- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
PANKAJ SHUKLA v. GOVT. OF NCTD
1
OA No. 1789 of 2020 and batch Item No. 19/item -2-4(supp.)(C-3)
CENTRAL ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL
PRINCIPAL BENCH, NEW DELHI
OA No. 1789/2020 with MA No. 3068/2023 OA No. 1791/2020 with MA No. 3069/2023 OA No.995/2019
OA No. 2311/2021 with MA No. 2917/2021 OA No. 3493/2022 with MA No. 3067/2023, MA No. 3539/2022 OA No. 3055/2022 with MA No. 3064/2022
OA No. 2623/2022 with MA No. 2701/2022
OA No. 2595/2022 with MA No. 900/2024, MA No. 2658/2022 This the 18th Day of September, 2024 Hon'ble Mrs. Pratima K. Gupta, Member (J) Hon'ble Mr. Chhabilendra Roul, Member (A) OA No. 1789/2020
1. Pankaj Shukla, Age-38 Years, S/O Sh. Subhash Chand Shukla, ` R/O 46, Old Anarkali, Delhi, Designation - Occupational Therapist, Place Of Posting - DHAS, Karkardooma.
2. Prem Singh, Age-36 Years, S/O Sh. Nihal Singh, | R/O V & P - Boraka, Hodal, Distt- Palwal (Faridabad), Haryana- 121106.
Designation - Lab. Technician, Place Of Posting - HCCMH, Kanti Nagar.
3. Sonu, Age-39 Years, S/O Sh. Satbir Singh, R/O R Z - 15, Baba Haridas, Enclave, Jharoda Kalan, New Delhi-110072. Designation - OT Technician, Place Of Posting - HCCMH, Kanti Nagar.
4. Vijay Gautam, Age- 42 Years, S/O Late Sh. Devi Singh, R/O B6/382, Janta Flat, Nand Nagri, Delhi-110093.
Designation - Junior Radiographer, Place Of Posting - HCCMH, Kanti Nagar.
2
5. Nitin Attary, Age - 34 Years, S/O Sh. A.K. Attary,
R/O V-1687, Gali No-4,
Vijay Park, Mohjpurr,
Delhi-110053.
Designation - Dark Room Assistant, Place Of Posting - HCCMH, Kanti Nagar.
6. Ruchin Rajran, Age - 39 Years, S/O Sh. Padam Singh,
R/O 84-D, F/F, R-Block, Dilshad Garden, Delhi-110095. Designation - Med. Lab. Technician. Place Of Posting - DHAS, Karkardooma.
7. Rinky Sharma, Age - 38 Years, W/O Sh. Kamal Sharma,
R/O 1/10052 B,ST. No.-3-H, West Gorakh Park, Shahdara, Delhi-110032. Designation - Med. Lab. Technician, Place Of Posting - DHAS, Karkardooma.
8. Mohd. Saleem, Age - 38 Years, S/O Late Sh. Munna Khan, R/O 427-A, Zakir Nagar West, Delhi- 110025.
Designation - OT Assistant, Place Of Posting - DHAS Karkardooma.
9. Vinod Kumar Verma, Age- 40 Years, S/O Sh. Suresh Chand,
R/O 92, Bonjha, G.T. Road, Ghaziabad, Near Hotel Heaven, U.P- 201001. Designation - Senior Radiographer, Place Of Posting - DHAS, Karkardooma.
10. Rupesh Sharma, Age - 33 Years, S/O Sh. Rajender Singh,
R/O C-325, Chayyupur, Chanakya Marg, Shahdara, Delhi-110032.
Designation - Junior Radiographer, Place Of Posting - DHAS, Karkardooma.
11. Mukesh Kumar, Age - 33 Years, S/O Sh. Yogendra Prasad, R/O 4/172, flat No. - UG-2, Sector-4,
3
Vaishali, Ghaziabad, U.P.-201010 Designation - Junior Radiographer, Place Of Posting - DHAS, Karkardooma.
12. Nitin Kumar Sharma, Age - 31 Years, S/O Sh. Satya Prakash Sharma, R/O 406-E, Gali No.-4, Shastri Marg, East Babarpur, Shahdara,
Delhi- 110032.
Designation - Junior Radiographer, Place Of Posting - DHAS, Karkardooma.
13. Amit Kumar, Age - 39 Years, S/O Sh. R.S. Vishwakarma, R/O B-79, Gali No.-14, Chander Nagar, Delhi- 110051.
Designation — Lab. Assistant, Place Of Posting - DHAS, Karkardooma.
14. Krishan Kumar Sharma, Age — 39 Years, S/O Sh. Khem Chand,
R/O G-1139, Mansarover Park,
Shahdara, Delhi-110032.
Designation — Lab. Assistant, Place Of Posting - DHAS, Karkardooma.
15. Priyanka Arora, Age — 33 Years, D/O Sh. Ravindra Kumar Arora, R/O Sh. ST. No.- 13 Ashok Nagar, Shahdara, Delhi-110093.
Designation — Lab. Assistant, Place Of Posting - DHAS, Karkardooma.
16. Rakesh Kumar, Age — 34 Years, S/O Sh. Devraj Singh,
R/O B-1, Jagatpuri, Krishna Nagar, Delhi-110051.
Designation — Lab. Assistant, Place Of Posting - DHAS, Karkardooma.
17. Vijay Kumar Ranga, Age — 44 Years, S/O Sh. Ram Chander,
R/O 493, C/19, Subhash Nagar Civil Hospital Jhajjar, Haryana-124103. Designation — Lab. Assistant, Place Of Posting - DHAS, Karkardooma.
4
18. Mohit Sharma, Age — 38 Years, S/O Sh. Brahm Dutt,
R/O RZD-1/315, Gali No.- 5, Mahavir Enclave, Palam Part-1, New Delhi.
Designation — Lab. Assistant,
Place Of Posting - DHAS, Karkardooma.
19. Sangeeta Singh, Age — 38 Years, D/O Sh. Ram Singh,
R/O 308, MIG DDA Flats, South End Apartment, Pulpehladpur, M.B. Road,
New Delhi — 110044.
Designation — Lab. Assistant,
Place Of Posting - DHAS, Karkardooma.
20. Surender Kumar, Age — 32 years, S/O Sh. Beelu Ram,
R/O 8/@ Top Floor, Gali No.-1, Ramnagar Ext., Near Gurudwara Singh Sahab, Krishna Nagar, Delhi- 110051.
Designation — Dental Hygienist,
Place Of Posting - DHAS, Karkardooma.
21. Sanjay Kumar, Age- 46 Years, S/O Sh. Omprakash,
R/O 311, Mangol Pur, Rohini, Delhi-110085.
Designation — OT Assistant, Place Of Posting - SRHC Hospital.
22. Praveen Kumar Yadav, Age — 39 Years, S/O Sh. Ram Chandra Yadav,
R/O 5/558, Haiderpur, Ambedkar Nagar, Delhi-110088.
Designation — Nsg. Officer,
Place Of Posting - HCCMH, Kantinagar.
23. Pankaj Kumar Trivedi, Age — 37 Years, S/O Sh. Suraj Mal Trivedi,
R/O 76 A, 3" Floor, Gali No.- 6, Radheypuri Extension —2,
Krishna Nagar, Delhi — 11051. Designation — Nsg. Officer,
Place Of Posting - HCCMH, Kantinagar.
24. Pravesh Kumar Joshi, Age — 40 Years, S/O Sh. Sant Kumar Joshi,
5
R/O B-53, Flat No.- 301(Front), Gali No Radheypuri Extension — 2, Krishna Nagar, Delhi — 11051. Designation — Nsg. Officer, Place Of Posting - HCCMH, Kantinagar-5, Matiala Extension, Uttam Nagar, Delhi — 110059. Designation — Nsg. Officer,
Place Of Posting - HCCMH, Kantinagar.
25. Rajeeta Singh, Age —40 Years, D/O Sh. Rajendra Singh, R/O 132, Gali No. — 14, Bholanath Nagar, Near Jharkhandi Mandir, Shahdara, Delhi — 110032.
Designation — Nsg. Officer,
Place Of Posting - HCCMH, Kantinagar.
26. Lokesh Sharma, Age —41 Years, S/O Sh. Laxman Prasad Sharma, R/O 76 A, 3" Floor, Gali No. - 6, Radheypuri Extension — 2, Krishna Nagar, Delhi — 11051. Designation — Nsg. Officer, Place Of Posting - HCCMH, Kantinagar.
27. Sardar Singh Rundla, Age — 35 Years, S/O Sh. Bhom Singh Rundla,
R/O 29/46 A, Gali No.- 12,
Viswash Nagar, Shahdara,
Delhi — 110032.
Designation — Nsg. Officer,
Place Of Posting - HCCMH, Kantinagar.
28. Sanjay Kumar Sharma, Age — 38 Years, S/O Sh. Hira Lal Sharma,
R/O A — 68 A, Gali No. — 1, Kabir Nagar, Shahdara, Delhi — 110094.
Designation — Nsg. Officer,
Place of Posting - HCCMH, Kantinagar.
29. Mohd. Asim, Age — 33 Years, S/O Sh. Mohd. Akhlaque, R/O 310, Shipra Krishna Azure, Kaushambi, Ghaziabad, U.P. - 201010. Designation — OT Technician, Place Of Posting - DHAS, Karkardooma.
6
30. Debendra Kr Sial, Age — 41 Years, S/O Sh. Panchanan,
R/O A-120, Gali No- 4, Jagatpuri, Mandoli Road, Shahdara, Delhi — 110093. Designation — OT Technician, Place Of Posting - DHAS, Karkardooma.
31. Santosh Kumar, Age — 38 Years, S/O Sh. Jhakari Prasad,
R/O 822, Near Devi Mandir, Vill:- Rithala, Delhi — 110085, Designation — OT Technician, Place Of Posting - DHAS, Karkardooma.
32. Gautam Jugran, Age — 31 Years, S/O Sh. Dheeraj Jugran,
R/O 1-25, Gadhwali Mohalla, Laxmi Nagar, Delhi — 110092. Designation — Pharmacist, Place of Posting - DHAS, Karkardooma.
33. Aju George, Age — 38 Years, S/o Sh. P.T. George,
R/o F31/S-1,
Dilshad Coloney
Delhi-110095
Designation — Nsg. Officer Place of Posting - DHAS, Karkardooma
34. Angom Sunanda Devi Age - 10 years D/o Sh. Angom Pamchou Singh R/o B-12, East Arjun Nagar, Karkardooma Delhi -1100312 Designation — Nsg. Officer Place of Posting - DHAS, Karkardooma
35. Anu George, Age - 36 years D/o Sh. T.P. George,
R/o N-10/A-2, Dilshad Garden, Delhi-110095
Designation — Nsg. Officer Place of Posting - DHAS, Karkardooma
36. Ashish Mahror, Age - 41 years S/o Sh. Padam Chander Jain R/o B-1/131, 2/F, DLF Sahibabad Ghaziabad, U.P. - 201005
7
Designation — Nsg. Officer Place of Posting - DHAS, Karkardooma
37. Bhanwar Lal Jat Age - 43 years S/o Sh. Kanhaiya Lal Jat R/o P-201, H. No. 77, 78, Gali No. 7, Matiyala Ext. Uttam Nagar, Delhi-59 Designation — Nsg. Officer Place of Posting - DHAS, Karkardooma
38. Charu Bala Ratra, Age - 37 years S/o Late Sh. Dr. H.L. Ratra R/o 580, Ganesh Nagar-2 ST No.-2 Shakarpur, Dethi-11092
Designation — Nsg. Officer Place of Posting - DHAS, Karkardooma
39. Deep Mala Somani, Age - 38 years W/o Sh. Shobhit Somani,
R/o B-55, Upper Ground Floor, Pandav Nagar, Delhi-110092 Designation — Nsg. Officer Place of Posting - DHAS, Karkardooma
40. Dinesh Kumar Swarnkar, AGe - 43 years S/o Sh. Chhagan Lal Swarnkar, R/o R-122, JJ Colony, Raghubir Nagar, Delhi - 110027
41. Dinesh Kumar, Age - 39 years S/o Sh. Rohitasav,
R/o B-33, F/F Indira Enclave, Neb Sarai, Delhi
Designation — Nsg. Officer Place of Posting - DHAS, Karkardooma
42. Krishna Kumar Yadav, Age - 42 years S/o Sh. Jairam
R/o D-32, South Anarkali, Gali No. 3, Krishan Nagar, Delhi-110001 Designation — Nsg. Officer
Place of Posting - DHAS, Karkardooma
43. Megha Masih, Age - 38 years W/o Mr. Sumit Masih,
R/o S-2, Plot No. 52, Gyan Khand-2 Indirapuram, Ghaziaba, U.P. - 201014
8
Designation — Nsg. Officer Place of Posting - DHAS, Karkardooma
44. Mukesh Kumar Yadav, Age - 44 years S/o Sh. Bhore Lal Yadav
R/o 34, Ram Nagar Extension, Krishna Nagar, Delhi-110002
Designation — Nsg. Officer
Place of Posting - DHAS, Karkardooma
45. Namita Sharma, Age - 37 years D/o Sh. Ashok Kumar Sharma R/o 77, Vill - Pochanpura, Dwearka Sector 23, PO Dhulsiras, Delhi Designation — Nsg. Officer Place of Posting - DHAS, Karkardooma
46. Neetu Sharma, Age - 37 years D/o Sh. Umesh Sharma
R/o A-139, Bank Colony Road, Mandoli Ext. Delhi-110093 Designation — Nsg. Officer Place of Posting - DHAS, Karkardooma
47. P.T. Esher, Age - 41 years D/o Sh. P.S. Thaiho,
R/o D-13, 2/F, Lehri Colony, East Arjun Nagar, Delhi-110032 Designation — Nsg. Officer Place of Posting - DHAS, Karkardooma
48. Raj Kumar Yadav, Age 41 years S/o Sh. Amar Singh Yadav, R/o 55, Upper G/F New Layalpur, Krishna Nagar, Delhi-110051 Designation — Nsg. Officer Place of Posting - DHAS, Karkardooma
49. Rajesh Kumar, Age - 39 years S/o Sh. Ram Prasad,
R/o 77/78, S.T. No. 7, B Block Matiyala Ext. Uttam Nagar, Delhi-110059 Designation — Nsg. Officer
Place of Posting - DHAS, Karkardooma
50. Rohitash, Age- 37 years
9
S/o Sh. Jagan Singh R/o 156, Gali No. 2, Usmanpur, Delhi-110053
Designation — Nsg. Officer Place of Posting - DHAS, Karkardooma
51. Ravi Kumar, Age- 37 years, S/0 Sh. Vinod Kumar Mittal, R/O A-2/63.F/F Back Side, Uttam Nagar, Hastsal Road, Near Gurdwara, New Delhi-110059.
Designation — Nsg. Officer
Place of Posting - DHAS, Karkardooma
52. Shakuntala, Age:- 37 years, D/O Sh. Roop Chand,
R/O B-5, East Arjun Nagar, Delhi-110032. Designation — Nsg. Officer
Place of Posting - DHAS, Karkardooma
53. Shakuntla Rani, Age:- 41 years, D/O Sh. Satnarayan Sharma, R/O 5-A, Bazar Lane, Bhogal, Jangpura, Delhi-110014.
Designation — Nsg. Officer Place of Posting - DHAS, Karkardooma
54. Suman Bala, Age:- 39 years, W/O Sh. Kuldeep Juneja, R/O 108, Eight Marla, Opp- JOBI Bank, Sonepat, Haryana-131001,
Designation — Nsg. Officer Place of Posting - DHAS, Karkardooma
55. Sunil Dutt Yadav, Age:- 41 Years S/O Sh. Tara Chand Yadav, R/O 35/2, Gali No.-3, Jagatpuri, Delhi-110051.
Designation — Nsg. Officer Place of Posting - DHAS, Karkardooma
56. Vijay Singh Meena, Age:- 36 Years S/O Sh. Faphu Lal Meena,
R/O 76A, Ext-2, Gali No.-6, Radheypuri, 3/F, Krishna Nagar, Delhi-110051 Designation — Nsg. Officer
Place of Posting - DHAS, Karkardooma
10
57. Vipin Kumar Yadav, Age:- 40 Years S/O Sh. Hanuman Singh,
R/O 66, Gali No-2, West Arjun Nagar, Krishna Nagar, Delhi-110051. Designation — Nsg. Officer Place of Posting - DHAS, Karkardooma
58. Angom Bimola Devi, Age:-38 Years D/O Sh. Angom Amu Singh,
R/O 1472, PKT-GH-1, Sector-28, Sanskriti Aptt, Rohini, Delhi-110042. Designation — Nsg. Officer Place of Posting - DHAS, Karkardooma
59. Ashish Kaushik, Age:- 33 Years S/O Sh. Navneet Kaushik, R/O D-119, Ganga Vihar, Gokalpuri, Delhi-110094.
Designation — OT Assistant, Place of Posting - HCCMH, Kantinagar,
60. Vipin Kumar, Age:- 37 Years S/O Sh. Dharamvir Singh, R/O Vill- Vikash Nagar, Post- Loni, Ghaziabad, U.P.-201102.
Designation- Junior Rediographer, Place Of Posting- HCCMH, Kantinagar.
61. Subhash Chand, Age:- 39 Years S/O Sh. Raja Ram,
R/O E-278, Madipur Colony, New Delhi- 110063
Designation- OT Assistant, Place of Posting- ABG Hospital.
62. Sonu Kardam, Age:- 31 Years S/O Sh. Ratan Singh Kardam, R/O 223, BSAH, Rohini, Delhi-110085 Designation- OT Assistant, Place of Posting- ABG Hospital.
63. Preeti, Age:- 29 Years W/O Sh. Anil Kumar, R/O 971, Sector-8, R K Puram, New Delhi-110022.
Designation- OT Assistant,
11
Place of Posting- ABG Hospital.
64. Manish Kumar, Age :- 37 Years S/O Latie Sh. Mordhwaj, R/O H 1/351-352, Sultanpuri, New Delhi-110086.
Designation- OT Assistant, Place of Posting- ABG Hospital.
65. Imam Mehdi, Age:- 38 Years S/O Late Mr. Zaved Hussain, R/O Mehdi Aara RZ-20 F/8 Agli No. 6 Main Sagarpur, New Delhi-110046 Designation- OT Assistant, Place of Posting- ABG Hospital.
66. Deepika, Age:- 30 Years W/O Mr. Calling Manish, R/O H.No. 95, Shankar Garden, Gali No.2 Line Par Bahadurgarh, Haryana. Designation- OT Assistant,
Place of Posting- ABG Hospital.
67. Urmila, Age:- 33 Years D/O Sh. Satbeer Singh, R/O D-58, Near Girls Pre. Nursery School (MCD) V&P Qutub Garh, New Delhi-1 10029 Designation- OT Assistant,
Place of Posting- Bhagwan Mahavir Hospital. … Applicants
(By Advocate: Mr. Narender Kaushik with Mr Pankaj Kaushik)
Versus
1. Govt. of NCT of Delhi, Through its Chief Secretary, I.P. Sachivalaya, New Delhi.
2. Directorate of Health Services, Secretary Health, I.P. Sachivalaya, New Delhi.
… Respondents
(By Advocate: Mrs Purnima Maheswari)
OA No. 1791/2020
12
1. Shailendra Kumar Yadav, Age:- 43 Years, S/O Sh. Ram Chandra Yadav,
R/O B-3/384, Sector-6, Rohini, Delhi-110008. Designation- Nsg. Officer.
Place of Posting-BSAH, Rohini.
2. Shadab Khan, Age:- 30 Years, S/O SH. Idrees Khan
R/O Plot no.-1 A, Sector-6, Idgah Colony, Faridabad, Haryana-121006. Designation- OT Assistant.
Place of Posting- HCCMH, Kanti Nagar.
3. Jai Kishan, Age:- 30 Years, S/O SH. Sunder Lal,
R/O 841, Pana Udyan, Narela, Delhi-110040.
Designation- OT Assistant. Place of Posting- HCCHM, Kanti Nagar.
4. Rajnikant, Age:- 36 Years, S/O SH. Gajanand Sharma, R/O B-46, Saraswati Enclave, Near Sect.-10/A, Opp. Shiv Mandir Gurugram, Haryana-122001.
Designation-OT Technician.
Place of Posting- DHAS, Karkardooma.
5. Pankaj Kumar, Age:- 30 Years, S/O SH. Lekhpal Singh,
R/O 559, Gali no.-33, D-Block, Harsh Vihar, Delhi-110093. Designation- OT Assistant, Place of Posting- DHAS, Karkardooma.
6. Manoj Kumar, Age:- 35 Years, S/O Sh. Kartar Singh,
R/O 1169, Vill.-Nahri, Sonepat, Haryana-131103.
Designation-ECG Technician. Place of Posting- DHAS, Karkardooma.
7. Peush Raj Singh, Age:- 42 Years, S/O Sh. Pratap Singh Harit, R/O 46 Old Anarkali, Delhi Designation-ECG Technician. Place of Posting- DHAS, Karkardooma.
13
8. Sanjay Kumar, Age:- 39 Years, S/O Sh. Laxmi Prasad,
R/ON.W. 23 B, Vishnu Garden, Gali no.-4, New Delhi-110018. Designation- Audiometry Assistant, Place of Posting- DHAS, Karkardooma.
9. Priya Darshni Gaurav, Age:- 31 Years, D/o Sh. Tooki Ram,
R/O D-119, Ganga Vihar, Delhi-110094. Designation- Pharmacist,
Place of Posting- CDMO Shahdara.
10. Anu Bala Kumari, Age:- 36 years, D/O SH. M.P. Keshari,
R/O C-1/15,F/F, Mohan Garden, Gurudwara Road, Metro Pillar no:- 744, Uttam Nagar, New Delhi-110059. Designation- Nsg. Officer,
Place of Posting- Bhagwan Mahavir Hospital.
11. Vidya, Age:- 30 Years, W/O SH. Amit Kumar Jha, R/O WZ 47 A, 3rd Floor, Baludyan Road, Near BSES Office, Uttam Nagar, New Delhi-110059.
Designation- ANM,
Place of Posting- CDMO (South West Distt.) Dwarka.
12. Renu, Age:- 32 Years, W/O Mr. Dev Nasir, R/O 16/3162, Amrit Kaurpuri, Tank Road, Karol Bagh, New Delhi - 110005. Designation- ANM
Place of Posting- CDMO, Dwarka.
13. Neha Sharma, Age:- 35 Years, W/O Sh. Krishan Kumar Sharma, R/O G-1139, Mansarovar Park, Delhi-110032. Designation- Lab. Technician, Place of Posting-
14. Neel Kamal, Age:- 43 Years, S/O Sh. Bhagat Ram,
R/O C-6/G1, DLF Colony, Bhopura, Ghaziabad, U.P-201005.
14
Designation- Lab. Technician, Place of Posting- Lok Nayak Hospital.
15. Naushad Khan, Age:- 45 Years, S/O Sh. Shahbaz Khan,
R/O F-12, West Jawahar Park, Laxmi Nagar, Delhi-110092. Designation- Junior Radiographer, Place of Posting- Aruna Asaf Ali Hospital.
16. Mohd. Islam, Age:- 40 Years, S/O Sh. Bashir Ahmad,
R/O WZ 48 A, Bhoomiya Chowk, Basai Darapur, New Delhi-110015. Designation- OT Assistant, Place of Posting- ABG Hospital.
17. Moin Ahmad, Age:- 37 Years, S/O Late Sh. Abdul Hakim, R/O RZ-25, Gali no.-25 A, Indra Park, Palam Colony, New Delhi-110045. Designation- ECG Technician Place of Posting- ABG Hospital.
18. Ravi Dahiya, Age:- 30 Years, S/O Sh. Balwan Dahiya,
R/O Garhibala, (223) Sonipat, Haryana, Pin Code-131403.
Designation- Junior Radiographer, Place of Posting- Sanjay Gandhi Hospital.
19. Ms. Preeti, Age:
W/o Sh. Arun Priya R/O DB/109, Rohini, Sector - 6, Delhi-85 Designation- Nursing Officer Place of Posting- ABG Hospital. …. Applicants
Vs.
1. Govt. of NCT of Delhi, Through its Chief Secretary, I.P. Sachivalaya, New Delhi.
2. Directorate of Health Services,
15
Secretary Health, I.P. Sachivalaya, New Delhi. …. Respondents
OA No. 995/2019
1. Sh. Sanjeev S/o Sh. Mahinder Singh R/o H.No.208 Vill. P.O. Mungeshpur, Delhi-39
D.O.B. 20.05.1985
D.O.J. 30.05.2008
Junior Radiographer (group C)
2. Ms. Jagvati W/o Shri Mahinder Singh R/O RZ-152/91, Street no.2 East Sagarpur, Delhi-46
D.O.B. 15.07.1981
D.O.J. 16.12.2008
Junior Radiographer (group C)
3. Sh.Amit Kumar S/o Shri Joginder Singh R/o C-2/16, DDU Hospital Complex Hari Nagar, New Delhi-64
D.O.B. 24.08.1978
D.O.J. 30.05.2008
Junior Radiographer (group C)
4. Shri Parikshit Gautam S/o Shri Niwas Gautam E-58-B, Maksudabad Colony Near BBM Public School Najafgarh Delhi-43
D.O.B. 26.07.1980
D.O.J. 30.05.2008
Junior Radiographer (group C)
5. Shri Santosh Kumar Suman S/o Sh. Ramdeo Singh Block R, 77A, Chanakya Palace II Delhi-110059
D.O.B. 08.01.1979
D.O.J. 08.07.2008
Junior Radiographer (group C) ........ APPLICANTS
16
(By Advocate: Mr Narender Kaushik with Mr Pankaj Kaushik)
VERSUS
1. GOVT. OF NCT OF DELHI
Through its Secretary (Health & F/W)
New Secretriate
I.P.Sachivalaya, New Delhi
2. Medical Director (HD) Din Dayal Upadyay Hospital Hari Nagar, Delhi. ........ RESPONDENTS (By Advocate: Mrs Purnima Maheshwari)
OA No. 2311/2021
1. Md. Arshad Nurul Hassan, Age:-38Years, S/O Nurul Hassan,
R/O A-11A, Shivngi Kunj,
Paschim Vihar,
Delhi
Designation- Junior MLT
2. Hemlata, Age:- 42 Years, W/o Vijay Kumar,
R/O RZF1 Sadh Nagar, Pallam Colony,
New Delhi-110045
Designation- ECG Technician
3. Shiv Babu Gupta, Age:- 41Years, S/O Sh. Jokhi Parshad Gupta, R/O WZ 1079 B2, 1st Floor Ashok Apptt. Nagal Raja, New Delhi-110046
Designation- ECG Technician
4. Umesh Kumar Kushwaha, Age:- 41Yeasr, S/O Sh. Raj Bali Kushwaha,
R/O WZ 1246B,
Nagal Raja,New Delhi-110046 Designation- ECG Technician
5. Manoj , Age:- 42 Years, S/O Sh. Azad Singh
17
R/O VPO - Ashodpur, Nandnore Distt. Sonepat, Haryana Designation- OT Assistant,
6. Taliwar Singh, Age:- 43 Years, S/O Sh. Chhitermal,
R/O C-76/A, Gali No. 7, Khajuri Khas Delhi-110094
Designation-O.T. Asstt.
7. Preeti Manav, Age:- 42 Years, S/O Sh. Shubhash Chand, R/O G+78, Gali No. 10, Rajapuri Uttam Nagar, New Delhi-110059 Designation- Lab Asstt..
8. Monika Rana, Age:- 42 Years, D/O Sh. Pritam Singh,
R/O 305, Sharshpur,
Delhi-110042
Designation- Lab Assistant,
9. Raman Sharma, Age:- 41Years, D/o Sh. Naresh Sharma, R/O 4/D, Bashant Gaon
Near Vashant Vihar,
Designation- Lab Assistant .... Applicants / Petitioner (By Advocate: Mr. Narender Kaushik with Mr Pankaj Kaushik)
Vs
1. Govt. of NCT of Delhi, Through its Chief Secretary, I.P. Sachivalaya, New Delhi.
2. Director, Directorate of Health Services, Secretary Health,
I.P. Sachivalaya, New Delhi.
....Respondents
(By Advocate: Mrs Purnima Maheswari)
OA No. 3493/2022
1. Mrs. Meenakshi W/o - Mr.AbhinavKaushik D.O.B. - 23.11.1991 D.O.J.. - 18.10.2012
18
CDMO North Distt. Address - 63/64, Prem Nagar, Nathupura, Delhi - 110084 Mobile - 9013402368
Designation - LA/JMLT
2. Mrs. Shelly Sharma W/o - Deepak Sharma D.O.B. -
D.O.J.. - 04.12.2012 CDMO Central Distt. Address - 46/2/a1/1, East Azad Nagar, Street No. - 14,Shahdara, Delhi - 110051 Mobile - 9958646015
Designation - LA/JMLT
3. Mr.Pradeep Kumar S/o - Dharampal D.O.B - 15.05.1982 D.O.J. - 11.12.2012 CDMO Central Distt. Address - C-272/2, Street No.- 10, BhajanPura, Delhi-110053 Mobile - 9873124481
Designation - Junior Radiographer
4. Mrs.Ankita W/o - VinayDagra D.O.B - 28.05.1991 D.O.J. - 11/01/2013 CDMO North Distt. Address - Home No.- 241, D-1, PDS Apartment, Ghitrori, Delhi-110030 Mobile - 9560122649
Designation - LA/JMLT
5. Mrs.Jyoti Sharma W/o - Ashok Kumar D.O.B - 12.09.1989 D.O.J. - 15.01.2013 CDMO West
Address - 1/2252 A, Gali No.- 12, Ram Nagar, Shahdara, Delhi-110032 Mobile - 9716237781
Designation - LA/JMLT
6. Mrs.Geeta Joshi W/o - Rajeev Pandey
19
D.O.B - 04.10.1987 D.O.J. - 15.01.2013 CDMO North Distt. Address - 722, DDA LIG, Flats, Hasasthal, Uttam Nagar, New Delhi - 110059 Mobile - 7840045476
Designation - JMLT
7. Mr.Amit Singh S/o - Mr. Anil Kumar Singh D.O.B - 23.09.1987 D.O.J. - 13.02.2013 CDMO East
Address - Ashok Vihar, Delhi Designation -LC/JMLT
8. Mrs.RuchiYadav W/o - Rahul Yadav D.O.J. - 18 Jan 2013 Bhagwan Mahavir Hospital Address - B-45, TyagiVihar, Nangloi, Delhi Designation -JMLT
9. Mrs. Preeti W/o - Vijay Sharma D.O.B -
D.O.J. - 16.01.2013 CDMO North Distt., Model Town Address - H.No.-20, Near Shiv Mandir, Village Sadpura, Delhi
Mobile -
Designation -
10. Shailender Sharma S/o Rambilas Sharma D.O.B - 02.09.84 D.O.J - 20.10.2012 Designation - LA/JMLT Place of Posting - CDMO North Distt., Model Town
Address - Ho. - 398, Sec- A-9, Plot- I, Group- III, Narela Delhi.
11. Sumit Sharma S/o Sh. Anand Prakash Sharma D.O.B. - 02.04.1986
D.O.J. - 11.01.2013
20
Place of Joining - CDMO North Distt., Currently Posted - CDMO Central Distt., Address - B-16/2, Chandu Nagar, Karawal Nagar Road,
North East, Delhi-94
.... Applicants / Petitioner (By Advocate: Mr. Narender Kaushik with Mr Pankaj Kaushik)
Vs
1. Govt. of NCT of Delhi, Through its Chief Secretary, IP Estate New Sachivalaya, New Delhi- 110002
2. Directorate of Health Services Secretary, Health
F-17, Karkardooma
Delhi- 110092
....Respondents
(By Advocate: Mrs Purnima Maheswari)
OA No. 3055/2022
1. Narendra Sharma S/o Radhe Shyam Sharma DOB - 05.08.1980 DOJ - 13.07.2008 ID No. 22813670
Address - RZ-668/14-A, Gali No. - 18D Upper Ground, Sadh Nagar, Delhi-45 Designation - Nursing Staff
2. Deepa D/o Subhash Chand DOB - 48.08.1985 DOJ - 03.07.2008 ID No. 42733253 Address - H.No. 82 Kambal Wali Gali Delhi Gate Ghaziabad (U.P.) 201005 Designation - Nursing Staff
3. Seema Kumari W/o Joginder Kumar DOB- 27.12.1984 DOJ - 05.07.2008 ID No . : 57175411
21
Address - H. No.-6, Near State Bank of Patiyala, Pooth Kala Delhi-86
Designation - Nursing Staff
4. Anita. V. Yoyakim D/o Yoyakim V.A. DOB - 28.05.1985 DOJ - 08.12.2008 ID NO. - 41871595 Address: F-1, A-93 DLF, Dilshad Extn-1 Delhi-96
Designation - Nursing Staff
5. Prakash Chand S/o Subhash Chand DOB: - 05.01.1978
DOJ : 30.04.2007
ID NO. - 69617248 Address: Vill-Garhi Post/Teh.- Mundawar Dist. Alwar (Raj.) Designation - Nursing Staff
6. Vijay Pal Yadav S/o Ramji Lal Yadav
DOB : 07.05.1977
DOJ : 26.04.2007
ID No. 79948066 Address : V.P. Kankara Barrod Th. Behror Dist. Alwar-301020 Designation - Nursing Staff
7. Sibi Paul D/o P.P. Paul
DOB : 13.01.1984
DOJ : 05.09.2008
ID No. 38426837 Address : H. No. 95, D-4, Alhamd Apartment,
64 Khamba, Near MAML, Mirdard Lane, New Delhi-02
Designation - Nursing Staff
8. Suni. K. Chacko D/o M.K. Chacko
DOB : 23.04.1983
DOJ : 10.07.2008
ID No. 66541067 Address : RZG 1/14, 2nd Floor Mahavir Enclave,
22
Mandir Marg Palace, New Delhi-45 Designation - Nursing Staff
9. Neenu Maria Jose D/o Jose
W/o Tony. J. Pullappally
DOB : 14.12.1983
DOJ : 21.07.2008
ID No. 94576591 Address : Flat No. 303, Plot No. 11-12, Mahagun Eslales-2, Dudh Bazar Road, Shalimar Garden Ext-1, Sahibabad, UP, - 201005 Designation - Nursing Staff
10. Ambili PJ D/o P.N. Janardanan
DOB : 30.05.1985
DOJ : 05.09.2008
ID No. 70699856 Address : C4/95, Alharod Buildig, 64-Khamba,
84 Masjid, Behind, G.B. Pant Hospitals Mirdard Lane New Delhi-02
Designation - Nursing Staff
11. Charan Singh Ola S/o Bularam
DOB : 01.11.1982
DOJ : 26.04.2007
ID No. 51445945 Address : Tulsipura, Teh.- Paota, Dist.- Jaipur, Raj-303106 Designation - Nursing Staff
12. Dharm Singh Gurjar S/o Lt Shri. Ram Phool Gurjar.
DOB : 19.06.1982
DOJ : 14.07.2008
Address :RZ-116, 1st Floor Nand Vihar, Kakrola Dwark Sec-16A,
New Delhi-78
Designation - Nursing Staff
13. Mrs. Promila Pal W/o Kunwal Pal
DOB : 02.04.1984
DOJ : 29.05.2005
Address : P-181, Gali No. 7,
23
Bihari Colony, Shahadra, Delhi-110032
Designation - Nursing Staff
14. Mrs. Rashmi W/o Lalit
DOB : 01.05.1984
DOJ : 12.01.2009
Address :847/7, Ist Floor, Govindpuri, Kalkaji, Near Gurudrawa, Delhi Designation - Nursing Staff .. .... Applicants / Petitioner (By Advocate: Mr. Narender Kaushik with Mr Pankaj Kaushik)
Vs
1. Govt. of NCT of Delhi, Through its Chief Secretary, I.P. Estate, New Sachivalaya, New Delhi-110002
2. Directorate of Health Services, Secretary Health,
I.P. Estate, New Sachivalaya, New Delhi-110002
....Respondents
(By Advocate: Mrs Purnima Maheswari)
OA No. 2623/2022
1. Vikas Yadav S/o - Karan Singh B.O.B. - 20/01/1983 D.O.J. - 12/03/2007 Address - Plot No.- 126, Bagdolla Village, Dwarka, Sec-8, South West Delhi-110077 Designation - Nursing Staff.
2. Dharam Singh S/o - Manna Lal D.O.B. - 20.08.1985 D.O.J. - 09.03.2007 Address - R2-69, Roshan Garden, Najafgarh, New Delhi-110043
Designation - Nursing Staff
24
3. Bastiram Yadav S/o - Harsahai B.O.B. - 09/01/1977 D.O.J. - 12/03/2007 Address - Quarter No.- 55, Type-2, BMH Campus, Pitampura, Delhi-110034 Designation - Nursing Staff
4. Gayatri Devi S/o - Dheerender Kumar D.O.B. - 15.02.1982 D.O.J. - 01.07.2007 Address - A-35, A-Block, Shiv Vihar, Vikas Nagar, Uttar Nagar, Delhi-110059
Designation - Nursing Staff
5. Rajesh Singh Shekhawat S/o - Nathu Singh
D.O.B. - 05.09.1978 D.O.J. - 03.05.2007 Address - A-136, 1st Floor, Baba Farid Puri, Patel Nagar, Delhi-110008
Designation - Nursing Staff
6. Surender Kumar Dhayal S/o - Sagar Mal Dhayal D.O.B. - 24.04.1984 D.O.J. - 08.03.2007 Address - Quarter No.-55, Type 2 BMH Champus, Pitampura, Delhi-110034
Designation - Nursing Staff
7. Sarjeet Singh S/o - Shersingh Yadav D.O.B. - 13.09.1980 D.O.J. - 07.05.2007 Address - Quarter No.-55 Type-2, BMH Campus, Pitampura, Delhi-110034
Designation - Nursing Staff
8. Mahendra Kumar Yadav S/o - Devisahai
D.O.B. - 01.07.1977 D.O.J. - 03.05.2007 Address - 24, Block-G, Gali No.-5, Prem Nagar, Najafgarh Delhi-110043
Designation - Nursing Staff
25
9. Priyanka C/o - Rajesh Malik D.O.B. - 15.09.1982 D.O.J. - 05.07.2007 Address - 5/188 Nehru Park, Bahadurgarh, Jhajjar, Haryana, 124507
Designation - Nursing Staff
10. Moolchand Jangid S/o - Lt. Bhorri Lal Jangid D.O.B. - 15.03.1977 D.O.J. - 08.05.2007 Address - H.No.-201/A, Block-C, Ramvihar, Delhi Designation - Nursing Staff
11. Kanta Rani S/o - Satpal Singh D.O.B. - 12.07.1985 D.O.J. - 14.05.2007 Address - Flat No.-73, Ground Floor, Pocket-11, Sector-21, Rohini, Delhi-110086 Designation - Nursing Staff
12. Vinod Kumari W/o - Mamraj Singh D.O.B. - 01.06.1983 D.O.J. - 01.03.1983 Address - W2-1234, Palam Extension, Dwarks, Sector-7, Delhi
Designation - Nursing Staff
13. Jagesh W/o - Sumit Sharma D.O.B. - 05.01.1983 D.O.J. - 03.07.2007 Address - 36-C, LIG Flat, Rampura, Delhi-110035
Designation - Nursing Staff
14. Prakash Yadav S/o Sh. Kishan Lal Yadav D.O.B. - 01.01.1979 D.O.J. - 05.03.2007 Address - Plot No.- 126, Dwarka, Sector-8, South West Delhi-110077
26
Designation - Nursing Staff
15. Monika Arora S/o - Keshav Kamra D.O.B. - 02.01.1986 D.O.J. - 01.05.2007 Address - H-2/65, IInd Floor, Rohini, Sector-16, West Delhi-110085 Designation - Nursing Staff …..Petitioners (By Advocate: Mr. Narender Kaushik with Mr Pankaj Kaushik)
Vs
1. Govt. of NCT of Delhi, Through its Chief Secretary,
I. P. Estate, New Sachivalaya, New Delhi-110001.
2. Directorate of Health Services, Secretary Health,
I. P. Estate, New Sachivalaya, New Delhi-110001. ....Respondents
(By Advocate: Mrs Purnima Maheswari)
OA No. 2595/2022
1. Pawan Kumar Sharma S/o Vinod Kumar Sharma DOB - 01.03.1984 DOJ - 01.05.2007 (LNH) Address - C-76/A, Gali No. 7 Khijan Khurd, Delhi-110094 Designation - Nursing Staff
2. Neetesh Kumar S/o Jagdish Prasad DOB - 08.07.1984 DOJ - 09.07.2008 (LNH) Address - D-211/5, Gali No. 2, Rama Vihar, Rohini, Delhi-110081
Designation - Nursing Staff
3. Mukesh Kumar Swarankar S/o Ram Dayal Soni DOB - 30.03.1981
27
DOJ - 19.09.2008 (LNH) Address - R/O R Z - 15, Baba Haridas, Enclave, Jharoda Kalan, New Delhi-110072. Designation - Nursing Staff
4. Sandeep Kumar S/o Mam Chand Joshi DOB - 30.09.1982 DOJ - 30.06.2008 (LNH) Address - R/O 46, Old Anarkali, Delhi Designation - Nursing Staff
5. Arun Kumar Mishra S/o Subhash Chand Sharm DOB - 26.05.1985 DOJ - 28.04.2007 (LHN) Address - RC-3N/266, 2nd Floor Near Shiv Mandir, M Block West Sagarpur, South West, Delhi-110046 Designation - Nursing Staff
6. Dinesh Kumar Saini S/o Mahaveer Prasad Saini DOB - 13.02.1984
DOJ - 27.09.2005 (LNH) Address - J-59/60,Gali No- 2, J- Block, West Sagarpur, New Delhi-110046
Designation - Nursing Staff
7. Raj Kumar Gupta S/o Ram Vilas Gupta DOB - 05.12.1980 DOJ - 21.07.2008 (LNH) Address - 1/458, Trilokpuri, East Delhi-110091 Designation - Nursing Staff
8. Satveer Singh S/o Samdar Singh DOB - 08.09.1981 DOJ - 01.06.2007 (LNH) Address - R/O B6/382, Janta Flat, Nand Nagri, Delhi-110093. Designation - Nursing Staff
9. Batti Lal Meena S/o Ram Charan Meena DOB - 03.07.1980
28
DOJ - 24.04.2007 (LNH) Address - R/O V-1687, Gali No-4, Vijay Park, Mohjpur, Delhi-110053.
Designation - Nursing Staff
10. Mareena Sara Ninan S/o Dinoj Alexander DOB - 17.02.1984 DOJ - 10.07.2008 (LNH) Address - G-84, Flat No-102, St No- 01, Palam Ext. Sec-7, Dwarka Palam Village, South West Delhi-110045
Designation - Nursing Staff
11. Hariom Gupta S/o Ram Sahay Gupta DOB - 15.09.1981 DOJ - 14.07.2008 (LNH) Address-R/O V-1687,Gali No-4, Vijay Park, Mohjpur, Delhi-110053.
Designation - Nursing Staff
12. Laltesh Kumar Tiwari S/o Mahaveer Parsad Tiwari DOB - 09.07.1977
DOJ - 27.09.2005 (LNH) Address - RC-I-133/213, 1st Floor Gavialo, 8B I-Block, West Sagarpur , New Delhi, 110046 Designation - Nursing Staff
13. Arun Kumar Rawat S/o Damodar Lal Rawat DOB - 08.08.1984 DOJ - 30.04.2007 (LNH) Address - R/O V-1687, Gali No-4, Vijay Park, Mohjpur, Delhi-110053.
Designation - Nursing Staff
14. Sanoj Devi S/o Makhan Ram DOB - 03.06.1978 DOJ - 26.09.2005 (LNH) Address - R/O V-1687, Gali No-4, Vijay Park Mohjpur, Delhi-110053.
Designation - Nursing Staff
15. Mahesh Chand Meena
29
S/o Arjun Meena DOB - 07.10.1978 DOJ - 24.04.2007 (LNH) Address - G-C-1A, 4th Floor, Pehladpur, New Delhi-110044
Designation - Nursing Staff
16. Yogendra Kumar Bhardwaj S/o Rajendra Prasad Sharma DOB - 05.07.1983
DOJ - 27.09.2005 (LNH) Address - R/O 427-A, Zakir Nagar West, Delhi- 110025.
Designation - Nursing Staff
17. Manish Kumar S/o Yogesh Chand Sharma DOB - 17.12.1980 DOJ - 12.07.2007 (LNH) Address - R/O C-325, Chayyupur, Chanakya Marg, Shahdara, Delhi-110032
Designation - Nursing Staff
18. Rajesh Aggarwal S/o Ghanshyam Gupta DOB - 24.02.1981 DOJ - 21.03.2007 Address - R/O 406-E, Gali No.-4, Shastri Marg, East Babarpur, Shahdara, Delhi- 110032. Designation - Nursing Staff
19. Seema D/o Mohd. Waqar DOB - 28.10.1981 DOJ - 01.08.2008 Address - 166, Gali No.-3, Sangam Vihar, Waziarabad, Delhi-110084
Designation - Nursing Staff
20. Mahesh Kumar Yadav S/o Sambhu Dayal Yadav DOB - 16.07.1982 DOJ - 01.01.2009 Address - 57, First Floor, Pocket-9, Rohini, Delhi-110086
Designation - Nursing Staff
30
21. Vishnu Sahu S/o Moolchand Sahu DOB - 31.01.1985 DOJ - 14.07.2008 Address - B-79, Gali No.-14, Chander Nagar, Delhi- 110051.
Designation - Nursing Staff
22. Saroj Devi W/o Dulichand Yadav DOB-04.05.1985 DOJ-21.07.2008 Address - B-1, Jagatpuri, Krishna Nagar, Delhi-110051.
Designation - Nursing Staff
23. Rajendra Kumar Saini S/o Kanhaya Lal Saini DOB-25.06.1980
DOJ - 26.06.2012
Address - B-20/23, Gali No.-3, Gulab Bagh, Navada, Uttam Nagar, Delhi-110059 Designation - Nursing Staff
24. Usha Khanna D/o Maxwell Khanna DOB-04.09.1980 DOJ-24.07.2007 Address 40, Khasra No.-2/21, Gali No.-2, A Block, Extension, Jharoda Majra, New Delhi-110084 Designation - Nursing Staff
25. Sita Ram Jaat S/o Javahar Lal Jaat DOB-08.08.1978 DOJ-02.01.2009 Address RZD-1/315, Gali No. 5, Mahavir Enclave,
Palam Part-1, New Delhi Designation - Nursing Staff
26. Jai Narayan Dudi S/o Khem Chand Dudi DOB-07.12.1978 DOJ-26.04.2007 Address - 308, MIG DDA Flats, South End Apartment, Pulpehladpur,
31
M.B. Road, New Delhi-110044. Designation - Nursing Staff
27. Rajesh Kumar S/o Rohitashwa DOB-01.01.1980 DOJ-18.03.2007 Address C-161, Gali No.-14/3, Sadh Nagar, Part-II, Palam Colony, New Delhi-110045
Designation - Nursing Staff
28. Jai Prakash S/o Ramji Lal DOB-25.06.1980 DOJ-06.10.2005 Address - 8/@ Top Floor, Gali No.-1, Ramnagar Ext., Near Gurudwara Singh Sahab, Krishna Nagar, Delhi-110051.
Designation - Nursing Staff
29. Amar Singh Yadav S/o Kisan Lal Yadav DOB-01.01.1981 DOJ-28.09.2005 Address - RCC-10A, Third Floor, Gali No.-5, Sindicate INC, Delhi-110045 Designation - Nursing Staff
30. Rajkumar Yadav S/o Bisamber Dayal Yadav DOB-02.04.1980
DOJ-26.09.2005
Address 301, Shyam Vihar, Phase-II, Najafgarh, New Delhi-110043 Designation - Nursing Staff
31. Choth Mal Yadav S/o Ram Prasad Yadav
DOB16.07.1975
DOJ-26.09.2005 Address - RC-60, Nand Vihar, Dwarka, Delhi-11007
Designation - Nursing Staff
32. Deepika W/o Deepak Chauhan DOB-05.03.1982
32
DOJ-03.07.2008 Address - D-1, B-Block, 28/29, Welcome, Shahdhara, Delhi
33. Satyender Designation - Nursing Staff S/o Chitramal
DOB-23.02.1981
DOJ-24.02.2007
Address - 102, Room No.-517, Mirdard Lane, Behind GB Pant Hospital, Delhi-110002 Designation - Nursing Staff
34. Linu Manuel S/o K.V. Manuel DOB-29.01.1981 DOJ-01.07.2008 Address JD-13E, Hari Enclave, Hari Nagar, Delhi-110064
Designation - Nursing Staff
35. Jai Ram Jaat DOB-10.07.1978 S/o Prabhat Ram Jaat DOJ-27.09.2005 Address - 311, Mangol Pur, Rohini, Delhi-110085.
Designation - Nursing Staff
36. Ashok Kumar Sharma S/o Om Prakash Sharma DOB-01.01.1978
DOJ-27.09.2005
Address - 5/558, Haiderpur, Ambedkar Nagar, Delhi-110088.
Designation - Nursing Staff
37. Krishna Kumar Mittal S/o Hanuman Prasad Mittal DOB-08.01.1980
DOJ-04.07.2008
Address Plot No.-118, T/F, Kh. No.-10/17, Nand Vihar, Kakraula, South West, Delhi-110078 Designation - Nursing Staff
38. Jagram S/o Hosiyar Singh
33
DOB-05.02.1977 DOJ-20.02.2007 Address - A-1A/32, Chanakya Palace, Gali No.-9, Opp- Chanakya Puri, Delhi-110059
Designation - Nursing Staff
39. Shravan Kumar S/o Sambhu Prasad DOB-15.07.1978 DOJ-09.07.2008 Address - RC-224, First Floor, Gali No.- 25, Nand Vihar, Kakraula, Dwarka,
New Delhi-110078
Designation - Nursing Staff
40. Jaideep Singh S/o Mohan Singh DOB-25.01.1986 DOJ-03.08.2008 Address 3814/6, Kanhaya Nagar, Trinagar, Omkar Nagar, North West Delhi-110035
Designation - Nursing Staff
41. Kavita D/o Jai Singh DOB-01.05.1984 DOJ-20.07.2008 Address RZ-22, Ekta Vihar, New Anaaz Mandi, Nazafgarh, New Delhi-110043
Designation - Nursing Officer
42. Monika Francis D/o Lt. Francis DOJ-24.09.2008 DOB-28.02.1975 Address - GB Pant, Nurses Hostel, R-29, Second Floor, New Delhi-110002 Designation - Nursing Staff
43. Mumtaz Praveen D/o Majid Ali W/o Mohammad Shadab DOB-13.08.1987 DOJ-26.06.2012 Address - A-80/A, 5th Floor, Abul Fazal Enclave, Part-II,Shahin Bagh, Jamia Nagar, Okhla, New Delhi-110025.
34
Designation - Nursing Staff
44. Sangeeta Kumari W/o- Rajkumar Sharma DOB-14.01.1988 DOJ-25.06.2012 Address - H.No.-54, Pocket-5, Sector-25, Rohini, Delhi.
Designation - Nursing Staff
45. Harish Kumar S/o Tota Ram DOB-06.09.1978 DOJ-15.03.2007 Address - 2A/30, Geeta Colony, Delhi-110031
Designation - Nursing Staff
46. Jal Singh S/o - Badam Singh DOB-03.09.1979 DOJ-16.12.2008 Address - Room No.-308, Muskan Hotel, Delhi
Designation - Nursing Staff
47. Sanjay Kumar S/o-Jagdish Prasad DOB-10.07.1981 DOJ-06.11.2008 Address 4L, Extension, Gali No.-6, Lakshmi Vihar, Mohan Garden, Delhi-110059 Designation - Nursing Staff
48. Vikram Singh Yadav S/o- Vijay Singh Yadav DOB-15.01.1983
DOJ-30.12.2008
Address - 2A/30, Second Floor, Geeta Colony, Delhi-110031
Designation - Nursing Officer
49. Ashok Kumar S/o-Om Prakash Yadav DOB-10.03.1981. DOJ-16.03.2007 Address - H.No.-222, Gali No.-9,
35
G Block, Prem Nagar, Nazafgarh, Delhi-110043
50. Ravinder Kumar Designation - Nursing Officer S/o - Deshram
DOB-05.07.1982
DOJ-03.10.2008
Address - 84 Masjid 64 Khamba, Mirdard, New Delhi-110002 Designation - Nursing Officer
51. Vandana W/o - Jayant Kumar DOB-11.07.1985 DOJ-04.11.2008 Address - H. No.-23G, Flat No.-102, Shri Ram Apartment, Shahdhara, Delhi
Designation - Nursing Officer
52. Vineeta Kuchhar W/o-David Kachhar DOB-10.11.1976 DOJ-12.04.2007 Address - H.No.-103, Sampanda, Apartment, Flat-A2, Ward-8, Mehrauli, Delhi Designation - Nursing Officer
53. Sujan Singh S/o - Jai Singh
DOB10.01.1979
DOJ-12.04.2008 Address - 308, MIG DDA Flats, South End Apartment, Pulpehladpur, M.B. Road,
New Delhi-110044.
Designation - Nursing Officer
54. Dimple D/o - Ram Gopal DOB-02.01.1983 DOJ-04.04.2008 Address - 76 A, 3rd Floor, Gali No.- 6, Radheypuri Extension - 2,
Krishna Nagar, Delhi - 110051. Designation - Nursing Officer
36
55. Mukesh Chand Verma S/o - Girdhari Lal Bairwa DOB-01.01.1980
DOJ-10.05.2008
Address - 29/46 A, Gali No.- 12, Viswash Nagar, Shahdara, Delhi-110032.
Designation - Nursing Officer
56. Rajpal S/o - Ramavtar DOB-1978
DOJ-04.04.2008 Address - A-120, Gali No- 4, Jagatpuri, Mandoli Road, Shahdara, Delhi - 110093. Designation - OT Technician, Date of Appointment - 14.12.2011 Designation - Nursing Officer
57. Divesh Kumar S/o - Anugor Sahay DOB-09.07.1979 DOJ-10.04.2008 Address - Quarter No.-89, Staff Quarters, BSA Hospital, Sector-6, Rohini, Delhi-85
Designation - Nursing Officer
58. Ekta Malik D/o - Jagat Singh DOB-02.05.1979 DOJ-31.08.2008 Address - E-21, Upper Ground Floor, Arya Samaj Road Uttam Nagar, West, Delhi-59
Designation - Nursing Staff.
59. Sumitra W/o Sushil Kumar DOB-15.07.1982 DOJ-28.08.2008 Address - RZ-43 Dharampura-1, Nazafgarh, New Delhi-43
Designation - Nursing Staff.
60. Dev Krishan Godara S/o Prahalad Godara DOB-09.02.1978
DOJ-26.02.2007
37
Address - 211-C, New Lahore Colony, Shastri Nagar,
East, Delhi-31
Designation - Nursing Staff.
61. Mukesh Kumar Yadav S/o- Rohitash Yadav DOB-1986
DOJ-14.07.2008
Address - H.No.-62, Pocket-5, Sector-25, Rohini, Delhi.
Designation - Nursing Staff
62. Mahesh Kumar S/o - Ganpat Lal DOB-23.12.1978 DOJ-02.07.2008 Address - RZ-60, H. No. 10, Nand Vihar, Near Dwarika Metro Station, Delhi-78 Designation - Nursing Staff
63. Dharmendra Kumar S/o - Umrao Singh DOB-10.12.1979 DOJ-17.07.2007 Address Room No. 501, Muskan Hostel Designation - Nursing Staff 84/86, Kamla Near Dard Road, Delhi-110002
64. Vijay Veer Yadav S/o-Om Prakash Yadav DOB-12.01.1985 DOJ-02.07.2008 Address - S-133, IIIrd Floor, Front Side School Block Sakarpur, Delhi-92
Designation - Nursing Staff
65. Tejpal Singh Jatav S/oOm Prakash
DOB-05.07.19/84
DOJ-05.05.2008
Address - C-3/158, Sultanpuri, New Delhi-86 Designation - Nursing Staff
66. Surender Kumar Yadav S/o - Jugnal Singh Yadav
DOB16.11.1979
38
DOJ-01.10.2005 Address - H.No.-89B, Ram Park Road, Mohan Garden, Uttam Nagar, New Delhi-59 Designation - Nursing Staff
67. Satyapal Yadav S/o Mara Ram
DOB-29.07.1979 DOJ-04.07.2007 Address - RZ-60, H. No. 10, Nand Vihar, Delhi-78
Designation - Nursing Staff
68. Rakesh Kumar S/o Mohan Singh DOB-20.07.1986 DOJ-20.02.2007 Address - B- 3/394 Sector-6, Rohini, Delhi- 85 Designation - Nursing Officer
Mob. 9963056088
69. Jai Prakash Saini S/o Kalu Ram Saini DOB-05.07.1984
DOJ-07.04.2007
Address - E-163A, E-Block, Yadav Nagar, Samaypur, Delhi-42
Mob. 9313191611
Designation - Nursing Officer
70. Mukesh Kumar Jaat S/o Kushal Singh D.O. B.-01.08.1983 D.O.J.-03.04.2007 Address - B-2/345, Sector-6, Rohini Delhi 85 Designation- Nursing - Officer
Mob-9013757644
71. Prakash Chand Saini S/o Mali Ram Saini D.O. B.-02.07.1980 D.O.J.-21.02.2007 Designation- Nursing - Officer Address - G-23/07, Sector-7, Rohini, Delhi-85 Mob.-9868753488
39
72. Hari Ram S/o Sultan Singh D.O. B.- 10.02.1981
D.O.J. 13.04.2007
Address - 30, Block AIA, Chankya Place Part-1, D.K. Mohan Garden, West Delhi-59
Designation- Nursing - Officer
Mob-8178319884
73. Surender Kumar S/o Jagan Singh D.O. B.- 12.07.1977 D.O.J.-04.04.2007 Address Rz6/11,Gali No-07, IndraPark, Palam Colony, N.D.-45
Designation- Nursing - Officer Mob-99698428171
74. Balbindra Pal S/o Shishu Pal D.O. B.-01.02.1978 D.O.J.-03.04.2007 Address -C4/309, Sector-6, Rohini, Delhi-85 Designation- Nursing-Officer
Mob-9868024446
75. Gopal Sharma (LNJP) S/o Babu Lal Sharma D.Ο.Β.-01.07.1977
D.O.J. 20.03.2007
Address J-74, Gali No.-1, Khartar Nagar, Ghonda, Delhi-110053
Designation - Nursing - Officer
76. Rajender Singh Yadav S/o Jagram Yadav
Β.Ο.Β.-08.12.1978 D.O.J.-30.09.2005 Address - Plot No.- 126, Vill Badolla, Dwarka, Sec-8, Delhi
Designation - Nursing - Officer
Mob -
77. Asha Galav W/o Arvind Kumar Kushwah Β.Ο.Β.-08.12.1987
40
D.O.J.-04.07.2005 Address - Prop No.- 84, Flat No.- 204, Behind GB Pant, Hospital Durga Ganj, Delhi-110002 Designation - Nursing Officer
78. Ram Raj Kumhar S/o Ramniwas Kumar Β.Ο.Β.-17.10.1985 D.O.J.-21.07.2008 Address H.No.- 117B, Sector-16A, Nand Vihar, Dwarka, New Delhi-110078
Designation - Nursing - Officer
79. Naomi Chiinngashlian Tonsing D/o Suang Khopan Tosing, God D.O.B.-1977
D.O.J.-17.07.2008
Designation - Nursing - Officer …………Applicants
(By Advocate: Mr. Narender Kaushik with Mr Pankaj Kaushik)
Vs
1. Govt. of NCT of Delhi, Through its Chief Secretary, I.P. Sachivalaya, New Delhi.
2. Directorate of Health Services, Secretary Health,
I.P. Sachivalaya, New Delhi. ....Respondents
(By Advocate: Mrs Purnima Maheswari)
OA No. 2305/2021 (item 4-supp.)
1. Sh. Parikshit Gautam, Age:- 35 Years, S/O Shri Niwas Gautam,
R/O 58B, Gautam Niwas
Near BVM Public School
Najafgarh, Delhi-110043
Designation- Junior Radiographer
2. Sh. Santosh Suman, Age:- 36 Years, S/O Sh. Ramdeo Singh,
R/O R-77A Chanakya Place-II, New Delhi-110059
Designation- Junior Radiographer
41
3. Ms. Jagwati, Age:- 34 Years, D/O Sh. Naresh Kumar
R/O RZ-152/91, St. No., East Sagarpur, Delhi
Delhi-110040.
Designation- Junior Radiographer
4. Sh. Amit Kumar, Age - 36 years S/o Sh. Joginder Singh
R/o C-2/16, DDU Campus
Hari Nagar, Delhi
Designation - Junior Radiographer
5. Sh. Sanjeev, Age - 30 years S/o Sh. Mahinder Singh R/o House No. 208
Munguspur, Delhi
Designation - Junior Radiographer
6. Sh. Manoj, Age - 27 years, S/o Sh. Azad Singh
R/o VPO Azadpur, Nandnore, District Sonepat, Haryana Designation - Junior Radiographer
7. Sh. Taliwar Singh, Age - 40 years S/o Sh. Chhitermal
R/o C-76/A, Gali No. 7
Khijan Khurd, Delhi-110094 Designation - O.T. Assistant
8. Sh. Satish Singh, Age - 30 years S/o Sh. Ganga Ram
R/o 705/30, Vikas Nagar,
Gali no. 1, Kakori Road,
Sonepat, Haryana - 131001 Designation - O.T. Assistant …………Applicants
(By Advocate: Mr. Narender Kaushik with Mr Pankaj Kaushik)
Vs
1. Govt. of NCT of Delhi, Through its Chief Secretary, I.P. Sachivalaya, New Delhi.
2. Directorate of Health Services, Secretary Health,
42
I.P. Sachivalaya, New Delhi. ....Respondents
(By Advocate: Mrs Purnima Maheswari)
OA No. 2298/2020
1. Jitendra Kumar Mishra Father Name- Santosh Kumar Mishra Age-33
Designation- Pharmacist Date of joining-09-11-2011 Place of posted DGDTADE & Taxes CDMO CENTRAL Under DHS Delhi. Address- H.No FF 5 D8/15 DLF Ankur Vihar Loni Gaziabad UP 201102.
2. Amlan Mishra Father Name-Subodh Chandra Mishra Age-35 year
Designation-Pharmacist
Present Posting- Delhi High court medical and Health Center(Directorate of Health Services) Office of the Cheif district medical officer(New Delhi district) Residential address-F 402 Alpha 2
Greater Noida Pari Chowak Uttar Pradesh
Date of joining-10/1/2013.
3. Jyoti Jain Father name -Sushil Jain Designation -pharmacist Age-32
Date of joining- 9-01-2013 Place of posting with CDMO-CDMO Central district Under DHS Delhi.
Residential address 60/24 shiv Nagar, near Hindu Institute of Management, Sonipat Haryana.
4. Nirmala Kumari Father Name- Ramswaroop Saharan AGE-35
Designation- ANM
Date of Joining- 13/01/2012 Place of Posting- DGD Mangolpuri CDMO North West district under DHS Delhi
Residential Address Flat No.80 type 3 Dr.B.S.A. Hospital campus. Sector- 6 Rohini Delhi-110085
43
5. Monisha Jainer D/o Girl Chand Jainer Age 30
Designation lab assistant Date of joining 9.12.2011 Place of posting with CDMO office-DGD Yamuna Vihar CDMO North East District under DHS Delhi
Residential address C Block Gali Number 6 House Number 26 Dayalpur Delhi 94
6. Jyoti Sharma D/o Suresh Chander Sharma Age:-31Year
Designation: Lab Assistant Date Of Joining:-14/01/2013 Place Of Posting:-DGD Chander Nagar (on detailment CDMO East) Salary Draw West under DHS DELHI. CDMO
Residential Address:-H.No.-1/2252A Gali No-12 Ram Nagar Shahdara Delhi-110032.
7. Nepal Singh S/o Sh.PanmeshwariDayal Age 40yrs
DESIGNATION-LA/JMLT
DATE OF JOINING- 06/09/2012 Place of Posting- DGD JOHRI PUR CDMO NORTH EAST DISTRICT UNDER DHS Delhi RESI. ADD. D-2/61 A, Rama Bai Mohalla Johripur, Delhi 94.
8. Kavita W/o Vijay Kumar Age:-39Year
Designation:-ANM
Date of Joining:-13/01/2012 Place Of Posting:-DGD Katewara CDMO North West District under DHS Delhi Residential Address:-H.No.227 V&PO Auchandi Delhi-110039.
9. Poonam D/o Shree Brahmdutt Age-32
Designation-ANM Date of joining 17-01-2012 Place of posting- NORTH DISTRICT Under DHS Delhi
DGD KHERA KALAN CDMO
Residential address- H.NO-140/239 Patel Nagar
44
Sonipat near Bandepur police naka Haryana.
10. Kusum D/o Mr.Vikram Singh Age-29 year
Designation- Pharmacist Date of joining- 11-01-2013 Place of posting-DgdBhalaswa dairy (detailment in North zone) Salary drawn CDMO office-central zone under DHS Delhi Residential address-1/241 B-block baba Colony Burari delhi-110084.
11. Babita Pandey D/o BaldevPandey Designation-Pharmacist Age- 33 year
Date of joining-8/01/2013 Place of posting- DgdJharoda Ajra CDMO central district under DHS Delhi Residential address H.No- 1901, Street No - 55, B-block, Sant Nagar BurariDelhi 110084
12. Shilpi Mishra D/o Dr B.K. Mishra AGE-29
DESIGNATION Pharmacist
DATE OF JOINING- 10-01-2013
PLACE OF POSTING DGD MODEL TOWN
CDMO NORTH WEST (now North district) RESIDENTIAL ADDRESS-H15A, Bhagat Singh Park, SirasPur Delhi-110042. (NeelBhawan).
13. Manoj Kumar Father's name - Sh. Rambhaj DESIGNATION-LAB ASST Age - 36
Date of joining - 07.02.2012 Place of posting DGD Bhorgarh CDMO NORTH WEST Under DHS
Residential address - 14 A Vijay Nagar Colony, near Ravi Das Mandir, Hanuman gali, Bawana, Delhi-110039.
14. Vishal Bhat S/o- Ramesh Bhat Age-35
Designation- Lab Assistant Date of Joining- 7/2/2012
45
Posting-- Dgd H block Jahangirpuri CDMO North District under DHS Delhi
Residential Address 114-A Shiva Enclave Village Hiranki (Alipur) Delhi-110036.
15. Preeti Rani D/o Sh.Anoop Singh Age-32
Designation ANM Date of joining-02/12/2011 Posting -DGD H block Jahangir Puri
CDMO NORTH DISTRICT UNDER DHS
Delhi Residential address-H.No 238/30B Main Gali Vikash Nagar Sonipat (Near Vivekananda school)-131001.
16. Shiksha. D/o Ram Kunwar Age 31
Designation- LA Date of joining- 05/12/2011 Place of posting- DgdDariyapur Kalan CDMO NORTH DISTRICT UNDER DHS Delhi Address H.N.322, v.p.o. Saidpur, Near Airtel Tower, Tehsil Kharkhoda District- Sonipat.
17. Sumit S/o. Jaipal Age-20/02/1988 Designatoin-ANM Date of joining-08-02-2013 Place of posting---DGD KheraKalan, CDMO office North District, Residential Address-H no-770, VPO, KheraKhurd, Delhi-110082
18. Anita D /o- Sh. Shishpal Date of joining-07/12/2011 Designation- Lab Assistant Age-37 yrs.
Place of Posting- Seed PUHC PREM NAGAR-2&3 CDMO North west District under DHS Delhi Residential address-B-3/133,134 Sultan Puri delhi-110086.
19. Ajay Nair S/o-Shankar Nair Designation Lab assistant Date of joining 3/1/2013
46
Place of posting -Baba Sahab Ambedkar hospital CDMO- North West Under- DHS Delhi Residential address F5. 278 sector 16 Rohini Delhi-89 Age 33
20. Amit kumar S/o Kumar Anil Designation Lab assistant Date of joining - 28/12/12 Age-36
Place of posting Bhagwan Mahavir Hospital Pitampura CDMO NORTH WEST District Under DHS Delhi,
Residential address AT Puraniganj (Agarwal tola) Munger Bihar.
21. Kunal B Dass S/oBhagwan Dass Age:- 34
Designation- LA Date of joining:- 05/12/11 Place of posting:- DGD MadanpurDabas (currently) CDMO SOUTH EAST Under DHS Residential address:
House No-130, Pooth Khurd, Delhi-110039.
22. Mohit Kumar. S/o Shyam Lal. Age - 37. Designation Lab Assistant.
Date of joining 07/12/2011.
Posting -DgdBhalaswa Dairy CDMO NORTH District under DHS Delhi, Residential address H.No 253 Near Om Shanti Bhawan BakhtwarPur Delhi 110036
23. Shipra Sharma D/o SH. Kuldeep Sharma Age-29
Designation- ANM Date of joining-23-10-2012 Place of posting- DGD Bakhtawarpur from CDMO central district Under DHS Delhi.
Residential address- H.No. 1091 Near bada Shiv mandir, street No 4, Alipur, Delhi-10036.
24. SUNITA KUMARI
W/o-BHIM SINGH YADAV Age 40 year
Designation- ANM Date of joining 05-12-2011 Place of posting with CDMO office- CDMO SOUTH WEST DISTRICT POLYCLINIC PANDWALA KALAN UNDER DHS Delhi Residential
47
address HNO 221 G NO 9G BLOCK PREM NAGAR NAJAFAGARH
ND 43.
25. Ankur Pandey S/o Leeladhar Pandey Age - 36 Year
Designation Pharmacist Date of Joining - 08/12/2011 Place of Posting CDMO NORTH EAST DISTRICT
UNDER DHS
Residential Address D 272, Street No -6 West Vinod Nagar Delhi -92.
26. Saroj Dubey W/o Dilip Upadhyay Age-35 year
Designation- Lab Assistant/JMLT Date of joining- 09/12/2011 Place of posting - DgdGarhi CDMO SOUTH EAST UNDER DHS Delhi.
Address F 183/18 Mittal colony pulprahladpur New Delhi 110044.
27. Veena Rani D/oMahanvir Parsad Designation. ANM
DOJ. 07.12.2011
Age-39 year Posting. DGD shiv vihar CDMO West district under DHS Delhi. Residential Address- House no 97,
AherMohalla, Nagloi, Delhi-110041.
28. Sikha D/o Surender Singh Age -28
Designation-ANM Date of joining- 05/12/2011 Posting - DGD Tank road CDMO Central District under DHS Delhi
Residential address 319/1 Dayanand Nagar Bahadurgarh Haryana 124507.
……Applicants
(By Advocate: Mr Kartik Dabas)
Versus
1. Government Of NCT Of Delhi Through Principal Secretary (Health) Health & Family Welfare, 9th Level' 'A' Wing, Delhi Secretariat New Delhi-110002
48
2. The Chief Secretary, GNCTD 5 Th Level 'A' Wing, Delhi Secretariat New Delhi-110002
3. The Director Directorate Of Health Services F-17, Karkardooma, Delhi
4. Delhi Subordinate Services Selection Board (DSSSB) Through The Chairman Fc-18, Institutional Area, Karkardooma, Delhi-110092 .........Respondents
(By Advocate: Mrs Purnima Maheswari)
OA No. 1131/2020
1. Rimple Saini Father Name-Baldev Singh Saini Designation-Lab.Astt
Age-33
Place Of Posting- Cdmo Shahdara Account Branch
Cdmo Office- Shahdara
Residential Address With Pincode-D- 30, Street No.2, Madhuban Mohalla, North Gonda Delhi.
Pin Code: 110053
Date Of Joining- 05/12/2011
2. Sumit Sharma Father Name. Anand Prakash Sharma Designation.. Lab Astt. Age-34
Lace Of Posting..Dgd Timarpur Cdmo Office..Central District, Nabi Karim Address..B-16/2, Chandu Nagar, K.N Road, Delhi-110094 Date Of Joining.. 11 Jan 2013
3. Shalu Fathers Name-Sh Rajkumar Designation - Refractionist Age-34yrs
Posted At-Dgd Kondlin Dgd Bank Enclave Cdmo Office- East
Address -House No B47 Street No 4 Jyoti Colony Shahdara Delhi 32
Date Of Joining-13/12/11
4. Neeraj Kumar Sharma Father Name Late Sh. Ram Prakash Designation-Lab.Assitt
49
Age-36 Place Of Posting- Dgd Ashok Nagar Cdmo Office- Shahdara
Residential Address With Pincode-J-357, Old Seema Puri. Pin
Code-: 110095
Date Of Joining-01/03/2007
5. Subhash Chander Maurya Father's Name: Drigpal Maurya Posted At: Deep Chand Bandhu Hospital Age: 36 Years
Designation: Lab Assitant
Office: Sector, 13 Rohini, Cdmo, Northwest Delhi Under Dhs Address: D-294/1 Gali No.7 Mukund Vihar, Karawal Nagar, Delhi Date Of Joining: 11.02.2013
6. Sachin Kumar Father Name- Shri Ompal Singh Designation- Lab Assistant (Dhs) Age-34 Yrs Date Of Joining-10/09/2012 Place Of Posting-West District Cdmo Office-West District
Address-D-1508, 14th Floor Sg Grand Village Morti Rajnagar Extension
Ghaziabad Nh58
Pin Code-201017
7. Geeta Father's Name: Maham Singh Designation: Anm
Age:35
Place Of Posting: Dgd, Karkardooma Court, Cdmo Office Shahdra Address: Village, Bain, Tehsil Gannaur, Sonipat, Haryana-131101 Date Of Joining: 05/12/2011
8. Nisha Father's Name: Vijay Singh Designation: Lab Assistant Age: 35 Years
Place Of Posting: Dgd, Wazirabad, Cdmo Office, Nabi Karim Address: 46-C, Mig, Flats, Nand Nagri, Gtb Enclave, Delhi-110093 Date Of Joining: 20.12.2011
9. Jyoti Verma
50
Father Name:Sh Harpal Singh Verma Age:30
Designation :Anm
Place Of Posting: Dgd Khera Kala On Detailment Cdmo Office:Dilshad Garden North East District Address:H. No 248/16 Gandhi Nagar Ganaur Near Dhankhad Nursing Home Distt.Sonipat Haryana 131101
Date Of Joining: 02-12-2011 Dhs Joining
10. Sandeep Kumar Father Name- Hari Krishan Designation- Pharmacist Age-32
Place Of Posting District North-East Shs Office-School Health Scheme
Residential Address:- 1/3 Main Road, Mandoli Extension, Delhi-
110093
Date Of Joining- 07/12/2011
11. Amit Joshi Father Name Harish Joshi Designation-Pharmacist Age-30
Place Of Posting- Cdmo North Cdmo Office-Cdmo Northgulabi Bagh Date Of Joining-8/12/2011 Addres: H.No.363, Block A, Street No.6, Kaushik Enclave Burari Delhi.
12. Vinod Kumar Father Name Budh Prakash.. Designation - L. A. Age 35 Yrs
Place Of Posting Seed Puhc Jagatpur, Delhi
Cdmo Office Central District (Nabi Karim, Pahar Ganj) Address H. No 14, Gali No. 01, Jatav Basti, Burari, Delhi-110084 Date Of Joining - 09/12/2011
13. Renu Bala Father Name -Banwari Lal. Age 40 Yrs
Designation -Lab Astt. Date Of Joining-07-12-2011 Address-B-83 Jagat Puri Delhi -51 Posting - Karkardooma Court Dispensary..
51
14. Donhauching Age-33 Yrs
Father Name V. Pauthang Designation-Anm
Place Of Posting-Dgd Pandav Nagar Cdmo Office-Surajmal Vihar East District Delhi-92
Residence Add-House No. 117 2nd Floor Kilokri Ashram New Delhi
110014
Date Of Joining-13-01-2012
15. Madhu Sharma Father 'S Name Yogesh Sharma Designation - Lab Asst. Age-32yrs
Place Of Posting -Dgd Pandav Nagar (East Delhi) 110092 Cdmo Office
Gulabi Bagh Dda Flat 1st Floor 110007
Residential Address - H.No.154 Pandit Chowk Mandawali Delhi 110092
Date Of Joining 8. December 2011
16. Pooja Aggarwal Father's Name: Anil Kumar Designation: Lab Asst. Age:34 Years
Place Of Posting: Dgd, Geeta Colony, Cdmo Office: Cdmo Office East District, Surajmal Vihar Address: 9/21 Kailash Nagar, Delhi-110031 Date Of Joining - 07/09/2012
17. Sarla Bisht Father's Name-Bache Singh Bisht Designation-Lab Assistant Age-35
Place Of Posting-Dgd Himmatpuri Cdmo Office-Cdmo East Dist
Date Of Joining- 16/01/2013 Residential Address- F-46, Street No. 2 East Vinod Nagar State
Delhi-110091
18. Pooja Fathers' Name: Girdhari Singh Designation: Lab Asst. Date Of Joining: 10.01.2013
52
Age: 32 Place Of Posting: Dgd Kondli Mayur Vihar Cdmo Office: Cdmo East District Surajmal Vihar
Address; E-189, Gali No.5, East Vinod Nagar, Delhi
19. Suman Father's Name: Indra Dev Prasad Designation: Lab Asst. Age: 36 Years
Place Of Posting: Dgd, Mandawali Cdmo Office: Cdmo East District Address: E-290-A, Gali No.8, East Vinod Nagar, Mayur Vihar Phase -Ii, Delhi-110091 Date Of Joining: 14.12.2011
20. Νεετα Bala Father Namesh Ram Babu Designation - Lab Asst. Age-34 Yr
Place Of Postingdgd Trilokpuri Cdmo Office East District (Surajmal Vihar) Address H. Nog 14, Sgm Nagar, Gali No 1/1, Near Shiv Mandir Faridabad (Haryana) - 121001 Date Of Joining - 07/12/2011
21. Ritu Chauhan Father Name- Mr Rajkumar Chauhan Designation-Jr Radiographer Age-30
Place Of Posting- Deep Chand Bandhu Hospital Delhi 110052. Ashok Vihar Phase 4 Residential Address With Pincode- H.No 12 Samaspur Near Pandav Nagar Patparganj
Delhi 91
Date Of Joining- 17 January 2013
22. Anu Marwaha Father's Name: Ramesh Marwaha Age:33 Years
Post: Pharmacist
Date Of Joining: 08.12.2011 Address: C-447, St No. 17, Bhajanpura, Delhi- 110053 Posted At: Dgd, Bank Enclave Place Of Posting (Cdmo) - Cdmo East
23. Dhananjay Kumar Tiwari Father's Name Late Sri Ram Ekbal Tiwari Designation - La
53
Age-31 Place Of Posting -Dgd Nabikarim Cdmo Central
Date Of Joining-13/01/2013 Address-A267 2nd Floor North Block West Vinod Nagar Street No-05 Delhi 110092
24. Tarun Kumar Bhatia Father Name- Sh. Harish Kumar Bhatia Designation- Pharmacist
Age-31
Place Of Posting- Cdmo East Cdmo Office-Cdmo East
Residential Address With Pincode-C-15, Jhilmil Colony, Delhi
110095
Date Of Joining-8/12/2011
25. Dhirender Sharma Father Name- Sh.Ramakant Sharma Designation- Pharmacist Age-36
Place Of Posting-Dgd Kalyanpuri Cdmo Office- Cdmo East District Surajmal Vihar
Residential Address With Pincode-D-25, Street No.7, New Govind Pura Delhi 110051
Date Of Joining-14-1-2013
26. Sangeeta Rawat Father's Name Late D.S Rawat Designation Pharmacist Age-30
Place Of Posting Dgd Pandav Nagar Cdmo Office-Cdmo East District Date Of Joining-8/12/2011 Residential Address - C-47/A 3rd Floor Pandav Nagar Delhi-110092
27. Sumedha Saini Father Name Ishwar Dayal Saini Designation Pharmacist Age-33
Place Of Posting Dgd Mayur Vihar Ph 1, Cdmo Office-Cdmo
East Dist, Surajmal Vihar
Date Of Joining 14/01/2013
Residential Add-117. 4th Floor, Masjid
54
Moth Village, South Ex Part 2, New Delhi
110049
28. Richa Mumgaie Father's Name: Rishi Dev Mumgaie Post: Lab Asst.
Date Of Joining: 18.10.2012 Age:30
Place Of Posting: Seed Puhc Rajbeer Colony Cdmo Office: Cdmo East District, Surajmalvihar
Address: H.No.A-56, Street No.08, East Vinod Nagar, Delhi-110091
29. Sushma Father Name Narendra Singh Designation-Anm
Age- 29 Year
Place Of Posting- Dgd Bank Enclave Cdmo Office-East
Residential Address With Pincode-A9 Sankalp Apartment, Sec-64, Ballabgarh, Faridabad, Haryana Date Of Joining 17-01-2013
30. Deepak Kumar Father Name- Dharmvir Singh Designation- Lab Asst. Age-32
Place Of Posting- Dgd Bank Enclave Cdmo Office- East District Residential Address- H. No. 413,Q - Pocket Dilshad Garden. Pincode 110095 Date Of Joining-07-12-2011
31. Jai Prakash Ram Sewak
Designation: Lab Asst. Age:37 Years
Posted At: Aamc East Azad Nagar, Delhi Cdmo Office: Shahdra District Address: B-70/3, Kondli Colony Delhi-96 Date Of Joining: 10/02/2012
32. Atul Kumar Father Name- Mr. Rajender Prasad Desigpharmacist
55
Age-33years Place Of Posting- Cdmo Office North West Sec 13 Rohini
Addlig Flat 148, Pocket-5, Sector-2, Rohini Delhi-110085
Date Of Joining 19-10-2012
33. Amit Kumar Father Namelt. Sh. Kunwar Pal Singh Designation Pharmacist
Age-32 Year
Place Of Posting - O/O Cdmo North District Gulabi Bagh
Cdmo Office North District Gulabi Bagh Date Of Joining 8/12/2011
Address-B-15 Shiv Colony Budh Vihar Phase-2 Delhi-110086
34. Nidhi Father's Namesh. Om Parkash Hasija Designation - Pharmacist Age-32years
Place Of Posting Seed Puhc Gopal Nagar Najafgarh Cdmo- Southwest District
Date Of Joining 16-01-2013
Address-H Nb. 1506/40 Maksudabad Colony
Najafgarh New Delhi 110043
35. Binita Shreya Father's Name Kapil Deo Prasad Designation-Pharmacist Age 35
Place Of Posting-Seed Puhc Begumpur, North West Dist Residential Add- House No 23-24,Pkt 11 Sector 22, Rohini New Delh186 Date Of
Joining-15.1.2013
36. Devashish Bhattacharjee Father Name Mr. P. K Bhattacharjee Designation Jr. Radiographer D.O.B-27/12/1988
Place Of Posting Deep Chand Bhandhu Hospital Residential Add: R253 Mohan Garden Near Peepal Wala Chowk Uttam Nagar New Delhi: 110059 Date Of Joining: 19/01/2013
56
37. Amita Father Name- Ram Vir Singh Designation- Refractionist Age-31
Place Of Posting Deep Chand Bandhu Hospital
Residential Address -H No.34 3rd Floor Kewal Park Azadpur. 110033
Date Of Joining-. 25 April 2013
38. Rakhi Father's Name Mahendra Singh Place Of Posting-Aam Aadmi Polyclinic Cd Block Pitampura Delhi-110034 Cdmo North West District
Residential Address Flat No. 62 Type 2 Varun Niketan Au Block Pitampura.. Date Of Joining 5/12/11 Dob-10/10/1989 Designation - La
Age-31
39. Suman Father Name- Vedpal Designation- Anm Age- 32 Place Of Posting- Dr. N.C.Joshi Memorial Hospital Karol Bagh, Central Disst.110005 Residential Address With Pincode- Hno.11005, Gali No-3,
2nd Floor, Dori Walan,
Karol Bagh Gaushala Road, Pin No.110005
Date Of Joining-22/01/2013
40. Reena Father Name: Rajpal Age: 28 Years Designatio: Anm
Place If Posting: Dgd Tilangpur Kotla Cdmo Office: A2 Pashchim Vihar. West Zone Address: W/O - Amit Kumar Singh, Vpo - Tandaheri, Tehsil Bahadurgarh, Distt. Jhajjar, Haryana. 124507 Date Of Joining: 17-01-2013
41. Ankit Taneja Father Name-Sh Satish Kumar Taneja Designation-Lab Assistant Age-29
Place Of Posting- Dgd Tilangpurkotla Cdmo Office-West District
Residential Address = D 27 Bhagwati Vihar
57
Uttam Nagar Pincode-110059 Date Of Joining-9.1.2013
42. Sanjay Kumar:
Father's Name: Chandrika Prasad Post: Lab Asst.
Age:35 Yrs
Place Of Posting: Dgd Chowkhandi Cdmo Office: West District Address: A-70, Deepak Vihar, Vikas Nagar Delhi
Date Of Joining:07.12.2011
43. Mandeep Malik Father's Name: Dharamvir Singh Malik Post: Pharamcist
Age:32 Yrs
Place Of Posting: Dgd Chowkhandi Cdmo Office: West District Address: Rz-12 L/1, Gali No.5/12 Main Sagarpur, Delhi
Date Of Joining: 07.12.2011
44. Amit Kujur Father's Name: Habil Kujur Post: Lab Asst.
Age:34 Yrs
Place Of Posting: Dgd Bakarwala & Mundka Cdmo Office: West District
Address: A-2, Bosco Colony, Gopal Nagar, Extn. Najafgarh, Delhi
Date Of Joining:07.12.2011
45. Chanda Father Name Jogendra Prasad Designation Lab Assistant Age 32 Yrs
Place Of Posting- Dgd Nawada Cdmo Office-West Dist Residential Address-G2-313, Gali No-4, Jai Vihar Phase-2, Baprolla Najafgarh New Delhi 110043
Date Of Joining 10/01/2013
46. Gyan Chand Maurya S/O- Dinesh Maurya Designation-Pharmacist
58
Age-30 Joining Date- 08/12/2011 Place Of Posting-Dgd Jonapur (Cdmo South Distt.) Residential Address- E-132/A Chhatarpur Extension New Delhi-110074
47. Pooja Bharti. Father Name-Mr Deερακ. Designation-Lab Assisstant. Place Of Posting-Cdmowest District. Date Of Joining-13/1/2013. Address. B-353 Chowkhandi Tilaknagar Delhi 110018
48. Chandni Talwar Father Name- Mr.Rajan Kumar Talwar Designation- La
Age-29
Place Of Posting- Dgd A4/A Janak Puri Cdmo Office-West
Residential Address With Pincode-A-13, Shish Ram Park, Newdelhi-
110059
Date Of Joining- 9 January 2013
49. Pardeep Kumar Sharma Father's Name: Shyam Lal Post: Dental Hygienist Age:37 Yrs
Place Of Posting: Aruna Asaf Ali Hospital Address: E-77-A Punjabi Basti, Baljeet Nagar Delhi-110008 Date Of Joining: 13.02.2013
50. Sunny Ruhil Father Name: Shri Ramesh Chander Ruhil Age 32
Designation: Ot Technician
Hospital Name, Aruna Asaf Ali Hospital Rajpur Road Delhi: 110054. Date Of Joining: 23.8.2013. Budhpur Ashram Road Delhi 110036. Residential Add.. House No.127 Gaon
51. Aarti Devi Father's Name: Harswaroop Chhikara Post: O.T Asst.
Age:31 Yrs
Place Of Posting: Aruna Asaf Ali Hospital Address: H.No 4195, Gali No 75a, Swatanter Nagar, Near Aggersen School, Bawana Road, Narela, Delhi-110040
59
Date Of Joining: 21.01.2013
52. Anju Father's Name: Krishan Lal Post: Cssd Technician Age:39 Years
Place Of Posting: Aruna Asaf Ali Hospital Date Of Joining: 30.04.2013
Address: 32/4 Lajpat Nagar, Sonipat Haryana
53. Modasseruz-Zaman Father Name-Mozaffaruz Zaman Designation-Lab Assistant Age-35
Place Of Posting-Dgd Tank Road Karol Bagh Cdmo Office-Central District
Residential Address-100c Iind Floor Okhla Vihar Jamia Nagar Pincode-110025 Date Of Joining-8/01/2013
54. Diplove Harit Father Name: Mahavir Singh Post: Junior Radiographer Date Of Joining: 14.02.2013 Age:35 Yrs
Posted At: Aruna Asaf Ali Hospital Address: Flat No. 1179,Sector-19 Pоскет-3, Dwarka, Delhi
55. Amit Sharma Father Name Late Sh. Dayanand Sharma Desgnation- Pharmacist
Age-33 Yrs
Place Of Posting- Dgd Khajoori Khas, Khajoori Khas Village, Delhi-90 Cdmo Office-North East District Residential Address- Block C-8, House No-42 Yamuna Vihar, Delhi-110053
Date Of Joining- 11/09/2012
56. Seema Rani Father's Name: Tarsem Chand Post: Pharamcist
Age:36 Years
Place Of Posting: Seed Puhc Budh Vihar Cdmo Office: North West, Rohini Sector 13 Address: F-1/12, Phase 1, Budh Vihar, Delhi-
60
Date Of Joining: 11.02.2013
57. Manisha Rani Father's Name: Satish Chander Age:30 Yrs
Post:Lab Asst.
Date Of Joining:03.02.2012 Place Of Posting: Seed Puhc Budh Vihar Cdmo: North West Delhi
Address: H.No.231, Shahbad Daulatpur, Samaypur Badli, Delhi-
110039
58. Dheeraj Aggarwal Father Name-- Rajkumar Designation- Pharmacist Date Of Joining- 07/12/2011 Place Of Posting- Dgd Prem Nagar
Cdmo West Dob And Age - 01/07/1986
Age 34 Years
Add-S-221/204 Vishnu Garden New Delhi 110018
59. Prashant Goyal (New Name From Dated 04/08/2018 Tinku Aggarwal Older Name Father Name- Mohan Lal Aggarwal Place Of Posting School Health Scheme Date Of Joining-07/02/2013
Address: F-86,87 Raghubir Nagar New Delhi-110027 Age :33
Place Of Posting -School Health Scheme Designation-Pharmacist
60. Rekha Solanki Father Name-Sh. Chanderpal Solanki Designation-Lab Assistant Age-33
Place Of Posting-Aam Aadmi Polyclinic, Cd Block, Pitampura Cdmo Office-North West Residential Add-
11/31, Block-F, Sector-15, Rohini, New Delhi- 110085 Date Of Joining-28 March 2007
61. Μαμτα Father's Name: Omprakash Saini Post:Anm
Age:33 Yrs
Place Of Posting: Aam Aadmi Polyclinic, Sector-18, Rohini Cdmo Office: North West
Address: 309, Bhorgarh Narela, Delhi-110040
61
Date Of Joining: 5.12.2011
62. Neha Taneja Father's Name: Shyam Lal Taneja Designation: Pharmacist Age:31 Yrs
Place Of Posting: Dgd Sunlight Colony Cdmo Office: South East
Address: H.No. 46, Sector-18, Housing Board Colony, Faridabad, Haryana-121002 Date Of Joining: 07.12.2011
63. Balvinder Kaur Father's Name-Gurnam Singh Designation- Pharmacist
Age-30
Place Of Posting-Dgd Khyala Cdmo Office-Cdmo West Distt. Date Of Joining- 08/12/2011 Residential Address- Da-540 Shalimar Bagh Delhi-110088
64. Abhishek Kumar Jha Father's Name Shri Gyanesh Kumar Jha. Date Of Joining- 07/12/2011 Address.Tf A Wing M Lakeview Appartment Plot No 9 Khasra No 482 Shakti Enclave Burari Delhi 110084
Age 29 Years
Place Of Posting
Cdmo Central Distt.
Designation Lab Assistant
65. Name-Pardeep Kumar Father Name-Amar Singh Designation-Ot Technician Age-34 Place Of Posting-Dr N C Joshi Memorial Hospital Karol Bagh Delhi Cdmo Office- Residential Address
With Vpo Nandnour Dist Sonipat
Haryana Pincode-131001
Date Of Joining-12/12/2011
66. Pankaj Sharma Father Name-Shri Om Prakash Sharma Address: Ws 18 B Shri Ram Gali Sudama Puri Babar Pur Shahdara Delhi 110032
Designation Lab Asst. Date Of Birth-17.09.1979
62
Place Of Posting: Dgd Khajoori Khas Cdmo North East District Under Dhs
Date Of Joining 01.03.2007
67. Lucky Father Name- Dharam Chand Age-32 Dob-11-04-1986 Post- Lab Assistant Date Of Initial Joining- 11-01-2013 Residential Address- H.No. 70/13, Makkar Villa, Sikka Colony Near Anandpur Kuttiya Sonipat 131001
Place Of Posting:- Dgd Sangam Park (North West District)
68. Ruchika Father Name Jasbir Singh Designation-Anm
Age-35
Place Of Posting-Dgd Suiwalan Residential Address-713, Katra Abasian, Pahar Ganj, New Delhi-55 Date Of Joining 17 Oст 2012
69. Manish Kumar Singh Father Name - Sri Dharam Pal Singh Designation Lab.Asstt.
Age 37 (Dob 09/12/1982)
Place Of Posting Gautampuri Polyclinic Cdmo-North East Date Of Joining - 09/03/2007
Address H. No 107 Sec 2b 2nd Floor Vaishali Ghaziabad Up 201010
70. Shweta Bansal Father Name-Sunil Bansal Designation-La Age-31
Place Of Posting-Dgd Bholanathnagar Cdmo Office-Shahdara
Residential Address With Pincode-E58 Jhilmil Colony Date Of Joining-5.11.12
71. Sonia Verma Father Name Shri Suresh Verma Age-31 Years Designation- Pharmacist
Place Of Posting Polyclinic Paschim Vihar Cdmo Office West District
Address- H. Noa-282, Sudershan Park, Moti Nagar Date Of Joining - 08/12/2011 ……Applicants
(By Advocate: Mr. Kartik Dabas)
63
Versus
1. National Capital Territory Of Delhi Through Principal Secretary (Health) Health & Family Welfare, 9th Level' 'A' Wing, Delhi Secretariat New Delhi-110002
2. The Chief Secretary, Gnctd 5 Th Level 'A' Wing, Delhi Secretariat New Delhi-110002
3. The Director Directorate Of Health Services F-17, Karkardooma, Delhi
4. Delhi Subordinate Services Selection Board (Dsssb) Through The Chairman Fc-18, Institutional Area, Karkardooma, Delhi-110092 ….Respondents
(By Advocate: Mrs Purnima Maheshwari, Mr. Amit Yadav)
ORDER (ORAL)
Hon'ble Mrs. Pratima K. Gupta, Member (J):
The facts and issues in the captioned OAs are stated to be common, the grounds urged on behalf of the parties are also common and the reliefs sought by the applicants are similar. However, in OA No.3257/2024, the applicants participated in the selection process initiated by the respondents vide Advertisement No.2/23 dated 31.07.2023 and in view of the order passed by the Hon'ble High Court of Delhi, the benefit in terms of age relaxation was extended to the applicants in OA No.3257/2024. In the background of such an admitted position and with the consent of the learned counsel for the parties, the captioned OAs are being heard and decided together by the present common order.
64
However, for the sake of convenience, OA No. 1789/2020 has been taken as a lead case and facts are being taken from the pleadings therein.
2. Brief facts as explained by the learned counsel for the applicants are that the respondents issued a notification dated 23.01.2007 (placed at Page 21 of OA), inviting applications from eligible candidates for the post of Paramedical/Nursing Staff on contract basis. In pursuance of the same, the applicants have applied and after going through an interview, they were placed with the service of the respondents on contractual basis and they have continued on the same post till date. In the year 2020, in the wake of Covid-19, the respondents passed an order dated 20.08.2020 whereby existing contractual employees i.e Paramedical/Nursing staff were allowed to continue till 31.12.2020 by delinking such engagement with the regular number of vacancies, this was reiterated on 03.09.2020 by the respondents. However, the remuneration of the applicants was adjusted from "wages" head up to 31.12.2020. Aggrieved by the said order, the applicants approached this Tribunal by way of filing the instant Original Application seeking following reliefs:-
"i) to quash the Letter of this engagement dated 20.08.2020 and 08.09.2020 wef 31.12.2020
ii) to direct the respondent to regularize the applicant with consequential benefits in view of judgement of Uma Devi reported in SCC(1) 2006 18 order 06.11.2023 in CWP6798 of 2002 attended finally by withdrawal of SLP."
65
3. While issuing notice to the respondents on 17.11.2020, this Tribunal extended interim protection to the applicants. The same is reproduced as under:-
"We direct that the interim orders passed in the OAs shall be modified to the effect that in case there exists any work for the applicants, the respondents shall continue them subject to the same terms. However, they shall not be replaced by another set of contractual employees. Under no circumstances, the pendency of the OAs shall be a factor to deny appointment to the persons who are already selected by the Selecting Agency. It shall also be open to the applicants to avail the benefit of policy framed by the Government of Delhi on 11.10.2020."
4. Learned counsel for the applicants, in support of the cause of the applicants, argues that the respondents issued an advertisement, which was in public domain and in pursuance to the advertisement, the applicants applied, after going through scrutiny and filtration by way of a walk-in interview. The respondents after assessing their ability, suitability and educational qualification, appointed them on contractual basis against the sanction posts. The fact that the applicants have been allowed to continue from the date of their respective dates of appointment establishes that the job requirement in the hospital is of perennial nature. He draws strength from the decisions of the Hon'ble Supreme Court and Hon'ble High Court of Delhi in the following matters:-
(i) Sonia Gandhi & Ors. Vs. Govt. of NCT of Delhi & Ors. in WP (C) No. 6798/2002 decided on 06.11.2013. Paras 16, 17 & 22 of the said judgment read as under:-
66
"16. We take note of the decision dated May 22, 2009 in W.P.(C) No.8476/2009 as also the decision dated March 20, 2013 in W.P.(C) No.4641/2012 and direct that not only the writ petitioners in the above two writ petitions but additionally all contract appointed employees shall be paid wages by the Government of NCT of Delhi as per the decision of the Division Bench of this Court in W.P.(C) No.8476/2009 and shall be entitled to leave of all kind including maternity and sick leave in terms of the decision in W.P.(C) No.4641/2012.
17. On the subject of regularization the undisputed position which emerges is that over the last two decades i.e. 20 years the Government of NCT of Delhi has not assessed the man power requirement in its various departments and offices resulting in large scale contract appointment being resorted to. xxxx xxxx xxxx
22. Accordingly, we issue another direction and simultaneously dispose of the two writ petitions. The direction would be that the Government of NCT Delhi would carry out a manpower requirement assessment in all its departments keeping in view the fact that the population in Delhi has crossed 1.7 crore persons. Such number of posts shall be sanctioned as are necessary to provide services to the citizens of Delhi. A one time policy of regularization shall be framed and existing rules pertaining to service in different departments shall be amended. Existing contractual employees shall be considered for appointment to these new posts as per a policy framed."
(ii) K. Ragupathi Vs. The State of Uttar Pradesh and Ors. in Civil Appeal No. 3913 of 2022 decided on 12.05.2022. Para 11 of the said decision is reproduced herein below:-
"11. It is thus clear that the appellant was appointed after he underwent the entire selection process. Even as per the University, though the appointment shows that it is on a contractual basis, for all the purposes, it is on a regular basis. It could thus be seen that even for the appointment on a contractual basis in the said University, a candidate is required to undergo the entire selection process. Though he is appointed on a contractual basis, his terms and conditions are almost like a regular employee. It will be relevant to note that the Annual Performance Assessment Report (for short "APAR") of the appellant during the period 201213 show his performance to be outstanding. Every other parameter in his APAR is shown as excellent. With regard to his integrity, it is mentioned that there is nothing against the appellant adversely
67
reflecting his integrity. It is further stated in his APAR that he enjoys a good reputation and his integrity is good."
(iii) Raman Kumar & Ors. Vs. UOI & Ors. in Civil Appeal No. 7898/2020 decided on 03.07.2023. Para 13 of the said judgment read as under:-
"13. The services of the appellants are directed to be regularized from the date on which the services of other 35 employees were regularized and the backwages and other consequential benefits etc., to which the appellants would be entitled to, shall be paid to them within a period of six months from today."
(iv) Vikram Kumar & Ors. etc. Vs. UOI & Ors. in Civil Appeal Nos. 5153-54 of 2024 decided on 30.01.2024. Para 7 is as under:-
7. The judgement in the case Uma Devi (supra) also distinguished between "irregular" and "illegal" appointments underscoring the importance of considering certain appointments even if were not made strictly in accordance with the prescribed Rules and Procedure, cannot be said to have been made illegally if they had followed the procedures of regular appointments such as conduct of written examinations or interviews as in the present case. Paragraph 53 of the Uma Devi (supra) case is reproduced hereunder:
"53. One aspect needs to be clarified. There may be cases where irregular appointments (not illegal appointments) as explained in S.V. Narayanappa [(1967) 1 SCR 128 : AIR 1967 SC 1071] , R.N. Nanjundappa [(1972) 1 SCC 409 : (1972) 2 SCR 799] and B.N. Nagarajan [(1979) 4 SCC 507 : 1980 SCC (L&S) 4 : (1979) 3 SCR 937] and referred to in para 15 above, of duly qualified persons in duly sanctioned vacant posts might have been made and the employees have continued to work for ten years or more but without the intervention of orders of the courts or of tribunals. The question of regularisation of the services of such employees may have to be considered on merits in the light of the principles settled by this Court in the cases above referred to and in the light of this judgment. In that context, the Union of India, the State Governments and their instrumentalities should take steps to regularise as a one-time measure, the services of such irregularly appointed, who have worked for ten years or more in duly sanctioned posts but not under cover of orders of the courts or of tribunals and should further ensure that regular recruitments are
68
undertaken to fill those vacant sanctioned posts that require to be filled up, in cases where temporary employees or daily wagers are being now employed. The process must be set in motion within six months from this date. We also clarify that regularisation, if any already made, but not sub judice, need not be reopened based on this judgment, but there should be no further bypassing of the constitutional requirement and regularising or making permanent, those not duly appointed as per the constitutional scheme."
5. Learned Counsel for the respondents has placed on record the Recruitment Rules with respect to different cadre of Paramedical/Nursing Staff existing with the respondents, amended rules issued from time to time for various para medical staff, that may include Lab Assistant (Gr.IV), Assistant (OT/CSSD), Technician (OT/CSSD), Audiometric Assistant, Technical Assistant (OT/CSSD), Assistant Security Office, Refractionist, Occupational Therapist, Radiographer, Speech Therapist, Assistant Dietician, Physiotherapist. She confirms that in pursuance to the Recruitment Rules the respondents have sent requisition to DSSSB to notify the vacancies vide Advertisement No. 02/23 on 31.07.2023, wherein the posts have been advertised and numbered from Serial No. 15 to 26.
6. In rejoinder, learned counsel for the applicants submit that recruitment rules placed on record by learned counsel for the respondents have not been notified so far. Therefore, he submits that recruitment rules placed on record by the respondents are rather, incorrect or not in existence. He strengthened his submission from the different proceedings before Delhi High Court in WP(C ) No. 1629/2010 in the matter of Lalit
69
Kumar Vimal Vs. Secretary (Health) & Ors. and batch decided on 29.11.2010. Para 39 of the said Order dated 29.11.2010 reads as under-
"39. Before concluding we must express our anguish at the fact that the Government of NCT Delhi and its Department concerned i.e. the Board of Technical Education have not been discharging their Constitutional obligations evidenced by the fact that knowing fully well that Paramedical Education is not the subject matter of any legislation, they have neither legislated nor have framed any norms for recognizing institutions awarding diplomas in Paramedical Education."
7. Heard the learned counsel for the parties.
8. The issue in these OAs is that the applicants who were appointed on contractual basis seek regularization along with the consequential benefits. In order to decide the present Original Applications, we may revert back to the advertisement dated 23.01.2007 placed at page 21. From the advertisement, it is clear that the respondents had invited applications from eligible candidates for Paramedical/Nursing Staff purely on contract basis for a period of 11 months on consolidated monthly remuneration. The same is reproduce herein below:-
"Notice for Walk IN Interview
Application from eligible candidates are invited for engagement of the following Paramedical/Nursing Staff purely on contract basis for a period of 11 months on consolidated monthly remuneration (inclusive of all allowances). Interviews will be held in the Conference Room. Office of the Medical Superintendent, Dr. Hedgewar Arogya Sansthan, Karkardooma, Delhi-32. The appointment is purely on contract basis initially for a period of 11 months OR till regular candidate joins the post, whichever is earlier. The candidates can register their names with the office of the MS, as per the specimen application from given in along with the advertisement, for interview from 24-01-08 to 31-01-08 between
02.00 p.m. to 4.00 p.m. No application will be entertained after scheduled time and date. The name of posts, qualification required,
70
remuneration (consolidated) and dates of interviews are given as under:-
xxx xxx xxx xxx"
9. To elaborate, the appointment was on contractual basis on a consolidated salary, on the basis of the Walk- in- Interview. The Recruitment Rules placed on record confirm that they were notified in the year 1959 and subsequently amended in 1984, in some of the cases in 1998 and they were in place at the relevant point in time , when the advertisement was issued on 23.01.2007. In the exigency of service, the Applicants were appointed on contractual basis and have been continued, since then, particularly in view of interim protection extended by this Tribunal. Evidently, it is clear from the Advertisement itself that the Applicants were not appointed against any substantive posts. The same is further confirmed by the subsequent Order of Hon'ble Lt. Governor on 20.08.2020 and reiterated on 03.09.2020. Therefore, the Applicants cannot be stated to be appointed against any regular vacancies.
10. With respect to the submissions of the learned counsel for the applicants that the Applicants were filtered and selected after the selection process initiated by the respondents against the regular vacancies and discharging their duties since the inception, the contentions, according to us, are misplaced, to clarify, that they never participated against the regular process prescribed under the recruitment rules and neither were
71
they appointed against the regular posts. However, they have continued for a fairly long time. Precisely, for the reason that the Applicants have continued for a long period, they have been extended one time age relaxation in terms of order dated 11.10.2020 passed by the respondents, in compliance of the decision of the Hon'ble High Court of Delhi in matter of Sonia Gandhi & Ors. Vs. GNCTD & Ors. The Applicants were extended the relaxation and allowed to participate in the regular selection process. However, the Applicants have chosen not to respond to the advertisement. The judgment relied upon by the learned counsel for the applicants i.e. Sonia Gandhi & Ors. (Supra) clearly mentions that the respondents were directed to take a policy decision with respect to regularization of the contractual employees. The respondents have taken decision and passed orders on 11.10.2020 as explained above and the Applicants have been extended the benefits of the said decision, this decision has not been challenged in the instant O.A.
11. With respect to decision in the matter of K. Ragupathi Vs. The State of Uttar Pradesh and Ors. in Civil Appeal No. 3913/2022 of Hon'ble Apex Court as relied upon by the learned counsel for the applicants, in the said judgment of the Hon'ble Apex Court, the Applicants though were appointed on contractual basis, however, they went through a selection process which was almost like a regular process which is not existed in the present case. Therefore the said judgment may not come to the rescue of the Applicants. The judgement in Raman
72
Kumar & Ors. Vs. UOI & Ors. in Civil Appeal No. 7898/2020 of the Hon'ble Supreme Court may also not come to the rescue of the Applicants, as the facts in the said matter were completely different from the present Original Application, as in the facts before the Apex Court, there were two sets of the applicants before the Hon'ble Apex Court wherein one set of the applicants were extended certain benefits and second set though were denied, therefore the Honorable Supreme Court extended the relief for the reasons of parity, which is also not the same situation as in the present case. In the judgment of Vikram Kumar & Ors. etc Vs. UOI & Ors in Civil Appeal No. 5153-54 of 2024 of the Hon'ble Supreme Court, it has reiterated the decision in the matter of
Uma Devi, wherein certain directions have been issued by the Hon'ble Supreme court with respect to "irregular" and "illegal" appointments. In the present case, the Applicants have not participated in the due process.
12. The submission of the learned counsel for the applicants that the recruitment rules have not been notified is not accepted, in light of the fact that the notified RR are placed on record. Relying upon recruitment rules, the respondents have sent a requisition to DSSB to notify the vacancies on 31.07.2023. The said advertisement also clearly mentions in para 4 that the respondents have extended the relaxation to all the contractual employees working with the Department of Health & Family Welfare which was also extended to the Applicants. However, the Applicants have chosen not to participate in the selection process.
73
Moreover, with respect to the submission of the learned counsel for the applicants that the Hon'ble Lt. Governor has sought amendment in the RRs, it is clear that Recruitment Rules that have been notified by the respondents in respect to post 1959 amended in 1988 &1998 and are sought to be revised and amended by the respondents, however, this amendment has not been placed so far. Therefore, the present Recruitment Rules are in force.
13. The submission of the Applicants in the OA that the Applicants have been placed incorrectly under the "Wages Head", it will be worthwhile to mention the Order dated 03.09.2020 whereby the Applicants' services have been adjusted from the Wages Head. From the said order, it is clear that in view of exceptional circumstances that prevailed due to Covid-19, the Applicants' service continued with the respondents and therefore, the respondents were persuaded to accommodate the Applicants and continued.
14. For the reasons detailed hereinabove, the instant OAs are dismissed.
15. Pending MAs, if any, shall stand disposed of. No costs.
(Chhabilendra Roul) (Pratima K. Gupta) Member (A) Member (J)
/pinky
Alert