Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

SHANKAR GANBAJI GABHANE v. STATE OF MAH.THR.PSO BHANDARA

Bombay High Court
Mar 15, 2010

1

IN THE HIGH COURT OF JUDICATURE AT BOMBAY :

NAGPUR BENCH : N A G P U R.

CRIMINAL REVISION No. 156 OF 2005

Shankar s/o Ganbaji Gabhane, aged 33 years, Occ.: Private, r/o Kondha, Tahsil Pauni, District Bhandara. ... APPLICANT.

-VERSUS - State of Maharashtra, Through P.S.O. P.S. Adyal, Tahsil Pauni, District Bhandara. ... RESPONDENT.

....

Mr. S.V. Sirpurkar Advocate for the Applicant. Mr. Y.B. Mandpe, A.P.P., for the Respondent.

....

CORAM : A.B. CHAUDHARI, J.

DATED : 15 th MARCH, 2010.

ORAL JUDGMENT :

This revision is directed against the judgment and order dated 26.7.2005 in Criminal Appeal No. 76 of 2003 passed by 3rdAd hoc Additional Sessions Judge, Bhandara, quashing the conviction of the applicant for the offence under Section 304 part II of Indian Penal Code

2

and confirming the order of conviction for the offence punishable under Section 314 of Indian Penal Code whereby the applicant was ordered to undergo rigorous imprisonment for seven years and to pay fine of Rs.2000/-, in default to undergo rigorous imprisonment for one month and also the conviction under Section 33 of the Maharashtra Medical Practitioners Act sentencing him to pay fine of Rs.500, in default to undergone simple imprisonment for one month.

2. In support of the present revision application, inviting my attention to the evidence of P.W.1 Deorao- the husband of deceased Satyafula so also the other evidence, Mr.Sirpurkar argued that on the question of actual act of abortion the only evidence that is available is that the applicant had given some medicine to Satyafula when she had gone to the applicant along with her husband with a view to have abortion since they were already having five children. The counsel argued that except the fact that the applicant had given some medicine to Satyafula there is no evidence worth the name on the record to show that the applicant had performed overt act to cause her abortion and that due to such act she expired. The counsel further argued that the statement of Satyafula was not recorded before her death and the post mortem report shows that Satyafula died because of septicaemic shock which would mean that she had suffered severe infection and the said infection actually caused her

3

death. He argued that there is no evidence on record to show that the applicant had been practising medicine and therefore he could not have been convicted for any of the offences and the applicant was required to be acquitted by the courts below.

3. The counsel has today tendered affidavit of the applicant which is taken on record and marked "X" for identification. In the affidavit it is stated that the applicant undertakes not to practice medicine in future and also ready to compensate the complainant by making payment of Rs.15,000/- to him. In support of his alternate submission, the learned counsel submitted that the applicant should not be pushed in jail at such a late stage, looking to his age, his undertaking not to practice medicine in future and also this being the first offence.

4. Per contra, Mr.Mandpe learned A.P.P. opposed the Revision and argued that there is concurrent finding of facts recorded by the courts below that it is the applicant who is responsible for the death of Satyafula since prosecution has amply proved that Satyafula did not want sixth child and she being pregnant for 8 to 10 weeks, she and her husband went to the applicant, the applicant took Satyafula inside the cabin and treated her for about 30 minutes which shows that the applicant must have used some instruments or something or rustic method for causing abortion and therefore he would be obviously guilty of the offence punishable under

4

Section 314 of Indian Penal Code. Mr.Manpde submitted that this Court is not entitled to interfere with the findings of facts concurrently recorded by the courts below on that aspect. He, therefore, prayed for dismissal of the Revision.

5. I have gone through the judgments recorded by the courts below so also the evidence of the witnesses produced before me by the learned counsel for the applicant. It is true that in revisional jurisdiction it is not possible to interfere with the finding of facts concurrently recorded by the two courts. However, in the instant case, I find that the courts below have gone on assumption and presumption rather than legal evidence before them. Perusal of the evidence tendered by the prosecution shows that P.W.1 Deorao and Satyafula had gone to the applicant for causing abortion as they did not want sixth child. The evidence further shows that Satyafula was taken inside the cabin by the applicant and she was there for about 30 minutes. Thereafter she was relieved and went home. After some hours she started getting severe pains in her stomach and she died because of septicemia, which is the finding recorded in the post mortem report. Merely because Satyafula was in the cabin of applicant for about 30 minutes the courts below should not have readily inferred that the applicant must have applied rustic method for causing abortion. The only evidence that has come on record from Deorao, who says that his wife was

5

telling him that some medicine was given to her. But then the burden was on the prosecution to show what was the nature of medicine and what could have been the effect of such medicine. Unfortunately, there is no evidence to that effect. Statement of Satyafula was never recorded in support of the prosecution case that any rustic method was adopted by the applicant to cause abortion and as a matter of fact it is not the prosecution case that there was in fact an abortion, that too caused by the applicant. Therefore, the only piece of evidence available before the Court was that the applicant had given some medicine to Satyafula and that she was inside the cabin for about 30 minutes. Beyond this, there is nothing to show or connecting the applicant for the proof of the fact that the applicant had caused abortion by any method including any rustic method. Thus it is seen that the evidence against the applicant on the question of Section 314 of Indian Penal Code is infirm and does not carry the prosecution any where. Under such circumstances, benefit of doubt ought to have been given to the applicant. I am, therefore, of the opinion that taking into consideration the evidence of prosecution as it is as completely true, the offence is not proved by the prosecution. The doctor who conducted post mortem also did not say that because of medicine she died. On the contrary, opinion was that she died because of septicemia which means that she died because of heavy infection and therefore it was the

6

bounden duty of the prosecution to show that it was the applicant who was responsible for causing septicemia. Even that evidence has not been tendered by the prosecution. I am therefore inclined to interfere in the revisional jurisdiction in the above peculiar facts and circumstances of the case. Finding of conviction under Section 314 of Indian Penal Code will therefore have to be overturned.

6. Insofar as the offence under Sections 33 and 36 of the Maharashtra Medical Practitioners Act is concerned, I find that there is evidence on record to show that the applicant had given medicine to Satyafula and he had been regularly practising as a doctor in the village in violation of the provisions of Sections 33 and 36 of the Maharashtra Medical Practitioners Act. The finding recorded by the courts below concurrently on that count therefore cannot be disturbed. I have gone through the said finding recorded by the courts below and I find that offence under Section 33 of the Maharashtra Medical Practitioners Act is committed by the applicant and therefore his conviction under that section is legal, correct and proper.

7. Now the question is about awarding of sentence as a sequel to his conviction under Section 33 of the Maharashtra Medical Practitioners Act. The trial Court has imposed fine of Rs.500/- after finding him guilty of the said offence. It is not the prosecution case that this was not the first

7

offence committed by the applicant and therefore in the absence of any evidence it will have to be presumed that it was the first offence. In Criminal Application No.32 of 2010 filed in this Revision there is a statement that the applicant was never convicted for any offence. Taking into consideration this aspect, this appears to be the first offence of the applicant and as per the provisions of Section 33 of the Maharashtra Medical Practitioners Act the applicant could not have been sentenced with fine above Rs.500/-. The appellate court has thus imposed fine of Rs.500/- on the applicant and in default to suffer simple imprisonment for one month. This sentence of Rs.500/- will have to be confirmed and in addition the applicant has agreed to pay amount of Rs.15,000/- to Deorao- the husband of deceased Satyafula. In the result, I make the following order.

8. Criminal Revision No. 156 of 2005 is partly allowed. Finding of conviction and sentence recorded against the applicant for the offence punishable under Section 314 of Indian Penal Code is quashed and set aside. However, the conviction and sentence of the applicant for the offence under Section 33 of Medical Practitioners Act is maintained. The applicant shall pay Rs.15,000/- in addition to payment of fine of Rs.500/-, as agreed by him. This amount of Rs.15,000/- shall be deposited by the applicant before the trial Court within four weeks from today. Upon

8

deposit of said amount of Rs.15,000/-, the trial Court shall summon P.W.1 Deorao and handover the same to him. With these observations, this revision stands disposed of.

JUDGE