Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Smt. Sundara Devi (Since Deceased) & 4 Others v. Shri Ram Karan & Another

Allahabad High Court
Jan 25, 2017
Smart Summary (Beta)

Summary of Opinion

Factual and Procedural Background

The petition under Article 227 (MATTERS UNDER ARTICLE 227 No. 496 of 2017) was filed by Smt. Sundara Devi (since deceased) & 4 Others against Shri Ram Karan & Another. The petition challenged an order dated 20.10.2014 of the A.C.M.M., Court No. 4/Additional Civil Judge (SD), Kanpur Nagar which rejected an application filed by the petitioners for restoration under Order 9 Rule 9 CPC on the ground that it did not contain the applicants' signatures; the court gave liberty to file a fresh application. The petitioners' revision against that order was dismissed by the Special Judge, E.C. Act, Kanpur Nagar by order dated 10.11.2016. The High Court (Hon'ble Manoj Misra, J.) heard the petition and dismissed it by order dated 25.1.2017.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether, when an application for restoration under Order 9 Rule 9 CPC is filed without the applicants' signatures, the court ought to permit the applicants to sign the application instead of directing them to file a fresh application.
  2. Whether Order 6 Rule 14 CPC (requirement of signature on pleadings) empowers the court to allow subsequent signing of such an application.
  3. Whether directing the applicants to file a fresh application raises limitation concerns and, if so, the availability of condonation of delay.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioners' Arguments

  • If the restoration application was defective only for lack of parties' signatures, the court should have allowed the parties to sign the application instead of requiring a fresh filing.
  • The court had discretion to permit subsequent signing in view of Order 6 Rule 14 CPC.
  • Requiring a fresh application may create unnecessary limitation issues for the petitioners.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court examined Order 6 Rule 14 CPC, noting that every pleading must be signed by the party and his pleader; it observed that a plaint and written statement are pleadings while an application may not necessarily be a pleading. The court declined to express a definitive opinion on whether the lower court had power to permit subsequent signing of the application. The court accepted the lower court's course of action—directing the applicants to file a fresh application with their signatures—to ensure the application was actually filed by the applicants and found no fault with that approach. Regarding limitation, the court noted that the applicants remain entitled to seek condonation of delay and that the trial court could act on any explanation offered and proceed accordingly.

Holding and Implications

Petition dismissed.

Direct effect: The orders of the lower courts (order dated 20.10.2014 and the revision dismissal dated 10.11.2016) are upheld and the petition is dismissed. Consequence for parties: the petitioners may apply for condonation of delay if limitation becomes an issue when filing a fresh application. No new legal precedent was laid down by this opinion.

Show all summary ...

Court No. - 2 Case :- MATTERS UNDER ARTICLE 227 No. - 496 of 2017 Petitioner :- Smt. Sundara Devi (Since Deceased) & 4 Others Respondent :- Shri Ram Karan & Another Counsel for Petitioner :- Tariq Naiyer,Himanshu Kumar,Zafar Naiyer

Hon'ble Manoj Misra,J.

Heard Sri Zafar Naiyer, learned senior counsel, assisted by Sri Tariq Naiyer for the petitioners.

The present petition has been filed against an order dated 20.10.2014 passed by A.C.M.M., Court No. 4/ Additional Civil Judge (SD), Kanpur Nagar by which application 5Ga2 filed by the petitioners for restoration of his application under Order 9 Rule 9 CPC was rejected on the ground that the same did not contain the signature of the applicants though liberty was also given to the applicants to file a fresh application. The petitioners have also challenged the order dated 10.11.2016 passed by Special Judge, E.C. Act, Kanpur Nagar by which the revision of the petitioners against the order dated 20.10.2014 has been dismissed.

The submission of counsel for the petitioners is that if the application was defective, without signature of the parties, the court could have allowed the parties to sign the said application as such there was no necessity to move a fresh application. Because, now, unnecessarily the question of limitation in filing the application would arise. It has been submitted that the court has discretion to allow a party to sign the application in view of the provisions of Order 6 Rule 14 CPC.

Order 6 Rule 14 CPC provides as follows:

"Every pleading shall be signed by the party and his pleader (if any):

Provided that where a party pleading is, by reason of absence or for other good cause, unable to sign the pleading, it may be signed by any person duly authorized by him to sign the same or to sue or defend on his behalf."

Perusal of the aforesaid provision would go to show that every pleading has to be signed by the party and his pleader. A plaint and written statement is considered to be pleading whereas an application may not be considered to be a pleading. However, without expressing any opinion as to whether the court had power to allow the party to subsequently sign the application, keeping in mind that the court below has only directed the applicants to file a fresh application by putting their signatures on the application just to ensure that the application is filed by the applicants, no fault can be found with the order passed by the court below. In so far as the limitation aspect is concerned, the applicants can always file application for condonation of delay and it is always open to the court to be satisfied on the basis of explanation offered to allow the application and thereafter proceed accordingly.

I therefore find no good reason to interfere with the order passed by the court below. The petition is dismissed.

Order Date :- 25.1.2017 Arvind

Neutral Citation No. - 2017:AHC:21527