- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
STATE OF KERALA, v. SRI. A.N. SOJAN
High Court of Kerala — OP(KAT) No.508 of 2023 (Judgment dated 10 July 2024)
Factual and Procedural Background
This summary is drawn exclusively from the judgment delivered by A. Muhamed Mustaque, Acting Chief Justice, and S. Manu, J., dated 10 July 2024 in OP(KAT) No.508 of 2023.
The State of Kerala filed the original petition challenging the Kerala Administrative Tribunal's order dated 25.01.2023 in O.A. (EKM) No.946/2019. The respondent in the petition (the applicant in the Tribunal) is A.N. Sojan, who retired as Senior Superintendent from the Transport Commissionerate on 31.05.2015. On retirement he was sanctioned provisional pension but his Death-cum-Retirement Gratuity (DCRG) was withheld under Rule 3A of Part III of the Kerala Service Rules (KSR). The stated reason for withholding was the registration of a vigilance case by the Vigilance and Anti-Corruption Bureau, Kannur unit, registered under Section 13(1)(d) read with 13(2) of the Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988 and Section 120B IPC.
The respondent and other government employees challenged the FIR in Crl.M.C.No.1607/2016; a learned Single Judge allowed that criminal petition on 12.01.2018 on the basis of submissions by the State Attorney that no forgery or criminal misconduct was detected and that no amount or forged envelope was recovered from the accused. Following this, the respondent sought release of withheld pensionary amounts and gratuity. Pensionary benefits and a non-liability certificate were issued in June–July 2018, and gratuity payment order was issued on 10.07.2018.
The respondent requested interest (16.08.2018) at 12% per annum on the gratuity amount for the period the DCRG was withheld; the Transport Commissioner rejected this request. The respondent then approached the Kerala Administrative Tribunal in O.A. (EKM) No.946/2019 seeking interest. The Tribunal allowed the O.A., holding that Rule 3A of Part III KSR did not justify withholding DCRG in the respondent's case because no departmental or judicial proceeding, as required by the Rule, was pending; it awarded interest at 7% per annum for the period from 01.11.2015 to 06.06.2018. The State challenged that Tribunal order by filing the present petition in this Court.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether withholding of the respondent's DCRG under Rule 3A of Part III of the Kerala Service Rules was legally justified when the matter was at the stage of investigation (i.e., mere registration of FIR) and no judicial proceeding was pending as contemplated by the Rule.
- Whether the respondent was entitled to interest on the delayed payment of gratuity/DCRG, and if so, at what rate, despite the absence of any express provision in the service rules granting interest.
Arguments of the Parties
Petitioners' (Government) Arguments — as advanced by the learned Government Pleader
- The withholding of DCRG was justified because vigilance proceedings were pending; pendency of such proceedings is a sufficient reason to withhold gratuity under Rule 3A(a) of Part III KSR.
- The criminal proceedings were quashed only on 12.01.2018 and the respondent submitted representation for disbursal only on 02.03.2018; the authorities acted without delay once the termination of criminal proceedings came to their knowledge and benefits were sanctioned on 06.06.2018 and gratuity order issued on 10.07.2018.
- No provision in the service rules entitles the respondent to claim interest; therefore the Tribunal's direction to pay interest at 7% per annum imposes an unwarranted financial burden on the Government and is contrary to public interest.
- Absent any legally sustainable right to interest, the respondent cannot claim interest on the gratuity amount.
Respondent's Arguments — as advanced by counsel for the respondent
- The denial/withholding of DCRG was illegal because no judicial proceeding was pending against the respondent; the matter was only at the stage of investigation.
- The State had earlier, in the Crl.M.C., admitted through its State Attorney that the respondent and the other officials were innocent and that no criminal misconduct was detected; since the FIR was quashed, the Government was not justified in refusing to pay interest for the period the DCRG was withheld.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| S.K. Dua v. State of Haryana and another [(2008) 3 SCC 44] | That, even in the absence of statutory rules, administrative instructions or guidelines, an employee can claim interest on delayed payment of retirement benefits by relying on fundamental rights (Articles 14, 19 and 21) under Part III of the Constitution. | The Court relied on this authority to hold that absence of a specific provision in the KSR does not preclude an employee from claiming interest on delayed gratuity; interest can be claimed on constitutional grounds. |
| State of Kerala and others v. M. Padmanabhan Nair [(1985) 1 SCC 429] | That pension and gratuity are valuable rights/property and not a bounty; culpable delay in settlement and disbursement attracts payment of interest at the market rate. | The Court invoked this principle to reinforce that retirement benefits are protected rights and delays warrant interest as compensation; it supports awarding interest on delayed DCRG. |
| D.D. Tewari (D) Thr. Lrs v. Uttar Haryana Bijli Vitran Nigam Ltd. and others [(2014) 8 SCC 894] | Illustrative authority on quantum of interest where the Supreme Court granted interest at 9% for pension and gratuity and prescribed enhanced consequences for non-payment within a specified time. | The Court used this case to assess the reasonableness of the rate of interest awarded by the Tribunal (7%): it observed that the Tribunal's 7% award is moderate and reasonable in view of authorities that have awarded higher rates (e.g., 9%). |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court proceeded in a stepwise manner, applying legal rules to the facts disclosed in the record:
- Interpretation of Rule 3A of Part III KSR: The Court explained that Rule 3A(a) can be invoked only where "any departmental or judicial proceeding is instituted under Rule 3" or where a departmental proceeding is continued under clause (a) of the proviso thereto. Thus, the pre-condition for invoking Rule 3A is the existence of a departmental or judicial proceeding as contemplated by Rule 3 and its Explanation.
- Application of Explanation (b) to determining whether a "judicial proceeding" was pending: The Court relied on Explanation (b) to Rule 3 which states that a judicial proceeding in a criminal matter is deemed instituted on the date on which the complaint or police report on which the Magistrate takes cognizance is made. The Court examined the record and the order in Crl.M.C.No.1607/2016 which showed investigation was pending and that the Crl.M.C. was disposed on 12.01.2018. Consequently, the Court agreed with the Tribunal that mere registration of an FIR/investigation did not amount to a judicial proceeding under Rule 3.
- Conclusion on withholding of DCRG: Because the proceedings had not reached the stage of a judicial proceeding as required by Rule 3 (and its Explanation), the withholding of DCRG by the Government on account of mere registration of a vigilance FIR was held to be improper and illegal.
- Entitlement to interest despite lack of express rule: The Court addressed the Government's contention that no rule entitles the employee to interest. Relying on S.K. Dua and related authorities, the Court held that even in absence of statutory or administrative provision, pension and gratuity are valuable rights and an employee can claim interest on constitutional grounds (Articles 14, 19 and 21). The Court reiterated established principles that pension and gratuity are property rights and culpable delay invites payment of interest.
- Equity and trust rationale: The Court reasoned that when the Government withholds gratuity during pendency of investigations, it effectively holds the amount in trust and may utilize it; if ultimately the employee is absolved, fairness and equitable principles require compensation for the delayed enjoyment, typically by way of interest. The Court noted that in this case the State had earlier conceded before the High Court that no criminal misconduct was detected, strengthening the case for compensation by interest.
- Assessment of rate of interest: The Tribunal had awarded interest at 7% per annum for the period 01.11.2015 to 06.06.2018. The Court observed comparative authorities (for example, the 9% award in D.D. Tewari) and found the Tribunal's rate of 7% to be moderate and reasonable; thus there was no reason for interference.
- Final procedural direction: Given the respondent's prolonged pursuit of remedies since 2019, the Court directed the petitioners to comply with the Tribunal's directions within six weeks from receipt of the copy of the judgment.
Holding and Implications
Core Ruling: O.P.(KAT) is dismissed. The High Court declined to interfere with the Kerala Administrative Tribunal's order dated 25.01.2023 in O.A. (EKM) No.946/2019 which (i) held that withholding of DCRG on account of mere registration of an FIR/investigation was improper and (ii) awarded interest at 7% per annum for the period from 01.11.2015 to 06.06.2018.
Implications and direct consequences:
- The Tribunal's direction to pay interest at 7% per annum on the withheld DCRG (for the specified period) stands affirmed.
- The petitioners (State and concerned authorities) are directed to comply with the Tribunal's order within six weeks from the date of receipt of a copy of this judgment.
- The Court did not purport to lay down a new general rule superseding service rules; rather it applied existing Supreme Court authorities and equitable principles to the facts at hand. The decision upholds established precedents that pension/gratuity are proprietary rights and that interest may be awarded for culpable delay even absent express rule-based entitlement.
End of summary. This document reflects only the content and reasoning contained in the provided opinion and does not add information beyond that text.
IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM
PRESENT
THE HONOURABLE THE ACTING CHIEF JUSTICE MR. A.MUHAMED MUSTAQUE
&
THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE S.MANU
WEDNESDAY, THE 10TH DAY OF JULY 2024 / 19TH ASHADHA, 1946
OP(KAT) NO. 508 OF 2023
AGAINST THE ORDER DATED 25.01.2023 IN OA (EKM) NO.946 OF
2019 OF KERALA ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL, THIRUVANANTHAPURAM
PETITIONERS/RESPONDENTS IN O.A.:
1 STATE OF KERALA,
REPRESENTED BY THE SECRETARY,
DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORT,GOVERNMENT SECRETARIAT,
THIRUVANANTHAPURAM, PIN - 695001
2 THE PRINCIPAL ACCOUNTANT GENERAL(A&E), OFFICE OF THE PRINCIPAL ACCOUNTANT GENERAL(A&E), STATUE,THIRUVANANTHAPURAM,KERALA, PIN - 695001
3 THE TRANSPORT COMMISSIONER,
TRANSPORT COMMISSIONERATE, 2ND FLOOR,
TRANS TOWERS, VAZHUTHACAUD, THYCAUD, P.O,
THIRUVANANTHAPURAM, KERALA, PIN - 695014
BY SR.GOVERNMENT PLEADER SMT.VINEETHA
RESPONDENT/APPLICANT IN O.A.:
A.N.SOJAN,
AGED 60 YEARS, S/O. KESAVAN NARAYANAN, (RTD)
SENIOR SUPERINTENDENT, TRANSPORT COMMISSIONERATE,
VAZHUTHACAUD, THIRUVANANTHAPURAM - 695 014,
RESIDING AT AMBALLOOR KUZHIYIL, CHETTIAMPARAMBU
P.O., KELAKAM, IRITTI TALUK, KANNUR, KERALA,
PIN - 670674
ADV.SRI.T.C.GOVINDASWAMY
THIS OP KERALA ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL HAVING COME UP
FOR HEARING ON 21.06.2024, THE COURT ON 10.07.2024
DELIVERED THE FOLLOWING:
1
2
A.MUHAMED MUSTAQUE, Acg.C.J. & S.MANU, J.
------------------------------------------------------------------------------
O.P.(KAT) No.508 of 2023
------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Dated this the 10thday of July, 2024
JUDGMENT
S.MANU, J.
Aggrieved by the order dated 25.1.2023 in O.A. (EKM)No.946/2019 of the Kerala Administrative Tribunal, Additional Bench, Ernakulam the State has filed this original petition.
2. The applicant in the O.A. is the respondent herein. He superannuated from service in the cadre of Senior Superintendent on 31.5.2015 from the office of the 3rd respondent. He was sanctioned the provisional pension and DCRG due to him was withheld invoking Rule 3A of Part III of Kerala Service Rules. Reason for withholding the DCRG and sanction of provisional pension was registration of a case by Vigilance and Anti-Corruption Bureau, Kannur unit against four Government employees including the respondent and three others. As revealed from Annexure-A2 the case was
3
registered under Section 13(1)(d) read with 13(2) of Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988 and Section 120B of IPC.
3. The Government employees including the petitioner involved in the case approached this Court in Crl.M.C.No.1607/2016 praying for quashing the FIR lodged against them. Order passed by this Court in the Crl.M.C. is produced with the original application as Annexure-A3. A learned Single Judge of this Court allowed the Crl.M.C. on the basis of submissions made by the learned State Attorney. Submissions made by the learned State Attorney as recorded in the order of the learned Single Judge are extracted hereunder:-
"It has been submitted by the learned State Attorney that no forgery was committed by the petitioners. It has been further submitted by the learned State Attorney that no amount was recovered from accused Nos.1 to 4. No forged envelope was also recovered from Accused Nos.1 to
4. However, the envelopes with the seal of the Postal Department were found in the almirah of the Joint Regional Transport office. The said covers were allegedly handed over to the office along with the applications by the agents of Driving Schools. The learned State Attorney has submitted no
4
criminal mis-conduct was detected on the side of the petitioners."
4. Emerging victorious in the attempt to quash the proceedings under the Prevention of Corruption Act from the stage of inception, the respondent submitted Annexure-A4 representation to the Transport Commissioner for release of some payments withheld by the department. By order dated 06.06.2018 produced as Annexure-A5 pensionary benefits were sanctioned to the respondent. No liability certificate for enabling release of gratuity was also issued. By Annexure-A7 gratuity payment order, gratuity was also sanctioned.
5. On 16.8.2018, the respondent submitted Annexure-A8 representation to the Transport Commissioner requesting for payment of interest at the rate of 12% per annum on the gratuity amount. By Annexure-A9 the request was rejected. In Annexure-A9 the Transport Commissioner stated inter alia that the pensionary benefits were not disbursed immediately after retirement on account of pendency of vigilance case.
5
6. Challenging the rejection of the request for interest the respondent approached the Tribunal in O.A. (EKM)No.946/2019. On completion of pleadings, learned Tribunal heard the matter and allowed the O.A. by the impugned order. The learned Tribunal found that Rule 3A of Part III KSR justifies withholding of DCRG only where any departmental or judicial proceeding is instituted under Rule 3 or where a departmental proceeding is continuing under Clause A of the proviso thereto. Taking note of the Explanation (b) under Rule 3 of Part III KSR the learned Tribunal held that the case of the respondent though a vigilance case was registered it was only at the stage of investigation and therefore it cannot be said that a judicial proceeding was pending against him. Finding that retention of the DCRG by the Government was not in accordance with law, the learned Tribunal granted interest at the rate of 7% per annum for the period from 01.11.2015 to 06.06.2018.
7. The learned Government Pleader Smt.B.Vinitha strenuously contended before us that there was no fault on the part of the Government in disbursing the DCRG in this
6
case. She pointed out that the proceedings against the respondent was quashed by this Court only on 12.1.2018 and representation was submitted by the respondent for disbursing the amounts withheld only on 02.03.2018. She contended that the factum of termination of the criminal proceedings came to the knowledge of the concerned authorities when they received the representation and without any delay the benefits were directed to be granted and no liability certificate was also issued on 06.06.2018. She also pointed out that the gratuity payment order was issued on 10.07.2018. She therefore urged that the direction issued by the Tribunal to pay interest at the rate of 7% per annum on the amount of DCRG imposes
unwarranted financial burden on the Government. She also contended that the same is against public interest. She asserted that the pendency of vigilance proceedings against the respondent was a sufficient reason justifying withholding of DCRG. The learned Government Pleader further contended that no provision in the service rules enables the respondent to raise a claim for interest. She in this context
7
argued that unless there is a legally sustainable claim or in other words infringement of a legal right the respondent is not entitled to seek interest on the amount of gratuity.
8. The learned counsel for the respondent Smt.Kala T.Gopi submitted that the denial of DCRG to the respondent was illegal as no judicial proceeding was pending against him. She also pointed out that in the Crl.M.C. filed by the respondent and other officers involved, the submission made by the Government was that the officials were totally innocent. She also pointed out that the FIR itself being quashed, the Government is not at all justified in refusing to pay interest for the period during which the DCRG was withheld.
9. The Government justifies withholding of gratuity relying on Rule 3A(a) of Part III KSR. The language of the said provision makes it explicit that the said provision can be invoked where any departmental or judicial proceedings is instituted under Rule 3 or where a departmental proceeding is continued under clause (a) of the proviso thereto. Hence, pre-condition for invoking the said provision is existence of
8
departmental or judicial proceedings under Rule 3 or continuation of departmental proceedings under clause (a) of the proviso thereto. The case of the respondent, the pensionary benefits were withheld citing registration of a case by the Vigilance and Anti-Corruption Bureau. The proceeding had not reached the stage of submitting final report. The order in Crl.M.C.No.1607/2016 makes it clear that investigation was pending when the Crl.M.C. came up for admission and was disposed on 12.1.2018. Hence, we find that the conclusion of the learned Tribunal in reference to the Explanation (b) under Rule 3 of Part III KSR that the Government was wrong in stating that judicial proceeding was pending against the respondent is perfectly justified. The Explanation is extracted below:-
"3. xxx xxx
Explanation.- For the purpose of this rule-
(a) xxx
(b) a judicial proceeding shall be deemed to be instituted -
(i) in the case of a criminal proceeding, on the date on which the complaint or report of police officer on which the Magistrate takes cognizance, is made, and"
9
10. Hence the withholding of DCRG for mere registration of FIR by the Vigilance and Anti-Corruption Bureau was improper and illegal.
11. The next aspect to be considered is the argument of the learned Government Pleader that the respondent has no legal right to claim interest as the department had released the amounts without any unreasonable delay after receipt of the representation seeking the payments. The assertion of the learned Government Pleader is that no provision in the service rules provides support to the claim raised by the respondent. It may be true that a search for such an enabling provision in the KSR or any other Rules applicable would be an exercise in vain. However, by long line of precedents it is clear that the pension and gratuity are no longer any bounty to be distributed by the Government to its employees on their retirement, but, have become, under the decisions of the Court, valuable rights and property in their hands and any culpable delay in settlement and disbursement thereof must be dealt with the penalty of payment of interest at the current market rate till
10
actual payment to the employees. We find perfect answer to the above said contention in S.K.Dua v. State of Haryana and another [(2008) 3 SCC 44] the relevant portion from the said judgment is extracted hereunder:-
"............... If there are Statutory Rules occupying the field, the appellant could claim payment of interest relying on such Rules. If there are Administrative Instructions, Guidelines or Norms prescribed for the purpose, the appellant may claim benefit of interest on that basis. But even in absence Statutory Rules, Administrative Instructions or Guidelines, an employee can claim interest under Part III of the Constitution relying on Art.14, 19 and 21 of the Constitution."
Therefore, an employee can claim interest on the strength of fundamental rights guaranteed under Articles 14, 19 and 21 of the Constitution even if no provision in the statutory rules governing the field enables him to raise the same. We note that the retirement benefits are also protected under Article 300 of the Constitution.
12. It is also well settled that pension and gratuity are valuable rights and property due to the employees on their retirement. The Hon'ble Supreme Court has declared in
11
unmistakable terms that they are no longer any bounty to be distributed by the Government to the employees on their retirement. In State of Kerala and others v. M.Padmanabhan Nair [(1985) 1 SCC 429] the Supreme Court held that any culpable delay in settlement and disbursement of pension and gratuity must be visited with the penalty of payment of interest at the market rate.
13. It is relevant to note that in the case of employees governed by Payment of Gratuity Act, 1972 the right to get interest on delayed payment of gratuity is statutorily protected by Section 7(3A) of the Act. Under the said provision, if the amount of gratuity is not paid by the employer within the period stipulated under sub-section 3 the employer shall be liable to pay simple interest at such rate, not exceeding the rate notified by the Central Government from time to time for repayment of long term deposits.
14. In our view principles of equity also justify payment of interest in cases of this nature. By operation of law, right of an employee to receive DCRG crystallises on
12
retirement. When gratuity is withheld for the reason that any disciplinary proceedings/criminal proceedings are pending, the Government is deferring enjoyment of the statutory entitlement by the employee till the conclusion of such proceedings. The objective is to recover loss if any suffered by the Government depending upon the outcome of such proceedings. In the end, if the retired employee is absolved in the disciplinary proceedings or acquitted in the criminal proceedings the Government have to pay the entire amount. During the interregnum, it is to be presumed that the Government is holding the amount in trust. The employee is denied the benefit of the amount which is actually due to him. On the other hand, the employer Government can meanwhile utilize the sum of money for its purposes, though it is under obligation to restore the same to the retired employee once he egress blemish less in the departmental or criminal proceedings. Even when this situation is analysed solely on the basis of principles of equity, we are of the view that such restoration without an element of compensation would not do justice to the employee. This is for the reason
13
that a trustee who utilises the amount held in trust for his purposes is liable to restore the same to the beneficiary with an element of compensation usually by way of interest or a part of the profits earned out of utilization by the trustee. Therefore, we find that the claim regarding interest made by the applicant is justified on equitable considerations also.
15. It is very relevant to note in this case that when the Crl.M.C. was considered by this Court the State Attorney who represented the Government made a candid statement before this Court that the 1strespondent and also the other officials had not committed any forgery as alleged. It was also stated that no amounts were recovered from them. The State Attorney further submitted that no criminal misconduct was detected on the side of the employees. Therefore, in the case of the respondent, the Government on an earlier occasion, admitted before this Court that he had not committed any criminal act. In other words, the Government realized much earlier that the initiation of proceedings under the Prevention of Corruption Act against the respondent was totally unfounded. In such a case,
14
definitely, when the retirement benefits withheld on account of pendency of investigation are being restored, the employee is entitled for compensation for delayed payment by way of interest.
16. Regarding the rate of interest, we note that the prayer of the respondent was for granting it at the rate of 12% per annum. The learned Tribunal has granted interest at the rate of 7% per annum in its discretion. In D.D.Tewari.
(D) Thr. Lrs v. Uttar Haryana Bijli Vitran Nigam Ltd. and others [(2014) 8 SCC 894] the Hon'ble Supreme Court granted interest at the rate of 9% for the amount of pension due and gratuity and further directed that in case of non- payment of interest in the said rate within six weeks the same shall carry interest at the rate of 18% per annum. In view of the aforesaid, we find that the rate of interest awarded by the learned Tribunal is moderate and reasonable.
17. We, therefore, do not find any reason to interfere with the order passed by the learned Tribunal. O.P.(KAT) is hence dismissed.
15
Since the respondent has been pursuing legal remedies since 2019 we find it proper to direct that the petitioners shall comply with the direction issued by the learned Tribunal within six weeks from the date of receipt of a copy of this judgment.
Sd/-
A.MUHAMED MUSTAQUE,
ACTING CHIEF JUSTICE
Sd/-
S.MANU,
JUDGE
skj
16
APPENDIX OF OP(KAT) 508/2023 PETITIONERS' ANNEXURES Annexure A1 TRUE COPY OF INTIMATION SLIP OF
PENSIONARY BENEFITS ISSUED FROM THE
OFFICE OF THE 2 ND RESPONDENT TO THE
APPLICANT BEARING NO.P-
01/2101543364/5/P/15/10/70261834 DATED
06.07.2015
Annexure A2 TRUE COPY OF VIGILANCE CASE BEARING NO.VC3/15/KNR UNDER SECTION 13(1)(D)
READ WITH 13(2) OF PC ACT, 1988 AND 120
B IPC, BEARING
NO.C6(VC3/15/KNR)6578/2015 DATED
17.03.2015.
Annexure A3 TRUE COPY OF ORDER IN CRL.M.C. NO.1607/2016 DATED 12.01.2018 OF THE
HONOURABLE HIGH COURT OF KERALA
Annexure A4 A4:-TRUE COPY OF REPRESENTATION DATED
02.03.2018 GIVEN BY THE APPLICANT BEFORE
THE 3 RD RESPONDENT.
Annexure A5 TRUE COPY OF PROCEEDINGS OF THE 3 RD RESPONDENT BEARING NO.K3/16480/TC/2014
DATED 08.06.2018
Annexure A6 TRUE COPY OF DEPARTMENTAL CERTIFICATE OF NON-LIABILITY BEARING FILE
NO.K3/16480/TC/2014 DATED 06.06.2018 Annexure A7 TRUE COPY OF PROCEEDINGS OF THE 2 ND
RESPONDENT, BEARING NO.GPO121861416
DATED 10.07.2018.
Annexure A8 TRUE COPY OF REPRESENTATION GIVEN BY THE
APPLICANT TO THE 3 RD RESPONDENT DATED
16.08.2018.
Annexure A9 TRUE COPY OF REPLY GIVEN BY THE 3 RD
RESPONDENT TO THE APPLICANT BEARING FILE
NO.K3/20/2018-TC DATED 04.04.2018 Annexure A10 A10:-TRUE COPY OF G.O.(P) NO.185/2002//FIN DATED 27.03.2002. Exhibit P1 A TRUE COPY OF THE AMENDED O.A (E) NO.946/2019
17
Exhibit P2 TRUE COPY OF MISCELLANEOUS APPLICATION
FOR AMENDMENT FILED BY THE APPLICANT
DATED 09.08.2019.
Exhibit P3 TRUE COPY OF G.O.(P) NO.803/2022/FIN
DATED 30.12.2022 OF THE FINANCE
DEPARTMENT.
Exhibit P4 TRUE COPY OF THE REPLY STATEMENT DATED
18.03.2020 FILED BY THE 3 RD RESPONDENT.
Exhibit P5 REJOINDER FILED BY THE APPLICANT DATED
07.08.2020
Exhibit P6 TRUE COPY OF ORDER IN O.A (EKM) NO.946/2019 DATED 25.01.2023.
Alert