- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
TARUN KUMAR MAJHI v. STATE OF WEST BENGAL
Summary of Opinion — Ajay Kumar Gupta, J. (CRR 1439 of 2021)
Factual and Procedural Background
The petitioner, an advocate, purchased a Hyundai Xcent (Reg. No. WB-52 AG-4147) in 2017 under a loan. The vehicle was seized by police in connection with Nandan Ghat P.S. Case No. 180 of 2017 (alleged NDPS offences dated 15.07.2017). The petitioner was initially named in the FIR but was discharged during investigation; other accused were acquitted by the Special Judge (NDPS) on 23.12.2020. The trial court's final order stated the vehicle was "liable to be confiscated to the state" but directed preservation of the vehicle pending trial of an absconding accused. The petitioner applied under Section 452 CrPC to recover the vehicle; the learned Additional Sessions Judge rejected the application by Order No. 2 dated 20.04.2021 on the ground that the petitioner's application was belated. The petitioner filed this revisional application challenging that order and seeking release of the vehicle to the registered owner.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the learned Court below correctly rejected the petitioner's application for release of the seized vehicle solely on the ground of belated filing.
- Whether the petitioner, as registered owner and having been discharged/where the trial concluded in acquittal of others, is entitled to delivery of the seized vehicle under Section 452 CrPC, and on what conditions.
Arguments of the Parties
Petitioner's Arguments
- The petitioner is the registered owner of the seized vehicle and was falsely implicated; he was discharged during investigation.
- After learning of the acquittal, he applied under Section 452 CrPC for release of the vehicle; rejection on the ground of belated application is without merit.
- Counsel relied on precedents to support that seized vehicles should not remain indefinitely in police custody or open space and may be released to owners subject to conditions.
State's Arguments
- The learned Court below rightly rejected the release application because it was filed belatedly.
- If released, the vehicle might again be used to transport contraband; therefore the impugned order should be affirmed.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Shajahan Vs. Inspector of Excise & Ors.1 | Referred by petitioner to support that a seized vehicle should not be kept in police custody or in the open and may be released subject to conditions. | The Court considered the judgments referred by the petitioner along with Section 452 CrPC; no distinct, case-specific reliance beyond that consideration is recorded in the opinion. |
| Anil Navnath Marathe Vs. State of Maharashtra and Anr.2 | Referred by petitioner for the same purpose: supporting release of seized vehicle with terms/conditions. | Considered by the Court together with Section 452; the opinion does not record a separate, detailed application of this precedent. |
| Sunderbhai Ambalal Desai V. State of Gujarat3 | Referred by petitioner in support of release principles for seized property. | The Court noted the judgments and relied on Section 452 CrPC in permitting interim delivery; no further specific application of this precedent is recorded. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court examined the impugned order and found the learned Court below rejected the petitioner's application solely because it was filed "at belated stage." The Court held that this ground of delay was insufficient to deny release when: (a) the petitioner is the registered owner; (b) he was discharged during investigation before cognizance; (c) the trial concluded in acquittal of the other accused; and (d) the vehicle has not been confiscated or disposed of and remains in police custody. The Court referred to Section 452 CrPC (orders for disposal of property at conclusion of trial and delivery to persons claiming possession, including power to impose bonds/sureties). On perusal of Section 452 and the judgments relied upon by the petitioner, the Court concluded there was no impediment to allowing release of the vehicle to the owner. The Court imposed conditions to secure restoration if required (bond with surety, prohibition on transfer/use for offences, and obligation to produce the vehicle when called by the trial court). The trial court was directed to determine the ultimate fate of the vehicle in accordance with law.
Holding and Implications
IMPUGNED ORDER NO. 2 DATED 20.04.2021 SET ASIDE; CRR 1439 OF 2021 ALLOWED.
Direct effects and consequences:
- The revisional court set aside the learned Additional Sessions Judge's order rejecting the petitioner's application and allowed interim delivery of the seized vehicle to the registered owner subject to conditions: (i) execution of a bond with surety of Rs. 6,00,000 and undertaking to produce the vehicle when called and not alter its character; (ii) prohibition on transfer, sale or alienation until final decision by the trial court; and (iii) prohibition on using the vehicle to commit any offence.
- The final fate of the vehicle is to be decided by the learned Trial Court in accordance with law.
- No broader, novel precedent is declared by this opinion; the decision applies the statutory provision (Section 452 CrPC) to the facts and returns the matter for final adjudication by the trial court.
Note: All content in this summary is confined to and reproduced from the provided opinion.
IN THE HIGH COURT AT CALCUTTA
CRIMINAL REVISIONAL JURISDICTION
Appellate Side
Present:
The Hon'ble Justice Ajay Kumar Gupta C.R.R. 1439 of 2021
Tarun Kumar Majhi
Versus
The State of West Bengal
For the Petitioner : Mr. Pinak Kumar Mitra, Adv. Mr. Soumen Nanda, Adv.
For the State : Ms. Faria Hossain, Adv. Ms. Suparna Chatterjee, Adv.
Heard on : 16.04.2024
Judgment on : 15.07.2024
1
2
Ajay Kumar Gupta, J:
1. By filing this revisional application, the petitioner has challenged the propriety, legality and correctness of the impugned Order No. 2 dated 20thApril, 2021 passed by the learned Additional Sessions Judge, 3rdCourt, Burdwan in Criminal Misc. Case No. 578 of 2021, thereby rejected the prayer of the petitioner for releasing of the seized vehicle being registration No. WB-52 AG-4147 involved in Special Case No. 34 of 2017 arising out of Nandan Ghat Police Station Case No. 180 of 2017 dated 15.07.2017 under Sections 20(b)(ii)(C) and 29 of the Narcotic Drugs and Psychotropic Substances Act, 1985.
2. The essential facts of the instant case are relevant for the purpose of disposal of this instant case as under:
2a. The petitioner is an advocate by profession and in the year 2017, he purchased a vehicle, namely, Hyundai Xcent Car being registration No. WB - 52 AG-4147 financed by Axis Bank amounting to Rs. 5,95,796/- payable in 84 months equal instalments at the interest rate 9.50% in connection with the car loan account number
AUR000502322954.
2b. It is the contention of the petitioner that the said car was seized by the police in connection with Nandan Ghat P.S. Case No.
3
180 of 2017 dated 15.07.2017 under Sections 20(b)(ii)(C) and 29 of the Narcotic Drugs and Psychotropic Substances Act, 1985 and since then the said car is under the custody of the investigating agency. 2c. It is further contention that though the petitioner is absolutely innocent and he has no way connected with the aforesaid Nandan Ghat P.S. Case. However, his name was initially transpired in the First Information Report but after culmination of investigation, he was discharged from the said case on the basis of prayer made by the investigating officer before the learned Court below as no evidence found against the petitioner. However, his car is still in the custody of police as an alamat of this case.
2d. It is further case of the petitioner that the said proceeding has been finally disposed of on 23.12.2020 by the learned Special Judge, 3rdCourt (NDPS) thereby acquitted the accused persons, namely, Sanjib Roy, Sukhdeb Das, Samir Saha and Pintu Mallik from the charge framed under Sections 20(b)(ii)(C) and 29 of the Narcotic Drugs and Psychotropic Substances Act, 1985 and the learned Court was pleased to pass the following order in respect of the seized vehicle of the petitioner as under:
"Since there is no prayer for release of the alleged seized vehicle during investigation or trial of this case the said vehicle is liable to be confiscated to the state
4
but the same along with other seized alamats and the mat Exts be preserved till disposal of this case after trial of the absconding accused Bhagna @ Rajus Debnath @ Raju Das."
2e. It is further contention of the petitioner that when he came to know about the final disposal of the case by way of acquittal of the accused persons, he preferred an application before the learned Trial Court praying for releasing of his vehicle under Section 452 of the CrPC but the learned Trial Court has rejected his prayer for return of his vehicle on 20.04.2021 vide Order No. 2 in Criminal Misc. Case No. 578 of 2021 only on the ground that the application u/s 452 of the CrPC filed by the petitioner made at belated stage. It has no merit to release of the said vehicle. Petitioner is owner of the offending vehicle. He made an application for releasing of his vehicle after knowing the final result of the case of acquittal. As such, the instant revisional application has come up before this Court with a prayer to set aside the impugned order and praying for releasing of the vehicle to the original owner i.e. petitioner herein.
SUBMISSIONS ON BEHALF OF THE PETITIONER:
3. Learned counsels appearing on behalf of the petitioner submitted that the petitioner is an advocate by profession and he is
5
the owner of the seized vehicle being registration No. WB - 52 AG- 4147. He had been falsely implicated into this case by naming in the FIR but subsequently during investigation, no evidence found against the present petitioner as such, investigating officer prayed for discharge. As such, he has been discharged from Nandan Ghat Police Station Case No. 180 of 2017 dated 15.07.2017 under Sections 20(b)(ii)(C) and 29 of the Narcotic Drugs and Psychotropic Substances Act, 1985.
3a. It is further submitted that after knowing the final result of acquittal of other accused persons, he has applied for returning of his vehicle under Section 452 of the CrPC but the learned Court below outrightly rejected his prayer for returning of his seized vehicle only on the ground that the petitioner has made his application for releasing at belated stage, which has no merit to release the said vehicle.
Learned advocate has referred the following judgments to bolster his submissions that seized vehicle cannot be kept in the custody of police or shall not remain in open space. It may be released with terms and conditions to the original owner.
6
i. Shajahan Vs. Inspector of Excise & Ors.1
ii. Anil Navnath Marathe Vs. State of Maharashtra and Anr.2
iii. Sunderbhai Ambalal Desai V. State of Gujarat3
SUBMISSION ON BEHALF OF THE STATE:
4. On the other hand, learned counsels appearing on behalf of the State submitted that the learned Court has rightly rejected the prayer for return of the seized vehicle. If it would be released then again it may be used to transport contraband goods as such order passed by the learned Court should be affirmed. Furthermore, prayer was made at belated stage.
DISCUSSIONS, ANALYSIS AND CONCLUSION OF THIS COURT:
5. Having heard the submissions of the parties and on perusal of the impugned order, this Court finds the learned Court below rejected his prayer only on the ground that the application was filed under Section 452 of the Cr.PC by the petitioner at the belated stage. Application has no merit to release the said vehicle. That ground of delay is not sufficient to reject his prayer for releasing of the vehicle
7
though there is no dispute that the present petitioner is not the owner of the seized vehicle.
6. Furthermore, he has been discharged from the case at the initial stage before taking cognizance of the offence by the learned Trial Court. At the same time, the said case was disposed of by declaring the other accused persons not found guilty and acquitted them from the said case. Coming to know the final result of the case, the present petitioner has filed the application for releasing of his vehicle. It is also not disputed that the said vehicle was not confiscated or disposed of. The vehicle is still lying with the custody of the police. Question of delay in filing application for release of vehicle after final conclusion of trial does not arise.
7. In view of the fact, there is no any impediment to allow the prayer for releasing of the vehicle under Section 452 of the Cr.PC. This Court would like to refer Section 452 of the CrPC for ready reference and for better understanding as under:
"S. 452. Order for disposal of property at conclusion of trial. — (1) When an inquiry or trial in any Criminal Court is concluded, the Court may make such order as it thinks fit for the disposal, by destruction, confiscation or delivery to any person claiming to be entitled to possession thereof or otherwise, of any property or document produced before it or in its custody, or regarding which any
8
offence appears to have been committed, or which has been used for the commission of any offence.
(2) An order may be made under sub-section (1) for the delivery of any property to any person claiming to be entitled to the possession thereof, without any condition or on condition that he executes a bond, with or without securities, to the satisfaction of the Court, engaging to restore such property to the Court if the order made under sub-section (1) is modified or set aside on appeal or revision.
(3) A Court of Session may, instead of itself making an order under sub-section (1), direct the property to be delivered to the Chief Judicial Magistrate, who shall thereupon deal with it in the manner provided in sections 457, 458 and 459.
(4) Except where the property is livestock or is subject to speedy and natural decay, or where a bond has been executed in pursuance of sub-section (2), an order made under sub-section (1) shall not be carried out for two months, or when an appeal is presented, until such appeal has been disposed of.
(5) In this section, the term "property" includes, in the case of property regarding which an offence appears to have been committed, not only such property as has been originally in the possession or under the control of any party, but also any property into or for which the same may have been converted or exchanged, and anything acquired by such conversion or exchange, whether immediately or otherwise."
8. Upon perusal of the said provision as well as judgments referred by the petitioner, this Court finds there is a specific provision for order of disposal of the property at conclusion of trial. Here the
9
property is vehicle being registration No. WB - 52 AG-4147 which was seized in the instant case and the trial has already been concluded. It appears from the final judgment that the learned Court below passed an order with regard to the seized vehicle of the petitioner as under:
"Since there is no prayer for release of the alleged seized vehicle during investigation or trial of this case the said vehicle is liable to be confiscated to the state but the same along with other seized alamats and the mat Exts be preserved till disposal of this case after trial of the absconding accused Bhagna @ Rajus Debnath @ Raju Das."
And acquitted the accused persons, namely, Sanjib Ray, Sukdeb Das, Samir Saha and Pintu from the charges framed under Sections 20(b)(ii)(C) and 29 of the Narcotic Drugs and Psychotropic Substances Act, 1985. Only one accused person, namely, Bhagna Raju @ Raju Debnath has been found absconding from the said case and whenever he will arrest, his case may be started de novo trial till such date, the vehicle would not be confiscated or disposed of in view of the order passed by the learned Trial Court as such, vehicle is still in the custody of police authorities.
9. Furthermore, it appears from the provision stipulated under sub-Section (1) of Section 452 that when an inquiry or trial in any
10
Criminal Court is concluded, the Court may make such order as it thinks fit for the disposal, by destruction, confiscation or delivery to any person claiming to be entitled to possession thereof or otherwise, of any property or document produced before it or in its custody, or regarding which any offence appears to have been committed, or which has been used for the commission of any offence.
10. Similarly, sub-Section (2) of Section 452 also provides that an order may be made under sub-section (1) for the delivery of any property to any person claiming to be entitled to the possession thereof, without any condition or on condition that he executes a bond, with or without securities, to the satisfaction of the Court, engaging to restore such property to the Court if the order made under sub-section (1) is modified or set aside on appeal or revision.
11. In view of the provisions stipulated under sub-Sections (1) and (2) of Section 452 of CrPC, there is no impediment to allow the prayer for releasing of the vehicle to the petitioner since he is the owner of the seized vehicle and he has submitted sufficient document to show that he is the owner of the seized vehicle. The trial of the case has already been concluded in acquittal. It is not that the absconding accused is the owner of the seized vehicle as such prayer for releasing of vehicle may be disallowed. Question of filing application for
11
releasing of vehicle at belated stage does not arise as it should be allowed at conclusion of trial.
12. In the light of above discussions, this Court is of the opinion that the seized vehicle can be allowed to be returned to the registered owner as an interim custody subject to the following conditions: -
i. Vehicle be released upon furnishing of the bond with surety of Rs. 6,00,000/- (Rupees Six Lakhs) only and on further condition that the petitioner will produce the said vehicle before the learned Trial Court as and when called for and he will not change the nature and character of the vehicle till final decision of the learned Trial Court.
ii. The petitioner shall not transfer, sell or alienate the seized vehicle without final decision of the learned Trial Court.
iii. The seized vehicle shall not be used for the commission of any offence.
13. Accordingly, the impugned Order No. 2 dated 20thApril, 2021 passed by the learned Additional Sessions Judge, 3rdCourt, Burdwan in Criminal Misc. Case No. 578 of 2021, thereby rejecting the prayer of the petitioner for releasing of the seized vehicle being registration No. WB-52 AG-4147 involved in Special Case No. 34 of 2017 arising out of Nandan Ghat Police Station Case No. 180 of 2017 dated 15.07.2017 under Sections 20(b)(ii)(C) and 29 of the Narcotic
12
Drugs and Psychotropic Substances Act, 1985 is hereby set aside. The fate of the said vehicle will be decided by the learned Trial Court in accordance with law.
14. Accordingly, CRR 1439 of 2021 is, thus, allowed. Connected applications, if any, are also, thus, disposed of.
15. Case Diary, if any, is to be returned to the learned Advocate for the State.
16. Let a copy of this judgment and order be sent to the learned Court below for information and taking necessary action.
17. Interim order, if any, stands vacated.
18. Parties shall act on the server copies of this order uploaded on the website of this Court.
19. Urgent photostat certified copy of this judgment, if applied for, is to be given as expeditiously to the parties on compliance of all formalities.
(Ajay Kumar Gupta, J)
P. Adak (P.A.)
Alert