Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

AKSHAY CHOUDHARY  v. UNION OF INDIA MINISTRY OF HOME AFFAIRS & ORS.

Delhi High Court
May 20, 2024
Smart Summary (Beta)

High Court of Delhi — W.P.(C) 5602/2024 (Judgment dated May 20, 2024)

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioner, Akshay Choudhary, challenged the decision of the respondents (Union of India, Ministry of Home Affairs and others) declaring him medically unfit for appointment as Assistant Commandant (Group A) in the Central Armed Police Forces (CAPF). The advertisement for the post was issued on April 26, 2023. The petitioner underwent tattoo removal surgery on December 8, 2023 (removing a tattoo of 'OM' engraved in Hindi on the inner anterior part of his right forearm). He cleared the written examination on December 19, 2023, and was called for physical and medical tests at 39 Battalion, ITBP, Noida. He was found unfit initially because of the tattoo mark. On December 27, 2023, he applied for a Review Medical Examination (RME) and underwent another tattoo-removal procedure the same day. The RME on December 28, 2023, declared him unfit due to an unhealed/unhealthy scar on the ventral surface of the right forearm. The petitioner later (on April 20, 2024) obtained a dermatologist's opinion and a photograph indicating no visible tattoo residue and that only 2–3 additional sittings might be needed for complete clearance of post-laser hyper-pigmentation. The petitioner filed the present writ petition seeking quashing of the RME dated December 28, 2023, reconstitution of the Review Medical Examination Board, and direction to conduct a fresh RME by dermatology members.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the petitioner was rightly declared medically unfit by the Medical Board / Review Medical Board on the basis of an unhealed/unhealthy scar following tattoo removal on the right forearm.
  2. Whether, given the timing of the RME soon after surgery and subsequent evidence suggesting healing, a re-examination by a fresh Medical Board is warranted.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Arguments

  • The petitioner got the tattoo removed (initially on December 8, 2023 and again on December 27, 2023) and, by April 20, 2024, a medical examination showed no visible tattoo residue.
  • The conclusion of the Medical Board / Review Medical Board that he was unfit due to an unhealed/unhealthy scar was misconceived and untenable.
  • If re-examined now, the petitioner would be found fit under the respondents' own tattoo guidelines.
  • Counsel relied on three precedents in support of the petitioner's case (Sunil Kumar; Shubham Sharma; Himanshu Kumar).

Respondents' Arguments

  • The advertisement/examination notice stipulates eligibility conditions including a Tattoo Clause that permits tattoos only on certain locations (inner aspect of the left forearm — the non-saluting limb — and dorsum of hands) and within size limits; a tattoo on the front/right forearm is outside permitted locations.
  • The medical condition of a candidate must be assessed as on the date of the medical examination/RME and cannot be later remedied by an examination months after the RME; therefore the petition should be dismissed.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Sunil Kumar vs Union of India and Ors. [SWP No. 2108 of 2016] The opinion records that the petitioner relied on this judgment; the specific rule or principle invoked from it is not detailed in the provided opinion. The court's text does not describe any specific application of this precedent to its reasoning.
Shubham Sharma Vs Union of India & Ors. [2022/DHC/004749] The opinion records that the petitioner relied on this judgment; the specific rule or principle invoked from it is not detailed in the provided opinion. The court's text does not describe any specific application of this precedent to its reasoning.
Himanshu Kumar Vs Union of India and Ors. [2023: AHC:105831] The opinion records that the petitioner relied on this judgment; the specific rule or principle invoked from it is not detailed in the provided opinion. The court's text does not describe any specific application of this precedent to its reasoning.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court first acknowledged the advertisement's eligibility conditions and the Tattoo Clause (which permits tattoos on traditional sites such as the inner aspect of the left forearm and dorsum of the hands, and sets size limits). The court noted two factual points asserted by the petitioner: (a) he had the tattoo removed and, strictly speaking, there was no tattoo post-surgery; and (b) by April 20, 2024 a skin specialist opined that no tattoo residue was visible and further laser sittings might complete clearance.

The court observed that the Tattoo Clause does not expressly state that an unhealed or unhealthy scar resulting from a tattoo removal would, by itself, cause disqualification. Nevertheless, the Medical Board / Review Medical Board had a "cogent purpose" to examine the scar — namely, to ensure that the visible parts of the hand while saluting were clear. That gave prima facie justification to the Board's concern.

Importantly, the court found fault with the timing of the Review Medical Examination: the RME was conducted only a few days after the petitioner's surgery, foregoing sufficient time for the scar to heal. Considering the photograph at Annexure P-6 and the dermatologist's opinion at Annexure P-7 (dated April 20, 2024), the court concluded prima facie that the scar might now have healed.

Balancing these conclusions, the court exercised its extraordinary jurisdiction under Article 226 to direct a re-examination: it ordered respondents to constitute a new Medical Board to examine the petitioner's right forearm and determine whether the scar remains unhealed/unhealthy or has healed leaving no tattoo residue. The court set procedural directions and an outer time limit for completing the re-examination.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The petition was disposed of by directing the respondents to conduct a re-examination of the petitioner's right forearm by a new Medical Board and to conclude whether the scar consequent to tattoo removal remains unhealed/unhealthy or has healed. The re-examination was to be completed within six weeks; if the Medical Board's view is favourable to the petitioner, the respondents shall, subject to availability of vacancies for Assistant Commandant (Group A), take further action for his appointment; otherwise the Medical Board's conclusion shall be final against the petitioner. The petition was disposed of with no costs.

Implications: The direct effect is an order for a fresh medical re-examination within a specified time and conditional direction regarding appointment if the Board finds the petitioner fit. The opinion does not announce or purport to establish any new wider legal precedent; it resolves the petitioner's factual and procedural grievance by remitting the matter to a fresh medical assessment under the directions stated.

Show all summary ...

W.P.(C) 5602/2024 Page 1 of 6

IN THE HIGH COURT OF DELHI AT NEW DELHI

Judgment delivered on: May 20, 2024

+ W.P.(C) 5602/2024 AKSHAY CHOUDHARY ..... Petitioner Through: Mr. Pankaj Mehta, Advocate. versus

UNION OF INDIA MINISTRY

OF HOME AFFAIRS & ORS. ..... Respondents

Through: Mr. Abdhesh Kumar

Chaudhary, CGSC with

Mr. Chetan Jadon, GP with

Ms. Shivangi Jadon and Ms.

Hemlata Singh, Advocates for R-1 and 3.

CORAM:

HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE V. KAMESWAR RAO HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE RAVINDER DUDEJA

J U D G M E N T

V. KAMESWAR RAO, J

1. This petition has been filed by the petitioner with the following prayers:

"In the light of the aforesaid facts and circumstances, the Petitioner herein most humbly pray that this Hon'ble Court may graciously be pleased to: -

i. Issue a writ order, or direction in the nature of certiorari or any other appropriate writ, thereby directing Respondent No.3 to quash the Review Medical Examination Report dated 28.12.2023;

ii. ii Issue a writ order, or direction in the nature of mandamus or any other appropriate writ to

1

Respondents to reconstitute the Review Medical Examination Board for the Petitioner in consonance with the applicable guidelines;

iii. Issue a writ order, or direction in the nature of mandamus or any other appropriate writ to Respondents to constitute a fresh review medical examination board consisting of members from the Department of Dermatology for fresh medical examination of the Petitioner at the earliest;

iv. Pass any such/further orders or directions as this Hon'ble Court deems fit in the interest of justice."

2. It is the case of the petitioner and so contended by Mr. Pankaj Mehta, learned counsel appearing on behalf of the petitioner that the respondents had issued an advertisement/ examination notice on April 26, 2023 for making appointment to the post of Assistant Commandant (Group A) in the Central Armed Police Forces ('CAPF', for short).

3. That on December 8, 2023, the petitioner had undergone a surgery for removal of tattoo which was engraved on his right forearm. Subsequently, on December 19, 2023, the petitioner successfully cleared the written examination and was further called by the respondent No. 3/ ITBP, for Physical Standard Test (PST) / Physical Efficiency Test (PET) & Medical Standard Test (MST) / Review Medical Examination (RME) at 39 Battalion, ITBP, NOIDA, wherein, he was found unfit on the basis of tattoo mark of 'OM', which was engraved in Hindi on the inner anterior part of the right forearm.

4. On December 27, 2023, the petitioner diligently applied for the Review Medical Examination ('RME', for short). On December, 27 2023, itself, the petitioner again undergone a tattoo removal surgery.

2

Thereafter, on December 28, 2023, the RME took place, wherein the petitioner was declared unfit on the basis of unhealed / unhealthy scar present over the ventral surface of the right forearm.

5. It is his case that on April 20, 2024, the petitioner again visited the hospital where he has got the tattoo removal surgery done and on medical examination by the doctor, it was found that no residue of tattoo is visible on the hands of the petitioner.

6. Hence, it is his case that the conclusion drawn by the medical board / review medical board that the petitioner is unfit on the basis of unhealed / unhealthy scar of tattoo is totally misconceived / untenable. Moreover, it is his submission that if the re-examination is conducted today, the medical board / review medical board would be satisfied that the removal of tattoo is complete and the petitioner is fit in terms of the guidelines issued by the respondents themselves for appointment. He has relied upon the following judgments in support of his case:

i. Sunil Kumar vs Union of India and Ors. [SWP No. 2108 of 2016];

ii. Shubham Sharma Vs Union of India & Ors. [2022/DHC/004749];

iii. Himanshu Kumar Vs Union of India and Ors. [2023:

AHC:105831].

7. On the other hand, Mr. Abdhesh Kumar Chaudhary, learned CGSC, appearing for the respondents would contest the submissions made by Mr. Mehta, by stating that the advertisement/ examination notice, issued by the respondents clearly stipulates that every candidate is required to fulfill all the eligibility conditions for successful admission in the respondents' Force and the advertisement itself

3

stipulates that tattoo marked on traditional sites of the body like inner aspect of forearm, but only LEFT forearm, being not saluting limb or dorsum of the hands are to be allowed.

8. It is his submission that in the case of the petitioner, since the tattoo was on the front side of the right forearm, his case is not covered under the eligibility conditions clearly stipulated in the concerned advertisement. That apart, the medical position needs to be seen on the date when the medical examination / RME is held and not after four months thereof, as sought by the petitioner in the present case and as such, the present petition needs to be dismissed.

9. Having heard the learned counsel for the parties, the short issue which arises for consideration is whether the case of the petitioner was rightly rejected the Medical Board / Review Medical Board.

10. It is true that the advertisement clearly states that the candidates need to fulfill all eligibility conditions before even applying for the post in question. However, it is the case of Mr. Mehta that the petitioner has got his tattoo removed which was present on the front side of the right forearm only after he realizes that he successfully cleared the written examination. So, in that sense, the petitioner may be called as fence- sitter, but the fact remains that the petitioner got his tattoo removed from the right forearm.

11. It is the submission of Mr. Mehta that having got the tattoo removed from the right forearm, technically, there exists no tattoo on the right forearm of the petitioner and in that sense, the petitioner meets the eligibility conditions stipulated as under:

4

"(6) Tattoo Clause:

a) Content- being a secular country, the religious sentiments of our countrymen are to be respected and thus tattoos depicting religious symbol or figure and the name, as followed in Indian army, are to be permitted.

b) Location- tattoos marked on traditional sites of the body like inner aspect of forearm, but only LEFT forearm, being non saluting limb or dorsum of the hands are to be allowed.

c) Size- size must be less than ½ of the particular part (Elbow or Hand) of the body."

12. Strictly, there exists no tattoo post the tattoo removal surgery, and also, prima facie, the Tattoo Clause, does not stipulate that if a scar pursuant to removal of tattoo is unhealthy / unhealed, the same would lead to disqualification of a candidate, but we find that there was a cogent purpose for the Medical Board / Review Medical Board to examine the scar pursuant to the surgery to ensure that the visible part of the hand while saluting is clear in all respect. To that extent, the conclusion of the Review Medical Board, may be justified. But the fact remains that the Review Medical Board should not have examined the petitioner immediately after few days of surgery and should have given sufficient time to the petitioner to ensure healing of the scar and then decide the fitness / unfitness of the petitioner, as from the photograph of the petitioner's right forearm at ANNEXURE P-6, as well as the opinion sought by the petitioner from a skin specialist at ANNEXURE P-7 on April 20, 2024, who opined that no residue of tattoo can be seen and 2-3 sittings, would be needed for complete clearance of post-laser hyper-pigmentation, prima facie, it appears that the scar might have healed. As such, this Court in exercise of its extraordinary jurisdiction

5

under Article 226 is of the view that the appropriate shall be that the respondents conduct re-examination of the petitioner's right forearm through a new Medical Board and come to a conclusion, whether the scar on the right forearm pursuant to removal of tattoo continues to be unhealed and unhealthy or has completely healed leaving no residue of tattoo. If the view of the Medical Board is in favour of the petitioner then the respondents shall, subject to availability of the vacancies in the grade of Assistant Commandant (Group A) take further action in respect of appointment of the petitioner as Assistant Commandant. Otherwise, the matter shall be treated as final against the petitioner. The aforesaid process of re-examination shall be completed within a period of six weeks from today as an outer limit and further action, if any, shall be taken as expeditiously as possible.

13. The petition is disposed of in above terms. No Costs.

V. KAMESWAR RAO, J

RAVINDER DUDEJA, J

MAY 20, 2024/jg

6