- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
NABHIMULLA AJIMULLA PATHAN v. PRAMILABAI HARISHCHANDRA POHEKAR AND ANOR.
1
IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY
NAGPUR BENCH : NAGPUR.
Writ Petition No. 2848 of 2003.
PETITIONER : Satish S/o Chaturbhuj Panchariya, aged about 38 years,
Occupation-Nil,
R/o Hind Nagar,
Wardha, Distt. Wardha.
-VERSUS-
RESPONDENTS : 1. The President, New Education Society, Badnera Railway,
Tq. And Distt. Amravati.
2. The Head Master, Janta Vidyalaya, Anjangaon Bari, Tq. and Distt. Amravati.
3. The Dy. Director of Education, Amravati Division, Amravati. ======================================================= Shri N. R. Saboo, Advocate for the petitioner. Shri R. S. Sunderam, Advocate for the respondent no.1 & 2. Shri A. S. Sonare AGP for respondent no.3. =======================================================
CORAM: A. H. JOSHI, J.
2
DECIDED ON: 29thNOVEMBER 2007.
ORAL JUDGMENT :
1. Rule. Rule is made returnable forthwith and heard by consent of the parties.
2. Civil Application No.6684 of 2007 was listed for hearing. In the midst of hearing, it was transpired that the petition, which is already admitted, itself can be taken for final hearing
3. The controversy that has been raised in the petition is as to whether the petitioner is entitled for relief of reinstatement by modifying the Judgment and order of the School Tribunal.
4. The School Tribunal had granted compensation in lieu of the reinstatement holding that the termination though erroneous, reinstatement could not be granted in absence of permission to fill in the vacancy in view of backlog.
3
5. In view of the changed circumstances, during the pendency of petition, now the affidavit has been filed by the Education Officer. While answering the contents of Civil Application No.6684 of 2007, which consists the following versions:
"2. In this context, it is submitted that there are 8 vacant posts of Assistant Teachers, out of which one post is reserved for the candidate belonging to Special Backward Class Category. It is submitted that if the respondent management makes appointment of the candidate belonging to S.B.C. Category to fulfill the backlog of S.B.C. AND therefore, if the Respondent Management appoints the petitioner on the post of Assistant Teacher then the approval to the appointment of the petitioner can be considered as per Rules. It is, however, submitted that the petitioner is not entit6led for any previous claim. Hence, this submission."
[Quoted from page 18 of W.P. Paper Book.]
6. The management has also come with a plea while replying the application seeking interim direction i.e. Civil Application No.6684 of 2007, that if the Education Department okays, the petitioner can be appointed.
4
7. In view of these admissions, it is not necessary to go into the legality and details of reasons leading to refusal of reinstatement by the Tribunal.
8. The petitioner's claim for reinstatement is thereby fructified and crystallized. It is however, clear that the petitioner would not be entitled to any payment towards arrears of back- wages.
9. In the aforesaid background, Rule is made absolute as follows:
(A) The Judgment and order passed by the School Tribunal, Amravati in appeal No.35 of 1999, decided on 21-4-2003 is modified.
(B) The petitioner shall be entitled for reinstatement and continuity of service, but no amount towards the arrears of back- wages.
(C) The order of reinstatement shall be issued by the
5
management within 30 days from the date of this order.
(D) The Education Officer shall extend necessary approval within one month from reinstatement.
(E) All Civil Applications are disposed of.
(F) In the circumstances, parties are directed to bear own costs.
JUDGE
//MULE//
Alert