- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
M S COMPETENT ENGINEERS v. CANARA BANK
Factual and Procedural Background
The petitioner, M/s Competent Engineers, a Micro, Small and Medium Enterprise (MSME), challenged the demand notice dated 24.04.2024, the sale notice dated 18.07.2024, and the declaration of its account as a Non-Performing Asset (NPA) by Canara Bank. The petitioner sought quashing of these actions and a writ of mandamus directing the bank to constitute a committee as per the Reserve Bank of India (RBI) Framework for Revival and Rehabilitation of MSMEs dated 17.03.2016. The petitioner contended that coercive measures were initiated under the SARFAESI Act without attempting restructuring as mandated by the RBI Framework.
The respondent bank stated that restructuring of the petitioner's loan account was carried out on 29.12.2021 with a two-year moratorium. The petitioner defaulted on repayments after the moratorium period, leading to the initiation of proceedings under the SARFAESI Act and declaration of the account as NPA on 31.03.2024. Notices under Section 13(2) of the SARFAESI Act were issued, and the bank proceeded with auctioning the secured asset.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the demand notice, sale notice, and declaration of the petitioner's account as NPA can be quashed on the ground that the bank failed to follow the RBI Framework for Revival and Rehabilitation of MSMEs prior to initiating SARFAESI proceedings.
- Whether the bank is obligated to constitute a committee as per the RBI Framework before taking coercive action under the SARFAESI Act.
- Whether the writ jurisdiction can be exercised by the High Court in the presence of a statutory remedy under the SARFAESI Act.
Arguments of the Parties
Applicant/Petitioner’s Arguments
- The bank initiated coercive measures under the SARFAESI Act without attempting restructuring as mandated by the RBI Framework for Revival and Rehabilitation of MSMEs.
- Reliance was placed on the Supreme Court judgment in M/s Pro Knits vs. The Board of Directors of Canara Bank and others, which held that the RBI Framework is statutory and binding on banks and that enforcement of security interest under SARFAESI can only commence after proper classification and procedural compliance.
- The petitioner emphasized that the bank had not constituted the required committee before declaring the account as NPA and initiating SARFAESI proceedings.
Respondent/Bank’s Arguments
- The restructuring of the petitioner's loan account was duly undertaken on 29.12.2021, with a two-year moratorium period during which only interest payments were required.
- The petitioner defaulted on repayments after the moratorium period, justifying the bank's declaration of the account as NPA on 31.03.2024 and initiation of SARFAESI proceedings.
- Reference was made to Supreme Court judgments including United Bank of India vs. Satyawati Tandon, Celir LLP vs. Bafna Motors, and South Indian Bank Limited vs. Naveen Mathew Philip, asserting that writ jurisdiction should not be exercised when a statutory remedy is available.
- The petitioner had not made any payment after issuance of the Section 13(2) notice under the SARFAESI Act.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| M/s Pro Knits vs. The Board of Directors of Canara Bank and others (SLP (C) No.7898-2024, decided 01.08.2024) | RBI Framework for MSMEs is statutory and binding; SARFAESI enforcement can only begin after borrower defaults and account is classified as NPA following due procedure. | Distinguished on facts: In the present case, restructuring was done and moratorium was granted before account was declared NPA, unlike in Pro Knits where procedure was not followed. |
| United Bank of India vs. Satyawati Tandon and others, (2010) 8 SCC 110 | Writ jurisdiction should not be exercised where statutory remedy exists. | Supported respondent’s contention that writ petition should be dismissed as statutory remedy under SARFAESI Act is available. |
| Celir LLP vs. Bafna Motors (Mumbai) Private Limited and others, (2024) 2 SCC 1 | Writ jurisdiction is limited where alternative statutory remedies are provided. | Reinforced the principle that statutory remedies under SARFAESI Act must be availed before approaching writ court. |
| South Indian Bank Limited and others vs. Naveen Mathew Philip and another, 2023 SCC OnLine SC 435 | Similar principle regarding limitation on writ jurisdiction when statutory remedies exist. | Applied to uphold dismissal of writ petition in favor of statutory remedy under SARFAESI Act. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court examined the petitioner's reliance on the M/s Pro Knits judgment, which mandates following the RBI Framework before initiating SARFAESI proceedings against MSMEs. However, the Court found that the facts in the present case were distinguishable. The petitioner was registered as an MSME and restructuring was duly carried out on 29.12.2021, including a two-year moratorium during which only interest was payable.
Post moratorium, the petitioner failed to repay the loan installments as per the restructured schedule. Consequently, the bank declared the account as NPA on 31.03.2024 and initiated SARFAESI proceedings after issuing notices under Section 13(2). The Court noted that the petitioner had not made any payment towards the loan amount after the notice.
The Court also accepted the respondent's argument, supported by Supreme Court precedents, that the writ jurisdiction should not be exercised where a statutory remedy is available under the SARFAESI Act. Given the procedural compliance by the bank and the petitioner's default, the Court concluded that the writ petition lacked merit.
Holding and Implications
The writ petition is dismissed.
The direct consequence of this decision is that the bank may proceed with the SARFAESI Act enforcement actions against the petitioner, including auction of the secured asset. The petitioner remains free to pursue remedies available under the statutory framework. No new precedent has been established by this decision; rather, the Court applied established principles distinguishing the present facts from prior rulings and emphasizing the availability of statutory remedies over writ jurisdiction.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF PUNJAB & HARYANA
AT CHANDIGARH.
108 CM-14550-CWP-2024 IN CWP-20591-2024. Date of Decision: 11.09.2024.
M/s Competent Engineers ....Applicant/petitioner.
VERSUS
Canara Bank ....Respondent.
***
CORAM : HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE ANUPINDER SINGH GREWAL HON'BLE MS. JUSTICE LAPITA BANERJI
---
Present: Mr. Abhay Karan Khanna, Advocate for the applicant/petitioner. Mr. Iqbal Mohammed, Advocate for the respondent.
****
ANUPINDER SINGH GREWAL, J. (Oral)
With the consent of learned counsel for the parties, hearing of the main case is preponed and the same is taken on Board today itself.
2. The petitioner-MSME has sought quashing of the demand notice dated 24.04.2024, sale notice dated 18.07.2024 as well as quashing of the wrongful declaration of the petitioner's account as NPA. The petitioner has also sought a writ of mandamus directing the bank to constitute the committee as per the RBI Framework for Revival and Rehabilitation of Micro, Small, Medium Enterprises dated 17.03.2016 (for short 'RBI Framework') and that the respondent-bank be prohibited from taking any coercive action against the petitioner.
3. Learned counsel for the petitioner submits that coercive measures
1 of 5
have been initiated under the SARFAESI Act, without any effort towards restructuring as mandated under the RBI Framework. He has relied upon the judgment of the Supreme Court in the case of M/s Pro Knits vs. The Board of Directors of Canara Bank and others, bearing Special Leave Petition (C) No.7898-2024, decided on 01.08.2024. He also submits that respondent is to take possession of the secured asset on 12.09.2024 and has put the property to auction vide Sale Notice dated 31.08.2024 for 25.09.2024.
4. Learned counsel for the respondent-Bank while referring to the written statement filed in Court today, which is taken on record, submits that the restructuring was undertaken on 29.12.2021 and a moratorium for a period of two years was put in place. The account of the petitioner was restructured in the following manner:-
Nature of Limit Existing Exposure
Permitted
Exposure
OCC 775.00 Lac 600.00 Lac Fresh WCTL -- 175.00 Lac WCTL (Existing GECL) 160.45 Lac 160.00 Lac Term Loan 21.82 Lac 21.82 Lac Fresh GECL 1.0 Ext -- 83.00 Lac Total 957.27 Lac 1039.82 Lac
Thereafter, when the petitioner defaulted on repayment towards the loan, proceedings under the SARFAESI Act were initiated and the account was declared as NPA on 31.03.2024. The notice under Section 13(2) of SARFAESI Act was issued on 24.04.2024. He has also relied upon the judgments of the Supreme Court in the cases of United Bank of India vs. Satyawati Tandon and others, (2010) 8 SCC 110; Celir LLP vs. Bafna Motors (Mumbai) Privated Limited and others, (2024) 2 SCC 1 and South Indian Bank Limited and others vs. Naveen Mathew Philip and another,
2 of 5
2023 SCC OnLine SC 435, to contend that Writ Court should not exercise jurisdiction when statutory remedy has been provided.
5. Learned counsel for the respondent also submits that after issuance of notice under Section 13(2) of SARFAESI Act, for a sum of Rs.9,65,02,048.55, no amount has been paid by the petitioner for discharging its liability.
6. Heard.
7. Learned counsel for the petitioner has placed heavy reliance on judgment in M/s Pro Knits Vs. The Board of Directors of Canara Bank & Ors(supra). The relevant paragraphs are reproduced hereunder:-
"14. However, pertinently the whole process of enforcement of security interest as contained in Chapter III of the SARFAESI Act, could be initiated only when the borrower makes any
default in repayment of secured debt or any installment thereof , and his account in respect of such debt is classified by the secured creditor as non-performing asset , in view of Section 13(2) of the said Act.
16. The said Framework also enables the Micro, Small or Medium Enterprise to voluntarily initiate the proceedings under the said Framework, by filing an application along with the affidavit of an authorized person. Therefore, the stage of identification of incipient stress in the loan account of MSMEs and categorization under the Special Mention Account category, before the loan account of MSME turns into NPA is a very crucial stage, and therefore it would be incumbent on the part of the concerned MSME also to produce authenticated and verifiable documents/material for substantiating its claim of being MSME, before its account is classified as NPA. If that is not done, and once the account is classified as NPA, the banks i.e. secured creditors would be entitled to take the recourse to
3 of 5
Chapter III of the SARFAESI Act for the enforcement of the security interest."
8. However, the same is distinguishable on facts as in that case the appellants who were MSME units had been declared as Non-Performing Assets (NPA), without following the procedure laid down in the Instructions for Framework for Revival and Rehabilitation of MSMEs and it was under such circumstances that Supreme Court had held that these instructions are statutory in nature and binding on all Scheduled Commercial Banks, licensed to operate in India by the Reserve Bank of India. In the instant case, petitioner was registered as MSME on 22.12.2021 and restructuring was duly carried out by Bank on 29.12.2021 while it was only in 2024 that the account of the petitioner was declared as NPA after two years of moratorium, during which the petitioner was only required to pay the interest component. Once the moratorium was lifted, the borrower was required to repay the loan in terms of the restructured schedule. Since, the borrower/petitioner failed to repay the loan amount, the consequential proceedings were initiated by the secured creditor-Bank under the SARFAESI Act.
9. The petitioner-MSME had not made any payment towards the loan amount even after the moratorium was lifted and therefore, due to the default in repayment of debt, the petitioner's account was declared as NPA.
10. The petitioner-MSME is stated to have taken a loan from the respondent-bank and restructuring had been carried out in terms of the RBI Framework by the respondent on 29.12.2021. Moratorium for a period of two years was put in place and thereafter respondent-bank had initiated proceedings under the SARFAESI Act. The petitioner has not paid any
4 of 5
amount after issuance of notice under Section 13(2) of SARFAESI Act . Even after the moratorium had been lifted, the petitioner has not paid anything.
11. We are, therefore, of the considered view that the writ petition is liable to be dismissed and the same is accordingly dismissed. The petitioner would be at liberty to seek recourse to the alternative remedy in accordance with law.
Pending application(s), if any, also stands disposed of accordingly.
(ANUPINDER SINGH GREWAL)
JUDGE
(LAPITA BANERJI)
JUDGE
11.09.2024
jitender Whether speaking/ reasoned : Yes/ No Whether Reportable : Yes/ No
5 of 5
Alert