- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Appeal No.5978 of 2024 filed by Ram Karan
BEFORE THE APPELLATE AUTHORITY
(Under the Right to Information Act, 2005)
SECURITIES AND EXCHANGE BOARD OF INDIA
Appeal No. 5978 of 2024
Ram Karan : Appellant Vs
CPIO, SEBI, Mumbai : Respondent
ORDER
1. The appellant had filed an application dated March 22, 2024 (received by the respondent through RTI MIS Portal) under the Right to Information Act, 2005 ("RTI Act"). The respondent, by a letter dated April 05, 2024 responded to the application filed by the appellant. The appellant filed an appeal (Reg. No. SEBIH/A/E/24/00072) dated April 08, 2024. I have carefully considered the application, the response and the appeal and find that the matter can be decided based on the material available on record.
2. Requests in the application -The appellant, vide his application dated March 22, 2024, sought the following information:
1. The SEBI FAQ no.22 (Secondary Market) dated 28.02.2009 states that according to BSE & NSE By Laws a broker can not charge more than 2.5% brokerage from his clients. Please clarify whether this rule also applies to trading in derivative segment?
2. Please clarify whether in option trade the brokerage is to be levied as per lot or per order of executed trade?
3. Please clarify whether in option trade one contract is treated as trade executed per lot, trade executed per order or trade executed per strike price?
4. As per NSE circular reference no. NSC/INSP/8338 circular number NSC/INSP/2006/56 dated 5th January 2007, it is mentioned that brokerage on option contracts shall not exceed 2.5% of the premium amount or Rs 100 whichever is higher. Please clarify whether the above rule is vague and give full liberty to a broker to charge any flat rate of brokerage from Rs 50 to Rs 100 per lot irrespective of the volume/value of the executed trade? If so the justification thereof?
If not, what is the actual criteria to fix minimum, maximum and flat rate of brokerage per lot, per order and per trade?
5. In Bank nifty option lot size was 25 on 31.03.2023 and reduced to 15 scripts per lot. Has any step been taken by SEBI to advise or instruct the brokers to change flat brokerage rates in proportion to the change in lot size?"
3. Reply of the Respondent - The respondent, in response to aforesaid requests, informed that the information sought are in the nature of seeking clarification/opinion. Accordingly, the same cannot be
1
construed as "Information" as defined u/s 2(f) of the RTI Act. However, the respondent informed the appellant to refer to SEBI FAQs on Stock Brokers, issued on March 15, 2023 and SEBI Master Circular on Stock Brokers issued on May 17, 2023. The respondent also provided the relevant links to access the aforesaid FAQ and circular on SEBI website.
4. Ground of appeal - The respondent filed the appeal on the ground that the he has been refused access to information requested.
5. I have perused the application and the response provided thereto. On consideration, I find that the request of the appellant is in the nature of seeking clarification/opinion from the respondent. It is understood that the respondent is not supposed to create information; or to interpret information; or to furnish clarification to the appellant under the ambit of the RTI Act. I find that the said request cannot be construed as seeking 'information' as defined under section 2(f) of the RTI Act. Consequently, the respondent did not have an obligation to provide such clarification or opinion under the RTI Act. In this context, reliance is placed on the matter of Azad Singh vs. CPIO, Oriental Insurance Company Limited (order dated March 23, 2021), wherein, Hon'ble Central Information Commission observed that "7. The Commission, after hearing the submissions of both the parties and after perusal of records, observed that some queries of the appellant are in the nature of seeking explanation/opinion/advice/confirmation/clarification from the CPIO and he has expected that the CPIO firstly should analyze the documents and then provide information to the appellant. But the CPIO is not supposed to create information; or to interpret information; or to compile information as per the desire of the appellant under the ambit of the RTI Act. As per Section 2(f) of the RTI Act, the reasons/opinions/advices can only be provided to the applicants if it is available on record of the public authority. The CPIO cannot create information in the manner as sought by the appellant. The CPIO is only a communicator of information based on the records held in the office and hence, he cannot be expected to do research work to deduce anything from the material therein and then supply it to him" Accordingly, I do not find any deficiency in the response.
6. In view of the above observations, I find that there is no need to interfere with the decision of the respondent. The Appeal is accordingly dismissed.
Place: Mumbai B RAJENDRAN Date: April 23, 2024 APPELLATE AUTHORITY UNDER THE RTI ACT
SECURITIES AND EXCHANGE BOARD OF INDIA
2
Alert