Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

P RAMESH v. NEHRU YUVA KENDRA SANGATHAN

Central Administrative Tribunal
Apr 5, 2024

OA/700/2021 Page 1 of 6

CENTRAL ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL

HYDERABAD BENCH

OA/021/0700/2021

HYDERABAD, this the 05thday of April, 2024

Hon'ble Dr. Lata Baswaraj Patne, Judicial Member

1. P.Ramesh, S/o Ramulu, Aged 53years, Occ: Retd Multi Task service, (Gr-C), R/o 4-69/30/A/30, Theegalaguttapally, Karimnagar-505001, Telangana.

2. P.Raj Kumar, S/o P.Ramesh, Aged 29years, Occ: unemployed, R/o R/o 4-69/30/A/30, Theegalaguttapally, Karimnagar-505001, Telangana. …Applicants.

(By Advocate: Mrs. S Anuradha) Vs.

1. The Union of India Rep by its Secretary, Director to Government of India, Ministry of Youth affairs & Sports, C-Wing, Shastri Bhavan, New Delhi.

2. The Director General, Nehru Yuva Kendra Sangathan, StreetNo.4, Gr-Floor Jeevandeep Building Parliament Street, New Delhi.

3. The State Director, Nehru Yuva Kendra Sangathan, 16-2-738/4/5/4, Plot No.4, SBH Colony, Asmangad, Malakpet, Hyderabad-500036. ... Respondents

(By Advocate: Mrs. K Rajitha, Sr. PC for CG) -----

1

Page 2 of 6

ORAL ORDER

(As per Hon'ble Dr. Lata Baswaraj Patne, Judicial Member)

Heard Mrs. S Anuradha, learned counsel for the applicants and Mrs. K Rajitha, learned counsel for the respondents.

2. By this Original Application the applicants are seeking the following relief(s):

"to call for the records pertaining to the order Ref.No.11023/NYKS/PERS:rectmnt/1246/2021, dt.21.09.2021 which was passed stating that the VRS case is not applicable for Compassionate Appointment which is against DOPT Instructions vide F.No.43019/9/2019-Estt(D) dt.23.08.2021 and the Format for the application for Compassionate grounds also states details of the Deceased while in service or retired on medical grounds and set aside the same by declaring the order dt.21.09.2021 as arbitrary, illegal, malafide and violative of Articles 14, 15, 16 and 21 of the Constitution of India and as well as opposed to the concept of providing compassionate appointment to the dependents and also the DOPT instructions and consequently give a direction to the respondents to consider the case for compassionate appointment in any suitable post by considering the 2nd applicant's candidature and may pass any other order or orders as deemed fit and proper in the circumstances of the case."

3. Brief facts of the case in a nutshell are as follows:

The applicant no.1 was appointed in the Nehru Yuva Kendra Sangathan on 05.06.1987 as Gr-D. Later the post of Gr-D is modified and renamed as Multi Tasking Service. While working the applicant had a paralytic stroke and was medically de-categorised and the Medical Board constituted by the Osmania Hospital has declared him completely and permanently incapacitated for further service in the department. Having no other option the applicant no.1 submitted application for voluntary retirement on 12.03.2020 and was permitted to retire on 12.06.2020. The applicant still has more than 9 years of left over service. The family of applicants consists of his wife, two- sons, two-daughter-in-laws and two- small kids aged about 12 and 3 years. The sons are working as labourers and they don't have regular employment or any regular source of income to maintain

Page 3 of 6

themselves. The applicants have submitted application for compassionate appointment to the 2nd applicant (who is the elder son of the 1st applicant) on 16.06.2020. The department has issued an order dated 21.09.2021 which was passed stating that the VRS case is not applicable for Compassionate Appointment which is against the DOPT instructions vide order dated 23.08.2021. Hence, the applicants are seeking a direction to consider the case for compassionate appointment in any suitable post by considering 2ndapplicant's candidature.

4. After notice, the respondents have appeared through their counsel, filed a detailed reply and opposed the relief on the ground that as per DOPT instructions vide F.No. 43019/9/2019-Estt(D) dt. 23.08.2021, the terms of Compassionate Appointment is applicable to a dependent family member (F/5):

(A) of a Government servant who:-

a) dies while in service (including death by suicide); or

b) is retired on medical grounds under Rule 2 of the CCS (Medical Examination) Rules 1957 or the corresponding provision in the Central Civil Service Regulations before attaining the age of 55 years (57 years for erstwhile Group 'D'Government servants);

c) is retired on medical grounds under Rule 38 of the CCS(Pension) Rules, 1972 or the corresponding provision in the Central Civil Service Regulations before attaining the age of 55 years (57 years for erstwhile Group 'D' Government servants);

OR

(B) of a member of the Armed Forces who:-

a) dies during service; or

b) is killed in action; or

(c) is medically boarded out and is unfit for civil employment. Therefore, the representation of Shri P.Raj Kumar (S/o.Shri P Ramesh) was disposed of due to retirement of Shri P Ramesh under Rule 48 (1) (a) of CCS

Page 4 of 6

(Pension) Rule, 1972 and not under Rule 2 of the CCS (Medical Examination) Rules 1957 & Rule 38 of the CCS(Pension) Rules, 1972, vide Letter No.1023/NYKS/PERS:rectmnt/1246/20221 Dated 21.09.2021. Hence, the applicant's son is not entitled for grant of compassionate ground appointment. Therefore, respondents prayed for dismissal of the O.A.

5. Heard both sides and perused the records.

6. The learned counsel for the applicants strongly argued on the point that when the applicant was met with the accident, he was completely and permanently incapacitated for further service in the office of the respondents to which he belongs in consequence of "right side hemiparesis - paralysis of right upper limb and lower limb, post traumatic" he cannot perform his duties, hence invalid (falls under G.O.Ms.No. 661, dt 23.10.2008 at Sl. No.16 (i) (g) (1) (ii)" and the applicant's this incapacity does not appear to have been caused by irregular or intemperate habits as certified in the medical invalidation certificate by the Board on 30.01.2020. However, by office order dated 01.06.2020, the respondents have retired the applicant under Rule 48 (1) (a) of CCS (Pension) Rules on voluntary ground w.e.f. 12.06.2020 (A/N). When the 1stapplicant submitted his request for grant of compassionate appointment to his son, an inquiry was made and a Report was submitted by the District Youth Co-ordinator (D.Y.C) on 15.06.2020 and looking into the indigent condition of the applicant's family, he recommended and requested that the application for compassionate appointment be considered positively. However, the respondents, just following the parameters of the DOPT OM dated 23.08.2021, denied the said appointment and rejected the claim of the applicant, which is against the scheme of grant of compassionate appointment.

Page 5 of 6

7. On the other hand, the learned counsel for the respondents vehemently opposed the relief on the ground that the applicant does not fulfill the criteria as per DOPT instruction dated 23.08.2021 for grant of compassionate appointment as well the applicant's case was also considered under Rule 48 (1) (a) of CCS (Pension) Rules, 1972 and not under Rule 2 of the CCS (Medical Examination) Rules, 1957 & Rule 38 of the CCS (Pension) Rules, 1972, dated 21.09.2021.

8. It is also to be noted that, admittedly, the applicant met with the accident and is completely and permanently incapacitated for further service in the department as per the Medical Invalidation Certificate dated 30.01.2020. It is also to be noted that when the Medical Board has issued such a certificate that the applicant is completely and permanently incapacitated, the department by force made him retire on VRS Scheme under Rule 48 (1) (a) of CCS Pension Rules, w.e.f. from 12.06.2020. It is not the case of the respondents that the applicant has opted for VRS and therefore, the respondents cannot take shelter under the DOPT instruction dated 23.08.2021.

9. It is also to be noted that the main object behind the said compassionate ground appointment is to support the family, suffering from medical invalidation or on the death of the employee who is the sole breadwinner of the family. It is also to be noted that the certificate, which was issued by the Medical Board was well within the knowledge of the respondents authority. The family of the applicant, who was serving as an MTS, as seen from the record is in indigent condition and facing hardship. Hence, the rejection by the respondents does not sustain in the eyes of law. Therefore, the respondents are directed to re-consider the applicant's case in proper perspective to fulfill the object behind the grant of compassionate appointment to support the employee's family with immediate financial assistance by granting the said compassionate ground appointment.

Page 6 of 6

10. In view of the same, the impugned order to the extent of the applicants dated 21.09.2021 is hereby quashed and set aside. The respondents are directed to re- consider the claim of the 1stapplicant for grant of compassionate ground appointment to his son, i.e., 2ndapplicant, within a period of three (03) months, followed with the Medical Invalidation, from the date of receipt of the order and accommodate the 2ndapplicant with available post on MTS thereafter.

11. In view of the above, the O.A. is allowed. No order as to costs.

(DR. LATA BASWARAJ PATNE)

JUDICIAL MEMBER

/SB/