Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Appeal No.6047 of 2024 filed by Ajay Basudev Bose

SEBI
Jul 9, 2024
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

The appellant, Ajay Basudev Bose, filed an application dated May 30, 2024, under the Right to Information Act, 2005 (RTI Act), seeking information related to Show Cause Notices (SCNs) issued by the Securities and Exchange Board of India (SEBI) to seven listed Adani Group companies for alleged violations of various rules including disclosure and related party transaction norms. The appellant requested copies of the SCNs and details of actions taken by SEBI against these companies. The respondent (CPIO, SEBI) replied on June 13, 2024, denying the information citing exemptions under Sections 8(1)(d), 8(1)(e), and 8(1)(h) of the RTI Act, 2005. The appellant filed an appeal dated June 17, 2024, challenging the incompleteness and alleged misleading nature of the information provided. The appellate authority considered the application, response, and appeal based on the record before it.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the Show Cause Notices issued by SEBI to the seven Adani Group companies are exempt from disclosure under Sections 8(1)(d) and 8(1)(e) of the RTI Act on grounds of fiduciary relationship and commercial confidence.
  2. Whether disclosure of the requested information would impede the process of examination or investigation, thereby attracting exemption under Section 8(1)(h) of the RTI Act.
  3. Whether the appellant was entitled to the requested information or if the denial by SEBI was justified.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments

  • The information provided by SEBI was incomplete.
  • The information supplied was misleading and false.

Respondent's Arguments

  • The Show Cause Notices contain confidential commercial information, including analysis of bank statements, transactions, and internal discussions, held by SEBI in a fiduciary capacity.
  • Disclosure of such information could harm the competitive position of the entities involved.
  • The information is exempt under Sections 8(1)(d), 8(1)(e), and 8(1)(h) of the RTI Act as it relates to fiduciary information, commercial confidence, and ongoing investigations.
  • SEBI conducts examinations and investigations confidentially, and premature disclosure may impede these processes.
  • Post-investigation enforcement actions culminate in public orders available on the SEBI website, which the appellant can access.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Institute of Chartered Accountants of India Vs. Shaunak H. Satya and Ors, Civil Appeal No. 7571 of 2011 (02/09/2011) Definition of fiduciary relationship under Section 8(1)(e) of the RTI Act; confidentiality of information given and taken in confidence. The court relied on this precedent to affirm that information held in fiduciary capacity, including commercial confidence, is exempt from disclosure.
Mr. Ashok Kumar Rajak vs. CPIO, SEBI (CIC order dated December 21, 2021) Information received from third parties held in fiduciary capacity is exempt under Sections 8(1)(e) and 8(1)(j) of the RTI Act. The court cited this decision to support non-disclosure of investigation reports and communications involving third-party information.
Smt. Pushpa Devi Mohta vs. SEBI (CIC order dated February 08, 2022) Exemption under Section 8(1)(h) of the RTI Act for information related to ongoing examination/investigation that has not reached logical conclusion. The court applied this principle to uphold denial of information as disclosure would impede the investigation process.
Deepti Maheshwari vs. CPIO, SEBI (CIC order dated February 09, 2023) Exemption under Section 8(1)(h) of the RTI Act for ongoing proceedings to prevent impediment to investigation/prosecution. The court referred to this precedent to confirm that denial of information during ongoing proceedings was justified.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court examined the appellant’s request and the respondent’s response, finding the respondent’s claim that the requested Show Cause Notices contain confidential commercial information held in fiduciary capacity to be credible and consistent with legal principles. The court relied on the Supreme Court’s definition of fiduciary relationship and prior CIC decisions to affirm that such information is exempt from disclosure under Sections 8(1)(d) and 8(1)(e) of the RTI Act. Furthermore, the court accepted that disclosure at this stage could impede SEBI’s ongoing examination and investigation process, invoking Section 8(1)(h) of the RTI Act. Precedents from the CIC were cited to support the view that information relating to ongoing investigations, which have not reached a conclusion, must be withheld to preserve the integrity of the process. The court noted that enforcement actions, once completed, result in public orders accessible on SEBI’s website, thus balancing transparency with confidentiality.

Holding and Implications

The appeal is DISMISSED. The court upheld the respondent’s refusal to disclose the requested information, affirming that the Show Cause Notices and related details are exempt from disclosure under Sections 8(1)(d), 8(1)(e), and 8(1)(h) of the RTI Act. The direct effect of this decision is that the appellant will not receive the copies of the SCNs or details of actions taken by SEBI at this stage. No new precedent was established; the decision reinforces existing principles regarding fiduciary information, commercial confidence, and protection of ongoing investigations under the RTI Act.

Show all summary ...

Appeal No. 6047 of 2024 Page 1 of 3

BEFORE THE APPELLATE AUTHORITY

(Under the Right to Information Act, 2005)

SECURITIES AND EXCHANGE BOARD OF INDIA

Appeal No. 6047 of 2024

Ajay Basudev Bose : Appellant

Vs

CPIO, SEBI, Mumbai : Respondent

ORDER

1. The appellant had filed an application dated May 30, 2024 (received by the respondent through RTI MIS Portal) under the Right to Information Act, 2005 ("RTI Act"). The respondent, by a letter dated June 13, 2024 responded to the application filed by the appellant. The appellant filed an appeal (Reg. No. SEBIH/A/E/24/00129) dated June 17, 2024. I have carefully considered the application, the response and the appeal and find that the matter can be decided based on the material available on record.

2. Request in the application - The appellant, vide his application dated May 30, 2024, sought the following information:

"Under RTI act Please provide information related to Showcause Notices issued to 7 Listed Adani Group of Companies by SEBI for alleged Violations of various Rules including disclosure and related party transaction norms SEBI issued notices to

A) Adani Enterprises

B) Adani Energy Solutions

C) Adani Green Energy

D) Adani Ports

E) Adani Power

F) Adani Total Gas

G) Adani Wilmar In view of the aforesaid facts kindly provide following information

1) Please provide Copies of Showcause Notices issued by SEBI to above mentioned 7 Adani Group of Companies

2) Please provide details of action taken by SEBI against above mentioned 7 Adani Group of Companies"

3. Reply of the Respondent - The respondent, in response to the aforesaid request, informed that the Show Cause Notices (SCNs) contain information w.r.t. analysis of the bank statements, transaction with certain other entities, discussions held and approvals granted in Board Meeting, Audit Committee Meetings etc. Further, the respondent informed that SCNs issued to entities also contain information which is private and confidential and is held by SEBI in fiduciary capacity. Hence, the disclosure of the

1

Page 2 of 3

same could harm the competitive position of the entities. In view of these, the information sought is exempted u/s 8(1)(d) & 8(1)(e) of RTI Act, 2005

Additionally, the respondent informed that SEBI conducts examinations and investigations confidentially in a holistic manner. In view of the same, disclosure of details related to the matter may impede the said process and is therefore exempt from disclosure in terms of Section 8(1)(h) of the RTI Act, 2005. Additionally, the respondent informed that post investigation, whenever violations are established, appropriate enforcement actions are taken under the provisions of the SEBI Act, 1992 and Regulations framed thereunder which culminate in the issuance of Orders. The respondent informed that these orders are available in public domain and can be accessed from the SEBI website.

4. Ground of appeal - The appellant has filed the appeal on the ground that the information provided is incomplete, misleading and false information.

5. I have perused the application and the response provided thereto. With respect to the request seeking copy of SCNs issued by SEBI to Adani Group Companies, I agree with the response of the respondent that the requested information is held in a fiduciary capacity and includes commercial information which is confidential in nature. I have no reason to disbelieve the said response. In the context of non- disclosure of information under Section 8(1)(e) of the RTI Act, 2005, the decision of the Hon'ble Supreme Court of India in Institute of Chartered Accountants of India Vs. Shaunak H. Satya and Ors.), in Civil Appeal NO. 7571 of 2011- dated 02/09/2011 is referred to, wherein it was held that: "… In other words, anything given and taken in confidence expecting confidentiality to be maintained will be information available to a person in fiduciary relationship". Further, the Hon'ble Central Information Commission (hereinafter referred to as

"CIC"), in the matter of Mr. Ashok Kumar Rajak vs. CPIO, SEBI, (order dated December 21, 2021), held that "Further the details such as investigation report, file noting, directions and various communication involves with the third party information which is received from other agencies is being held by them in fiduciary capacity hence the same is barred from disclosure under section 8(1)(e) & (j) of the RTI Act, 2005." I, therefore, find that such information pertaining to commercial confidence and which contains information given/received in 'fiduciary relationship' to/from market participants etc. is exempted from disclosure under Sections 8(1)(d) and 8(1)(e) of the RTI Act. Accordingly, I do not find any deficiency in the response.

6. Further, I agree with the response of the respondent that disclosure of the requested information at this stage may impede the process of examination. In this context, I note that the Hon'ble CIC in the matter of Smt. Pushpa Devi Mohta vs. SEBI (order dated February 08, 2022), held that " The Commission observes that

Page 3 of 3

the information sought by the appellant is submitted to SEBI which is a quasi-judicial body for examination and the same has not yet reached a logical conclusion, therefore the respondent has denied the information under section 8(1)(h) and as per the said provisions of the RTI Act, such information cannot be provided to the appellant which would impede the process of investigation…….In view of the above ratio, the Commission is of the opinion that the CPIO has rightly denied the information sought under Section 8(1)(h) of the RTI Act as the forensic audit report is still pending and final decision is yet to be passed by the competent authority, therefore the said denial of information is being upheld by the Commission." I also note that the Hon'ble CIC, in the matter of Deepti Maheshwari vs. CPIO, SEBI (Order dated February 09, 2023), observed that "The Commission also accepted the submissions advanced by the CPIO qua queries 8, 10 and 11 that since the proceedings were on-going, the disclosure of any information at that juncture may have impeded the process of investigation/ prosecution of offenders. Therefore, the denial u/s 8 (1) (h) of the RTI Act, 2005 was upheld." In view of these observations, I do not find any deficiency in the response. Notwithstanding the above, I note that the respondent has informed the appellant that the enforcement actions culminate in issuance of Orders, which are made available in public domain on SEBI website.

7. In view of the above observations, I find that there is no need to interfere with the decision of the respondent. The Appeal is accordingly dismissed.

Place: Mumbai RUCHI CHOJER Date: July 09, 2024 APPELLATE AUTHORITY UNDER THE RTI ACT

SECURITIES AND EXCHANGE BOARD OF INDIA