Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Subodh Kumar Agrawal v. Steel Authority of India Limited SAIL

National Company Law Tribunal
Apr 23, 2024
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

This opinion addresses an application filed by the Resolution Professional (RP) of Hindustan Controls and Equipment Private Limited, the Corporate Debtor, seeking to set aside an Arbitral Award dated 06.03.2023 passed by a sole Arbitrator in an arbitration involving Steel Authority of India (SAIL), Hindustan Controls, and Amiya Commerce & Construction Co Private Limited. The RP contended that the award was passed after the initiation of the Corporate Insolvency Resolution Process (CIRP) on 05.07.2022, during the moratorium period under Section 14 of the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code (IBC), and thus the arbitration proceedings and award were in violation of the moratorium. The RP sought an order setting aside the award, restraining the respondent from taking steps to enforce it, and interim relief. The respondent contested the maintainability of this application before the National Company Law Tribunal (NCLT), asserting that the NCLT lacks jurisdiction to set aside an arbitral award under Section 60(5) of the IBC and that such challenge must be made under the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the National Company Law Tribunal has jurisdiction under Section 60(5) of the IBC to set aside an arbitral award passed during the moratorium period under Section 14 of the IBC.
  2. Whether an arbitral award passed after the initiation of CIRP and during the moratorium is valid or non est in law.
  3. Whether the challenge to the arbitral award should be entertained by the NCLT or only by the appropriate court under the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996.

Arguments of the Parties

Applicant's Arguments (Resolution Professional)

  • The arbitral award dated 06.03.2023 was passed after the initiation of the CIRP against the Corporate Debtor on 05.07.2022, during the moratorium period under Section 14 of the IBC.
  • The arbitrator proceeded with the arbitration despite being aware of the insolvency proceedings and moratorium, violating the moratorium provisions.
  • The arbitration instituted after the moratorium is non est in law, citing the Hon'ble Apex Court decision in Alchemist Asset Reconstruction Company Ltd. -Versus- M/s. Hotel Gaudavan (Civil Appeal No. 16929/2017).

Respondent's Arguments (Steel Authority of India)

  • The challenge to the arbitral award dated 06.03.2023 cannot be made under Section 60(5) of the IBC before the NCLT.
  • The interlocutory application filed before the NCLT is not maintainable.
  • The appropriate remedy to set aside the arbitral award lies under Section 34 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996.
  • The NCLT is not a "Court" under the Arbitration and Conciliation Act and therefore cannot exercise jurisdiction under Section 34 to set aside an arbitral award.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Alchemist Asset Reconstruction Company Ltd. -Versus- M/s. Hotel Gaudavan (Civil Appeal No. 16929/2017) Arbitration instituted after moratorium under IBC is non est in law. The applicant cited this decision to contend that arbitration proceedings during moratorium are invalid, but the Court noted that despite this, it does not have jurisdiction to set aside the award.
Decision of Hon'ble Apex Court in Gujarat Urja Vikas Nigam Limited appeal NCLT should not usurp jurisdiction of other courts for disputes dehors insolvency; disputes unrelated to insolvency must be decided by competent authority. The Court relied on this to emphasize that NCLT’s jurisdiction under Section 60(5) IBC is limited to insolvency-related matters and does not extend to setting aside arbitral awards.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court carefully considered the rival contentions and examined the scope of jurisdiction conferred upon the NCLT under Section 60(5) of the IBC. It acknowledged that while the NCLT has powers to issue injunctions before arbitration and to enforce arbitral awards, it does not possess the authority to set aside an arbitral award, as such power is vested exclusively in courts under the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996.

The Court noted the moratorium under Section 14 of the IBC prohibits certain actions against the Corporate Debtor during the insolvency resolution process. Although the arbitral award was passed during the moratorium, the Court found that the challenge to the award cannot be entertained by the NCLT. The Court referred to the Apex Court’s caution that NCLT must not encroach upon the jurisdiction of other forums where the dispute does not directly relate to insolvency proceedings.

Consequently, the Court concluded that the NCLT’s jurisdiction under Section 60(5) is circumscribed by the IBC and does not empower it to set aside arbitral awards. The RP was thus directed to pursue appropriate proceedings under the Arbitration and Conciliation Act to challenge the award.

Holding and Implications

The application IA(IB) No. 1820/(KB)/2023 is accordingly disposed of.

The Court held that the National Company Law Tribunal lacks jurisdiction to set aside an arbitral award, even if the award is passed during the moratorium period under Section 14 of the IBC. The direct consequence is that the Resolution Professional cannot challenge the arbitral award before the NCLT under Section 60(5) of the IBC, but must instead initiate proceedings under the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996. This decision confines the NCLT’s powers strictly to matters related to insolvency resolution and prevents it from encroaching upon the jurisdiction of other specialized fora, thereby maintaining the separation of powers between insolvency and arbitration adjudications. No new precedent altering the scope of NCLT’s jurisdiction was established beyond this clarification.

Show all summary ...

Page 1 of 6

In the National Company Law Tribunal Division Bench, (Court-II), Kolkata IA(IB) No. 1820/( KB) /2023 In CP(IB) No. 1256/KB/2019

Application under Section 60(5) of IBC, Code 2016 read with Rule 11 of the National Company Law Tribunal Rules, 2016;

In the Matter of:

Mahavir Industrial Corporation …..Operational Creditor Versus

Hindustan Controls and Equipment Private Limited …Corporate Debtor

In the mater of:

Subodh Kumar Agarwal, the Resolution Professional of Hindustan Controls and Equipment Private Limited having its office at Room No. 301, 3rd

Floor, 1, Ganesh Chandra Avenue, Kolkata -

700 013.

…Applicant Versus

Steel Authority of India (SAIL) having its registered office at Ispat Bhawan, Lodhi Road, New Delhi - 110 003 and the unit office at 4th

Floor, SAIL House 50 JLN Road, Kolkata - 700 071. ….Respondent

Date of Pronouncement of order: 23.04.2024 Coram:

Smt. Bidisha Banerjee : Member (Judicial) Shri D. Arvind : Member (Technical) Counsel appeared physically / through video Conferencing

Mr. Prantik Garai, Adv. ] For the Respondent IA(I.B.C)/1820(KB)2023 Mr. Abhishek Sikdar, Adv

Page 2 of 6

Mr. Avijit Ghoshal, Adv. ] For R-1 in IA(I.B.C)/782(KB)2022 Mr. Subhasis Sengupta, Adv. ] For R-3

Mr. Souvik Kundu, Adv.

Ms. Nilanjana Adhya, Adv. ] For R-4 in IA(I.B.C)/782(KB)2022 Ms. Bishalaxmi Ghosh, Adv. ]

Ms. Ranjana Seal, Adv.

Mr. Subodh Kumar Agarwal, CA ] For Ex. RP

Ms. Pooja Agarwal, CA

O R D E R

Per Bidisha Banerjee, Member (Judicial):

1. The Court convened through hybrid mode.

2. Ld. Counsel for the parties were heard at length.

3. The Applicant Resolution Professional of Hindustan Controls and Equipment Private Limited, the Corporate Debtor has preferred this application seeking the following reliefs:

a. An order be passed setting aside of the impugned Arbitral Award dated 06.03.2023 passed by Learned sole Arbitrator in an Arbitration Case between M/s. Steel Authority of India - Versus - Hindustan Controls & Equipment Private Limited and Amiya Commerce & Construction Co Private Limited.

b. To restrain the Respondent to take any steps in terms of Impugned Arbitral Award dated 06.03.2023.

c. Ad Interim orders in terms of above.

Page 3 of 6

4. It is the contention of the RP that the Arbitral Award was passed after initiation of Resolution Process against the Corporate Debtor vide order dated 05.07.2022 and ignoring the provisions of moratorium under Section 14 of the IBC.

5. It is submitted that the Arbitrator was aware of the order admitting the Corporate Debtor into Insolvency, yet it did not stay its hands off and went on with the Arbitration proceedings to pass its award during the course of Moratorium.

6. The Applicant has cited the decision of the Hon'ble Apex Court in Civil Appeal No. 16929/2017, arising out of S.L.P. (C ) No. 18195/2017 (Alchemist Asset Reconstruction Company Ltd. -Versus- M/s. Hotel Gaudavan to contend that Arbitration instituted after the Moratorium is non est in law.

7. Per contra, the sole Respondent would contend as under:

a. Challenge to the Award dated March 06, 2023 cannot be made under Section 60(5) of the IBC.

b. This Interlocutory Application is therefore, is not maintainable.

c. The application seeking setting aside of the Arbitration has to be preferred under Section 2(1)(e ) of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996.

d. NCLT as an Adjudicating Authority is not a Court within the meaning of Arbitration and Conciliation Act to excise power under Section 34 of the Arbitration and

Page 4 of 6

Conciliation Act, hence setting aside application can only be made under Section 34 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act, which power NCLT cannot invoke.

8. We have considered the rival contentions and perused the records.

9. We would note that although NCLT has the power to issue an Ante Arbitration injunction, in light of the Section 430 of the Companies Act and also has the power to refer parties to Arbitration or enforce Arbitration Award, it cannot set aside an Arbitral Award.

10. We are mindful of the decision of Hon'ble Apex Court where NCLT has been cautioned not to usurp the legitimate jurisdiction of the other Courts, Tribunals and Forum, when the dispute is not related to the Insolvency of the Corporate Debtor in an Appeal filed by Gujrat Urja Vikas Nigam Limited against the decision of the Hon'ble NCLAT upholding the decision of NCLT staying termination of a power, purchase agreement entered with a firm which latter went into Insolvency, Hon'ble Apex Court has held that "for adjudication of dispute that arise dehors the Insolvency of the Corporate Debtor, the Resolution Professional must approach the relevant Competent Authority"

and that Section 238 of the IBC stipulates that Code would over ride other laws including an instrument having effect by virtue of any such law, NCLT's jurisdiction can be invoked only on the

Page 5 of 6

ground that relates to Insolvency Resolution Process. NCLT cannot derive its power from the sprit and object of the IBC. The NCLT has a wide residuary jurisdiction, under Section 60 (5) of the IBC to adjudicate question of law a fact arising out of Insolvency Proceedings nonetheless it is defined by the text of IBC. The NCLT cannot do what the IBC consciously did not provide the power to do.

11. In as much as, the Arbitration Award has been challenged in this application, whereas this Tribunal lacks jurisdiction to set aside an Arbitral Award, although it was passed in course of moratorium under Section 14 of IBC, we dispose of the IA with liberty to the Resolution Professional to initiate appropriate proceedings to challenge the said Award.

12. This application IA(IB) No. 1820/( KB) /2023 is accordingly, disposed of.

13. The Registry is directed to send e-mail copies of the order forthwith to all the parties and their Ld. Counsel for information and for taking necessary steps.

14. Certified copy of this order may be issued, if applied for, upon compliance of all requisite formalities.

D. Arvind Member (Technical) Bidisha Banerjee, Member (Judicial)

Signed on this the 23rd

day of April, 2024

Page 6 of 6

M. Jana (P.S.)