Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

STAFF SELECTION COMMISSION AND ANR  v. SHUBHAM PAL ANR ORS

Delhi High Court
Oct 7, 2024
Smart Summary (Beta)

Case Summary: LPA 985/2024 – Staff Selection Commission & Anr. v. Shubham Pal & Ors.

Factual and Procedural Background

This Letters Patent Appeal was filed by the Staff Selection Commission (SSC) challenging a judgment dated 16 February 2024 of a learned Single Judge in WP(C) 16593/2023. The underlying dispute arises from the Combined Graduate Level Examination (CGLE) Tier-II, 2023 conducted by the SSC for recruitment to various civil posts under the Union. The respondents (candidates) challenged the correctness of answers provided in the final Answer Key released by the SSC in respect of seven Question IDs (264330172912, 264330164754, 264330162641, 264330164417, 264330172352, 264330173697 and 264330171997), contending that corrections would yield them 21 additional marks and materially alter their results.

The Single Judge rejected the respondents' challenge as to six of the seven questions but allowed the challenge in respect of Question ID 264330171997. The SSC appealed that part of the Single Judge's judgment. The Division Bench observed that, in principle, challenges of this nature may fall within the jurisdiction of the Central Administrative Tribunal (CAT) under Section 14 of the Administrative Tribunals Act, 1985 (relying on L. Chandra Kumar v. UOI), but declined to remit the matter to the Tribunal because of intervening proceedings (a Coordinate Division Bench had dismissed LPA 202/2024 on merits on 27 May 2024 and Special Leave Petitions arising therefrom had been filed in the Supreme Court), and therefore decided the present appeal on merits.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the High Court had jurisdiction to entertain the writ petition challenging the Answer Key in view of the law in L. Chandra Kumar v. UOI and Section 14 of the Administrative Tribunals Act, 1985 (i.e., whether such matters fall within the exclusive domain of the Central Administrative Tribunal).
  2. On the merits, whether the final Answer Key for Question ID 264330171997 (letters O, K, E, Y) correctly listed "two" meaningful English words ("YOKE" and "OKEY") or whether only one meaningful English word ("YOKE") could properly be formed (i.e., whether "OKEY" qualifies as a meaningful English word for the purposes of the question).

Arguments of the Parties

Appellants' (SSC) Arguments

  • Courts are ordinarily proscribed from interfering with answers suggested in examination answer keys because those decisions lie within the academic/subject-expert domain and judges lack the requisite expertise.
  • The SSC relied on opinions of subject experts who opined that two meaningful English words — "YOKE" and "OKEY" — can be formed from the letters O, K, E and Y.

Respondents' (Candidates) Arguments

  • The correct answer to Question ID 264330171997 is Option 2 ("One"): only "YOKE" constitutes a meaningful English four-letter word formed from the letters O, K, E and Y.
  • "OKEY" is not a meaningful English word in the context of the question; the references produced by SSC show "Okey-key" as the Turkish game's name and "okey dokey" as a phrase, not "OKEY" as a standalone, meaningful English word.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
L. Chandra Kumar v. UOI, (1997) 3 SCC 261 Establishes that matters within the jurisdiction of the Central Administrative Tribunal (as delineated in Section 14 of the AT Act) are to be instituted before the Tribunal and not as a first instance matter in the High Court. The court observed that, in principle, the respondents were not entitled to institute the writ petition before the High Court because the challenge related to recruitment to civil posts under the Union and thus fell within Section 14 of the AT Act. Nonetheless, the Division Bench refrained from setting aside the Single Judge's judgment on that ground due to the procedural posture (see reasons given regarding LPA 202/2024 and SLPs) and proceeded to decide the appeal on merits.
Om Prakash Verma v. National Testing Agency, 2024 SCC OnLine Del 909 Examined extensively the law concerning judicial interference with examination answer keys and distilled guiding principles about deference to experts and circumstances permitting interference. One Judge of the Division Bench relied on the detailed takeaways from this decision (summarised as items (i)–(xi) in the opinion) to frame the standard for when courts may examine answer keys and when deference to subject experts is appropriate.
Kanpur University v. Samir Gupta, (1983) 4 SCC 309 Cited among precedents considered in the court’s review of the principles governing challenges to answer keys and academic expertise. Referenced as part of the body of case law forming the basis for the court’s stated takeaways on judicial review of answer keys (supporting the principles listed at paragraphs summarising items (i)–(xi)).
Manish Ujwal v. Maharishi Dayanand Saraswati University, (2005) 13 SCC 744 Cited among precedents on judicial approach to academic/answer key disputes. Used as part of the jurisprudential foundation for the court’s summary of guiding principles about when interference with answer keys is appropriate.
Guru Nanak Dev University v. Saumil Garg, (2005) 13 SCC 749 Cited concerning handling of vague questions and relief for students who attempted vague questions. Referred to in support of the proposition that where questions are unacceptably vague, affected students may be entitled to marks after deleting the vague questions; used as part of the general approach to answer-key disputes.
H.P. Public Service Commission v. Mukesh Thakur, (2010) 6 SCC 759 Cited among authorities on judicial deference in answer-key disputes. Included in the set of cases relied upon in framing the principles (items (i)–(xi)) guiding judicial review of suggested answer keys.
Rajesh Kumar v. State of Bihar, (2013) 4 SCC 690 Cited as an example where a large number of wrong answers (45 out of 100) were at issue and the appropriate remedy was revaluation on corrected keys rather than cancellation and re-examination. Referred to by the court to illustrate that even significant numbers of wrong answers do not automatically justify cancellation of an exam, supporting the court's approach to remedies in answer-key disputes.
Ran Vijay Singh v. State of UP, (2018) 9 SCC 357 Cited among authorities on the court's approach to academic/answer key disputes. Formed part of the jurisprudential backdrop (items (i)–(xi)) for judicial review of answer keys.
Rishal v. Rajasthan Public Service Commission, (2018) 8 SCC 81 Cited among authorities on answer-key and exam disputes. Referenced as part of the corpus of decisions informing the court’s articulated principles governing interference with answer keys.
UPPSC v. Rahul Singh, (2018) 7 SCC 254 Cited among precedents addressing the judicial approach to examination answer keys and related relief. Included in the set of authorities relied upon to develop the list of takeaways governing when courts may examine answer keys and the scope of relief.
Shubham Pal & Ors. v. Staff Selection Commission & Anr. (WP(C) 16593/2023) — Single Judge judgment dated 16.02.2024 The impugned Single Judge decision rejecting challenges to six questions and allowing the challenge to Question ID 264330171997. This judgment is the subject of the appeal (LPA 985/2024). The Division Bench upheld the Single Judge’s decision insofar as it allowed the challenge to Question ID 264330171997.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Division Bench proceeded in two main strands: (A) procedural/jurisdictional point; and (B) merits of the challenged question.

A. Jurisdictional / Procedural Analysis

  • The court noted the clear principle in L. Chandra Kumar that disputes falling within Section 14 of the Administrative Tribunals Act, 1985 (which includes recruitment to civil posts under the Union) are to be instituted before the Central Administrative Tribunal and not first before the High Court.
  • Applying that principle, the court acknowledged that the respondents' challenge related to recruitment to Union civil posts and therefore, in principle, was amenable to adjudication by the Tribunal and not this Court.
  • However, the Division Bench declined to set aside the Single Judge's judgment on maintainability grounds because of the procedural posture: a Coordinate Division Bench of this Court had dismissed LPA 202/2024 on merits on 27 May 2024 (a matter connected to the unsuccessful challenge on six questions), and Special Leave Petitions against that decision were pending in the Supreme Court. The court concluded that remitting the parties to the Tribunal at that stage would be futile and inequitable and therefore proceeded to decide the appeal on its merits.

B. Merits — Treatment of Challenges to Answer Keys and Specific Analysis of Question ID 264330171997

  • The court addressed the SSC's preliminary objection that courts should generally defer to subject experts on answer-key issues. The court accepted that circumspection is generally appropriate, particularly where experts have considered objections, but emphasised that there is no absolute bar to judicial review when an answer is plainly and demonstrably incorrect.
  • The opinion relied on a prior detailed exposition (Om Prakash Verma v. NTA) and a cluster of precedents to distil guiding principles (set out in the judgment as items (i)–(xi)). Those principles include: general circumspection where experts opine; no absolute proscription on judicial examination of answer keys; courts may consult authoritative textbooks; interference is warranted in rare and demonstrable cases where the key is plainly wrong; where a key answer is demonstrably wrong, students should not be penalised; vague questions should be handled as in Saumil Garg; remedies such as revaluation (not necessarily cancellation) are often appropriate; and in doubt, benefit generally goes to the examining authority.
  • Turning to the specific question (QID 264330171997) the court reproduced the question and the contested options. The respondents said only "YOKE" could be formed (Option 2, "One"). The SSC and its subject experts said two words — "YOKE" and "OKEY" (Option 1, "Two") — could be formed.
  • The court examined the Subject Matter Expert (SME) material placed before the Single Judge. The SME note referred first to "Okey-key" as the name of a tile-based Turkish game and then, in the same paragraph, to "okey" as a less common variant of "okay" (as in the informal phrase "okey dokey"). Thus, the SME's references indicated that "Okey-key" is the game's name and "okey" occurs as part of the phrase "okey-dokey" or as a casual/informal variant, not as a standard meaningful standalone English word.
  • The Single Judge had held, and the Division Bench agreed, that the question required "meaningful English words" — a formulation that, by its plain meaning, excludes informal variants, colloquialisms or foreign game names that do not amount to meaningful English usage. The court reasoned that a Turkish game's name or an informal casual variant used in a phrase cannot, on its face, be treated as a "meaningful English word" for the purposes of the question.
  • Therefore, the Division Bench found no reason to interfere with the Single Judge's conclusion that "OKEY" did not qualify as a meaningful English word formed solely from the letters O, K, E and Y, whereas "YOKE" clearly did. The court emphasised that allowing a rare or informal spelling variant to stand would be unjust to candidates who were unaware of such usage.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The Division Bench concurred with the Single Judge and found that the correct answer to Question ID 264330171997 is Option (2) — "One" (only "YOKE"). The appeal challenging that part of the Single Judge's judgment was dismissed.

Final Disposition: The appeal is dismissed.

Implications

  • Direct effect on parties: The Single Judge's decision insofar as it allowed the respondents' challenge to Question ID 264330171997 is upheld; the final Answer Key's suggestion that two meaningful words could be formed (by counting "OKEY") was rejected by the court.
  • The court articulated and applied established guiding principles (derived from prior decisions) on when courts may and may not interfere with examination answer keys: judges must generally show circumspection and deference to experts but may intervene in rare cases where the suggested answer is demonstrably wrong or unjust to candidates.
  • The judgment contains observations warning that examination questions (and suggested answers) should be crafted sensitively and sensibly given their pan-India impact on candidates; the court criticised the usage of rare or informal variants as testing grounds for recruitment examinations.
  • No broader, novel binding precedent altering the settled principles about jurisdiction under the AT Act or judicial review of answer keys was set by this decision; the court applied existing principles to the facts and dismissed the appeal.

Decision authored by C. Hari Shankar, J.; concurred by Dr. Sudhir Kumar Jain, J. (Oral judgment dated 07 October 2024).

Show all summary ...

LPA 985/2024 Page 1 of 15

$~78 * IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI

+ LPA 985/2024 STAFF SELECTION COMMISSION AND ANR ....Appellants Through: Ms. Pratima N. Lakra, CGSC with Mr. Chandan Prajapati and Mr. Ashesh Chaudhary, Advs.

versus

SHUBHAM PAL ANR ORS .....Respondents Through: Mr. Ankur Chhibber, Adv.

CORAM:

HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE C. HARI SHANKAR HON'BLE DR. JUSTICE SUDHIR KUMAR JAIN

JUDGEMENT (ORAL)

% 07.10.2024

C.HARI SHANKAR, J.

1. This Letters Patent Appeal at the instance of the Staff Selection Commission1

assails the judgment dated 16 February 2024, passed by a learned Single Judge in WP (C) 16593/20232.

2. The facts of the case are set out in sufficient detail in the judgment of the learned Single Judge and, for the limited purposes of the present appeal, it is not necessary to advert to all of them. Suffice it to state that the dispute relates to the Combined Graduate Level Examination3

Tier-II, 2023 conducted by the SSC for recruitment to various civil posts under the Union. The respondents assailed the

1

"SSC", hereinafter

2

Shubham Pal and Ors. v. Staff Selection Commission & Anr.

"CGLE", hereinafter

3

correctness of the answers provided in the final Answer Key released by the SSC in respect of the CGLE. According to the respondents, the Answers provided in the final Answer Key to Question IDs

264330172912, 264330164754, 264330162641, 264330164417,

264330172352, 264330173697 and 264330171997 were incorrect. It was submitted that, if the suggested answers in the final Answer Key were corrected as sought by the respondents, it would result in the respondents obtaining as many as 21 additional marks, which would radically alter their result in the CGLE.

3. The learned Single Judge rejected the challenge laid by the respondents, save and except in respect of Question ID 264330171997. In other words, of the seven questions, forming subject matter of challenge in the writ petition, the challenge succeeded in respect of one question alone and failed in respect of the remaining six questions.

4. At this juncture, we deem it necessary to note that, in our view the respondents were not entitled to have instituted the writ petition before this Court at all, in view of the judgment of 7 Hon'ble Judges of the Supreme Court in L. Chandra Kumar v UOI4. In the said decision, the Supreme Court has held, with no equivocation whatsoever, that matters which fall within the jurisdiction of the Central Administrative Tribunal5, as delineated in Section 146

of the

4

(1997) 3 SCC 261

5

"the learned Tribunal", hereinafter

6

14. Jurisdiction, powers and authority of the Central Administrative Tribunal. - (1) Save as otherwise expressly provided in this Act, the Central Administrative Tribunal shall exercise, on and from the appointed day, all the jurisdiction, powers and authority exercisable immediately before that day by all courts (except the Supreme Court) in relation to -

2

Administrative Tribunals Act, 19857

have necessarily to be instituted before the learned Tribunal alone and that the High Court cannot entertain such challenges as a court of first instance. Section 14 of the AT Act includes, within its ambit, all disputes relating to recruitment and matters concerning recruitment, to civil posts under the Union.

"Recruitment" includes all stages from the point of issuance of advertisement till actual selection of the candidates. It is obvious, therefore, that the challenge laid by the respondents relates to matters

(a) recruitment, and matters concerning recruitment, to any All-India Service or to any civil service of the Union or a civil post under the Union or to a post connected with defence or in the defence services, being, in either case, a post filled by a civilian;

(b) all service matters concerning—

(i) a member of any All-India Service; or

(ii) a person not being a member of an All-India Service or a person referred to in clause (c) appointed to any civil service of the Union or any civil post under the Union; or

(iii) a civilian not being a member of an All-India Service or a person referred to in clause (c) appointed to any defence services or a post connected with defence,

and pertaining to the service of such member, person or civilian, in connection with the affairs of the Union or of any State or of any local or other authority within the territory of India or under the control of the Government of India or of any corporation or society owned or controlled by the Government;

(c) all service matters pertaining to service in connection with the affairs of the Union concerning a person appointed to any service or post referred to in sub-clause (ii) or sub-clause (iii) of clause (b), being a person whose services have been placed by a State Government or any local or other authority or any corporation or society or other body, at the disposal of the Central Government for such appointment. Explanation. - For the removal of doubts, it is hereby declared that references to "Union" in this sub-section shall be construed as including references also to a Union Territory.

(2) The Central Government may, by notification, apply with effect from such date as may be specified in the notification the provisions of sub-section (3) to local or other authorities within the territory of India or under the control of the Government of India and to corporations or societies owned or controlled by Government, not being a local or other authority or corporation or society controlled or owned by a State Government:

Provided that if the Central Government considers it expedient so to do for the purpose of facilitating transition to the scheme as envisaged by this Act, different dates may be so specified under this sub-section in respect of different classes of, or different categories under any class of, local or other authorities or corporations or societies.

(3) Save as otherwise expressly provided in this Act, the Central Administrative Tribunal shall also exercise, on and from the date with effect from which the provisions of this sub-section apply to any local or other authority or corporation or society, all the jurisdiction, powers and authority exercisable immediately before that date by all courts (except the Supreme Court) in relation to -

(a) recruitment, and matters concerning recruitment, to any service or post in connection with the affairs of such local or other authority or corporation or society; and

(b) all service matters concerning a person other than a person referred to in clause

(a) or clause (b) of sub-section (1) appointed to any service or post in connection with the affairs of such local or other authority or corporation or society and pertaining to the service of such person in connection with such affairs.

"the AT Act", hereinafter

7

concerning recruitment to civil posts under the Union and is, therefore, amenable to adjudication by the learned Tribunal in terms of Section 14 of the AT Act. Ergo, by application of the law laid down in

L. Chandra Kumar, this Court would not have the jurisdiction to entertain the petition.

5. We were, therefore, inclined to hold that the writ petitions instituted by the respondents were themselves not maintainable and on that ground, to set aside the impugned judgment of the learned Single Judge. However, we are constrained from doing so as, against the unsuccessful challenge to six questions, as raised by them, the respondents filed LPA 202/2024, which stands dismissed on merits by a detailed judgment of a Coordinate Division Bench of this Court on

27 May 2024. Against the said decision, some candidates have also petitioned the Supreme Court by way of Special Leave Petitions in which, too, notices stand issued.

6. In that view of the matter, the situation has reached a point of no return, and it would be futile as well as unjust and equitable to relegate the petitioners to seek their remedies before the learned Tribunal.

7. We had observed as much in a brief order penned by us on 04 October 2024, in which we noted that given these circumstances, we had no option but to decide the present appeal on merits.

8. The present appeal is, therefore, directed only against the

4

decision of the learned Single Judge to reject the challenge laid by the petitioners to the correctness of the answer provided in the final Answer Key in respect of Question ID 264330171997.

9. We have heard Ms. Pratima N. Lakra, learned CGSC for the appellants and Mr. Ankur Chhibber, learned counsel for the respondents.

10. Before we advert to the specific question under challenge, we may address a preliminary objection raised by Ms. Lakra to the effect that courts are ordinarily proscribed from interfering with answers suggested in Answer Keys to examinations, as these pertained to the academic sphere, which is, to some extent, no man's land to the Judge. This is especially so in cases where the challenge has been examined by subject experts, whose opinion is ordinarily entitled to deference. There are several decisions which hold that Courts do not possess the requisite expertise to sit in appeal over the decisions of the subject experts and that therefore, such challenges should, if at all, be entertained with a pinch of salt.

11. That said, however, it is equally obvious that the sphere of judicial review cannot be all together foreclosed when such challenges arise. There may be gross cases, or cases in which it is evident without any necessity for ratiocination or intricate reasoning that the answer under challenge is palpably incorrect. In such case, the interests of substantial justice have to prevail, and students who have attempted the examination cannot be allowed to suffer merely because of an obviously incorrect answer suggested by the subject experts.

5

12. One of us (C. Hari Shankar J.) has had an occasion to examine the law on this aspect in considerable detail in Om Prakash Verma v National Testing Agency8. After a chronological excursion through

Kanpur University v Samir Gupta9, Manish Ujwal v Maharishi Dayanand Saraswati University10, Guru Nanak Dev University v Saumil Garg11

H.P. Public Service Commission v Mukesh Thakur12,

Rajesh Kumar v State of Bihar13, Ran Vijay Singh v State of UP14,

Rishal v Rajasthan Public Service Commission15

and UPPSC v Rahul Singh16, the following takeaway emerged:

(i) Circumspection is the general rule, especially where experts have considered the objections raised to the answer key.

(ii) It is, however, equally the rule that there is no absolute proscription against courts examining the challenge to the key answers, even where experts have opined. The law does not commend, or even recommend, a "hands-off approach".

(iii) In an appropriate case, the court can even examine, for itself, the correctness of the key answers under challenge, in which process the court is also empowered to refer to authoritative textbooks on the subject, especially those which

8

2024 SCC OnLine Del 909

9

(1983) 4 SCC 309

10

(2005) 13 SCC 744

11

(2005) 13 SCC 749

12

(2010) 6 SCC 759

13

(2013) 4 SCC 690

14

(2018) 9 SCC 357

15

(2018) 8 SCC 81

(2018) 7 SCC 254

16

form part of the students' curriculum.

(iv) Where the question is simple, and not admitting of any complexity, and can command only one answer, which is apparent to the court, the court is not proscribed from taking a view based on its own perception of the question to take an extreme example, the sum of two and two. That, however, would have to be in a rare case in which the answer is so apparent that there can be no doubt about it, and not one where the opinion of someone with greater expertise would help, or where there is ambiguity.

(v) In any case, the guiding principle is that the general rule against accepting the suggested answer key stands relaxed only where the suggested answer is proved to be wrong, not by an inferential process of reasoning or rationalisation, but clearly and demonstrably wrong, in that no reasonable body of men well-versed in the subject would regard the key answer as correct.

(vi) Another guiding principle, which the court was required to bear in mind in such cases, is that, where it was beyond doubt that the key answer was wrong, it would be unfair to penalise students for not giving the suggested, demonstrably wrong answer. Any refusal on the part of the court to interfere, even in such a case, would amount to a serious illegality.

(vii) Where questions were unacceptably vague, the principle advocated in Saumil Garg is required to be followed. Any

7

student who attempted all or some of said vague questions would be entitled to be marked out of a total after deleting the marks assigned to the questions which she, or he, had attempted.

(viii) Even where a large number of key answers were found to be incorrect as in Rajesh Kumar, which involved 45 wrong key answers out of 100 it would not be justifiable to direct cancellation and re-holding of the examination. Revaluation of the papers on the basis of the corrected answer keys would still be the only correct approach.

(ix) Interference has, therefore, to be only in "rare and exceptional cases", and to a "very limited extent".

(x) In the event of doubt, the benefit of doubt would go to the examining authority, not to the candidate.

(xi) The general principle is that relief cannot be restricted to the candidates who approached the court, but must be extended to all who are similarity situated. While so doing, the court can direct that the revaluation, would not result in any negative impact on candidates who had attempted the disputed questions and whose answers corresponded to the suggested answer key.

13. Thus, while circumspection is expected of courts while dealing with challenges to answer keys in examinations, a hands-off approach is not always advocated. If the Court is satisfied that the answer provided in the impugned answer key is obviously incorrect, so that

8

allowing the answer to remain would result in injustice, the Court has necessarily to step in and set aright the situation. Any judge who, perceiving obvious injustice taking place before him, professes inability to interfere, breaches his solemn oath of office. Howsoever circumspect an approach the law may advocate, the approach can never be so circumspect as would allow injustice to occur, unredressed.

14. This is what the learned Single Judge has attempted to do in respect of Question ID 264330171997. The appellants contend that the learned Single Judge has erred in doing so.

15. Question ID 264330171997 read thus :

"How many meaningful English words can be formed with the second, fourth, fifth and sixth letters of the word HOCKEY (when counted from left to right) using each letter only once in each word?

1. Two.

2. One.

3. Zero.

4. Three."

16. The respondents contend that the correct answer is Option 2 i.e.

"One". The final Answer Key released by the SSC, on the other hand, noted the correct answer to be "two" i.e. Option 1. According to the respondents, the only meaningful four letter word, which can be formed from the letters O, K, E and Y is "YOKE". The SSC contends, however, based on the opinion of subject experts, that two meaningful English words can be formed from the letters O, K, E and Y, i.e.

"YOKE" and "OKEY".

9

17. The learned Single Judge has held that "OKEY" is not a meaningful English word and that therefore the only four letter meaningful English word which can be formed from the letters O, K, E and Y is in fact "YOKE". The impugned judgment, therefore, upholds the challenge raised by the respondents, and holds that the correct answer to Question ID 264330171997 is Option (2) i.e. "One".

18. The petitioner produced, before the learned Single judge, the analytical note of the subject experts as well as the explanation provided in the SME17

Confidential report thus:

"Note/Analysis of the Subject Matter Experts

Two words can be formed from the letters o, k, e, y - Yoke - A yoke is a wooden beam sometimes used between a pair of oxen or other animals to enable them to pull together on a load when working in pairs, as oxen usually do; some yokes are fitted to individual animals.

Okey-key (Turkish Pronunciation : [okej]) is a tile based game[1]. The aim of the game is to score points against the opposing players by collecting certain groups of tiles. Okey is usually played with four players, but can also be played with only two or three players. It bears resemblance to the game Rummikub, as it is played with same set of boards and tiles, but under a different set of rules.

Explanation provided in the SME Confidential Report:-

While "okay" is more commonly used, variations like "okey" may be informal or specific to certain contexts. "Okey" is a less common variant of the word "Okay", which is used to express agreement, approval, or acknowledgement. It's an informal term that signifies acceptance or understanding in a casual context. It is used as an adjective as another form of Ok. Please check the sentence in Oxford Dictionary page "everything is okey dokey now". This signifies that Okey is a word used as informal term that signifies acceptance or understanding in a casual context."

"Subject Matter Expert"

17

19. The learned Single Judge has dealt with the challenge, thus, in para 32 of the impugned judgment:

"32. However, with respect to Question ID - 264330171997 regarding how many meaningful English words can be formed from the specified 4 letters of the word "HOCKEY", the Tentative Answer Key referred to "One" as the answer. However, the Final Answer Key referred to "Two" as the answer. The Subject Matter Expert has reasoned that "Yoke" is one word and the other "okey- dokey" and also referred to a Turkish card game called "Okey".

This Court is unable to agree with the Experts on this question. What was asked was "meaningful English words" as per the question. The word "okey-dokey" appears in the Shorter Oxford English Dictionary (Sixth Edition), Volume - 2: N-Z, published by Oxford University Press, of the year 2007 and appears to be synonymous to the word "okay", but surely does not consist only of 4 letters of the word HOCKEY and the word "okey" read alone does not appear to be "meaningful". So far as the word "okey" stated to be a Turkish game is concerned, by no stretch of imagination, can the same be called a "meaningful word" of

"English" language. Surely, the name of a game cannot be said to be a meaningful English word, particularly a Turkish game. The game originally may be pronounced in such manner but has no relevance to the doubted question. Thus, it is clear that the Final Answer Key in respect of this question, is incorrect. This Court has ventured to examine this question as the alternate word appeared to be, on the face of it, incorrect."

(Emphasis supplied)

20. We have examined Question ID 264330171997, the suggested answers and the opinion of the subject matter expert and find no reason to interfere with the view expressed by the learned Single Judge.

21. That "YOKE" is a meaningful English word, which can be formed from the letters O, K, E and Y is obviously not in dispute, and all parties are ad idem in that regard. The dispute is whether "OKEY"

is also a meaningful English word. As the learned Single Judge has correctly observed, the analytical note of the Subject Matter Experts

11

first refers to "Okey-key", as the name of a tile-based game. The reference to "OKEY" later in the same paragraph is obviously an abbreviation of "Okey-key". The actual name of the tile-based game is not "OKEY" but "Okey-key" even as per the opinion of the Subject Matter Experts. Even otherwise, the use of a word as the name of a Turkish board game cannot, ex facie, be regarded as "meaningful English usage" of the word, as the learned Single Judge correctly holds.

22. The explanation provided in the SME Confidential Report refers to "OKEY" as an informal variation of "OKAY" used "in a casual context". This aspect is clarified by the sentence provided further in the passage as an example of use of the word "OKEY". The sentence reads "everything is okey dokey" now. The actual phrase that is used, therefore, is "okey dokey".

23. Even if "OKEY" by itself were to be regarded as a word, the SME Confidential Report clearly states that it is an informal variation, used in a casual context. The learned Single Judge is justified in the emphasis that he lays on the fact that the candidate was required to find out "meaningful English words" from the letters "OKEY", with stress on the word "meaningful".

24. The use of "OKEY-KEY" as the name of a Turkish game can obviously not be regarded as a meaningful English usage of the word. Nor can the manner in which the word "OKEY" is stated to be used as an informal variant of the word "OKAY", employed in casual context,

12

be regarded as a meaningful English usage of the word.

25. In such cases, the question has to be carefully examined. Every expression used in the question is supposed to have its own significance. The Court is required to be aware of the significance of the use of the word "meaningful", in the question. The obvious intent of the question is to exclude informal usages, colloquialism or slangs. Only words which can be regarded as "meaningful English usage"

would qualify.

26. Viewed thus, we are in agreement with the learned Single Judge that the opinions of the Subject Matter Experts, on which the appellants relied, do not make out "OKEY" as a meaningful English usage of the letters O, K, E and Y. "YOKE", on the other hand, undoubtedly qualifies.

27. We, therefore, concur with the view expressed by the learned Single Judge in the impugned judgment with respect to Question ID

264330171997.

28. Before parting, we deem it necessary to enter an observation in respect of cases such as this.

29. Questions in examinations, which have serious and often pan- India ramifications on the candidates who undertake them, are required to be crafted both sensitively and sensibly. We have come across cases in which questions, and the suggested answers to the questions, are such as no person, instructed in the subject to which the

13

question pertains, would be able to answer. Take the present case itself, as an example. While we do not claim to be experts in the English language, neither of us has, over half a century of existence each, come across the word "OKEY", in any manner of usage in the English language. The word "OK" is either spelt "OK" or "OKAY".

There may be a one-off instance, where the spelling "OKEY" is used. One wonders, however, whether anything meaningful is achieved by testing the ability of candidates in examination such as this, to qualify and obtain recruitment to civil posts, by testing whether they know that the word "OKEY", is used, rarely, as a vulgarism of "OKAY".

30. We wonder, equally, whether it is at all fair to pose such a question to candidates, and test their competence and ability to join civil posts, based on whether they are able to correctly answer the question - assuming, that, is, that "OKEY" is to be treated as one of the correct answers.

31. Even if, therefore, "OKEY" is a rare informal usage of the letters O, K, E and Y, we feel it totally unjust to treat a candidate, who is unaware of such usage, as having wrongly answered the question. To our mind, the only meaningful word which can be formed from the

letters O, K, E and Y is "YOKE". 32. We, therefore, find ourselves entirely in agreement with the learned Single Judge, insofar as the view adopted by him in respect of Question ID 264330171997 is concerned. Conclusion

14

33. For the aforesaid reasons, we see no reason to interfere with the impugned judgment of the learned Single Judge insofar as it has allowed the challenge raised by the respondent regarding Question ID

264330171997.

34. The appeal is accordingly dismissed.

C.HARI SHANKAR, J.

DR. SUDHIR KUMAR JAIN, J.

OCTOBER 7, 2024/yg/dsn Click here to check corrigendum, if any

15