- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
THE STATE OF HP AND OTHERS v. RAKESH KUMAR
Case Summary: High Court of Himachal Pradesh — CMP(M) No.937 of 2023
Factual and Procedural Background
This application was filed by the applicants under Section 5 of the Limitation Act, 1963 seeking condonation of a delay of 376 days in filing a Letters Patent Appeal (LPA) challenging the judgment dated 02.06.2022 delivered by the learned Single Judge.
The chronology as presented in the opinion is as follows (as stated by or recorded in the Court's opinion):
- Copy of the Single Judge's judgment was received by applicant no.3 and forwarded on 16.06.2022 to the office of the Engineer-in-Chief, PWD, which forwarded it to the Government on 11.07.2022 for obtaining advice/opinion of the Law Department.
- While the matter was under Government consideration, the respondent filed a contempt petition. The Advocate General thereafter advised the applicants to file a Review petition against the Single Judge's judgment; a Review petition was filed and the opinion records that it was dismissed (the opinion contains inconsistent references to dismissal on 23.12.2022 in some paragraphs and 23.12.2023 in another).
- The office of the Advocate General informed applicant no.3 about the Review petition judgment three months later on 24.03.2023.
- Applicant no.3 wrote to applicant no.2 on 31.03.2023 (received 12.04.2023); applicant no.2 forwarded the communication to the Government on 19.04.2023; the matter was referred to the Advocate General who advised filing the LPA.
- The LPA was filed on 23.05.2023 (with the above-noted period of delay) and challenges the order dated 02.06.2022 of the learned Single Judge. The LPA was unregistered at the time of dismissal.
The opinion records that no satisfactory explanation was furnished for long communications delays and highlights deficiencies in the applicants' handling of the matter.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether sufficient cause has been shown under Section 5 of the Limitation Act, 1963 to condone a delay of 376 days in filing the Letters Patent Appeal challenging the judgment dated 02.06.2022.
- Whether the filing and dismissal of a Review petition can be relied upon as a ground to justify or explain the delay in instituting the LPA within the prescribed period.
Arguments of the Parties
Applicants / Advocate General (on behalf of State)
- The Advocate General contended that there was a change in Government in December 2022 and that there was probably delay in appointing Law Officers, which caused late communication of the order passed in the Review petition and contributed to the delay in instituting the LPA.
- The Advocate General relied upon several Supreme Court decisions, including a recent decision titled Sheo Raj Singh (deceased) through LRs & others vs. Union of India & another (Civil Appeal no. 5867 of 2015 dated 09.10.2023) and the State of Manipur & Ors. vs. Koting Lamkang ((2019) 10 SCC 408), to support the contention that interference in discretionary exercises of lower courts should be cautious or that impersonal governmental functioning can be a ground for relief in particular circumstances.
Respondent
The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the respondent's legal arguments.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Postmaster General and others vs. Living Media India Limited and another ((2012) 3 SCC 563) | Establishes that delay by Government departments must be satisfactorily explained and that impersonal machinery or bureaucratic delay is not, without acceptable explanation, a ground to condone limitation; the law of limitation binds the Government as well. | The Court relied on this authority to emphasize that there was delay at multiple stages and that the applicants did not provide a plausible explanation; the Court applied this principle to conclude that the applicants had been negligent and the delay should not be condoned. |
| Sheo Raj Singh (deceased) through LRs & others Vs. Union of India & another (Civil Appeal no. 5867 of 2015 dated 09.10.2023) | Discusses appellate interference with discretionary grants of condonation by courts below and the limited scope of appellate review of discretionary orders. | The Court observed that this decision was not helpful to the applicants because the present application required the Court itself to consider whether sufficient cause had been shown to condone delay (i.e., it was not an appeal over an exercise of discretion by a subordinate court). |
| State of Manipur and Ors. vs. Koting Lamkang ((2019) 10 SCC 408) | Recognizes the impersonal nature of Government functioning and that individual officer failure can cause injustice to the institutional interest of the State; in some facts this may justify relief. | The Court distinguished this authority on facts: in Koting Lamkang an appeal had been filed within limitation but in the wrong forum — whereas in the present case no appeal was filed within limitation; the Court therefore treated the decision as distinguishable rather than directly controlling. |
| Cases noted as following Postmaster General (examples cited by the Court): | These Supreme Court decisions are cited in the opinion as subsequent authorities that have followed the reasoning in Postmaster General regarding Government delay and the expectation of diligence. | The Court recorded that the Postmaster General decision had been followed in several subsequent Supreme Court rulings (the opinion lists examples such as cases involving Commissioner of Customs Chennai v. M/s Volex Interconnect (India) Pvt. Ltd., Pr. Commissioner Central Excise Delhi-1 v. Design Dialogues India Pvt. Ltd., Union of India v. Central Tibetan Schools Administration & others, Union of India & others v. Vishnu Aroma Pouching Pvt. Ltd., and State of Uttar Pradesh & others v. Sabha Narain & others). The Court treated these as part of the settled legal position it was applying. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court undertook a step-by-step assessment of the explanation offered for the delay and the authorities relied upon:
- The Court first surveyed the factual timeline provided in the application and noted several unsatisfactory features: the applicants did not give specific dates for when the Review petition was filed; the opinion records inconsistent references to the date of dismissal of the Review petition (23.12.2022 in some paragraphs and 23.12.2023 in another) and observed that the applicants did not satisfactorily explain why the Advocate General's office informed applicant no.3 about the dismissal only on 24.03.2023—three months later.
- The Court found that no explanation to justify the long delay (including the period after 24.03.2023 leading up to filing the LPA on 23.05.2023) had been properly furnished. The Court rejected the contention (advanced by the Advocate General in oral submissions) that a change in Government and delay in appointing Law Officers explained the late communication—such reasons were not pleaded in the condonation application and, in any event, the Court observed that the State machinery existed and the officers should have diligently pursued the matter.
- The Court held that the filing of a Review petition and its dismissal could not be mechanically pleaded as a ground for condoning delay in filing an appeal (LPA) against the original judgment of the Writ Petition; that is, seeking review and later having it dismissed does not automatically justify an extended delay in filing the appeal.
- The Court applied the principle from Postmaster General v. Living Media India Ltd. and subsequent authorities that governmental departments and officers are bound by limitation rules and that impersonal bureaucratic explanations are not acceptable in the absence of plausible justification. The Court emphasized that the applicants had been negligent in pursuing their remedy of appeal and that this inordinate delay was not liable to be condoned.
- The Court considered Sheo Raj Singh but concluded that it did not assist the applicants because that case involved appellate review of a lower court's discretionary grant of condonation; by contrast, the present petition required the Court itself to decide whether sufficient cause existed to condone the delay (not whether a lower court had erred in exercising discretion).
- The Court also distinguished State of Manipur v. Koting Lamkang on its facts: that case involved an appeal filed within limitation but in the wrong forum, whereas in the present matter no appeal at all was filed within limitation.
- On the cumulative facts and authorities, the Court concluded that the applicants failed to make out sufficient cause to condone the delay and that the applicants had been negligent.
Holding and Implications
HOLDING: The application for condonation of delay is dismissed. Consequently, the unregistered Letters Patent Appeal (LPA) is also dismissed.
Implications:
- Direct effect: The applicants' prayer for condonation of a 376-day delay was rejected and the unregistered LPA challenging the Single Judge's judgment dated 02.06.2022 has been dismissed. Pending miscellaneous applications, if any, were also disposed of.
- Precedential effect: The Court applied established Supreme Court authorities (notably Postmaster General v. Living Media India Ltd. and subsequent cases) to reiterate that governmental delay must be satisfactorily explained and that impersonal bureaucratic delay will not ordinarily be accepted. The opinion does not announce any new legal principle; it applies existing precedent to the facts and denies relief on the ground of negligence and inadequate explanation for delay.
Disposition recorded by: M.S. Ramachandra Rao, Chief Justice; Satyen Vaidya, Judge. Date of pronouncement: 02 July 2024.
H
ig h Co ur t o f H
.P
.
1
2024:HHC:4276
IN THE HIGH COURT OF HIMACHAL PRADESH
AT SHIMLA
CMP(M) No.937 of 2023 Reserved on: 18.06.2024 Pronounced on:02.07.2024
The State of Himachal Pradesh & Others …Applicants Versus
Rakesh Kumar …Respondent
__________________________________________________________
Coram:
Hon'ble Mr. Justice M.S. Ramachandra Rao, Chief Justice. Hon'ble Mr. Justice Satyen Vaidya, Judge.
Whether approved for reporting?
For applicants : Mr. Anup Rattan, Advocate General with Mr. Pranay Pratap Singh,
Additional Advocate General.
For the respondent : Mr. Ashok Kumar, Advocate vice Mr. Nishant Khidtta, Advocate.
M.S. Ramachandra Rao, Chief Justice. This application is filed by the applicants under Section 5 of the Lim tation Act, 1963 to condone delay of 376 days in filing the Letters Patent Appeal challenging the judgment dt. 02.06.2022 passed by the learned Single Judge.
2. In the application filed seeking condonation of delay, it is stated that copy of the judgment of the learned Single was received by the applicant no.3, who forwarded it on 16.06.2022 to the office of Engineer-in-Chief of the PWD Department and the later then forwarded
1
2
it to the Government on 11.07.2022 for obtaining advice/opinion of the Law Department.
3. It is stated that when the matter was under consideration at Government level, the respondent filed a Contempt petition before the High Court, and the Advocate General, after examining the matter, advised the applicants to file Review petition against the judgment dt. 02.06.2022 of the learned Single Judge; that thereafter a Review petition was filed by the applicants, but the same was dismissed on
23.12.2023.
4. It is stated that the office of the Advocate General informed the office of applicant no.3 about passing of the judgment in the Review petition on 24.03.2023 after three months.
5. It is stated that applicant no.3 then wrote to the applicant no.2 on 31.03.2023, which letter was received on 12.04.2023; the applicant no.2 then forwarded it to the Government on 19.04.2023; that the matter was then referred to the Advocate General,that his office advised the applicants to file LPA against the judgment dt. 02.06.2022; and thereafter on 23.05.2023, the LPA was filed with the above period of delay.
6. The instant LPA is admittedly being filed by the applicants, challenging the order dt. 02.06.2022 passed by the learned Single Judge and this LPA had been filed on 23.05.2023.
3
7. No details have been furnished in the application for condonation of delay as to when the Review petition was actually filed, though it is stated that it was dismissed on 23.12.2022.
8. It appears that the office of the Advocate General informed applicant no.3 about the dismissal of the Review petition , which happened on 23.12.2022, 3 months later on 24.03.2023. Why such a long period of delay occurred is not satisfactorily explained by the applicants.
9. The Advocate General sought to contend that there was a change in Government in December 2022 and there was probably delay in appointing the Law Officers which was the cause for late communication of the order passed in the Review petition.
10. No such reasons have been assigned in the application for condonation of delay.
11. In any event, the State Government machinery was already there and it was the duty of the officers of the applicants' Departments to find out what transpired to their Review petition and to take further steps in the matter quickly.
12. Even otherwise, filing of the review Petition seeking review of the judgement in the Writ Petition and it's dismissal, cannot be pleaded as a ground for condonation of delay in filing an LPA against the judgment in the Writ Petition.
4
13. In our opinion, the delay in filing the LPA against the original judgment of the learned Single Judge delivered on 02.06.2022, after 24.03.2023 till 23.05.2023, is also not properly explained.
14. We hold that the applicants have been negligent in pursuing their remedy of appeal and the said inordinate period of delay is not liable to be condoned for the aforesaid reasons.
1 5. In Postmaster General and others vs. Living Media India Limited and another1, the Supreme Court held: - "25. We have already extracted the reasons as mentioned in the "better affidavit" sworn by Mr. Aparajeet Pattanayak, SSRM, Air Mail Sorting Division, New Delhi. It is relevant to note that in the said affidavit, the Department has itself mentioned and is aware of the date of the judgment of the Division Bench of the High Court in Office of the Chief Postmaster v. Living Media India Ltd. as 11.09.2009. Even according to the deponent, their counsel had applied for the certified copy of the said judgment only on 08.01.2010 and the same was received by the Department on the very same day. There is no explanation for not applying for certified copy of the impugned judgment on 11.09.2009 or at least within a reasonable time. The fact remains that the certified copy was applied only on 08.01.2010, i.e. after a period of nearly four months. 26. In spite of affording another opportunity to file better affidavit by placing adequate material, neither the Department nor the person in-charge has filed any explanation for not applying the certified copy within the prescribed period. The other dates mentioned in the affidavit which we have already
1
5
extracted, clearly show that there was delay at every stage and except mentioning the dates of receipt of the file and the decision taken, there is no explanation as to why such delay had occasioned. Though it was stated by the Department that the delay was due to unavoidable circumstances and genuine difficulties, the fact remains that from day one the Department or the person/persons concerned have not evinced diligence in prosecuting the matter to this Court by taking appropriate steps.
27. It is not in dispute that the person(s) concerned were well aware or conversant with the issues involved including the prescribed period of limitation for taking up the matter by way of filing a special leave petition in this Court. They cannot claim that they have a separate period of limitation when the Department was possessed with competent persons familiar with court proceedings. In the absence of plausible and acceptable explanation, we are posing a question why the delay is to be condoned mechanically merely because the Government or a wing of the Government is a party before us.
28. Though we are conscious of the fact that in a matter of condonation of delay when there was no gross negligence or deliberate inaction or lack of bona fides, a liberal concession has to be adopted to advance substantial justice, we are of the view that in the facts and circumstances, the Department cannot take advantage of various earlier decisions. The claim on account of impersonal machinery and inherited bureaucratic methodology of making several notes cannot be accepted in view of the modern technologies being used and available. The law of limitation undoubtedly binds everybody, including the Government."
16. The said judgment has been followed by the Supreme Court in several cases such as Commissioner of Customs Chennai vs. M/s
6
Volex Interconnect (India) Pvt. Ltd.2, Pr. Commissioner Central Excise Delhi-1 vs. Design Dialogues India Pvt. Ltd.3; Union of India
vs. Central Tibetan Schools Administration & others4; Union of India & others vs. Vishnu Aroma Pouching Private Limited and another5;
and State of Uttar Pradesh & others vs. Sabha Narain & others6.
17. Learned Advocate General relied on the judgment of the Supreme Court in Sheo Raj Singh (deceased) through LRs & others
Vs. Union of India & another, Civil Appeal no. 5867 of 2015 dt.
09.10.2023.
In Sheo Raj Singh, the High Court had condoned the delay of 479 days in filing a Land Acquisition Appeal in the High Court and the explanation offered found favour with the Supreme Court. In that case, the Supreme Court observed that it was not hearing an application for condonation of delay, but was sitting in appeal over discretionary exercise of the High Court granting the prayer for condonation of delay; that in the case of the former, whether to condone or not, would be the only question, whereas in the latter, whether there has been proper exercise of discretion in favour of grant of prayer for condonation, would be the question; and the law was well settled that a
3
4
5
(2022) 9 SCC 263
(2022) 9 SCC 266
6
7
Court of Appeal should not ordinarily interfere with the discretionary exercise by the Courts below; and that the appellate power should be exercised only when the order of appeal is clearly wrong and not when it is merely not right.
18. The said decision, therefore, cannot help the applicants since in the instant application, this Court has to consider the question whether sufficient cause has been shown to condone the said period of delay in filing the Letters Patent Appeal. It is not considering whether a Tribunal/Court subordinate to it was right in condoning or refusing to condone the delay.
19. Learned Advocate General also relied on the judgment of the Supreme Court in the State of Manipur and Ors. vs. Koting Lamkang7. That was a case where the State had preferred an RFA against an order of a Single Judge of the High Court, declining to condone delay of 312 days in filing a Regular First Appeal. The State had contended that being under a bonafide mistake, it had wrongly filed an appeal before the District Judge instead of the High Court and the said Court had dismissed the appeal on the ground that it had no pecuniary jurisdiction to entertain the appeal.
8
Government's functioning where individual officers may fail to act responsibly, resulting in injustice to institutional interest of the State. This case is distinguishable in the sense that there was an appeal filed in that case within limitation but in a wrong forum. It was not a case like the instant case where no appeal at all was filed within limitation.
Also in this judgment, the attention of the Court was not drawn to the judgment in Post Master General (supra-1) and other cases following it, referred to in Para 15 above.
20. Having regard to the above facts & circumstances and the legal position set-out above, we find no merit in the application and it is accordingly dismissed. Consequently, the unregistered LPA is also dismissed.
21. Pending miscellaneous application(s), if any, shall also stand disposed of.
(M.S. Ramachandra Rao) Chief Justice
(Satyen Vaidya) July 02, 2024 Judge
(Yashwant)
Alert