vashrambhai Mohanbhai Kukvav v. Dr Pinak Vadaliya

District Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission
Oct 21, 2024

G.4.yt, il-st22(lksl& Compiain Ne 152024 'age | of 10 4S-9-20X

2S-0q-2028

21-4O-R02

::2YER

Judgnent Exh-13

1

UAell

3L.

S

OO/- fudgment xh

-13 Iage 2 ot 10 Complan No

15/2024 rc¥lY

AUL

3L

.1000/-3ll-i

2

1.

3.

8.

u.

S.

3

(3) igsa?

(4) 15RHS

Complan No. I5/2024 Page 3 of I9 Judgmenl Exh -13

3

151RlrHS

(R)

lg4

(3)

9. c. Jdgment Exh13 Lomplan No 152024

4

A

e.

SINGH

(2021) 10 Supreme Court Cases 291

(BEFORE HEMANT GUPTA AND A.S. BOPANNA, JJ.)

a DR HARISH KUMAR KHURANA 291 Appellant; Versus

KARISH KUMAR KHURANA v. JOGINDER JOGINDER SINGH AND OTHERS --

Respondents. Civil Appeals No. 7380 of 2009f with Nos. 8118 and 6933 of 2009, decided on September 7, 2021

A Consumer Protection

practitioners/services

same

Complan Nn 15/2024

Services

Medical negligence - Res ipsa loquitur - May be considered applicable where negligence alleged is glaring. in the facts and circumstlances of a case, if the evidence on record establishes the Emphasised, that findings of medical negligence of doctors and/or the hospital, nmust be based on proper medical Medical

5

evidence on crucial medical aspects - Court or Consumer Forums cannot take decision on basis of mere legal principles and general standard of assessment sans expert medical evidence on highly technical medical issues - Such decision would amount to a situational perception by the court or the Consumer Forums - In present case, allegations of medical negligence, in absence of supporting medical evidence, in the facts and circumstances, held, not made out - NCDRC erred in holding appellants: anaesthetist and hospital, guilty of medical negligence and awarding compensation to respondent claimants

2022 Livel.aw (SC) 391

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA CIVIL APPELLATE

JURISDICTION AJAY RASTOGI; ABHAY S. OKA, JJ. CIVIL APPEAL NOs).6507 OF 2009; April 20, 2022 DR. (MRS,) CHANDA RANI AKHOURI & ORS. VERSUS DR. M.A. METHUSETHUPATHI & ORS.

Medical Negligence - A medical practitioner is not to be held liable simply because things went wrong from mischance or misadventure or through an error of judgment in choosing one reasonable course of treatment in preference to another - He/she would be liable only where his conduct fell bclow that of the standards of a reasonably competent practitioner in his field - Merely because heshe could not save the patient, that could not be considered to be a case of medical negligence. [Referred to Jacob Mathew v. State of Punjab (2005) 6 SCC 1] (Para 21-27)

Complan No 152024 IP'age t of 10

Judment Exh -13

6

Transplantation of Human Organs and Tissues Act, 1994 - The hospitals where the procedure of transplantation is undertaken are to be registered in terms of Section 14 of the Act 1994, but for postoperative care, particularly after the patient being discharged from the hospital where the procedure of transplantation has taken place, we have not come across any provision under the Act, 1994 where such hospitals are required to be registered under the Act 1994. (Para 35) Summary - Appeal against NCDRC which dismissed appellant's complaint of medical negligence - Dismissed - Commission has not committed any manifest error in arriving to a conclusion that in post operative medical negligence or follow up care, there was no negligence being committed by the respondents which may be a foundation for entertaining the complaint filed by the appellants,.

480 SUPREME COURT CASES

(2010) 3 Supreme Court Cases 480

(BEFORE DALVEER BHANDARI AND H.S. BEDI, JJ.)

KUSUM SHARMA AND OTHERS

(2010) 3 SCC Appellants; Versus

BATRA HOSPITAL AND MEDICAL

RESEARCH CENTRE AND OTHERS ...Respondents. Civil Appeal No. 1385 of 200 It, decided on February 10, 2010 A. Consumer Protection Services - Medical services Negligence Criminal negligence - Tests to determine existence of principles culled out from treatises and case law, laid down - Complain No 1S2024 l'age 7 ol |

Judgment Exh 13

7

Liability of doctor tow

ards

patient explained -

Adopting higher risk procedure -

W

hen not negligence Held,

doctor

must

have

a reasonable degree

of skill

and knowledge He

must

also

cxercise

care

of a reasonable degree, neither highest

nor

very

low,

in

the

light

of the

particular

circum

stances

of

the

case - He

would

be

liable

only

where

his

conduct

falls

below

that

of a

reasonably

competent

doctor

- Divergence of opinion

with

other doctors, not

by

itself

sufficient

to

infer

negligence

Tort

Law

- Negligence -

Adopting

of a procedure involving

higher

element

of risk

with

bona

fide

expectation of greater

chance

of success, in

preference

Medical

negligence

B.

Consum er

Protection - Services - M

edical

services -

M

edical knowing that

it was of such a degree that

injury was

most

likely imm inent with reccklessness and

indifference - Elem

ent

of

crim

inality

is

consequences thercof-

Penal

Judem

ent

I xh

1

3

Compiam Nn

I524

to

a procedure involving lesser

risk

but

higher

chances

of

failure, although not

yielding desired

result,

held,

may

not

am

ount

to

negligence - Removal of malignant abdom

inal

tum

our

by surgical operation with

anterior

approach

in

preference to

posterior approach, although

failing

to

save

patient from death,

held,

not

indicative of

negligence so

as

to render doctors/hospital liable

for

com

pensation

- Consum

er

Protection

Act,

1986

- Ss. 2(c), (g)

and

(0)

negligence involve rashness of

&

degree

am

punting to

taking

of

a hazard introduced by

running the

risk

of

doing

such

8

Code, 1860 - S. 304-A C. Consumer Protection Negligence

- Concepts of, in civil law and criminal law between - Held,

Services-Medical services

"simple lack of care" attracts civil liability whereas "very high degree of negligence" is required in criminal cases-Consumer Protection Act, 1986

0.

S. 304-A Ss. 2(c), (g) and (o) - Penal Code, 1860 D. Consumer Protection - Services-Medical services-Medical negligence-Standard of care-Date on which to be adjudged- Held, the standard of care, when assessing the practice as adopted, is judged in the light of knowledge available at the time of incident, and not at the date of trial Further held, when charge of negligence arises out of failure to use some particular equipment, charge would tail it the equipment was not generally available at that point of time on which it is suggested as should have been used.

Conplan No I5i4

Distinction

-:UMl:

Pade 9 of Judgment Lah -3

9

VLsl.

(3..L4R)

Comsan No l: 0:1 I'are of 10

. H. s2HR)

10